Forums > Kitesurfing General

The definitive light wind argument

Reply
Created by goog64 > 9 months ago, 16 Mar 2009
Beersy
TAS, 753 posts
17 Mar 2009 12:20PM
Thumbs Up

Move to Darwin and you'll learn to kite in light winds pretty quick

17 Mar 2009 12:49PM
Thumbs Up

goog64 said...

Here's a selection from the replies to my original question. Anyone notice a problem....
1. I think you can forget about 12-14 knots in the surf if you weigh 90kg
2. Can kite easy in 10 to 12 knts and 2to 3 foot surf with 10mtr rebel and 6'4 nsp fish lots of fun
3. use a kite no bigger than a 10m
4. Size does matter, end of story....the bigger kite will always be more powerful



Goog64

Opinions are like a***holes, we all have one. We are all full of it, like Schmik said.

On point 1
Well I've seen guys going it and enjoying themselves. Rich Stenning former double Aust Nat champ (80-85kgs') is often at Wanda in waves on a skimboard or Underground Freewave with no fins, in marginal conditions of 12-14 knots. Richies biggest kite is an 11M Cabrinha CB IDS. I see others there too on kites up to 14M in size, but I rarely see any kites in the surf bigger than that, that are seriously trying to ride waves. Anything over 14M just moves too slowly and will end up either not fun or in the water and getting pounded by waves and also not fun.


On point 2
No way, not riding upwind, downwinder maybe. I'm sure the rider does kite in waves with that board, but not in 10 knots, not upwind and not in fast breaking waves. The real wind will be more like 12-14 knots, he just does not realise it.
10 knots means that the wind is peaking at 10 knots and there will be lulls below, I cannot get going in flat water, upwind, on an Ozone Light XC 14M on an huge 1.44x46 TT in less that 12 knots. On a bigger inflatable on the same board I can go as low as 8-10 knots, I've used many different brands of big inflatables and foils.

On point 3
Use a faster flying and quicker turning modern kite, like the 13M Rev2 and Rev1, Ozone Light XC 12M or 14M, Best Waroo 09 13M, 08 is ok too, SS RPM 14M or 12M, etc, etc.

On point 4
True, but only up to a point as I've said above, bigger than 14M and I've never seen or flown a kite that moves quick enough to be regarded as a serious wave kite, although a bigger kite can still get you out in the ocean in light winds, you just might not be able to get in amongst the waves with it.
The bigger the kite, the better the board and kite skills need to be to ride in waves, or better put, the more experienced a rider is with that sort of gear in those lighter conditions the better they will do.

90kg does not mean you cannot surf in 12-14 knots, but that wind is really the lower end of the spectrum and you will have a lot more fun in just couple of knots more, like 14-16 knots (still on a 11-14M kite/and larger board combo).

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve

T one
NT, 321 posts
17 Mar 2009 11:50AM
Thumbs Up

Beersy said...

Move to Darwin and you'll learn to kite in light winds pretty quick


Damn right... especially at the moment... what wet season???
however, back on topic, my 16m 08 flow with the 144 underground (very flat board) gets me going in some pretty light stuff, bit hard to say exactly cos it seems that no two wind meters are the same, but i'd say upwind in maybe 10 or 11. once you get used to the lead time big kites can be fun... i have a raymarine wind meter (yacht racing type) sitting around doing nothing, so might have to add to the seabreeze knowledgebase with some more hard data

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
17 Mar 2009 1:24PM
Thumbs Up

Anyone who says that the max power you can get is with a Bandit 14 or Cab 16m needs to try an ultra flat. It ****s all over any of these for low end because the projected area of the kite is far bigger.

A ultra flat 15m has the same power as a 19/20m bow kite. If you don't believe me, try one and prove me wrong, I have nothing to gain, I ride a Rev.

There are a couple of companies that make them, Fluid is one, Wind-x are another, but I think the Fluid is the only one available locally.

Its the only kite that has low end close to a foil.

17 Mar 2009 1:37PM
Thumbs Up

Saffer said...

Anyone who says that the max power you can get is with a Bandit 14 or Cab 16m needs to try an ultra flat. It ****s all over any of these for low end because the projected area of the kite is far bigger.

A ultra flat 15m has the same power as a 19/20m bow kite. If you don't believe me, try one and prove me wrong, I have nothing to gain, I ride a Rev.

