Forums > Kitesurfing Victoria

Latest update on Boating Zone Review

Reply
Created by KiteboardingVic > 9 months ago, 19 Apr 2010
KiteboardingVic
VIC, 418 posts
19 Apr 2010 12:58PM
Thumbs Up

KBV met with Parks Victoria for an update on the Boating Zone Review and related kiting matters. The results of the meeting are documented on the KBV web site.

Kiters are responsible for informing themselves of the zones and applicable rules. All the zones are clearly shown on the Parks Vic charts available here:

http://www.parkweb.vic.gov.au/resources/mresources/haveyoursay/zones/FinalRecommendationMaps_LowRes.pdf

Any related queries can be directed to Parks Victoria between 9am and 6pm (5pm on weekends) on 13 19 63

Parks Victoria is also finalising a Guide to Kiteboarding brochure for Port Phillip and Westernport Bay - KBV will try to get these sent out to members once available.

tarzan
VIC, 133 posts
21 Apr 2010 11:02PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks KBV folk - great work

manicskier
VIC, 772 posts
22 Apr 2010 2:00AM
Thumbs Up

So can you give us a quick summary? (I cannot download that file, my internet connection is @*^$#&)

Has hampton been cut down to the 150m between the two rock groynes?

Has altona been severely limited?

Is Port Melbourne now completely of limits?

Has most of the rest of the bay been excluded for no apparent reason, or have you actually managed to negotiate better terms than i have seen previously

Cheers

axis
VIC, 399 posts
22 Apr 2010 8:33AM
Thumbs Up

Here are Altona and Hampton. Small area at Hampton moved away from the LSC. Has Altona been shifted further from the pier? Maybe not surprising.

St Kilda looks as expected and there is nothing down to Brighton, and then slim pickings from there. Zones may be crowded next Summer.




Harumaki
NSW, 68 posts
22 Apr 2010 10:01AM
Thumbs Up

According to KBV the published results are "first round" - as mentioned in the announcement on the kbv site there are other bay beaches suggested by KBV for the next round (Edithvale, Rosebud, Safety Beach etc).

Also something important to note is that just because there is no kiting zone declared doesnt mean the area is off limits to kiters (unless it is a no-boating zone) - it merely means that we have to transition the 5-knot zone "according to regulation" (ie body drag) to get to open water.

My understanding is that kiting zones mean no 5-knot issue within the zone but that the zone is not exclusive to kiters - so it can still be used by swimmers, boats etc and the standard "stay clear" rule applies.

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
22 Apr 2010 12:44PM
Thumbs Up

Harumaki said...

According to KBV the published results are "first round" - as mentioned in the announcement on the kbv site there are other bay beaches suggested by KBV for the next round (Edithvale, Rosebud, Safety Beach etc).

Also something important to note is that just because there is no kiting zone declared doesnt mean the area is off limits to kiters (unless it is a no-boating zone) - it merely means that we have to transition the 5-knot zone "according to regulation" (ie body drag) to get to open water.

My understanding is that kiting zones mean no 5-knot issue within the zone but that the zone is not exclusive to kiters - so it can still be used by swimmers, boats etc and the standard "stay clear" rule applies.



Spot on. If you want to kite close to home in a non-zoned area and are considerate. I.e. not kiting being swimmers, then chances are you will not be effected and the authorities will not bother unless they see you endangering people. If on the other hand you insist on kiting 10m from shore through swimmers, then you will be fined and justly so.

Smithy
VIC, 858 posts
6 May 2010 11:34PM
Thumbs Up

It is important to note that the nominated kiting areas, as previously stated, are not exclusive to kiteboarding. In short as soon as a swimmer or other craft is in the zone, the standard rules apply, i.e. 5knts, distances etc.

It was for this very reason we originally marked out and requested lots more areas as on a hot summers day we would have to abide by the standard rules but when the wind kicked in and the people left the beach we could "legally" kite in the areas.

It was a disappointment that so few zones were designated.

craggers
WA, 475 posts
4 Jun 2010 9:03AM
Thumbs Up

forgive me if this is a stupid question, but better to risk being stupid on a forum than risk being stupid on the water in public...

'no boating zone' usually indicated by signs on the beach (a boat with a circle/cross through it)... this translates to 'no kiting zone' ??? no kiting permitted whatsoever?

pisstakers welcome to respond, but if i could have at least one genuine answer that would be appreciated

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
4 Jun 2010 2:13PM
Thumbs Up

craggers said...

forgive me if this is a stupid question, but better to risk being stupid on a forum than risk being stupid on the water in public...

