Forums > Land Yacht Sailing Construction

How to find the balance points for a Landyacht....

Reply
Created by Gizmo > 9 months ago, 13 May 2011
Gizmo
SA, 2865 posts
15 May 2011 1:46PM
Thumbs Up

OK by allowing twist... which is like feathering the top of a sail, and in effect stopping it working.
It is good to watch a video of sailboards sailing with a lot of twist in the sail... I once saw a sailboard speed week championship video, the tops of the sails were flapping like a flag... the battens and tension on them stopped a fair bit of it but they were flapping. Next time your on the water watch other sails for the top flapping about just a little. (you won't see it on your board as your looking almost straight up)

I normally don't take into account twist to much because its one thing that the sailor can control with sheet pressure and angle.
And yes if you allow lots of twist of sail top feathering it will lower the CE, but it will also cause air drag.



I have done a picture of what would occur if the tops of these sail were twisted or feathering, the twisting line would be about where the black line is.... and if we then do the same line drawings on the effective sail area we end up with a totaly different CE point.



Clemco
430 posts
15 May 2011 1:36PM
Thumbs Up



Sorry I must disagree here. A twisted sail on a landyacht can still be producing drive. In fact more drive if you consider the direction that the wind is traveling over the surface. The sail shape becomes more like a turbine accelerating the wind in an upward direction.

Gizmo
SA, 2865 posts
15 May 2011 3:21PM
Thumbs Up





This picture is of a yacht has wind coming from behind the yacht at considerable strength... the main sheet has been let out and the mast has flexed forward indicating a tail wind, that sail is acting like a spinnaker rather than an aerodynamic wing. The yacht would be traveling at a speed less than the wind. Why? ... If he was at the same as wind speed the mast would be straight, if he was faster than the wind the mast would be flexing back.

Now not knowing the beach, if that guy wanted to go faster he would need to steer slightly to the left, and sheet in a bit to start to get the use of the apparent wind he would be starting to generate, the would then jibe the yacht and zigzag down the beach in l-a-r-g-e sweeping jibes. As he would end up faster than the wind those jibes become gentle tacks and HUGE speed [at that point I hope he's carrying a GPS] because he would be hooting along.

Clemco
430 posts
15 May 2011 2:27PM
Thumbs Up

It may look like the wind was coming from behind, but I can assure you the wind was from the side as I was standing next to the photographer. Yes the photo is an extreme example of sail twist, but my point was that a twisted sail can still hold camber and still be producing drive.

Nikrum
TAS, 1972 posts
15 May 2011 8:25PM
Thumbs Up

There was earlier mention of Sail Feathering and Air displacement over the top rear of the sail. I have mounted Long Woolen Telltales at the top of the new sail and it would seem that the tendency is for a fair bit of wind movement upwards and off the sail. This is where I was going to try a Truncation/Stall Packs to redirect the Air straight back over the sail. I am sure it would cure the p[roblem but whether it is worth the effort is the question?? How much efficiency it would gain?
Ron]

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
15 May 2011 8:44PM
Thumbs Up

Gizmo said...





This picture is of a yacht has wind coming from behind the yacht at considerable strength... the main sheet has been let out and the mast has flexed forward indicating a tail wind, that sail is acting like a spinnaker rather than an aerodynamic wing. The yacht would be traveling at a speed less than the wind. Why? ... If he was at the same as wind speed the mast would be straight, if he was faster than the wind the mast would be flexing back.

Now not knowing the beach, if that guy wanted to go faster he would need to steer slightly to the left, and sheet in a bit to start to get the use of the apparent wind he would be starting to generate, the would then jibe the yacht and zigzag down the beach in l-a-r-g-e sweeping jibes. As he would end up faster than the wind those jibes become gentle tacks and HUGE speed [at that point I hope he's carrying a GPS] because he would be hooting along.




given the way hes leaning Id reckon hes in the middle of a spin and is traveling backwards, even in a straight line blowies dont flex quite that much

cisco
QLD, 12321 posts
16 May 2011 12:42AM
Thumbs Up

Gizmo said...





This picture is of a yacht has wind coming from behind the yacht at considerable strength... the main sheet has been let out and the mast has flexed forward indicating a tail wind, that sail is acting like a spinnaker rather than an aerodynamic wing. The yacht would be traveling at a speed less than the wind. Why? ... If he was at the same as wind speed the mast would be straight, if he was faster than the wind the mast would be flexing back.

