Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

Cars you would and wouldn't recommend...

Reply
Created by shi thouse > 9 months ago, 23 Sep 2011
shi thouse
WA, 1136 posts
23 Sep 2011 2:29PM
Thumbs Up

Maybe as the years have passed, my memory of the life of a car has changed however it was not uncommon to have a car that lived well into its 300 000+kms, before any major mechanical issues arose. In those days cars rusted out before they wore out.

Before buying this vehicle I did my research and spent a fair bit of money. Currently my newish car which now has 120 000kms has and has had issues I wouldn't expect. I dont thrash my car and service it as expected however the issues that are occuring I am being told are "common" with this car.

Having had a gutfull of this "built to last" vehicle I am sad to take the necessary actions and to sell it. The car - current model Hilux Dual Cab Diesel 4WD. Bought it as it suited my lifestyle with the tray at back and the 4WD. Could be a Friday built vehicle, however when chatting to a number of mechanics the issues seem to extremely common with this extremely common and overpriced vehicle with very expensive parts. While at the mechanic he said he just repaired his as the injectors were stuffed and his had only done 60 000km's. While there another person rang him to ask about his issues with the vehicle.

I was seriously hoping to have this vehicle for a long time, till it was seriously outdated. Even Jeremy and James rated this vehicle seriously tough. What a load of **. May be tough and reliable for the first 80 000km's then the issues arise.

Anyway, is this fairly standard for most vehicles out there or are there any truly decent vehicles that are built to last out there? If so keen to get other peoples views and experiences of their vehicles so I know what to keep away from and what to look for.

doggie
WA, 15849 posts
23 Sep 2011 2:40PM
Thumbs Up

I could get in alot of trouble by answering that question.

mineral1
WA, 4564 posts
23 Sep 2011 2:55PM
Thumbs Up

shi thouse said...

Maybe as the years have passed, my memory of the life of a car has changed however it was not uncommon to have a car that lived well into its 300 000+kms, before any major mechanical issues arose. In those days cars rusted out before they wore out.

Before buying this vehicle I did my research and spent a fair bit of money. Currently my newish car which now has 120 000kms has and has had issues I wouldn't expect. I dont thrash my car and service it as expected however the issues that are occuring I am being told are "common" with this car.

Having had a gutfull of this "built to last" vehicle I am sad to take the necessary actions and to sell it. The car - current model Hilux Dual Cab Diesel 4WD. Bought it as it suited my lifestyle with the tray at back and the 4WD. Could be a Friday built vehicle, however when chatting to a number of mechanics the issues seem to extremely common with this extremely common and overpriced vehicle with very expensive parts. While at the mechanic he said he just repaired his as the injectors were stuffed and his had only done 60 000km's. While there another person rang him to ask about his issues with the vehicle.

I was seriously hoping to have this vehicle for a long time, till it was seriously outdated. Even Jeremy and James rated this vehicle seriously tough. What a load of **. May be tough and reliable for the first 80 000km's then the issues arise.

Anyway, is this fairly standard for most vehicles out there or are there any truly decent vehicles that are built to last out there? If so keen to get other peoples views and experiences of their vehicles so I know what to keep away from and what to look for.


A reasonable assumption in regards to vehicles you mention run for X period and don't fail, however the same size/sort nowadays, give far less reliability and have a very short service life.
What has happened in development is, that there have been leaps forward in engine/powertrain cyclic loads. Fuel systems that develop far more Kw or HP that impacts the vehicles service life all this out of the same size engine through the same size drive line.
To put this into perspective, my 100 series 1HZ engine only develops mid 74 kw range. My fuel burn rate is well above any new diesel engines, but the new engines develop far more kw/HP
I looked at a test Ford Ranger yesterday, 5 cylinder turbo common fuel rail that develops 150+kw.
There is no way that vehicle will make the same k's as my 100 series will, but its flash as with lots of extras, low fuel burn and lots of grunt.
Price we pay for progress I reckon.

SomeOtherGuy
NSW, 807 posts
23 Sep 2011 5:46PM
Thumbs Up

FWIW, I've been very happy with my 98 Mitsubishi Mirage. Owned since new, over 250,000 km on the clock. Aside from regular servicing (every 15,000 km) plus tyres, brakes it's had the ball joints replaced once. That's it. Just beginning to burn/leak a little oil as I have to top it up once or twice between services.

shi thouse
WA, 1136 posts
23 Sep 2011 4:00PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote


A reasonable assumption in regards to vehicles you mention run for X period and don't fail, however the same size/sort nowadays, give far less reliability and have a very short service life.
What has happened in development is, that there have been leaps forward in engine/powertrain cyclic loads. Fuel systems that develop far more Kw or HP that impacts the vehicles service life all this out of the same size engine through the same size drive line.
To put this into perspective, my 100 series 1HZ engine only develops mid 74 kw range. My fuel burn rate is well above any new diesel engines, but the new engines develop far more kw/HP
I looked at a test Ford Ranger yesterday, 5 cylinder turbo common fuel rail that develops 150+kw.
There is no way that vehicle will make the same k's as my 100 series will, but its flash as with lots of extras, low fuel burn and lots of grunt.
Price we pay for progress I reckon.





