Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

Facebook worries

Reply
Created by decrepit > 9 months ago, 19 Aug 2010
decrepit
WA, 12161 posts
19 Aug 2010 9:58PM
Thumbs Up

Just had a message from one of my wife's friends, inviting me to join face book.
Strange thing #1 it was asking me not my wife.
Strange thing #2 It also had a list of "other people I might know on facebook". I recognised all but 1 of these, thought they've made a mistake here, but when I checked my address book, this person was in there, a very old genealogy contact I'd forgotten about.

So how the hell, did facebook get this info?
Have they mined my address book somehow or is all email traffic records available to them?

I find this a bit of a worry, am I paranoid, or does it worry anybody else????

Commentator
NSW, 15 posts
20 Aug 2010 12:58AM
Thumbs Up


I've heard that...

ANYBODY OVER 30 YO ON FAECEBOOK IS A STALKER.

Mark _australia
WA, 22414 posts
19 Aug 2010 11:27PM
Thumbs Up

Decrep,

It is the same mob who built the pyramids and are fluoridating the water supply and bombed the WTC. Don't trust them.

Seriously though.... that is a worry - Facebook must have your email addressbook as the person who invited you cannot possibly list all the people you know who are also on Facebook.

decrepit
WA, 12161 posts
19 Aug 2010 11:47PM
Thumbs Up

Mark _australia said...

Decrep,

>>>>>>

Seriously though.... that is a worry - Facebook must have your email addressbook as the person who invited you cannot possibly list all the people you know who are also on Facebook.



Don't see how they could have my address book, I'm not on facebook, and my wife's friend wouldn't know the other people listed.
If they do have it, I agree it's a huge worry.
I think it's possible there's some sort of record somewhere of internet traffic, but some of it must be years old.

I guess it's possible they have the address books of the other people listed, who are on facebook. They would all have my address in them. Think that makes more sense but it's still a worry.

Commentator, I agree, don't want anything to do with it, especially after this.

deXtrous
NSW, 451 posts
20 Aug 2010 2:01AM
Thumbs Up

Don't think you're crazy for having that thought decript, here's a message from someone on a different forum I visit, which I thought was maybe a coincidence until I read this thread. He posted it yesterday (Thursday).



nice1 said:
I sold some games on ebay last week. I log into my facebook and it is suggesting me to be friends with guy I sold the games to.

1. I don't know this guy
2. I've never linked my facebook to my ebay or paypal in ANY way
3. This guy lives at the other end of the country to me, nobody I know would know him


Seriously, how the **** does facebook get the name from an ebay transaction then start suggesting me to be friends with him?

Its definately the same guy because I checked his full name & address on both site.

****s worrying because I never gave facebook access to my ebay or paypal.





Weird indeed.

busterwa
3777 posts
20 Aug 2010 5:09AM
Thumbs Up

When you add friends it allows you to do them via email contacts,Any email address not on the facebook will recieve a letter saying that you have a friend on there and please join... Nothing to worry about decrepid.

stamp
QLD, 2770 posts
20 Aug 2010 8:34AM
Thumbs Up

Commentator said...


I've heard that...

ANYBODY OVER 30 YO ON FAECEBOOK IS A STALKER.


faecebook? is that where people who love poo get together online?

grumplestiltskin
WA, 2331 posts
20 Aug 2010 7:34AM
Thumbs Up

decrepit said...

Mark _australia said...

Decrep,

>>>>>>

Seriously though.... that is a worry - Facebook must have your email addressbook as the person who invited you cannot possibly list all the people you know who are also on Facebook.



Don't see how they could have my address book, I'm not on facebook, and my wife's friend wouldn't know the other people listed.
If they do have it, I agree it's a huge worry.
I think it's possible there's some sort of record somewhere of internet traffic, but some of it must be years old.

I guess it's possible they have the address books of the other people listed, who are on facebook. They would all have my address in them. Think that makes more sense but it's still a worry.