Now not knowing the beach, if that guy wanted to go faster he would need to steer slightly to the left, and sheet in a bit to start to get the use of the apparent wind he would be starting to generate, the would then jibe the yacht and zigzag down the beach in l-a-r-g-e sweeping jibes. As he would end up faster than the wind those jibes become gentle tacks and HUGE speed [at that point I hope he's carrying a GPS] because he would be hooting along.




Gybes in a blokart at speed can get very interesting. Depending on surface they readily spin out or just slap themselves down if you are not careful.

I usually sheet right in coming into the gybe and ease it out as I round onto the other leg to save getting overpowered.

As you say Gizmo "l-a-r-g-e sweeping gybes" are the order of the day as sharp ones will usually get you into trouble.

Sharp tacks also get you into trouble and usually with a blokart you will not change direction of travel but just do it backwards. Not good if you are tacking to avoid running into a fixed object. Ouch!!!

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
15 May 2011 11:08PM
Thumbs Up

btw the formula for determining the spanwise position of the centre of effort for a wing with different lift at the root and the tip is as follows:

Position = Span * (A + 2B) / (3A + 3B)

Where A is the lift at the root, and B is the lift at the tip.


So for a triangular sail, the position is as follows:

Position = Span * (A + 0) / (3A + 0)
Position = Span * (1/3)

So the position of the centre of effort will be 1/3 of the way up the mast, measured from the boom.

If you know the theoretical position of the centre of effort (centre of pressure) for your particular foil, then you can draw a line between this point at the root, and the tip of the mast. The centre of effort will be 1/3 of the way up this line.

For a sail with a fat head and twist, you can assume that the lift at the top will be minimal, so the height of the centre of effort will still be 1/3 of the way up the mast.

Gizmo
SA, 2865 posts
18 May 2011 12:04PM
Thumbs Up

Unfortunately theories are fine for solid objects ... soft sails are VERY variable things the CE and the position can be changed up / down and forward / back.
Sailboards use this principle to the maximum for steering etc.

Knowing about CE, CB, CG, CLR / CR etc it's more about knowing what your yacht is doing and why its doing it......

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
19 May 2011 10:38AM
Thumbs Up

Gizmo said...

Unfortunately theories are fine for solid objects ... soft sails are VERY variable things the CE and the position can be changed up / down and forward / back.
Sailboards use this principle to the maximum for steering etc.

Knowing about CE, CB, CG, CLR / CR etc it's more about knowing what your yacht is doing and why its doing it......

so where are we on this new thread, Ijust read the whole thing agaian and the only change from the thread it came from is that there are no dummy spits, and we are using a block of wood as an alternative to a brick for the CG.
could this all be summarized by the brick and rope method for CLR and CG and move your CE of your sail down slightly in a gust if you have a big headed sail?
or am I missing something

Hiko
1229 posts
19 May 2011 12:09PM
Thumbs Up

Ya missed one... CE One third up One quarter back
In verticle line or thereabouts with the other two
Go sailing

aus230
WA, 1659 posts
20 May 2011 9:08PM
Thumbs Up

I found the balance point for aus230 today using a board to find the point with the sail fully sheeted. Could someone mark the center of effort point on the attached pic. Thanks
Cheers
vic


Test pilot 1
WA, 1430 posts
21 May 2011 12:13AM
Thumbs Up

As close as i can make out it would have to be a point directly on the top of the three

on the left hand third(RedSquare)

Clemco
430 posts
21 May 2011 8:12AM
Thumbs Up



Where the diagonal red lines intersect is the center of area of the sail. Draw a horizontal line at that point. I would balance between 25 and 33% back on that chord line. Directly below where you had your ratchet pulley attached. Dont believe a word these lefroy guys tell you Vic. They're just messin with ya.

Gizmo
SA, 2865 posts
21 May 2011 10:02AM
Thumbs Up

Hiko said...

CE One third up One quarter back
In verticle line or thereabouts with the other two
Go sailing


aus230
WA, 1659 posts
21 May 2011 9:16AM
Thumbs Up

thanks guys. That helps me heaps up to now I have been adjusting my sail rake without actually knowing what it is all about
Cheers
Vic

Gizmo
SA, 2865 posts
21 May 2011 10:57AM
Thumbs Up

What have you found the results to be by raking your mast forward and back?

