Forums > Kitesurfing General

Accident @ Pinnaroo

Reply
Created by wavehogger > 9 months ago, 13 Jan 2010
sleek1
VIC, 672 posts
13 Jan 2010 10:53PM
Thumbs Up

People new how to instruct once.

Gstar
WA, 391 posts
13 Jan 2010 8:04PM
Thumbs Up

sleek1 said...

People new how to instruct once.


People "knew" how to write once.

RedKite
VIC, 66 posts
13 Jan 2010 11:40PM
Thumbs Up

The thumbs for Kitehard's last post and pfr's post, give a clear picture of what the kite communitiy thinks about AKS suggestions.

jquigley
WA, 205 posts
13 Jan 2010 9:11PM
Thumbs Up

Any lawyers amongst you rabble?

Surely this couldn't happen in Australia, America maybe but here?

Someone can effectively own the beach?

Oh and just by the by thanks to AKS instructor for spotting one of my lines not connected just as I was about to launch, and averting potential tragedy.


J-P

Kitehard
WA, 2782 posts
Site Sponsor
13 Jan 2010 9:21PM
Thumbs Up

Hi everyone,

Now that I have your attention! Thanks for all the helpful comments and posts.

Just a little off topic, but the kiteschool was there long before 95% of kiters currently using the beach and is also the reason most of those kiters are there now. But anyway...

Seeing as I have your attention, my proposal is we do not cordon off the area, it is never our intention to do so. We are part of the crew too, but I did want to highlight the fact that there is a problem which needs to be addressed.

The fact that Pinnaroo is a newbie beach (no surf, wide sandy beach and clean wind) and no one is considerate of the newbies or instructors has pushed things to the point where there has now been an accident where someone has been injured.

Some things need to change and we all need to be on the same team to achieve the outcome which works for all of us.

Here is what I am asking local kiters for:-

1/ Roll your lines when you come in and move your kite to the area in front of the dunes if you aren't using it for more than 10 minutes. Most days, the whole beach is covered with kites from the dunes to the water line.

2/ Don't leave your boards on the beach. Move them up with your kites.

3/ Don't launch your kite with a student or instructor in your wind window

4/ Don't ride your kite with a newbie in your wind window.

5/ Have a little respect for newbies and give them some space.

6/ Don't setup in a newbies wind window. We start everyday before anyone is at the beach and continually have to move up or down the beach to keep our wind window clear of people. This is eventually impossible and leads to avoidable incidences like yesterday.

7/ If you see something about to go wrong, word up the offender. I can't do it alone. If everyone pitches in and doesn't leave it to someone else, we can change behaviours.

8/ Try riding through the flags at Mullas and see if anyone yells at you. We need the same at Pinnaroo for people doing the wrong thing.

9/ We have never wanted anything other than harmony with the local beach users. There are only two or maybe three guys from the original crew who were there before the school that still use Pinna's and they seem to get it, why doesn't everyone else? All the rest are there because of the school.

10/ Have some respect for the learners. We have lots of ladies learning now too and they all deserve a break so cut them some slack. As I said in my last post, the kites are blood red warning colours so keep clear of them.

So many people complain of newbies clobbering them with kites over their lines. This is only happening because you are inside their wind windows. Think about it!

A little help from everrone would be greatly appreciated. We're doing all we can to make it better and more enjoyable for all users. How about you all pitch in and do your bit too. We would appreciate the help.

Cheers,

KH

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
13 Jan 2010 9:33PM
Thumbs Up

Gstar said...

Here's your solution. Gets my vote anyway.



Not sure I agree with this, where you want to put the kite school is where the windsurfers launch and land from. I do both, and I'm a lot happier being around learner kiters when kiting than when windsurfing.

Perhaps this is what Kitehard is intending?


Spacemonkey!
SA, 2288 posts
14 Jan 2010 12:04AM
Thumbs Up

Just my 2 cents, I would have thought (regardless of who was there first) that it should be up to the business to do it's best efforts to not inconvenience the general public, not up to the general public to do their best to not inconvenience your business. Whilst asking people to mutually work together to have a safe beach is not unreasonable, some of your recommendations seem to rely a lot on the public avoiding causing you trouble rather than the other way around.

tailz8
QLD, 4 posts
13 Jan 2010 11:47PM
Thumbs Up

Spacemonkey,

Thats like building a housing development next to an international airport thats been around for 20 years, then when people move in they complain about the noise...