Commentator, I agree, don't want anything to do with it, especially after this.


are you a Gmail or Hotmail user? if so then probably yes they have mined your account.

I was on Facebook, joined just to find out what everyone was on about.
Then I deleted it, which was a mission to actually delete an account.
THEN my son decided to go overseas for a year, so now I back on the bloody thing as its the easiest way to stay in contact with him

To me its a sad reflection of society.
Even one of the Google founders reckons that all teens should be allowed to change their name at 20 (or somewhere near) so that they can be disassociated with all the rubbish they have posted on social networks ........ how sads that!

maxm
NSW, 864 posts
20 Aug 2010 10:12AM
Thumbs Up

Sounds like they've mined your address book but depending on what email hosting you use, they may have access to your emails. The address book is more likely though. If you ever tried out Facebook, you may have also given them access to your address book at that point.

BTW, there is a US government agency which does actually capture, store and analyse all email traffic. Don't know how they go with VPN encrypted stuff but that probably doesn't worry them too much. But I seriously doubt Facebook would have access to that stuff. Come to think of it, I seriously hope that Facebook doesn't have access to that stuff.

BTW BTW, I've noticed that Facebook also now are mining the info posted on their site and using it to suggest groups to you that don't exist. I guess the idea is that they get you to kick start new groups that way. Gave the missus a fright when she started receiving these things. Pain in the sphincter if you ask me.

AquaPlow
QLD, 1051 posts
20 Aug 2010 1:04PM
Thumbs Up

Coffee in hand and a poor wind forecast - then read on...
First up consider the internet - who and how is the vast structure being funded?
Back in the very early days - it was public but now it is big business.

There are a few very big players in the background running server farms on mind boggling scales. The owners of the OPERA browser are one, Google has mirrored the complete internet. And then there is the ability to plug into leaks and soft spots.

Security on the internet boils down to vested interests (Banks, government agencies etc). How far does your personal vested interest go?

Before going on think at how rapidly the SSL (Secure Socket Layer) encryption algorithms have grown.. 48 bit dead buried 128 bit should be dead and buried, 256 bit is common and 1056 bit on specific protocols. Basically it is what protects your data by churning it up when it leaves your PC to the destination where the reverse occurs. There is a reason - those soft spots...

What can you do with out being a total geek...?
YOUR SOFTWARE / HARDWARE
1) on the home front protect the front door (your adsl router to the internet) at a minimum set a password not the default.
2) For your LAN / PC review this it will give you an insight at the least..
(although controversial and taken over by a bigger concern it appears to still run on being impartial)
www.matousec.com/index.html

3) Optionally go for anonimity on the internet... read this...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Onion_Router
www.torproject.org/overview.html

You end up saying you have to trust someone - but do not under any circumstances sign-up for unsolicited PC protection products without at a minimum doing 15 - 30 minutes googling for 3rd party opinions...

YOUR HABITS or but willing to learn or ring in for allcomers...
The subject of safe habits.... ah perhaps someone else wants to run with this...
Where is that wind???

Gorgo
VIC, 4982 posts
20 Aug 2010 1:12PM
Thumbs Up

If they mine the address book of other people, and that person has received an email from you, or received an email with your address in it (because of forward or rely or or cc), then they will have your email address. It's then a simple process of networking all the addresses on common address lists to come up with a best fit score for people for you.

It's not hard to do, just time consuming.

Don't worry about it. Just make sure you don't go putting personal stuff up on the net.

grumplestiltskin
WA, 2331 posts
20 Aug 2010 12:27PM
Thumbs Up

Gorgo said...

Don't worry about it. Just make sure you don't go putting personal stuff up on the net.


And there in lies the rub.... How many times have you typed something and then later wished to take it back .... toooooo late, its out there.

Not a problem for Decrep, but how many of you have "friended" workmates or worse your boss, then bragged about a big night out and not turned up for work the next day??????