Absolutely, getting ridiculous amounts of power from a small engine seems to be the go. Mechanic was saying about 2000psi of pressure is created to enable this power to be generated by the engine. Somethings got to give.

Had a 100 series as well with 4.5 litre engine. Very reliable and had no issues for years. Petrol, unfortunately, was its best friend.

mineral1
WA, 4564 posts
23 Sep 2011 4:04PM
Thumbs Up

Look out for a good 6 cyl diesel 100 series, they are like A...holes, everyone has one.
Mine has just clocked 220,000 k's. No issues other than fuel system repairs at 180,000
not the V8, as there is some history there re oil usage/fule burn ratio.

Woodo
WA, 792 posts
23 Sep 2011 4:35PM
Thumbs Up

shi thouse said...
[
Having had a gutfull of this "built to last" vehicle I am sad to take the necessary actions and to sell it. The car - current model Hilux Dual Cab Diesel 4WD. Bought it as it suited my lifestyle with the tray at back and the 4WD. Could be a Friday built vehicle, however when chatting to a number of mechanics the issues seem to extremely common with this extremely common and overpriced vehicle with very expensive parts. While at the mechanic he said he just repaired his as the injectors were stuffed and his had only done 60 000km's. While there another person rang him to ask about his issues with the vehicle.



1kd motor? Injector knock?

Woodo
WA, 792 posts
23 Sep 2011 4:37PM
Thumbs Up

Holden Astra.
Biggest pieces of poo.

stringer
WA, 703 posts
23 Sep 2011 5:05PM
Thumbs Up

Woodo said...

Holden Astra.
Biggest pieces of poo.


holden viva.

anything holden.

shi thouse
WA, 1136 posts
23 Sep 2011 5:15PM
Thumbs Up

Woodo said...

shi thouse said...
[
Having had a gutfull of this "built to last" vehicle I am sad to take the necessary actions and to sell it. The car - current model Hilux Dual Cab Diesel 4WD. Bought it as it suited my lifestyle with the tray at back and the 4WD. Could be a Friday built vehicle, however when chatting to a number of mechanics the issues seem to extremely common with this extremely common and overpriced vehicle with very expensive parts. While at the mechanic he said he just repaired his as the injectors were stuffed and his had only done 60 000km's. While there another person rang him to ask about his issues with the vehicle.



1kd motor? Injector knock?


Good guess!

Woodo
WA, 792 posts
23 Sep 2011 5:20PM
Thumbs Up

shi thouse said...

Woodo said...

shi thouse said...
[
Having had a gutfull of this "built to last" vehicle I am sad to take the necessary actions and to sell it. The car - current model Hilux Dual Cab Diesel 4WD. Bought it as it suited my lifestyle with the tray at back and the 4WD. Could be a Friday built vehicle, however when chatting to a number of mechanics the issues seem to extremely common with this extremely common and overpriced vehicle with very expensive parts. While at the mechanic he said he just repaired his as the injectors were stuffed and his had only done 60 000km's. While there another person rang him to ask about his issues with the vehicle.



1kd motor? Injector knock?


Good guess!


Have you had your ECU reflashed?
(Computer reprogramed)

japie
NSW, 6830 posts
23 Sep 2011 7:34PM
Thumbs Up

At one stage in my life I owned a new honda Accord. It was a seriously good vehicle and saw more years of use through my ex than myself. That said it cost a motsa and looking back I regret the cash I squandered on something which was basically a wank.

I have since gone for long periods without a vehcle, ( I live 2 minutes from the beach), but am now the proud owner of a Ford, yes I swore I would never buy another Ford or a Holden, courier ute, 1994, Tray back for the grand total of $500. I have done quite a lot of work, replaced a door and panel for $175 and given it a touch up to kill the rust. Oh and I removed the radio!

I am in love with this vehcle. I understand it and it understands me. I check the fluids and never go over 150k'sph. It does not lock but is very unlikely to get nicked and if it does it owes me nothing. I would back it to go around the country.

Yup, I love my ute

adolf
1862 posts
23 Sep 2011 5:49PM
Thumbs Up

I'm not really a car person. I just like them to run and not cost too much.

