Forums > Land Yacht Sailing General

Cheap & easy to built (Class 5) land yacht

Reply
Created by agamackay > 9 months ago, 9 Jul 2008
Gizmo
SA, 2865 posts
25 Jul 2008 9:08PM
Thumbs Up

I know that several clubs display the Land yachts at car, boat, 4WD, and adventure shows to attract new members.
These people are looking for new adventure sports .. i just think that even pics displayed of "Bedsheet" type yachts will destroy the "New Enviromentally Friendly Sport" image we all are trying to create.
Do yourself a favor and have a look in the local newsagent at adventure sport magazines and this is where the sport should be heading rather than regressing to a "Gala Day" event along side the 'egg and spoon race'!

For example..... this classy magazine loves stuff on adventure sports. It would be terrific if Landsailing Australia could offer a well prepared article written in the style of this magazine.

www.anacondastores.com
www.outer-edge.com.au/index.html

lachlan3556
VIC, 1066 posts
25 Jul 2008 9:42PM
Thumbs Up

Exactly! Emphasis on the 'sleek' and 'cool' yachts to get attention and then when you get them talking to you mention that it doesn't cost the world to get started.

hills
SA, 1622 posts
25 Jul 2008 9:45PM
Thumbs Up

You can make a class spec yacht without spending any more than the "Dumpsters". My yacht is in class V spec, but it didn't cost as much to build as the entry level blokart. I spent a bit on the sail, but could have converted a donated windsurfer sail to bring the price down further.

I guess all I'm trying to say is the "Dumpsters" can be sleek and cool and within class spec too! Pauls Lefroy minis prove that

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
25 Jul 2008 8:21PM
Thumbs Up

agamackay said...

landyacht said...
the green and blue beauty had rear wheels that were secondhand in 1992

the front was a case of dont grind the weld to look better


Spoked wheels don`t take sideway strain applyed in a pitched landyacht for long.


Sorry the captions didn`t upload clearly...
"stingray hole-log-what-ever."
"Fork-chassis alignment does not allow shock/vibration transfer.
The chassis will break at the vibration point (red line) very quickly even without hitting anything as vibration (Steel Killer No.1) constantly works on this point. The join might have been square butt joint or mitre as in the STANDART that obviously inspired this yacht. Easily remideed

aga

I can assure you my children , when that weld breaks on a yacht that I welded, you have been hit by a truck and you are well stuffed." The vibration " would of course have been absorbed by the nylon bushes that have long been a feature of my front ends. designs such as this have quite low stresses on the extremities because I use heavier,tougher materials and less "stiffening "braces, achieving comfort,smoothness gracefullness,and simplicity of construction
the example of the bluegreen yacht that turned to algae had a "similar " front but was constructed of material 2/3 thinner than the material I would preach.
I am constantly impressed by the lighter materials that many builders have been able to build yachts from , But if you gave me one of those yachts to RACE I would destroy it [}:)]. FAZE 5 made that mistake many years ago I believe I have redeemed myself on that count
The very first PM weighed in fully rigged at 24kgs and was known to tear completely in half if you did too violent a 360. if I encouraged this level of construction in my designs and it failed I would be blamed. consequently i build and test them myselfor get my good faithful mate Test Pilot 1 to do it for me.
Some say hes just a big boofhead,and can devour cold cans of spaghetti by the truck load But I know that If I need something destroying with speed and reckless abandon TP1 is your man

lachlan3556
VIC, 1066 posts
25 Jul 2008 10:25PM
Thumbs Up

Good point Hills. Its easy to build within class spec just sometimes not so easy or competitive, everyone to their own. Not sure if comparing inexpensive to an entry level blowkart is supporting the point though

If I may ask, what did your seat set you back? I know i know, someone tell me to go jump whenever I mention the word 'seat'

hills
SA, 1622 posts
25 Jul 2008 10:24PM
Thumbs Up

Haha, very good point Lachlan

David Rose has the mould, he sold me that one for $220. I gotta say its really comfortable

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
25 Jul 2008 9:40PM
Thumbs Up

lachlan3556 said...

Not sure if comparing inexpensive to an entry level blowkart is supporting the point though



Lets do a realistic comparison
We built 4 PROMOS for $1800.each. that was material cost.
Get a boilermaker to weld the frame $300ea
sandblast and industrial finish(not Galv)$120 ea
Proff.fibreglassing $300ea
Anodizing of ALuminium $70ea
Pay full price for wheels $75 for 3
Proff assembly $250

plus the $1800. I believe thats $3215 and now we just need to deliver. .


cisco
QLD, 12337 posts
26 Jul 2008 12:10AM
Thumbs Up

[b]landyacht The very first PM weighed in fully rigged at 24kgs and was known to tear completely in half if you did too violent a 360.