I know I'm probably being overly paranoid, but more and more people are going to get burned by this stuff.

frant
VIC, 1230 posts
20 Aug 2010 2:40PM
Thumbs Up

Commentator said...


I've heard that...

ANYBODY OVER 30 YO ON FAECEBOOK IS A STALKER.


So does that mean that decrepit is a pair of stalkers

GreenPat
QLD, 4083 posts
20 Aug 2010 2:47PM
Thumbs Up

decrepit said...


I find this a bit of a worry, am I paranoid, or does it worry anybody else????


The question isn't whether you're paranoid. The question is; are you paranoid enough?

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
20 Aug 2010 10:36PM
Thumbs Up

Ok speaking as a web geek here, something you might not know is how all this happens. Put simply, when you visit a site, your computer sends the address of the last site you visited to the new site. This has been in place since the start of web browsers, as a way to easily figure out how to display the "go back" links you sometimes see.
What has started to happen recently is that this information has started to be mined by companies such as google and Facebook, as a way of figuring out who you are connected with. So let's say you visit a friend's page on facebook, then do a google search. Google will know that you just visited their page, and this information will be stored against your google profile. It doesn't take much of a leap of faith to figure out the connections that can be made. My guess is that some algorithms have just come online that can join the dots, and determine the connections between you, your friends, Facebook , Seabreeze, Gtc, the list goes on. There's a lot to be said for unplugging once in a while and seeing what sunlight feels like on the skin:-)

ginger pom
VIC, 1746 posts
21 Aug 2010 9:38AM
Thumbs Up

Not suspicious at all part

There is a "Friend finder" application.

You consent to it.

You give it your password for gmail.

It looks at people addresses in your account (both to and from).

It asks if you want to be friends with those who have accounts and asks you to invite the others to facebook.

You choose.

possibly suspicious part

It stores this for everyone

When the other end of the pairing (the person that mailed you or you mailed) logs onto facebook, it uses your email info to offer them possible contacts.



What happened in your situation seems to be that your geneology contact went through the same process, but didn't add you as a friend. Now facebook is using his email info to encourage you to invite him.

ginger pom
VIC, 1746 posts
21 Aug 2010 9:41AM
Thumbs Up

The issue, if there is one, is that other people can surrender a lot of your personal info, because it's their personal info too, without your consent...

ginger pom
VIC, 1746 posts
21 Aug 2010 9:51AM
Thumbs Up

deXtrous said...

Don't think you're crazy for having that thought decript, here's a message from someone on a different forum I visit, which I thought was maybe a coincidence until I read this thread. He posted it yesterday (Thursday).



nice1 said:
I sold some games on ebay last week. I log into my facebook and it is suggesting me to be friends with guy I sold the games to.

1. I don't know this guy
2. I've never linked my facebook to my ebay or paypal in ANY way
3. This guy lives at the other end of the country to me, nobody I know would know him


Seriously, how the **** does facebook get the name from an ebay transaction then start suggesting me to be friends with him?

Its definately the same guy because I checked his full name & address on both site.

****s worrying because I never gave facebook access to my ebay or paypal.





Weird indeed.



I think Nice1's counterparty has linked his email address...

ginger pom
VIC, 1746 posts
21 Aug 2010 9:52AM
Thumbs Up

really sorry - what gorgo said..

busterwa
3777 posts
21 Aug 2010 10:06AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
nebbian said...

