Forums > Kitesurfing General

passing windsurfers

Reply
Created by Leech > 9 months ago, 30 Dec 2008
Leech
WA, 1933 posts
30 Dec 2008 3:12PM
Thumbs Up

Hi I'm a windsurfer and there are often kiters at the breaks where I sail.

Just wanted some advice for protocol/manners when passing. How close can we pass?

Is it a problem to fly your kite higher as we pass (as seems to be the usual way things happen when windsurfer is downwind)?

Anything else I should be aware of? (other than that windsurfing is gay and i should get a kite etc etc. boring.)

I want to improve the stoke on the water between all wave riders so a little education will help.

Thanks!

poor relative
WA, 9089 posts
30 Dec 2008 3:36PM
Thumbs Up

When kites pass other windsurfers/kiters the rule of thumb is upwind kite high downwind kite low.
That being the case then you can come as close as you like.

However not all kiters seem to be aware of this basic rule which can lead to 'complications'

Personally if i turn up at a spot and there are other kiters out i watch for a while and make a note of who i should avoid/stay upwind of. They are easy to spot

IanR
NSW, 1261 posts
30 Dec 2008 6:22PM
Thumbs Up

As PR said.
The kite is high if we want to go upwind of someone.
Low if we are going down wind
I try to pass sailboarders on the downwind side it seems to make them happier.
Please don't play the bear off game MY kites low and I'm bearing off even though I'm on starboard tack so the Sailboarder bears off. That just being annoying!!!
If the sailboard is passing downwind don't get to close and make us move our kite to dead vertical as we lose power and may be force to jump you

slimjim
NSW, 54 posts
30 Dec 2008 6:28PM
Thumbs Up

Nice to see Windsurfers with a posative attitude out there.

Personally I get a bit nervous when a windsurfer gets too close down wind of me, just in case a big gust comes through. I have been riding toe side and a poley has come up from my blind side fast and gave me a start. I know you should always look before jibing or anything though but distance is always a good safety measure. I try to give Poley's plenty of space too.

Leech
WA, 1933 posts
30 Dec 2008 4:43PM
Thumbs Up

So can an experienced kiter fly the kite high quickly without upsetting his/her ride? For example if they haven't seen the downwind windsurfer till the last minute?

(i'm not going anywhere with this, just thinking of scenarios where i'd like to be better prepared).

Kalavas
WA, 146 posts
30 Dec 2008 5:02PM
Thumbs Up

"Lifting" the kite too quickly may boost the kiter and send them down wind anyway. That's my experience, but I would rate myself an inexperienced kiter. Unfortunetly we don't have special high visibility n00b wetsuits, so I'd assume everyone is inexperienced until it's proven otherwise.

Gorgo
VIC, 4960 posts
30 Dec 2008 7:20PM
Thumbs Up

If you can't make eye contact with someone and you think a collision is imminent, or fairly possible, then you should gybe and get away from them.

Never ride behind and just downwind of anyone. You are blocking their escape route and chances are they will clean you up when they gybe.

Kites are generally far more manouverable than sailboards and we can make room for you pretty easily provided we can see you.

GreenPat
QLD, 4083 posts
30 Dec 2008 6:35PM
Thumbs Up

Leech said...

So can an experienced kiter fly the kite high quickly without upsetting his/her ride?


To answer your question directly: Yes. But as Mr. Kalavas points out, how can you tell who that is?

My two cents, be doubly careful near kiters wave riding. In a wave they are (ok, I am) focussed more on the wave and the board, and just flying the kite by feel. They (I) just keep it from crashing and can forget how close it can get to the water. Some will (I usually) try and get amongst the waves with a whole lot of room to spare, more than just regular riding, but if things get crowded...

SaveTheWhales
WA, 1874 posts
30 Dec 2008 7:03PM
Thumbs Up

Hey Leech

Just adding a bit of a twist to the helpfull information...

Unfortunately there is in every sport, dis-curteous people will do as they please - kiteboarding included. Though we try our hardest to emphasis right of way, it is still much Safer to make a definate heading change (not minor deviation) to show this type of person your intentions... as they may not actually know any rules thus there actions.

Also NEVER test who has right of way as fully powered kitelines can cause serious injury

As mentioned above, watch for a while - they stick out like dogs B#lls & keep clear of them, unfortunately .

We try our best for the good of all beach users



Andrash
WA, 637 posts
30 Dec 2008 10:49PM
Thumbs Up

Leech said...

Hi I'm a windsurfer and there are often kiters at the breaks where I sail.



Welcome in the forum and on the surf as well!!

Leech said...


Is it a problem to fly your kite higher as we pass (as seems to be the usual way things happen when windsurfer is downwind)?

