Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

Salmon Fish farms

Reply
Created by theDoctor > 9 months ago, 28 Jan 2010
theDoctor
NSW, 5780 posts
28 Jan 2010 5:01PM
Thumbs Up





still looking for links to entire film, if anyone finds them could they please post them

SMG
QLD, 208 posts
28 Jan 2010 4:30PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks Doc...interesting! More reasons why people should be aware that eating farmed fish isn't always the environmentally friendly option.

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
28 Jan 2010 2:34PM
Thumbs Up

Awww fek!

I LOVE salmon, and yes I know the affordable stuff in the fishmongers is farmed (you can taste the diff) but fek me it is still yummy and I don't need to rip orf a convenience store to buy a few fillets.

Can we have a good news post some day soon?

sausage
QLD, 4873 posts
28 Jan 2010 4:44PM
Thumbs Up

Easy solution to protect the native salmon - just introduce something that loves to eat sea lice just like the cane toad was introduced to manage cane beetle.

theDoctor
NSW, 5780 posts
28 Jan 2010 6:42PM
Thumbs Up


the chinese love flied lice

petermac33
WA, 6415 posts
28 Jan 2010 6:38PM
Thumbs Up

my pussycat [katie] has been fed homebrand salmon for last 6 months.

she would hardly eat the tinned cat food [fish] i was feeding her.

she loves the salmon.

hope they're not poisoning my pussycat with this farmed salmon.

cause i love my pussy.

and its the only pussy i get.

japie
NSW, 6852 posts
28 Jan 2010 9:39PM
Thumbs Up

The salmon and trout industry is almost totally confined to the sea nowadays. There are a few exceptions where trout are grown in fresh water but most farms have been closed owing to the amount of pollution they create.

Growing the fish on in the sea makes a huge amount of sense financially as seawater varies little in temperature and oxygen content. Unfortunately their impact on the aquatic environment is not reduced, just spread about. Salmonids grow very fast but require a diet that exceeds 55% protein. This can only be provided by using trawled catch, mainly herring and krill which give a conversion ratio of up to 1:1.1.

The industry is huge.Largest of all is the feed suppliers, and any attempt to reduce their impact by regulation is backed by big dollars.

As nice as they are to eat I now will not partake. The only trout I eat comes out of a river on the end of a lure. The sulphonamides and other drugs used to combat disease in highly stressed enclosures is frightening.

Dr Funk
NSW, 348 posts
29 Jan 2010 9:17AM
Thumbs Up

Dr David Suzuki on salmon farming. This was once an industry that I was a part of and I have talked to DR Suzuki about this and other Environmental issues surrounding fish farming. Amazing and driven man.

cRAZY Canuk
NSW, 2528 posts
29 Jan 2010 1:26PM
Thumbs Up

Suzuki Rocks! I grew up watching his telly show back home.

It's been a well know fact since they started farming fish that it was bad for the enviroment.

Still makes be laugh when I tell people they feed farmed salmon dye to make the meat pink/orange/red.

maxm
NSW, 864 posts
29 Jan 2010 2:19PM
Thumbs Up

cRAZY Canuk said...

Still makes be laugh when I tell people they feed farmed salmon dye to make the meat pink/orange/red.


Is it actually a dye? I'd been told that it was a diet rich in krill in the final days/weeks before sale but I wouldn't put it past them to use chemicals. Kinda like Woolies puts the #1 red colouring (or whatever it is) in its meat to make it look red.

Salmon is still yummy though.

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
29 Jan 2010 12:08PM
Thumbs Up

Not to mention that chicken is bleached and steak is coloured to look more appealing/healthy. WTF are we doing to ourselves in order to make foods appear more healthy??

japie
NSW, 6852 posts
29 Jan 2010 3:31PM
Thumbs Up

It is called cantaxanthin or canthaxanthin. Sometimes soled as tanning pills!

ginger pom
VIC, 1746 posts
29 Jan 2010 8:39PM
Thumbs Up

petermac33 said...

my pussycat [katie] has been fed homebrand salmon for last 6 months.




Seriously, you shouldn't feed your cat fish all the time. We started feeding our cat (Moppet) tuna and then we realised how bad it was for cats.

doggie
WA, 15849 posts
29 Jan 2010 6:52PM
Thumbs Up

theDoctor said...




still looking for links to entire film, if anyone finds them could they please post them


The CIA have it!!

cisco
QLD, 12324 posts
29 Jan 2010 10:34PM
Thumbs Up

Suzuki certainly got his audience uncomfortable about what they had just eaten.

j murray
SA, 947 posts
30 Jan 2010 6:42AM
Thumbs Up


I note that 707flying film star flew into Hatti with 4 ton of medical supplies,

and a team of religious healers that can cure wounds by placing hands on them.

.....and we are worried about contaminated food...... WTF..HANDS OFF

shark
WA, 361 posts
3 Feb 2010 1:41AM
Thumbs Up

ginger pom said...

petermac33 said...

my pussycat [katie] has been fed homebrand salmon for last 6 months.