Ok speaking as a web geek here, something you might not know is how all this happens. Put simply, when you visit a site, your computer sends the address of the last site you visited to the new site. This has been in place since the start of web browsers, as a way to easily figure out how to display the "go back" links you sometimes see.
What has started to happen recently is that this information has started to be mined by companies such as google and Facebook, as a way of figuring out who you are connected with. So let's say you visit a friend's page on facebook, then do a google search. Google will know that you just visited their page, and this information will be stored against your google profile. It doesn't take much of a leap of faith to figure out the connections that can be made. My guess is that some algorithms have just come online that can join the dots, and determine the connections between you, your friends, Facebook , Seabreeze, Gtc, the list goes on. There's a lot to be said for unplugging once in a while and seeing what sunlight feels like on the skin:-)
[/quote/]
Seabreese should be advertising me hot sucking blonde lesbian babes when i log in ;-)

frant
VIC, 1230 posts
21 Aug 2010 3:23PM
Thumbs Up

busterwa said...

Select to expand quote
nebbian said...

Ok speaking as a web geek here, something you might not know is how all this happens. Put simply, when you visit a site, your computer sends the address of the last site you visited to the new site. This has been in place since the start of web browsers, as a way to easily figure out how to display the "go back" links you sometimes see.
What has started to happen recently is that this information has started to be mined by companies such as google and Facebook, as a way of figuring out who you are connected with. So let's say you visit a friend's page on facebook, then do a google search. Google will know that you just visited their page, and this information will be stored against your google profile. It doesn't take much of a leap of faith to figure out the connections that can be made. My guess is that some algorithms have just come online that can join the dots, and determine the connections between you, your friends, Facebook , Seabreeze, Gtc, the list goes on. There's a lot to be said for unplugging once in a while and seeing what sunlight feels like on the skin:-)
[/quote/]
Seabreese should be advertising me hot sucking blonde lesbian babes when i log in ;-)




Don't worry they have successfully linked you to the Doctor in the who built the pyramids thread.

Mark _australia
WA, 22414 posts
21 Aug 2010 6:54PM
Thumbs Up

busterwa said...

Select to expand quote
nebbian said...

Ok speaking as a web geek here, something you might not know is how all this happens. Put simply, when you visit a site, your computer sends the address of the last site you visited to the new site. This has been in place since the start of web browsers, as a way to easily figure out how to display the "go back" links you sometimes see.
What has started to happen recently is that this information has started to be mined by companies such as google and Facebook, as a way of figuring out who you are connected with. So let's say you visit a friend's page on facebook, then do a google search. Google will know that you just visited their page, and this information will be stored against your google profile. It doesn't take much of a leap of faith to figure out the connections that can be made. My guess is that some algorithms have just come online that can join the dots, and determine the connections between you, your friends, Facebook , Seabreeze, Gtc, the list goes on. There's a lot to be said for unplugging once in a while and seeing what sunlight feels like on the skin:-)
[/quote/]
Seabreese should be advertising me hot sucking blonde lesbian babes when i log in ;-)




Yes but that does not explain how when Decrep has never used Facebook that when he got a friend request emailed to him he later got one that included his whole email address book (well all the ones of Facebook anyway.
From how he describes it they must have read his email address book so thus the friend request includes a data miner

And that is a worry.

decrepit
WA, 12161 posts
21 Aug 2010 7:15PM
Thumbs Up

Mark _australia said...
>>>>>>>
Yes but that does not explain how when Decrep has never used Facebook that when he got a friend request emailed to him he later got one that included his whole email address book (well all the ones of Facebook anyway.
From how he describes it they must have read his email address book so thus the friend request includes a data miner

And that is a worry.




Don't think so now Mark. I agree with Ginger Pom, I think facebook, has the address books of all the people that agreed to search their address books for friends.
When my wife's friend emailed me, (and this must be an automatic thing on facebook's part, otherwise it would have been addressed to my wife). Facebook then searched it's database and came up with all the other people who have me in their address book, they're the ones it suggested I may also want to make friends, if I joined.

Smedg
NSW, 836 posts
21 Aug 2010 11:06PM
Thumbs Up

How good are those 'I facebooked ya Mum' T Shirts.

Very good is the answer to that particular question me thinks.

PS How good is stamp at noticing typos...

I read his reply and still thought, what the hell is he on about, for a little second. haha



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"Facebook worries" started by decrepit