Fooosh
WA, 563 posts
13 Jan 2010 9:53PM
Thumbs Up

^^ Just a reminder there's also a jetski zone there plus a bit of a wind shadow (and no one to watch you pull your big tricks except the odd kid / family)
AAARGHH!! We've run out of space!!

Kitehard, I think your DNAs are more a 'Strawberry Sorbet' red don't you? ... LOL!!

waveslave
WA, 4263 posts
13 Jan 2010 10:16PM
Thumbs Up

Kitehard said...

The fact that Pinnaroo is a newbie beach (no surf, wide sandy beach and clean wind) and no one is considerate of the newbies or instructors has pushed things to the point where there has now been an accident where someone has been injured.



Are you trying to blame this recent accident on inconsiderate people ? ^^^
lol.
The accident happened because the newbie over-steered the kite and cannonballed himself.
That's the main reason for most kiting accidents.
The rogue gust is just a myth.
Don't you teach your newbies to hold the bar with two fists close to the depower rope ?
I see so many kooks riding with fists wide apart gripping a broomstick of a bar.
Short bars and fists together will prevent over-steer.

Windmill
VIC, 33 posts
14 Jan 2010 1:22AM
Thumbs Up

Gstar said...

wavehogger said...

...I have to say that at least at Pinarroo we have a controlled environment which is nonexistant at Scarborough.

Elaborate please! I've kited Scarborough for 8 years and find your statement confusing!





I find this confusing as well?? I kite both spots daily (wind permitting) and Scarborough definitely doesn't seem as crazy as Pinna's on its day. (I do think Pinna's gets over populated which contributes to crazy)

mattyjee
WA, 575 posts
13 Jan 2010 10:35PM
Thumbs Up

Pinnaroo is a pretty **** place to kite anyway. I think that the only reason people tend to group there is because of the schools existance. If the school moved, then by the next 5 years that place would be full of people too...

I don't know if it has to be so official, but keeping general kiters and a kite school kind of seperate under some sort of mutual agreement has to happen. If we don't give schools space to teach, then there will be no lessons, and there will be a lot more unexperienced kiters out on the water causing havoc.

Spacemonkey!
SA, 2288 posts
14 Jan 2010 1:21AM
Thumbs Up

tailz8 said...

Spacemonkey,

Thats like building a housing development next to an international airport thats been around for 20 years, then when people move in they complain about the noise...


I see your point however, the kiteschool never owned the beach and the public always did a bit different IMO.

Bigwavedave
QLD, 2057 posts
14 Jan 2010 12:52AM
Thumbs Up

You whinge about schools and newbies? If it wasn't for this sport's growth potential the kite designers would not be wasting their time developing new and improved designs.

Schools have to operate somewhere, they pay lots of money in insurance and council licences etc. YES they DO own a bit of the beach and they probably taught you!!! If it wasn't for organised schools you would be paying a lot more for your kites. Do you want the sport to be closed to new participants? When is the cut-off time? Who decides?

Why would you want to kite in close proximity to a body dragging student? Why would you want to set up in a newbie's danger zone? Don't you remember how nervous you were when you were having lessons?

I think most of you complainers are just resentful of KH because he gets to make a living out of the sport and you don't. From what I see he gives back to the sport way more than he gets from it.

From the aerial shots I think you just don't like to walk too far to set up!!

Sheesh....this sport is full of whingers.....imagine if schools operated like surf schools!!! Churning out 50 or 60 people a day!!!

toddws
WA, 468 posts
13 Jan 2010 10:53PM
Thumbs Up

nebbian said...

Gstar said...

Here's your solution. Gets my vote anyway.



Not sure I agree with this, where you want to put the kite school is where the windsurfers launch and land from. I do both, and I'm a lot happier being around learner kiters when kiting than when windsurfing.

Perhaps this is what Kitehard is intending?


Nebbian has a point but perhaps the area should look more like this with the capable kiters staying upwind and the begginers getting the entrance to the beach!



This would still allow the better riders to hog the shoreline and bust-a-move for their kite-bi@ches (south of the missing fence) but give a wide berth to the learners. And lets remember the experienced guys are quite capable of going upwind as far as Hillary's Harbour without any drama.

And like some of the other post'ers added i do kite here also so this does affect me.

Gstar
WA, 391 posts
13 Jan 2010 10:58PM
Thumbs Up

nebbian said...

Gstar said...

Here's your solution. Gets my vote anyway.



Not sure I agree with this, where you want to put the kite school is where the windsurfers launch and land from. I do both, and I'm a lot happier being around learner kiters when kiting than when windsurfing.