About 5 years ago I lashed out after having numerous **** cars and bought myself a 2001 BMW 530i It's still a beautiful car. I was about to sell it last year and buy something else and spent $5K on it getting all the dents out a respray and some minor electronic things. When I got it back I couldn't part with it.

The **** cars I've had are:

Toyota Celica
Ford Cortina
Ford Capri
Ford XD
Mercedes 230e

Carantoc
WA, 6554 posts
23 Sep 2011 5:51PM
Thumbs Up

I'll let the evidence do the talking

200,000 miles, yes miles folks, and running as sweet as the day she drove out of the factory.



Need I say more

poor relative
WA, 9089 posts
23 Sep 2011 5:54PM
Thumbs Up

Carantoc said...


Need I say more



Oil change?

ok
NSW, 1087 posts
23 Sep 2011 7:59PM
Thumbs Up

stuff these days is not ment to last. If everything that was produced today was to the highest quality we would be able to own one car,tv,power tool, computer etc the economy would die in an instant. Everything that is made these days is manufactured to die sooner or later. i have worked in factorys where old machinery is used like metal lathes and other equipment that is from the world wars and it still works more reliably and more accurate then the new gear does.

Consumerism is a wonderful thing :)

Carantoc
WA, 6554 posts
23 Sep 2011 6:02PM
Thumbs Up

What d'ya mean ??

Oh the smoke ?

No, that was just a small issue with a 'cheech special' we had going at the time. Long story, and I don't remember much of it for some reason. Wow, look at the colour of the flowers man.... why can't horses talk ?

Carantoc
WA, 6554 posts
23 Sep 2011 6:07PM
Thumbs Up

ok said...

stuff these days is not ment to last. If everything that was produced today was to the highest quality we would be able to own one car,tv,power tool, computer etc the economy would die in an instant. Everything that is made these days is manufactured to die sooner or later. i have worked in factorys where old machinery is used like metal lathes and other equipment that is from the world wars and it still works more reliably and more accurate then the new gear does.

Consumerism is a wonderful thing :)



Heard the other day the US army captured some folks in Afganistan who had been firing at them.

The not so friendly folks had been using a rifle (if that is the right description) that had been used by the 1st British Expeditionary Force to Afganistan (or whatever it was back then) in 1910, but the rifle had been manufactured in 1890.

Obviously some things last.

nick0
NSW, 510 posts
23 Sep 2011 8:15PM
Thumbs Up

95 subaru liberty .. just this arvo i had a bit of a rally in the bush bottomed out so many times even pushed over a couple of small trees(bushes)...345,000 kms.. bullet proof

Ted the Kiwi
NSW, 14256 posts
23 Sep 2011 8:19PM
Thumbs Up

I have had a great run with cars over the last 11 years......I had a BJ42 that had 320K on the clock of the 3B when some drunk goose t-boned it and it was written off. I then needed a replacement car so started to use my old girlfriends 1990 Mazada 121 which I finally sold last year with a slipping clutch for $600 (paid $1,000 for it 5 yrs earlier) with that magic number of 320k on the clock - I did 75K in it for 2 sets of tyres, brake pads, 3 oil changes and some windscreen wipers! It was unreal - it was also very economical. I then brought a Charade which I have done 30K in for a front seal (did timing belt why I had the front end off), brakes pads and some tyres (plus a new wooden seat cover this week). Its upto 220K now and still never misses a beat. Awesome little car - powers up and down the F3 3 times a week no drama!

When I first moved to Aust in 2000 I brought a 1990 Pathfinder for $14K - sold it 3 yrs later for $12k......then 3.5 yrs ago when my girlfriend moved over we brought it back for $2,500 with only 35k more on the clock!! Lucky break. We still have it 70k later - its upto 235K now and still purring along nicely - needed a decent tune, tyres, several oil changes, brake pads and about 40 hrs of my weekends cutting out rust. Over than that it has hardly missed a beat.

Fingers crossed things continue along this way for a bit longer.........I would love to drive a nicer machine but find it hard to justify spending money on a car when there are other priorities.

saltiest1
NSW, 2488 posts
23 Sep 2011 9:16PM
Thumbs Up

kia rio

elizabethb
QLD, 2081 posts
23 Sep 2011 9:28PM
Thumbs Up

02 Nissan X-Trail - Been amazingly perfect, spacious and always run well! ( Although that's due to a service from my great mechanic)

Husband says anything Jap import because they make them well with high standards . i.e Even Suzuki Swift old school (95) are good, with small engine and good fuel

mineral1
WA, 4564 posts
23 Sep 2011 7:43PM
Thumbs Up

elizabethb said...