There are a couple of companies that make them, Fluid is one, Wind-x are another, but I think the Fluid is the only one available locally.

Its the only kite that has low end close to a foil.




I've tried one last winter, they need more development, they turn toooooo sloooooooow, very good bottom end though. The Kite I tried had probaly the worst bar I've ever seen, really crappy and dangerous, plus it was a 2:1 system, which no-one wants anymore.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve

Martiin
17 posts
17 Mar 2009 11:50AM
Thumbs Up

Upwind in 4knots?



Only set you back about 5 Grand.

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
17 Mar 2009 2:09PM
Thumbs Up

Kitepower Australia said...

Saffer said...

Anyone who says that the max power you can get is with a Bandit 14 or Cab 16m needs to try an ultra flat. It ****s all over any of these for low end because the projected area of the kite is far bigger.

A ultra flat 15m has the same power as a 19/20m bow kite. If you don't believe me, try one and prove me wrong, I have nothing to gain, I ride a Rev.

There are a couple of companies that make them, Fluid is one, Wind-x are another, but I think the Fluid is the only one available locally.

Its the only kite that has low end close to a foil.




I've tried one last winter, they need more development, they turn toooooo sloooooooow, very good bottom end though. The Kite I tried had probaly the worst bar I've ever seen, really crappy and dangerous, plus it was a 2:1 system, which no-one wants anymore.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve




That must have been one of the first generation ones, Steve. The one I tried was 1:1 and had the same bar setup as the Liquid Force Havoc. If I remember correctly, it was one of the 09 prototypes.

The 15m I tried still turned slowish, but it was grunty enough for me not to have to move it in very light winds. It may timing of jumps a little harder to get used to but I was jumping in conditions I would normally not be able to ride in so you can argue that slow turning is a slight compromise.

17 Mar 2009 2:21PM
Thumbs Up

Martiin said...

Upwind in 4knots?



Only set you back about 5 Grand.


No, more like double that IMO, the meter was way too close the ground to get an accurate reading of the wind the kite was "seeing".
There are signs of whitecaps, means its more like 7-8 knots, still impressive, and great skill needed to keep the SA kite out of the water and ride the foil board, kite will not relaunch in such light winds.

@Saffer
Yeah, overall the quality was poor would be keen to see the later versions, it seemed like it had potential. Not sure that its aimed at super light wind kiting though, thats just a side benefit of extreme projected area bow designs.
Turning speed of these super high ar/pa kites needs to be sorted, then inflatos will give the big foils a serious run for their money.
The 17M Contra2 came close to the performance of the SA 19M that was here in Sydney last year, he had the legs on me by about 2-3 knots at most, but the inflato had a much better overall wind range and better turning, the SA is also quite slow turning.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
17 Mar 2009 2:32PM
Thumbs Up

Kitepower Australia said...
@Saffer
Yeah, overall the quality was poor would be keen to see the later versions, it seemed like it had potential. Not sure that its aimed at super light wind kiting though, thats just a side benefit of extreme projected area bow designs.
Turning speed of these super high ar/pa kites needs to be sorted, then inflatos will give the big foils a serious run for their money.
The 17M Contra2 came close to the performance of the SA 19M that was here in Sydney last year, he had the legs on me by about 2-3 knots at most, but the inflato had a much better overall wind range and better turning, the SA is also quite slow turning.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve


Hi Steve

I suggest you try get a new demo model from Steve at Fluid to try out. The quality of the kite itself was fine. I couldn't comment on the bar, the bar wasn't a production bar but looked the same as a LF one.

When Bruno first released them it didn't seem like they were not aimed at light wind (4.5m kite with the power of a larger kite) but the 15m one I tried killed that argument completely. It out grunts any kite I have tried to date including the 17m Contra2 and it does so substantially. I'd love to try it side by side with a SA2 to see how close they are. The local pricing was reasonable as well, I couldn't justify a SA2 for the odd lightwind session but for the price of these, it becomes a feasible option to try sneak past the wife.

onepump
WA, 66 posts
17 Mar 2009 12:45PM
Thumbs Up

Slow turning, slow turning, scmhow turning.

We're talking about light winds here people. Adjust your ride style to suit the conditions, kiting is about running with nature, not conquering it.