Perhaps this is what Kitehard is intending?





I see your point but, switch the 2 kite zones around so the school is north of the point and downwind of experienced kiters. Learners are going to drift downwind all the time and it would be prudent to let the guys/girls that can stay upwind have the upwind spot. Don't you agree?

dave......
WA, 2119 posts
13 Jan 2010 10:58PM
Thumbs Up

Kitehard said...

dave...... said...

Instructing 10m upwind of others with any learner is crazy, especially if they were there first. This super qualified instructor should have known better.


Hi Dave,

Wave hogger was incorrect with his information. As exciting and sensational as his story sounds, it is not entirely correct. I would kindly ask that if you weren't there, to refrain from making your comments as you are working off heresay, and 2nd hand information.

Kind regards,

KH


What was the distance then Darren? I completed my IKO with you in 2005-2006. I heard from a number of sources it was about 10m tops 15m. The instructor made the student launch too close period! Try all the damage control you want. 6m kite brought it through the window in around 20 knots and got lifted.... Let me guess around 15m tops 20. Re-read your IKO book, what's the downwind safety zone.

OK I edited my original post to a general statement, but someone still got injured and was this through best and safest practice?

Kitehard
WA, 2782 posts
Site Sponsor
13 Jan 2010 11:00PM
Thumbs Up

Hmmmm,

Interesting about all the red thumbs considering all I'm asking for with most of my points is for people to adhere to the WAKSA C.L.E.A.R. recommendations, and nothing more.

Funny how you all support those rules so long as it doesn't inconvenience your daily kiting experience.

Does no one see that the few requests I have made will benefit ALL kiters in both convenience and safety? Don't bother, I don't expect an intelligent answer.

It should also be noted that most incidences on the beaches are not the students in our school, but learners and inexperienced intermediates who have long finished lessons and are starting to gain half a clue. We need to make it safer for ALL kiters including you.

So many close calls on the water and the beach of which about 5% is to do with the school. Mattyjee actually knows what's up

The only people I will respond to from this point on are people who ride at Pinna's and know the situation. No offense, but the rest of you are clueless to the situation at our beach. You wouldn't have a clue as to what AKS does for the local community and I'm not about to start spelling it out. The locals know!

Many thanks to the many locals who stopped by with words of support and for the concern for the injured learner today. Remember, this all came about because a fellow human, a fellow kiter was injured.

The rest of you can red thumb away and rabble on.

Cheers,

KH

Gstar
WA, 391 posts
13 Jan 2010 11:00PM
Thumbs Up

+ one on toddws new graphic. ^^^^

wavehogger
WA, 8 posts
13 Jan 2010 11:32PM
Thumbs Up

Windmill said...

Gstar said...

wavehogger said...

...I have to say that at least at Pinarroo we have a controlled environment which is nonexistant at Scarborough.

Elaborate please! I've kited Scarborough for 8 years and find your statement confusing!





I find this confusing as well?? I kite both spots daily (wind permitting) and Scarborough definitely doesn't seem as crazy as Pinna's on its day. (I do think Pinna's gets over populated which contributes to crazy)



At Pinarroo there is a kiteschool (more control), and we all know the area where you would most likely find newbies (more control) and since you know that you stand a good chance of getting a kite slamming into you or into your kite when on the water you should avoid the 100 meter stretch (more control) or at least take care when kiting or jumping close to shore. Most, not all, people are aware of the potantial danger and you therefore seldom find people swimming where all the newbies are. Imagine a newbie at Scarborough slamming a kite close to sunbathers or an abondoned kite with lines flying down the beach...it would be the last time any kite goes up there - this is what I mean with a more controlled environment.

Kudos to the kite school for taking this serious and putting suggestions out there to see if they can improve on their existing systems. All kiters can contribute to ensure a safer environment and we should assist the kite school since they are obviously trying to make kiting safer for all, including the public. Respect the newbies since they are not screwing up your session on purpose..stay bloody clear of them.

There is only one thing, besides no wind and ill health that can suspend kiting in Perth and thats kiting injuries...especially to the public. Safety must be our number 1 priority...the wild west days of slamming kites, jumping on the beach and ducking human projectiles on city beaches is a thing of the past. Please support the kite school since they are doing something positive about the incident and keep our beaches open!

SammyJ
WA, 570 posts
14 Jan 2010 1:34AM
Thumbs Up

mattyjee said...

