Forums > Kitesurfing Victoria

Beginners at Brighton

Reply
Created by tomvonoslo > 9 months ago, 31 Mar 2012
tomvonoslo
VIC, 30 posts
1 Apr 2012 12:18AM
Thumbs Up

Sorry to bring this up but I would encourage absolute beginners not to go out at Brighton Beach. There are submerged reefs and rocks both sides, strong undercurrents, and little space for errors. To kitesurf there, you must be able to go upwind and otherwise have a fair levels of skills, especially in the onshores (westerlies).
Today my kite got tangled by an absolute beginner who just steered his kite the wrong way as he attempted to start from shore. We got out of it really lucky, but it was a potentially dangerous situation. The German Kitesurfing champion Silke Gorldt died during a kiting contest in 2002, after being slammed into onshore obstacles by her and another kite that had gotten tangled into hers. Others, two.
Sorry for yelling at you there buddy but that situation was entirely unnecessary and avoidable. Apart from that, very happy for everyone who is entering the sport.

juggler
VIC, 243 posts
1 Apr 2012 12:31AM
Thumbs Up

or maybe beginners shouldn't kite at brighton in a northerly, its was strong & gusty today. ive been kiting 5 years & was on my 7m
Of if your a nuff nuff with no co-ordination, concider knitting

axis
VIC, 399 posts
1 Apr 2012 9:12AM
Thumbs Up

Yep don't go out there in a notherly unless you know what you are doing and are prepared to swim, self rescue or potentially ditch your kite.

Apart from that, how was it? Couldn't get out yesterday.

juggler
VIC, 243 posts
1 Apr 2012 11:17AM
Thumbs Up

Off and on, hung around and went out on the southerly change but that went south east, good Ti get wet

Kazan
QLD, 699 posts
1 Apr 2012 9:42PM
Thumbs Up

I hear ya Tomvo... However, how does a rant on these forums about what you experienced is sending the right message to the right people? For one, most likely that beginner is not a forum member, and two he is probably one of many it seems that are sold equipment by shops that should at least insist the beginner get professional lessons. I know as a consumer you have the right to purchase a product and use it with owner onus applies. I guess there is no rule stipulating to retailers that 'dangerous goods' (kiting is dangerous in the wrong hands) should come with some form of mandantory licensing. And in a way yes, i admit it, but I think kite surfing should have its levels of qualifications and certifications - similar to diving. But who is going to police it at the beach?! Who is going to stop you and ask for a card proving you have reached a competent level of training and experience? No one. It's impossible to police.
So really the onus comes down to the individual and yes to us as a community of ksurfers. We should shoulder some of the blame for accidents especially if we are in the immediate vicinity.
If you see a beginner struggling, drop your bar / kite / etc and offer to assist. Don't knod your head in the usual 'i hate noob' fashion. Offer to help and at least prevent a possile disaster to him and others. I've done this many times and many beginners are reluctant to making mistakes in the presence of those more experienced. But the majority appreciate the offer and learn to kite another day. I've asked guys if they need help and some - not all, try to think they know and don't need the help. Yet they don't launch properly, they launch to fast or try to self launch with disasterous results. In the end it's up to the individual. We cannot force anyone to do anything.
Look, it frustrates me no end when i see people (whether they are experienced or not) taking stupid risks, rushing setting up and suddenly abort and expect others to save their kite or board downwind. It's tempting to shout and call them d$wats, but I hope we are above that and take a deep breath with a smile and an offer of help.
It would certainly go a long way for them and for our sport in general.

gazman2
VIC, 112 posts
1 Apr 2012 11:39PM
Thumbs Up

Kazan you have got it right with helping the biginners.Most people ive talked to at the beach dont mind alittle advice on the local spot.But i also think that the more experienced riders should give them alittle more space(its a big lot of water out there).

MiniMx
8 posts
3 Apr 2012 12:46PM
Thumbs Up

Well, don't know if you are talking about the incident I saw in the afternoon, but the wind was no longer northely then....

Then, just to be the devil's advocate, basic priority rules say that the kitter leaving the beach has priority... so what were you doing so close, being that experienced, you should have turned before...

but don't get it wrong, I'm far from defending that other guy... just a bit upset of these guys always blaming so called beginners this way. We all started at some point and all made mistakes. Having a few signs, especially on a kite beach like Brighton's, that would remind a bit of the basic rules like priority and so on might not be a bad idea. Then, it's our responsability to keep it friendly, don't want to end up like surfer claiming their waves... so be helpful to beginners, tell them when they should maybe not get out, but for their sake, stop blaming them all the time...

foorked
VIC, 152 posts
3 Apr 2012 2:59PM
Thumbs Up

a

Pickle
QLD, 33 posts
4 Apr 2012 1:12PM
Thumbs Up

Kazan said...