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
21 May 2011 11:51AM
Thumbs Up

OK I just measured two of my sails, and the results are as follows:

7m: centre of effort is 30% back from the luff, as measured
5.2m: centre of effort is 27% back from the luff

So around 28% would be a pretty close sort of figure. You could even use 25% (1 quarter) as it would be near enough.

Note that the centre of effort does move around in gusts and with different amounts of outhaul and downhaul, but experimentally it only moves around a percent or two.

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
21 May 2011 12:17PM
Thumbs Up

This is what I got:





Note that this is assuming full twist under load -- if the sail is cut so that the head still provides lift then this point will move slightly up and backwards.

Hiko
1229 posts
21 May 2011 4:28PM
Thumbs Up

Gizmo said...

What have you found the results to be by raking your mast forward and back?


I have found in strong winds on the beach that the yacht balances better
upwind with the mast further back than its balanced position downwind
thats how it seems to me Someone may be able to make sense of this

aus230
WA, 1659 posts
21 May 2011 4:51PM
Thumbs Up

when I laid it right back the back wheels pushed sideways(on a loose surface). If I stood it right up there was no speed. Somewhere around 10 to 12% seems to work best

Hiko
1229 posts
21 May 2011 5:09PM
Thumbs Up

aus230 said...

when I laid it right back the back wheels pushed sideways(on a loose surface).


Thats what happens to me downwind but upwind is fine
Maybe a remote mast raking mechanism?
Just joking [I think]

Nikrum
TAS, 1972 posts
21 May 2011 8:53PM
Thumbs Up

Not quite sure what to make of this but i9t all sounds very familiar. Could it be that we are getting the mast Balance and tension to the point that it is acting like a Mast and Sail on a Square rigger only sideways Most certainly feels that way, particularly through a turn as one is bringing the machine through stronger winds and the Apparent Wind increases the whole unit slides sideways
Ron
PS; Is that what you are feeling AUS?

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
21 May 2011 7:26PM
Thumbs Up

Hiko said...

Gizmo said...

What have you found the results to be by raking your mast forward and back?


I have found in strong winds on the beach that the yacht balances better
upwind with the mast further back than its balanced position downwind
thats how it seems to me Someone may be able to make sense of this


I find the same thing on a windsurfer. Going upwind the sail foot is often brushing my toes, but going downwind it's normally raked a lot more upright. Not sure of the physics though!

Hiko
1229 posts
22 May 2011 4:56AM
Thumbs Up

nebbian said...

Hiko said...

Gizmo said...

What have you found the results to be by raking your mast forward and back?


I have found in strong winds on the beach that the yacht balances better
upwind with the mast further back than its balanced position downwind
thats how it seems to me Someone may be able to make sense of this


I find the same thing on a windsurfer. Going upwind the sail foot is often brushing my toes, but going downwind it's normally raked a lot more upright. Not sure of the physics though!


I guess I should clarify this a bit
Downwind to a landyacht travelling at three times or thereabouts the windspeed the apparent wind is still from in front but probably less so

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
22 May 2011 8:18PM
Thumbs Up

keep in mind that vics yacht has tall skinny wheels
the tall wheels give better resisstance to lateral forces, so the CLR moves back, which allows you to move your CG back and sail with less weight on the front wheel
this allows you to rake the sail back even further than you could if you were running 4.00x8 wheels.
the cl5 sportif heavy pilots were all raked at12degrees in Argentina, the light pilotsback at 10 degrees, and the promos were all between 7-10 degrees.
I suppose i could have told you all that before , but it was kinda nice to sit on the measurements for a few years

Hiko
1229 posts
23 May 2011 6:08AM
Thumbs Up

Clarifying once again [sheeesh] the yacht I was referring to above was a class5
also with tall skinny wheels
The mini with 4,00x8 wheels doesnt seem to be so sensitive to the CE position
or is that due to the unsurpassed skill of the designer? [landy]

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
23 May 2011 8:27PM
Thumbs Up

sorry , cant the credit there, original width,length and mast position were from a blokart , so credit to Paul Becket
raking the mast more, going back to a traditional rig, cutting the cost, getting the feet back to work,starting a Y frame race,
getting you all making your own sails,and generally having cheap fun.......
...... happy to take credit for those minor details



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Land Yacht Sailing Construction


"How to find the balance points for a Landyacht...." started by Gizmo