Pinnaroo is a pretty **** place to kite anyway. I think that the only reason people tend to group there is because of the schools existance. If the school moved, then by the next 5 years that place would be full of people too...


I must admit to only ever kiting there once, it wasn't very pleasurable till everyone had pissed off and we started racing (Well sort of, if you can call 4 a race)

Anyway during my visit I found it was similar atmosphere to other locations with schools. I think the attraction for newbies that have been through the lesson process is they feel a sense of security if they venture back to where they learnt.This mentality is the back lash from the big free lesson with every purchase push which started up a few years back, those free lessons soon turned into "yeah come down mate we'll keep an eye out for ya".

The result is alot of fresh kiters at the same location, which in turn are launching each other probably trying to not inconvenance the advanced riders. Due to lack of experience and other circumstances their probably not doing the launchers checks. If I'm launching an unknown, I will always check their lines arn't crossed the bar is extended and held on the correct angle for launch.If they don't know what way to walk and expect me to move around with the kite, that's when it raises alarm bells. I believe the launcher can prevent a lot of the incidents that happen.

I think Darren and his team have handled this pretty well. The protocol's followed would be similar to what you would get at a mining company after an injury. It might be an over reaction intially, but as the school and locals work through it I'm sure there will be a compromise to suit everyone. It's great some locals both poley's and kiters are being proactive with the arial graphics. I don't agree with cordoning off the beach and water physically with cones, but segregation and maybe a movable free standing sign placed either end of lesson area lesson explaining potential hazards to the public would be appropriate.

Just my observations and opinions guy's, not intended to offend but more give idea's good luck.

sleek1
VIC, 672 posts
14 Jan 2010 10:16AM
Thumbs Up

Gstar said...

sleek1 said...

People new how to instruct once.


People "knew" how to write once.




Damm. spelling bee.

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
14 Jan 2010 8:51AM
Thumbs Up

Gstar said...

I see your point but, switch the 2 kite zones around so the school is north of the point and downwind of experienced kiters. Learners are going to drift downwind all the time and it would be prudent to let the guys/girls that can stay upwind have the upwind spot. Don't you agree?



I do agree that learners will drift downwind, it's just that windsurfers often don't understand that they will hit lines if they go upwind of a downed kite. I'd rather run over some lines on my kiteboard (with 2cm fins) than run over some lines with my windsurfer (25cm fin, it will snag the lines and cause major problems).

I also drew the zones based on my experience of what actually happens at Pinaroo -- you don't see too many experienced kiters walking all the way up to the point, they all launch at the end of the path.
It's the newbies who walk up to the point.

As it's my local I'm concerned with making it work properly for everyone...

sebol
WA, 753 posts
14 Jan 2010 10:29AM
Thumbs Up

What the hell is going on!!!

Darren, I always respect your knowledge and genuine passion for the sport but this is unbelievable.

In fact I actually did my first and only lesson at your school a few years back so I am thankfull for the opportunity to learn the correct safe practice.

However,as per your first post, there is a small element of danger in kiting and that is probably the reason why we enjoy it so much.

No matter how much you attempt to have safe practice, accidents do and will happen on very rare occasions

Any attempt to use this opportunity to claim ownership of the beach and cordon off your own little private area is a disgrace in my eyes.

Considering your record for years of teaching, there is probably 10 000 times more risk in crossing the road than in attending a lesson at your premises so why create agro with the established crew who are probably ex-students in any case?

Let's keep things open and friendly just as they have always been and everyone can take care of themselves.

Kitehard
WA, 2782 posts
Site Sponsor
14 Jan 2010 10:39AM
Thumbs Up

Hi Guys,

AKS has carried out a review on our processes internally and come up with some new ways of operating to improve the safety of our students and reduce the potential for accidents, but it needs to maybe go a step further.

I propose a meeting with concerned kiters from Pinnaroo to come and have a chat with us this afternoon after kiting to see if we can come up with some changes to make the beach safer. Unfortunately, wind direction, beach layout and council designated zones make moving the school impossible. If there was a way to move the school to a more appropriate location, we would have done that long ago.

We will provide a few coldies and hopefully if there is some action that we can take, we'll be able to make the beach safer which has been our intention since day dot.

We finish work at 6pm so if you want to just have an informal chat come see me anytime I'm not busy, or wait until about 6.15 when the school trailer should be a bit quieter and we can have an orderly meeting.

Cheers,

KH

whatthe
WA, 186 posts
14 Jan 2010 10:52AM
Thumbs Up

Good on you Darren for actually doing something proactive for the kiting community and general safety of beach users. I doubt that any of the negative posters in this thread have done anything practical themselves other than post some rabble on this forum.