'no boating zone' usually indicated by signs on the beach (a boat with a circle/cross through it)... this translates to 'no kiting zone' ??? no kiting permitted whatsoever?

pisstakers welcome to respond, but if i could have at least one genuine answer that would be appreciated


No boat zone generally means 5 knot rule, no kiting within 50m of piers etc. I.e. you could use it as a channel to get out but you would have to kite slowly and then remain outside the no boating zone markers until you're ready to come to shore. Jumping and high speed carves inside the zone are a definitely no-no and give swimmers lots of room while getting out.

In some cases you could get away with being inside the zone, i.e. 30 knot days where its cold and miserable and the only people on the beach are kiters, but I wouldn't plan on it, and there is still a big likelihood that you will be fined so its better to just stay out and avoid the problem altogether but technically, even if the beach is quiet they could fine you for it.

JTheron
VIC, 46 posts
4 Jun 2010 2:58PM
Thumbs Up

Saffer said...

craggers said...

forgive me if this is a stupid question, but better to risk being stupid on a forum than risk being stupid on the water in public...

'no boating zone' usually indicated by signs on the beach (a boat with a circle/cross through it)... this translates to 'no kiting zone' ??? no kiting permitted whatsoever?

pisstakers welcome to respond, but if i could have at least one genuine answer that would be appreciated


No boat zone generally means 5 knot rule, no kiting within 50m of piers etc. I.e. you could use it as a channel to get out but you would have to kite slowly and then remain outside the no boating zone markers until you're ready to come to shore. Jumping and high speed carves inside the zone are a definitely no-no and give swimmers lots of room while getting out.

In some cases you could get away with being inside the zone, i.e. 30 knot days where its cold and miserable and the only people on the beach are kiters, but I wouldn't plan on it, and there is still a big likelihood that you will be fined so its better to just stay out and avoid the problem altogether but technically, even if the beach is quiet they could fine you for it.


With this being said, what is then actually the difference between a no boating zone and the 5 knot zone? Can I actually take a chance in the 5 knot zone without facing a possible fine like Saffer mentioned above?
If I read it as it absolutely stands, then a 5 knot zone should actually allow me to play around with my kite as long as I keep to 5 knots...but should there be swimmers in the 5 knot zone, do they have the same rights than in the no boating zone?

(Sorry for the technicality - if I can call it that)

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
4 Jun 2010 6:21PM
Thumbs Up

JTheron said...

Saffer said...

craggers said...

forgive me if this is a stupid question, but better to risk being stupid on a forum than risk being stupid on the water in public...

'no boating zone' usually indicated by signs on the beach (a boat with a circle/cross through it)... this translates to 'no kiting zone' ??? no kiting permitted whatsoever?

pisstakers welcome to respond, but if i could have at least one genuine answer that would be appreciated


No boat zone generally means 5 knot rule, no kiting within 50m of piers etc. I.e. you could use it as a channel to get out but you would have to kite slowly and then remain outside the no boating zone markers until you're ready to come to shore. Jumping and high speed carves inside the zone are a definitely no-no and give swimmers lots of room while getting out.

In some cases you could get away with being inside the zone, i.e. 30 knot days where its cold and miserable and the only people on the beach are kiters, but I wouldn't plan on it, and there is still a big likelihood that you will be fined so its better to just stay out and avoid the problem altogether but technically, even if the beach is quiet they could fine you for it.


With this being said, what is then actually the difference between a no boating zone and the 5 knot zone? Can I actually take a chance in the 5 knot zone without facing a possible fine like Saffer mentioned above?
If I read it as it absolutely stands, then a 5 knot zone should actually allow me to play around with my kite as long as I keep to 5 knots...but should there be swimmers in the 5 knot zone, do they have the same rights than in the no boating zone?

(Sorry for the technicality - if I can call it that)


Apologies, I stand under correction, I was thinking of the 5 knot zone, not the no boating zone. From the KBV website "Kiters must not enter any "no boating zone" and should body-drag through any 5-knot zones. Kiters are responsible for informing themselves of the zones and applicable rules. All the zones are clearly shown on the Parks Vic charts available here"

Just to clarify on swimmers, the 5 knot rule applying to swimmers applies in ALL area, boating , 5 knots, or kiting. In short, even if a swimmer is not supposed to be there, you should slow down to 5 knots while within 50m of them. I know this is harsh, but the laws protect swimmers.

If you want to understand more about the boating rules, you can download the entire Vic manual here:

transportsafety.vic.gov.au/maritime-safety

Here is an overview of the zones and what each zone means:

www.parkweb.vic.gov.au/resources/mresources/haveyoursay/zones/Boating%20Zone%20Review%20Information%20Flyer.pdf

JTheron
VIC, 46 posts
7 Jun 2010 1:49PM
Thumbs Up

Cool thanks a mill Saffer...



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing Victoria


"Latest update on Boating Zone Review" started by KiteboardingVic