...no, it is not at all....what you need to remember: most windsurfers are at least intermediate riders, but about 1/3 of kiters are pretty much beginners.....(ignore the small percentage of ignorants...)
Leech said...



Anything else I should be aware of? (other than that windsurfing is gay and i should get a kite etc etc. boring.)


Kiters can change track very quickly, but they are hopeless without the power of the kite.....so when you see a kiter in the water struggling to relaunch or water start, you are better stay upwind without jumping....
...we like to look out and look after each other and wave "hello" to each other on the water.....and as it was pointed out, you can recognize quickly who you may want to be aware of......no big deal, though, as most of us are out there to have a break and have fun....

Dawn Patrol
WA, 1991 posts
30 Dec 2008 11:09PM
Thumbs Up

Yes it can be safe to be quite close downwind when the kite is high. As long as the kiter is not a learner, you would be unlucky to get taken out.
It is no hassle at all to get the kite high enough to go over the height of the mast.

I'm aware windsurfers are uneasy being close downwind of kiters, so if it will be close, i go downwind quickly so they can go upwind of me. If i were a windsurfer it is what i would prefer.

fver
WA, 453 posts
30 Dec 2008 11:21PM
Thumbs Up

Leech said...



Is it a problem to fly your kite higher as we pass (as seems to be the usual way things happen when windsurfer is downwind)?



Hi Leech,
Welcome to our kitesurfing world

I d like to add some input to the responses regarding the above query.

Windsurfers are out when it is pretty windy (>22-25 knots?). During these days, kiters are generally significantly powered up and thus might push themselves towards the limits of their skills. This is something to keep in mind.

Lifting the kite to pass someone else who is downwind is generally not a problem. However, lifting the kite means lifting the pull and thus decreasing the board edge that stick the kiter to the water. If the kiter is near the upper limit of the wind range for his kite, and thus rides powered up, the kitesurfer might lose his board edge by lifting his kite and thus will be dragued downwind. The kiter always have the option to stop by dropping his bum into the water.

I hope this helps.

Cheers,

Fred








Knickers
WA, 256 posts
31 Dec 2008 9:27AM
Thumbs Up

IanR said...

As PR said.
I try to pass sailboarders on the downwind side it seems to make them happier.
Please don't play the bear off game MY kites low and I'm bearing off even though I'm on starboard tack so the Sailboarder bears off. That just being annoying!!!


^^^
Similar, even if I am on starboard tack I feel happier to bear away downwind of a windsurfer on opposing tack (and I make an obvious change of direction to go downwind, and dropping my kite to show my intentions).
I was MEGA peeved by the attitude of a woman windsurfer at Cott one session who on coming up to pass, repeatedly changed her line to bear away and force me more and more downwind (like about 4 or 5 times on each pass, in both directions, for about 10 passes!), ending up each time with me going full speed direct downwind and her still inisting on giving me a good carving spray when she finally passed about 1m upwind of me [}:)]

cRAZY Canuk
NSW, 2528 posts
31 Dec 2008 11:28AM
Thumbs Up

Leech said...

Hi I'm a windsurfer and there are often kiters at the breaks where I sail.

Just wanted some advice for protocol/manners when passing. How close can we pass?

Is it a problem to fly your kite higher as we pass (as seems to be the usual way things happen when windsurfer is downwind)?

Anything else I should be aware of? (other than that windsurfing is gay and i should get a kite etc etc. boring.)

I want to improve the stoke on the water between all wave riders so a little education will help.

Thanks!


My thought is if you can go to windward of a kiter it's probably the best way of getting around them. You never know what a kiter is going to do and 70% of them jump/turn/gybe.... with out a look or a care. If you have to go down wind of a kiter I'd say 10m (min.) it would give you "some" space between the lines and the tip of the mast if they where to dive the kite as you went by (see they don't care a little higher up)

poor relative said...

When kites pass other windsurfers/kiters the rule of thumb is upwind kite high downwind kite low.
That being the case then you can come as close as you like.

However not all kiters seem to be aware of this basic rule which can lead to 'complications'

Personally if i turn up at a spot and there are other kiters out i watch for a while and make a note of who i should avoid/stay upwind of. They are easy to spot


It's funny you bring this up PR. I was at a spot (that shall not be named) watching the kiting the last couple days and I was appaulled by the way people (kiters) where interacting on the water. No one used any of the right of way rules it was pretty sad.

mathew
QLD, 2037 posts
31 Dec 2008 10:59AM
Thumbs Up

Knickers said...

IanR said...

As PR said.
I try to pass sailboarders on the downwind side it seems to make them happier.
Please don't play the bear off game MY kites low and I'm bearing off even though I'm on starboard tack so the Sailboarder bears off. That just being annoying!!!