I hear ya Tomvo... However, how does a rant on these forums about what you experienced is sending the right message to the right people? For one, most likely that beginner is not a forum member, and two he is probably one of many it seems that are sold equipment by shops that should at least insist the beginner get professional lessons. I know as a consumer you have the right to purchase a product and use it with owner onus applies. I guess there is no rule stipulating to retailers that 'dangerous goods' (kiting is dangerous in the wrong hands) should come with some form of mandantory licensing. And in a way yes, i admit it, but I think kite surfing should have its levels of qualifications and certifications - similar to diving. But who is going to police it at the beach?! Who is going to stop you and ask for a card proving you have reached a competent level of training and experience? No one. It's impossible to police.
So really the onus comes down to the individual and yes to us as a community of ksurfers. We should shoulder some of the blame for accidents especially if we are in the immediate vicinity.
If you see a beginner struggling, drop your bar / kite / etc and offer to assist. Don't knod your head in the usual 'i hate noob' fashion. Offer to help and at least prevent a possile disaster to him and others. I've done this many times and many beginners are reluctant to making mistakes in the presence of those more experienced. But the majority appreciate the offer and learn to kite another day. I've asked guys if they need help and some - not all, try to think they know and don't need the help. Yet they don't launch properly, they launch to fast or try to self launch with disasterous results. In the end it's up to the individual. We cannot force anyone to do anything.
Look, it frustrates me no end when i see people (whether they are experienced or not) taking stupid risks, rushing setting up and suddenly abort and expect others to save their kite or board downwind. It's tempting to shout and call them d$wats, but I hope we are above that and take a deep breath with a smile and an offer of help.
It would certainly go a long way for them and for our sport in general.


Kazan, well said.
Its great to hear there are people out there willing to help beginners. I am still a newbee, and i ALWAYS ask for advice and help, but sorry to say these days there are people out there that aren't willing to give advice and a hand.
example, i was at rosebud not long ago, had help from a guy launching, but once it came to landing, no one was willing, didnt matter home much i tapped my head or waved or yelled out for help, the group of guys on the beach stood there watching, eventually a oldish guy sitting in his car ran down and assisted. i walked over to the group and said thanks for watching, one of them laughed and said "mate if you cant land you're kite on you're own, then you shouldn't be kiting"
Although there are places i wouldn't go as a beginner, i always ask the local kiters advice on the spot before i set up, and it helps alot, especially when we don't know the hidden dangers at all the different spots.

thanks for all the advice and all the help Guys/Girls, much appreciated.

gazman2
VIC, 112 posts
4 Apr 2012 11:37PM
Thumbs Up

Hey pickle,sorry to here about your experience at Rosebud.If any one comes up with that sort of crap about not being able to land your kite on your own then there a wanker.Have helped many a guy/gal over the years with launching and landing.I live at Rosebud and i have witnessed this before,can assure you it wasnt me.Not to sure which car park you were at but if you are at the one opposite safeway(boneo rd)then its not to bad to self land(if no one gives you a hand)of the grass as the wind gets chopped up by the trees.All the best....

Kazan
QLD, 699 posts
10 Apr 2012 9:26PM
Thumbs Up

Hi Pickle. That was digusting attitude from those knobs at Rosebud, to say the least. You would not get that at Altona way... I have yet to meet snobs out here and even though I am yet to kite at Rosebud, when I eventually do, I will certainly be keeping an eye out for beginners like yourself.!

tomvonoslo
VIC, 30 posts
13 Apr 2012 9:01PM
Thumbs Up

The reason to bring this up is as you guys point out, create a good community that takes care of the newcomers. But that doesnt mean newcomers have less responsibility. With that I definitely mean going for kite lessons and taking it stepwise until you have decent control. Reg that incident, I cant see how I could have prevented the guy suddenly steering his kite into mine. I am very careful about where I kite and watched him when heading in to shore. No indication at all he was out of control. probably the stats were against me after 11 years without any incidents.
As Brighton beach due to its reef has a narrow water access compared to other beaches it can be quite busy, meaning that there are always a few kiters about to start or come in, or air parking. conditions were southerly breeze, steady 20+ knots, so nothing spectacular or uncontrollable.
Reg snobs, I hate them as you guys do. No place for bullying in this sport, or anywhere else. I am kind and always helpful on the beach. dont know how many stray boards I have gotten to shore, and recently even a kite.
It is still meaningful to bring things like this up, Kazan, even if not every kiter and especially not that guy might be a forum member. need to raise awareness constantly.

ultrahits
VIC, 11 posts
16 Apr 2012 6:12PM
Thumbs Up

Nobody, and I mean nobody can tell a beginner not to kite at Brighton or anywhere else, for that matter. Now in saying that, more experienced kiters should keep an eye and approach and help beginners if deemed necessary, including discouraging them from kiting at a particular time if the conditions are not right.