Seriously, you shouldn't feed your cat fish all the time. We started feeding our cat (Moppet) tuna and then we realised how bad it was for cats.




Moppet? are you kidding? Is that cos hes not house trained (Mop it).
A better name for a cat is Clubit

cisco
QLD, 12324 posts
3 Feb 2010 7:59AM
Thumbs Up

shark said...
Moppet? are you kidding? Is that cos hes not house trained (Mop it).
A better name for a cat is Clubit


Or "Feedit"........to shark.

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
3 Feb 2010 12:32PM
Thumbs Up

Anybody know if 'Tasmanian Ocean Trout' is bad news? Same for Tasmanian Salmon?

I wouldn't be betting that the Innaloo fish markets are strictly genuine with their Tasmanian labelling but you live in hope I spose.

doggie
WA, 15849 posts
3 Feb 2010 12:59PM
Thumbs Up

getfunky said...

Anybody know if 'Tasmanian Ocean Trout' is bad news? Same for Tasmanian Salmon?

I wouldn't be betting that the Innaloo fish markets are strictly genuine with their Tasmanian labelling but you live in hope I spose.


They are pretty good there GF..

Dr Funk
NSW, 348 posts
3 Feb 2010 4:17PM
Thumbs Up

getfunky said...

Anybody know if 'Tasmanian Ocean Trout' is bad news? Same for Tasmanian Salmon?

I wouldn't be betting that the Innaloo fish markets are strictly genuine with their Tasmanian labelling but you live in hope I spose.


Ocean Trout are much better and surprisingly more sustainable than salmon. Below is a great answer to a similar question plus a great explanation of the chemicals used to colour the salmon.....enjoy your meals......

Tasmanian Ocean Trout has a distinctive rosy pink/orange flesh and high omega 6 content which makes them an ideal eating fish. The flavour is more subtle and less salty than Atlantic or farmed salmon, and according to many chefs, much better tasting.

while...

Salmon is a popular food. Consuming salmon is considered to be reasonably healthy due to the fish's high protein, high Omega-3 fatty acids, and high vitamin D[5] content. Salmon is also a source of cholesterol, ranging 23–214 mg/100g depending on the species.[6] According to reports in the journal Science, however, farmed salmon may contain high levels of dioxins. PCB (polychlorinated biphenyl) levels may be up to eight times higher in farmed salmon than in wild salmon. Omega-3 content may also be lower than in wild caught individuals, and in a different proportion to what is found naturally. Omega 3 comes in three types, ALA, DHA and EPA; wild salmon has traditionally been an important source of DHA and EPA, which are important for brain function and structure, among other things. This means that if the farmed salmon is fed on a meal which is partially grain then the amount of Omega 3 it contains will be present as ALA (alpha-linolenic acid). The body can itself convert ALA Omega 3 into DHA and EPA, but at a very inefficient rate (2–15%). Nonetheless, according to a 2006 study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, the benefits of eating even farmed salmon still outweigh any risks imposed by contaminants [1]. Type of Omega 3 present may not be a factor for other important health functions. A simple rule of thumb is that the vast majority of Atlantic salmon available on the world market are farmed (greater than 99%), whereas the majority of Pacific salmon are wild-caught (greater than 80%). Farmed salmon outnumber wild salmon 85 to 1.[7]


Raw salmon sashimiSalmon flesh is generally orange to red in colour, although there are some examples of white fleshed wild salmon. The natural colour of salmon results from carotenoid pigments, largely astaxanthin (E161j), in the flesh. Wild salmon get these carotenoids from eating krill and other tiny shellfish. Because consumers have shown a reluctance to purchase white fleshed salmon, astaxanthin, and very minutely canthaxanthin (E161g)), are added as artificial colorants to the feed of farmed salmon because prepared diets do not naturally contain these pigments. In most cases the astaxanthin is made chemically; alternatively it is extracted from shrimp flour. Another possibility is the use of dried red yeast, which provides the same pigment. However, synthetic mixtures are the least expensive option. Astaxanthin is a potent antioxidant that stimulates the development of healthy fish nervous systems and that enhances the fish's fertility and growth rate. Research has revealed canthaxanthin may have negative effects on the human eye, accumulating in the retina at high levels of consumption. Today the concentration of carotenoids (mainly canthaxanthin and astaxanthin) exceeds 8 mg/kg of flesh and all fish producers try to reach a level that represents a value of 16 on the "Roche Color Card", a colour card used to show how pink the fish will appear at specific doses. This scale is specific for measuring the pink colour due to astaxanthin and is not for the orange hue obtained with canthaxanthin. The development of processing and storage operations, which can be detrimental on canthaxanthin flesh concentration, has led to an increased quantity of pigments added to the diet to compensate for the degrading effects of the processing. In wild fish, carotenoid levels of up to 20–25 mg are present, but levels of canthaxanthin are, in contrast, minor.