^^^
Similar, even if I am on starboard tack I feel happier to bear away downwind of a windsurfer on opposing tack (and I make an obvious change of direction to go downwind, and dropping my kite to show my intentions).
I was MEGA peeved by the attitude of a woman windsurfer at Cott one session who on coming up to pass, repeatedly changed her line to bear away and force me more and more downwind (like about 4 or 5 times on each pass, in both directions, for about 10 passes!), ending up each time with me going full speed direct downwind and her still inisting on giving me a good carving spray when she finally passed about 1m upwind of me [}:)]


hmm... if you are on starboard tack, you are not meant to change course once there is a possibiltiy of collision -> you must hold your line and allow the port-tack craft enough time to determine the best possible change of direction... without more information on which direction you/she were travelling, both of you may have/not-had right of way.

As for the kite high/low thing... some kiters sail with the kite very high, then only dip slightly, while others fly the kite lower. I regularily see experienced kiters not able to determine how high a kite an oncoming sailor -> how can you expect non-kiters to figure this out, when kiters cant determine it?

Bigwavedave
QLD, 2057 posts
31 Dec 2008 11:06AM
Thumbs Up

Passing a windsurfer sounds painful.

richswing
WA, 724 posts
31 Dec 2008 11:26AM
Thumbs Up

NICE!

Buell
SA, 89 posts
31 Dec 2008 1:51PM
Thumbs Up

It’s the same as the road rules, they are there so everyone knows what everyone else is going to do.

Unfortunately a small minority choose to ignore the basic rules on the road as well as the water.

The right of way rules should be addressed at the lesson stage for kiters and sailboarders but this does not seem to be happening. I don’t recall getting much info during my kiting lesson’s even though the info on safety and kite control was very good.

Peer pressure is sometimes the only way to fix issues like this, let people know what they are doing wrong, do it nicely though, it’s not hard.

One thing that’s been forgotten in this debate is the transition from the beach to the water and back. This is a high risk time for kiter’s and the normal give way rules should be suspended. Give people the room they need to get safely on and off the water.

kitecrazzzy
WA, 2184 posts
31 Dec 2008 12:27PM
Thumbs Up

Given the circumstance of two kiters about to cross in close proximity (no one is obviously upwind) some basic principles apply.
Kiters have the advantage of being able to determine the skill level of the other kiter. If they are deemed competent someone will have to give way; To signal their intention they either put their kite high and (sometimes) edge harder (causes a bigger spray for 2 seconds or so) or they put it low and (sometimes) throw a bit of back spray (spray goes upwind). If it is a packed spot and a collision is imminent both kiters will change direction/stop or very quickly lose ground down wind (by method of down loop or something else). This only happens when other factors are at play such as a downed kite in the mix. Competent kiters can stop very quickly.
If it is believed that the other kiter is a beginner the competent kiter will go for the upwind pass or stay away from them.

Generally beginners go down wind for safety reasons. Kiters will also generally go down wind of a windsurfer out of good will in the belief that windsurfers are **** scared of kite lines near them. Also the spray from a close passing kite hurts.

Competent kiters are drastically different to beginners hence the reasons for avoiding beginners and taking note of them (so you can remember to stay away from them)

To answer the question; you can pass as close down wind of a competent kiter as you like but they would never expect you to do it!

poor relative
WA, 9089 posts
31 Dec 2008 3:10PM
Thumbs Up

Another way round it is to communicate.

Talking goes a long way over a cod beer or two in the car park after a mint session.

By making friends, having a chat sharing a beer you could probably iron out heaps of little issues and gain a better understanding of whats going on or how things could be better.

Most kiters like beer.

knot board
QLD, 1241 posts
31 Dec 2008 4:27PM
Thumbs Up

poor relative said...

Another way round it is to communicate.

Talking goes a long way over a cod beer or two in the car park after a mint session.

By making friends, having a chat sharing a beer you could probably iron out heaps of little issues and gain a better understanding of whats going on or how things could be better.

Most kiters like beer.



ewww, cod beer
You guys are stranger than I thought

GreenPat
QLD, 4083 posts
31 Dec 2008 4:32PM
Thumbs Up

It's not cod beer, but almost as good. A Northern Brown Ale from the home brew shop, I just bought these babies home on Monday.



edit: yes, that is the full box set of James Bond in the background.

Andrash
WA, 637 posts
31 Dec 2008 3:46PM
Thumbs Up

GreenPat said...

It's not cod beer, but almost as good. A Northern Brown Ale from the home brew shop, I just bought these babies home on Monday.



edit: yes, that is the full box set of James Bond in the background.


Wow...you, sure, will make lots of friends with these babies after the next session at Scarb...

Leech
WA, 1933 posts
1 Jan 2009 2:36AM
Thumbs Up

Excellent! Thanks for the info, I've learned a lot.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing General


"passing windsurfers" started by Leech