I love psyching up for a light wind session on a SS TD16m (slow turning and I love it) by cruising down to the beach real slow like with some beach boys on the system and then hitting the waves on a skim board and carving it real slow and lazy like.

"drive slow homey, put dem hazard lights on when you see dem hos"

Peace

schmik
NSW, 235 posts
17 Mar 2009 6:53PM
Thumbs Up

I have tried the Silver Arrow 2 19m. I was able to hold my ground at 6-7kn on a door style twinne (164 x 45). I know it was 6-7 because that is where my standard speed 2 15m won't stay in the sky.... and it wouldn't. I prefer the 15 to the 19 because it turns soooo fast ;)

Seriously... it turns a fair bit faster than the 19 but for me to have any fun it needs 11kn. i.e staying upwind and small jumps. All of this is on flat water. The surf is a different beast. It all comes down to dollars.... you can get a psycho 4 15 or 19 in the silver arrow fabric. They turn nicely and will be fine in 12-14kn but the price.....ouch the price.

I agree with steve that the difference between foild and LEI will narrow. The only standout will be the silver arrow. In this case is just comes down to weight. The kite will fly up to the top of the window in nearly nothing because it weighs nearly nothing.

BTW relaunch is pretty easy for any foil (except maybe PL) in > 10kn.

As ai said... depends on money and how often you get light winds.

mike

Surfrod66
NSW, 665 posts
17 Mar 2009 8:05PM
Thumbs Up

Just wanted to add something to my previous post.
1. KITEHARD is totally correct if you are talking about direct on shore you can forget it you need wind.
I assumed you mean cross onshore the the apparent wind gennerated by the wave makes a big difference.
2.The surfboard you pick must be wide Big fish or hybrid quad.
3.The boards the botany bay boys are talking about(SS glide etc) may work in the flat water of the bay,but as soon as you cross waves you need fins..
Hope this helps.

richierich
NSW, 226 posts
18 Mar 2009 12:11PM
Thumbs Up

Here's my two bobs worth,
I spend a lot of time kiting in less than 10 knots (like yesterday- have a look at the graphs, i think there was actually about 6-7 knots on the beach-right Mick?) with my 10m switchblade. The key is using the right board -skimboard- and the right part of the water -only the first 3m or so out where the water pushing back straight into the wind. Forget about getting 'out back' when there is little wind plus there is lots of fun to be had on the shore break.
Yesterday there was a fellow with 16m Naish that could not get moving as he had a twin tip with fins and was trying to start in a foot of water- i agree with the earlier posters it can't be done in such light wind regardless on the size of kite. He said he is going to look for a skimboard.
The main reason that kiting in such little wind can be done is you can get apparent wind happening when you run cross/upwind and skim on the wet sand. The sand is holding you up so the wind doens't have to. Sometimes -like yesterday- when its extremely light you get going fine on the wet sand and as soon as you get a bit deeper out you sink. This is when you have to loop the kite and pull yourself back to the wet sand again.
Also the skimboard having no fins has very little drag even in the deeper water. My surfboard has much more drag because of the fins so need more wind for it or take the fins off.
Best conditions for kite skimboarding is when there is a steep bank into the water and big waves so there is more water in the shore break. Ideally you want 15-20 knots but can easily go once the kite can be held happily in the edge of the window-6-7 knots.
The photos that Vasco took and stitched together here had very little wind but it was a great session as there was lots of water shooting back out to sea.
I used to hate onshore wind when i rode twin tips all the time, now i much prefer this direction it if the wind is less than 12 knots. Hope this can be helpful to you all.
Rich






kitesurfbali
WA, 531 posts
18 Mar 2009 12:03PM
Thumbs Up

Z try to get the Ozone Light 14m from Steve for a test ride and compare with the Bandit 14m...

I flown both (and sell both) and in my opinion the Ozone is a much nicer kite to fly in light wind.. But I like to have someone else opinion.
Bye Jankie

harry potter
VIC, 2777 posts
19 Mar 2009 5:22PM
Thumbs Up

my 2cents....

Turning speed !!!! Need to find the perfect balance between kite size and turning speed. Big KItes are slow and take a long time to turn back into the powerzone...small kites are fast and are easier to be kept in the powerzone with more power strokes.

I found ,with my old SB3 8m i could get going in about 15knots on a 126cm board on my 12m about the same.