I support your proposal to set aside an area for beginners to launch and body drag. It's not unreasonable in my eyes because you aren't restricting water space and everyone knows Pinaroo is full of beginner kiters. Most of the posters on this forum should be skilled enough to avoid beginners and kite upwind of them if they want to kite Pinaroo.

Maybe some of these people should try and kite at some spots in Sydney and Melbourne where space really is at a premium. You only spend 10 minutes on the beach rigging and launching a kite, so what does it matter if you can't do it wherever you like on the beach? Just laziness imo.

general_dude
WA, 150 posts
14 Jan 2010 11:03AM
Thumbs Up

Hi All,

I kite semi regularly at Pinaroo - more when I was beginning.

AKS IMHO run a really tight school & I would recommend them always. Darren is great. Will always help. Gives good (very very often free) advice on technique. Lend a bit of line when your bridle breaks!

The suggestions the AKS move are silly. Pinnas is a good learning spot.

The main problem at pinnas are that there are quite a few Beginner - nearly intermediates kiters who fancy themselves excellent. They kite too close to the newbies & give them a scare and then they do their half a#$d moves to show off in close. In an accident between newbie & intermediate kiter the fault is always the guys with the better skills. He/she should have stayed clear.

Pinnas is a learners beach. You wouldn't really want to kite there for any other reason. It's not flat (the knee breaking chop is famous) & there are no waves. It is actually a bit of a crap spot to kite.

I think that some cones on the beach seem like a good idea. Not for hard & fast enforcing of allowable locations, but to indicate the learning area. Downwind for newbies, up wind for those who can stay there. I personally sail up near the horse/dog beach anyway. The wind is better up there - no disruption from other kites. But I agree no one should ever ever think they own the beach.

Also to those making comments from QLD & NSW - WTF??? You guys have seemingly no idea of local conditions. The suggestion that AKS go North shows why you should stick to your own pond. The wind gets really squirrelly north near the ski area for some reason. I've been trapped out there as I'm sure most who've sailed there have experienced. You can't see this on GOOGLE MAPS!


Sad to hear that AKS had a bad incident. Hope the guys are ok.

Stay cool Darren. My guess is most of the negative posts on here are people who haven't seen you guys operate.



Kitehard
WA, 2782 posts
Site Sponsor
14 Jan 2010 11:05AM
Thumbs Up

Hi Guys,

Apart from the initial post about sectioning off the beach (which was a stunt to ensure response and discussion), I have not mentioned setting aside areas for anyone. It seems everyone has fixated on this and run with it like hell. It was a hoax, a stunt, to get people involved (and it worked ). Now lets get on with the second part of it .... finding a better way to do what we all love.

We believe the school has co-existed with the growing numbers of kiters, fishos, cat sailors and general public quite well over the years. We are just looking for ways to further improve safety for both learners and general beach users. We have done as much as we can within the school but more can be done with a little co-operation of the locals. This is why I invite all involved to a meeting this afteroon, to discuss ways to make it better for everyone.

If we are aware of a method of reducing danger and we don't do anything about it through complacency or apathy, and someone is badly injured or killed, aren't we guilty of inadvertently contributing to the incident?

Pinnaroo is a great spot that deserves protection. We can work together to improve it, it's now up to you .....

KH

rs83
WA, 23 posts
14 Jan 2010 11:05AM
Thumbs Up

Maybe kite boarding should just be banned completely - that would be much safer...

GreenPat
QLD, 4083 posts
14 Jan 2010 1:09PM
Thumbs Up

RedKite said...

The thumbs for Kitehard's last post and pfr's post, give a clear picture of what the kite communitiy thinks about AKS suggestions.


They give a clear picture to me that the kite community is a bunch of selfish inconsiderate r-soles. Is it also degenerating to the same primitive tribalism that other parts of Australian culture seem to be heading? pfr threatened violence against other kiters. Threatened to kill the instructors if they came to his beach. Does everyone who green thumbed that post feel the same way? I am quite thoroughly disgusted, and since my green thumbs for Darren don't show up against the sea of red, I figured it was time to voice my opinion.

Anyone who thinks violence is the answer should go and live in a country that lives by those values. Anyone who thinks Australia is a first world, civilised country, and we should behave as such - well that's what I believe in. And respect for other kiters, especially beginners.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing General


"Accident @ Pinnaroo" started by wavehogger