02 Nissan X-Trail - Been amazingly perfect, spacious and always run well! ( Although that's due to a service from my great mechanic)

Husband says anything Jap import because they make them well with high standards . i.e Even Suzuki Swift old school (95) are good, with small engine and good fuel



You got married, when did that happen.
Owyagoin anyway.
Did you ever sell that bloody Gath helmet

BarryDawson
WA, 175 posts
23 Sep 2011 7:47PM
Thumbs Up

Would recommend

Mazda2, 3 and 6 (be mindful the 3 can cost 3k to fix the air con when the compressor dies)
Toyota Corolla, Camry and Cruiser but only up to the 1HZ motor
Nissan Pulsar, and Patrol but not the 2.8 or 3.0 TD
Subaru (Brumby all the way ) Liberty, Forrestor and Outback.
Mercedes, only if you don't care how much it costs to fix it.
Holden Commodore up to VZ
Valiant, especially the E49 Charger

Would not recommend

Holden Astra (god they keep me busy!!!) Zafira, Vectra and Barina
Ford Focus, Falcon (any model from and including BA) Fiesta
Mercedes (if your worried about how much it will cost to fix it) especially anything with a 5cyl
Saab.... any of them
Volvo, as above
Landrover (Sorry Landrover lovers but my guys dive under the benches when one of these comes through the door)
Jeep, coz it stands for just empty every pocket.

elizabethb
QLD, 2081 posts
23 Sep 2011 9:55PM
Thumbs Up

mineral1 said...

elizabethb said...

02 Nissan X-Trail - Been amazingly perfect, spacious and always run well! ( Although that's due to a service from my great mechanic)

Husband says anything Jap import because they make them well with high standards . i.e Even Suzuki Swift old school (95) are good, with small engine and good fuel



You got married, when did that happen.
Owyagoin anyway.
Did you ever sell that bloody Gath helmet


Married last Saturday Going swimmingly thanks; works not-tooooooo-bad, have a house to keep me busy now That's my favourite part; renovating.

Totally forgot about that Gath lol; brings back some memories (of not being used). Was hard to get rid of lol.

I rarely pop in here; my monthly catch up lol

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
23 Sep 2011 7:57PM
Thumbs Up

Ted the Kiwi said...

I did 75K in it for 2 sets of tyres, brake pads, 3 oil changes and some windscreen wipers!



That's 25K per oil change...

Dart
NSW, 27 posts
23 Sep 2011 10:08PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Ted the Kiwi said...

(plus a new wooden seat cover this week)

That could be a bit hard on the backside

stamp
QLD, 2770 posts
23 Sep 2011 10:16PM
Thumbs Up

to avoid- camira (aka the camiran fix it), diesel gemini, ford falcons from XD onwards, any model lada, mitsubishi anything

recommend- subarus, datsun 120Y 200B, early hiluxes, early landcruisers

Ados
WA, 421 posts
23 Sep 2011 9:31PM
Thumbs Up

Some of the best cars I have owned:

1. 1992 Suzuki Sierra (unstoppable)
2. 1990 Mitsubishi Magna (boring but so reliable)
3. HJ 47 Troopie wagon. best offroad vehicle i have ever owned bar none.
4. Current owner of 2006 Pajero wagon. so far so good.

worst car:

1. Landrover Discovery Series 2. bought for $37,000 in 2005 with 70 000km and sold in 2010 with 140 000 km for $8,500.
My mechanic was very sad when I sold that car. He never did get to put in the swimming pool

Legion
WA, 2222 posts
23 Sep 2011 10:44PM
Thumbs Up

I'd be pretty happy with any Toyota diesel with an 'H' in the engine designation. Or a Nissan with a 4.2. Unfortunately I'm at the top of the 'H' tree right now so I don't know where to go from here.

In cars I like Toyota and Honda.

shi thouse
WA, 1136 posts
23 Sep 2011 11:31PM
Thumbs Up

Woodo said...

shi thouse said...

Woodo said...

shi thouse said...
[
Having had a gutfull of this "built to last" vehicle I am sad to take the necessary actions and to sell it. The car - current model Hilux Dual Cab Diesel 4WD. Bought it as it suited my lifestyle with the tray at back and the 4WD. Could be a Friday built vehicle, however when chatting to a number of mechanics the issues seem to extremely common with this extremely common and overpriced vehicle with very expensive parts. While at the mechanic he said he just repaired his as the injectors were stuffed and his had only done 60 000km's. While there another person rang him to ask about his issues with the vehicle.



1kd motor? Injector knock?


Good guess!


Have you had your ECU reflashed?
(Computer reprogramed)



Not too sure what is called that they are doing but something to do with the injectors without having to replace them (around $2600 for replacement).



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"Cars you would and wouldn't recommend..." started by shi thouse