So back where you started I guess

KitingCasey
QLD, 242 posts
19 Mar 2009 6:57PM
Thumbs Up

Why go out just go surfing instead?!?

warwickl
NSW, 2224 posts
19 Mar 2009 9:51PM
Thumbs Up

I bought a Hobbie peddle and paddle kayak great for many mussels but not the same as 20kn wind

goog64
NSW, 22 posts
20 Mar 2009 10:14AM
Thumbs Up

harry potter said...


I found ,with my old SB3 8m i could get going in about 15knots on a 126cm board on my 12m about the same.



Hi HP,
Just to clarify: you mean your 8m and 12m kites got you going about the same in 15 knots?

Wisha
SA, 255 posts
27 Mar 2009 2:03AM
Thumbs Up

I use a 16m Waroo with line extensions. Turns really well for a big kite. Gets going on almost nothing, plus there is a light wind bridle mod for it. Change it back for 14knots plus. 06 model is cheap as!

Ocean Rodeo One. Really flat bow kites, get going on not much. However, have weight issues (battle tanks) and turn like an old bus.

Got to agree on the Glide for a light wind board. Sensational. No rocker though so you will bite it in chop.

As for bottom end power, and if you are looking to do a light down wind session the Bandits seem the goods.

Summary: Use longer lines (30m), Get a big bar (faster turning) ,Get a fat board with little rocker.

waxman
SA, 1390 posts
27 Mar 2009 10:11AM
Thumbs Up

Had a light wind session this week only three made it out in the 10kts i had a 15m rev and a nobile skim weighing 90 kgs had a bit of a walk after each run. The other lad had a 13m rev and a glide weighing around 70kgs he was cruising and holding ground. The 3rd kiter had a psyco 3 15m and a 137 555 nobile board and he would weigh around the 90kg mark and he was ridding powered and going upwind. I took the glide for a spin and it was better than the skim i actualy held ground. but the flysurfer was definatly the go in the light stuff a couple more kts and you would be able to throw some tricks. a bit pricey though could fit a 40 inch flatscreen to my van and just chill out at the beach and watch kite vids for the same price.

Jacques
NSW, 159 posts
27 Mar 2009 2:01PM
Thumbs Up

waxman said...
The 3rd kiter had a psyco 3 15m and a 137 555 nobile board and he would weigh around the 90kg mark and he was ridding powered and going upwind.

The Psycho3 does not exist in 15m (only 13 or 17). It may have been a Psycho4 or a Speed2, all three kites are actually completly dfifferent from each other... if comparing same sizes, the Speed2 is much more powerfull than the Psychos and light wind perf differes by quite a large amount between the 2.

Buell
SA, 89 posts
27 Mar 2009 1:51PM
Thumbs Up


I'm the one with the Psycho, its PS4 in 15m, I weigh 80kgs. In the gusts (10-12knts ?) I managed a couple of small jumps (real small !!) but in the lulls it was a case of just cruise along and get some ground upwind

Cheers

walshd
SA, 601 posts
27 Mar 2009 3:49PM
Thumbs Up

I were on the 13 rev and glide (really weight 85kgs)

Wind was 10knts with 13-14knt gusts. In this we were all frantically signing our kites and I were about on par with the flysurfer.

When waxy got sick of walking he packed up and the wind gained a few knots. Buell and I could park our kites and cruise along nicely. But still, throwing kiteloops only just got me off the water to do a backroll.

Wind then dropped to about 7-10knts and I gave up.

I then had a shot of the flysurfer in this pi$$weak wind with no success.

In conclusion, even a flysurfer needs 10knts behind it. I cant back this up, but I'd expect youd be able to just park and cruise the flysurfer in 10knts on the glide, whereas I'd be signing flat out on the rev.

onepump
WA, 66 posts
27 Mar 2009 9:28PM
Thumbs Up

richierich said...

The key is using the right board -skimboard- and the right part of the water





Word.

Great photo sequence. I remember watching you at Wanda a couple of years ago on the Zappa when I lived in Sydneytown.
You were my inspiration to buy a skimboard dude. I love it to death. It's hard to find a better spot than Wanda but, cause the sand is so steep and it's often a very onshore wind.

Peace

Jon
NSW, 80 posts
2 Apr 2009 2:22AM
Thumbs Up

Earlier in the thread North Rebel 16m's were mentioned on a couple of occasions. Anymore opinions on them



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing General


"The definitive light wind argument" started by goog64