One problem with kiting is that is very hard to approach somebody out there if yours and his/hers kites are both up. Naturally you have to keep your distance from a fellow kiter to avoid tangling so you end up having to yell from a distance just to make yourself understood, and this can create problems and misunderstandings.

I have to say there are some individuals (not many...), experienced but no world champion material either (although they think otherwise), that think they own a particular spot, including Brighton. Show no regard for others, self land the kite almost on Beach road itself and think beginners, and even intermediates, are just a nuisance.

This kind of territorial behaviour has no place in kiting.

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
17 Apr 2012 9:35AM
Thumbs Up

ultrahits said...

Nobody, and I mean nobody can tell a beginner not to kite at Brighton or anywhere else, for that matter. Now in saying that, more experienced kiters should keep an eye and approach and help beginners if deemed necessary, including discouraging them from kiting at a particular time if the conditions are not right.

One problem with kiting is that is very hard to approach somebody out there if yours and his/hers kites are both up. Naturally you have to keep your distance from a fellow kiter to avoid tangling so you end up having to yell from a distance just to make yourself understood, and this can create problems and misunderstandings.

I have to say there are some individuals (not many...), experienced but no world champion material either (although they think otherwise), that think they own a particular spot, including Brighton. Show no regard for others, self land the kite almost on Beach road itself and think beginners, and even intermediates, are just a nuisance.

This kind of territorial behaviour has no place in kiting.




What? That's rediculous. Of course they can. In fact, the KBV do exactly that on their websites. There are many sports where they do it and it has nothing to do with territorial kiting, it has to do with protecting the beginner from themselves and protecting our kiting locations. If you've ever been hangliding you'll notice the hangliders do exactly that. Spots are rated suitable for beginners, advanced etc. Unless we take action to protect our kiting locations, we won't have them for long. Its all fine and well if they want to go to a remote location but when they are kiting at urban locations that impact on others, they need to have some respect for their fellow kiters. How often have you seen some newbie trying to launch his kite on the beach at Brighton in a northerly when there are 300 people on the beach? The problem with the current state of kiting is anyone with $1000 or less can go buy themselves a kite and then do whatever they feel like doing.

I've happily walked up to a beginner and said the conditions weren't suitable for them or the location isn't suitable. If they don't listen, they have themselves to blame when something goes wrong and i generally warn them if they hurt anyone or damage any property, I will happily say they were warned and chose to ignore it. Harsh? Damn right it is.

What beginners need to learn is:

1. They need to understand their limitations
2. They need to have respect for the kiting community as a whole. Buying a kite doesn't give you the right to destroy access for others.
3. They are locations rated for beginners for good reason.

I agree that some locals may act like they own locations and won't give way or do stupid things close to shore, but it's easier to deal with those people than random newbies pitching up at locations launching the wrong size kite in conditions that aren't suitable or at a location that isn't suitable.

Pickle
QLD, 33 posts
18 Apr 2012 1:10PM
Thumbs Up

Hey Guys, thanks for the comments. I am a newbee, and i can honestly say that there are a few spots that beginners should NOT kite at until they are comfortable going up wind. Guys the best thing is to chat to the locals, some locals are cool, they give awesome advice, ie. i had a guy last sat at rosebud give me a few tips where is the best spot to practice, and what dangers to look out for. i cant remember the guys name but i have seen him around a few times.

Although i have met a few newbee's that think they know everything and have ended up upsetting a few other kiters, including myself. its people like that that get hurt.

Thanks to everyone for the advice and please keep them coming , also if anyone is wanting a lift to kite please hit me up, i'm always keen to go out and i don't mind giving a lift or two.

Cheers

Kazan
QLD, 699 posts
22 Apr 2012 10:12PM
Thumbs Up

Pssst. Looks like StKilda tomorrow is going to be perfect and it's perfect for beginners.

theWILFRED
VIC, 77 posts
22 Apr 2012 10:28PM
Thumbs Up



Northerly today at brighton.. bit gusty definitely fun but would not recommend it for beginners.

suniboy21
VIC, 1090 posts
22 Apr 2012 11:06PM
Thumbs Up

Thats bulls.hit
Flew up to noosa with all my gear and wife, leaving 25knots behind in melbourne.
Not a breath of wind all day in noosa... What have i done to deserve this!

suniboy21
VIC, 1090 posts
22 Apr 2012 11:23PM
Thumbs Up

Just jizzed in my pants looking at next weekends forecast for melbourne.

MUKM
VIC, 2 posts
24 Apr 2012 11:08PM
Thumbs Up

After about 5 months I'm just starting to go to Brighton and even then only if wind is right. I've found there's always someone around to help launch etc and plenty of advice. Thanks

Kazan
QLD, 699 posts
24 Apr 2012 11:16PM
Thumbs Up

theWILFRED said...


Northerly today at brighton.. bit gusty definitely fun but would not recommend it for beginners.



Too crowded it seems.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing Victoria


"Beginners at Brighton" started by tomvonoslo