Canned salmon in the U.S. is usually wild Pacific catch, though some farmed salmon is available in canned form. Smoked salmon is another popular preparation method, and can either be hot or cold smoked. Lox can refer either to cold smoked salmon or to salmon cured in a brine solution (also called gravlax). Traditional canned salmon includes some skin (which is harmless) and bone (which adds calcium). Skinless and boneless canned salmon is also available.

Raw salmon flesh may contain Anisakis nematodes, marine parasites that cause Anisakiasis. Before the availability of refrigeration, the Japanese did not consume raw salmon. Salmon and salmon roe have only recently come into use in making sashimi (raw fish) and sushi.

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
3 Feb 2010 1:52PM
Thumbs Up

Interesting.. In previous years I found the Ocean Trout (OT) to be milder in flavout than salmon but in recent times i have been convinced I have been eating farmed salmon as the flavour has noticeably dimninished (and prices have remained stable compared to ther fish).

However, the OT i bought this week (couldn't bring myself to buy salmon after reading this thread) had a richer flavour and was absolutely deluxe. I thought the flavour was up on previous OT purchases (been about 6 months though) but it may well be that i have been conditioned by farmed salmon to expect blandness.

Glad to hear OT has less nasties so far.

petermac33
WA, 6415 posts
3 Feb 2010 2:49PM
Thumbs Up

japie....The sulphonamides and other drugs used to combat disease in highly stressed enclosures is frightening.

after reading this line would only eat the stuff if i caught it myself.

being a veggie has it's advantages.

myusernam
QLD, 6120 posts
4 Feb 2010 9:00AM
Thumbs Up

petermac33 said...

japie....The sulphonamides and other drugs used to combat disease in highly stressed enclosures is frightening.

after reading this line would only eat the stuff if i caught it myself.

being a veggie has it's advantages.


vegitarian and a cat lover who feeds his cat salmon
keep it in the cupboard

petermac33
WA, 6415 posts
4 Feb 2010 7:48AM
Thumbs Up

myusernam......vegitarian and a cat lover who feeds his cat salmon
keep it in the cupboard

nothing like a subway footlong vegetarian with extra olives + chillies on wholemeal bread of course.

nothing can possibly beat that.

theDoctor
NSW, 5780 posts
4 Feb 2010 2:00PM
Thumbs Up

petermac33 said...


being a veggie has it's advantages.


like cool parking spaces and larger toilet cubicles...?

japie
NSW, 6852 posts
4 Feb 2010 2:37PM
Thumbs Up

Today's food industry relies heavily on chemical solutions. The big drawback with fresh food is that it does not behave but goes off over time and time is what the logistics systems need. So we use chemicals.

I worked for Edgells Birds Eye, now Simplot in Bathurst. Believe it or not this is the largest fish processor in the country, or it was. Most of the raw material comes from Chile and New Zealand in the form of neatly frozen 7.5 kilo blocks packed five in a carton. The blocks are put through a series of slicers producing an oblong domino which is finally stamped into a fillet shape and then crumbed.

The slicer operator had responsibility to remove product with contaminants, the most frequent of which were large balls of undiluted preservative. So if you think that freezing is how they keep it fresh you need another think.

And as for animals bred in intensive systems try to imagine how long it would be before the doctor and his bag of chemicals was called in to keep us healthy if we were expected to live in the same conditions.

It is not a conspiracy either! Just straight forward sound economics.

maxm
NSW, 864 posts
4 Feb 2010 3:38PM
Thumbs Up

japie said...

It is not a conspiracy either! Just straight forward sound economics.


And remember that in the developed world our average lifespan is way longer than ever before. That's because of the huge improvements in both nutrition and the medical sciences, not in spite of them. That's not to say things couldn't be better but they're not too bad (for us anyways).

If you want to live a short, unhealthy life then best bet is to avoid all forms of modern diet and medicine and live like they did back when most people were dead before they hit fifty.

brucey65
79 posts
4 Feb 2010 1:26PM
Thumbs Up


CATS should be Eradicated.. there is no room in this world for stinkin hairy cats!!

theDoctor
NSW, 5780 posts
4 Feb 2010 5:34PM
Thumbs Up

maxm said...

Select to expand quote


And remember that in the developed world our average lifespan is way longer than ever before. That's because of the huge improvements in both nutrition and the medical sciences, not in spite of them. That's not to say things couldn't be better but they're not too bad (for us anyways).

If you want to live a short, unhealthy life then best bet is to avoid all forms of modern diet and medicine and live like they did back when most people were dead before they hit fifty.


thats rubbish...

sanitation and statistics is why we live longer now.

people clean themselves and their surrounds more and the birth rate is higher now and the rates of infant mortality and women dying during childbirth are lower, so statistically thats why we live longer.

diet and modern medicine are the two biggest killers in western civilisation

petermac33
WA, 6415 posts
4 Feb 2010 3:33PM
Thumbs Up

the doctor......diet and modern medicine are the two biggest killers in western civilisation

will second that.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"Salmon Fish farms" started by theDoctor