That's very impressive considering a blokart comes in at 30kg.

Further, 24kg is just less than half the minimum class 5 specified weight of 50kg.

You reached the point of diminished return first time round and then had to "back" design.

How much Alfoil did you actually use on that first PM?

cisco
QLD, 12337 posts
26 Jul 2008 2:00AM
Thumbs Up

landyacht said...

lachlan3556 said...

Not sure if comparing inexpensive to an entry level blowkart is supporting the point though

Lets do a realistic comparison
We built 4 PROMOS for $1800.each. that was material cost.
Get a boilermaker to weld the frame $300ea
sandblast and industrial finish(not Galv)$120 ea
Proff.fibreglassing $300ea
Anodizing of ALuminium $70ea
Pay full price for wheels $75 for 3
Proff assembly $250

plus the $1800. I believe thats $3215 and now we just need to deliver. .


Well put Paul. $3,215 is the ex factory cost. To that needs to be added promotional costs (brochures, advertising etc), distribution costs (central warehousing, stock management, spare parts) and dealer margins.

Blokart retails their product within $100 of your factory cost. Without diminishing your PROMOS or Lefroy Minis in any way, anybody can see that the level of sophistication in manufacture of a blokart is way beyond them.

Anybody who says a blokart is overpriced, in my opinion doesn't understand what they are looking at, wind sports in general or what they are talking about.

Last time I went into a surf shop (3 years ago), price of a kite surfing board was $1,000 and a rig for it $1,500. What is overpriced??

Dave Webster in Brisbane is about to release his Phoenix Swift. Performance, price and purchaseability (supply) will be the determining factors for the success of this or any other new land yacht.

When I was the blokart dealer here in Bundaberg and I had them on display at the show and other venues, people would ask me "What are they worth?". After quoteing the price and the cries of "What a rippoff." or "I could make one for a third of that!", I changed my tack.

When posed with the "Worth" question, I would respond with a statement and a question. (salesmanship) My response was "If you really want to go land sailing these things are worth more than they cost. Do you really want to go land sailing?" (Do you want to fish or cut bait?)

With all of the previous in mind I pose these two questions to those having read this far.

1.Do you really love land sailing or is it just a passing fad?

2.If you really love doing something, isn't it worth spending top shelf on it?

No more complaining about the price of this or that, please!!

Adios Amigos, Cisco.

hills
SA, 1622 posts
26 Jul 2008 10:24AM
Thumbs Up

I'm not sure in the context of this thread anyone is complaining about the price of a blokart. If Aga wants to build a super cheap dumpster, then Lachlan is saying there's no point me comparing the price of my PM to the price of a blokart. I think he's saying for my point to be valid in this context I should be comparing the price of my PM to that of Aga's dumpster. A point, in hindsight, I agree with.

EDIT: (I'm adding this after Split's repsonse below) Further to your post Cisco, I personally don't have an issue with the price of a blokart and may well own one, one day, as they're not much more than the amount I've just spent on my latest bike. But, when I got into cycling I was able to buy a $500 cheapy so that I could make sure it wasn't just a fad as you described. Once I decided it wasn't I upgraded. I think its this entry level cheapy that the people who gave you greif are looking for and unless you build your own, doesn't exist. Lets face it, granted they're good value for money (as detailed above) but its a lot for a person to outlay before they have been given the chance to determine if this sport is a fad or something they wish to persue.

My initial point was, if you're building your own dumpster, I don't think it would cost much more to make it comply with a class, if any at all. That way if this great sport entices you, like it has us, then you can start competing before you upgrade to the blokarts, promos or swifts. All of which are good value for money once you've decided its not a fad. If it doesn't entice you you can still have great fun on the beach as Aga and his team do and you haven't really lost anything.

I should add I'm not suggesting there's anything Aga should do differently as I suspect all he has to do is trim his axles and use his smallest sail and he'll probably be classV compliant (although I haven't gone through his specs that closely so don't quote me on that )

splitpin
104 posts
26 Jul 2008 9:12AM
Thumbs Up

cisco said...

landyacht said...

lachlan3556 said...

Not sure if comparing inexpensive to an entry level blowkart is supporting the point though

Lets do a realistic comparison
We built 4 PROMOS for $1800.each. that was material cost.
Get a boilermaker to weld the frame $300ea
sandblast and industrial finish(not Galv)$120 ea
Proff.fibreglassing $300ea
Anodizing of ALuminium $70ea
Pay full price for wheels $75 for 3
Proff assembly $250

plus the $1800. I believe thats $3215 and now we just need to deliver. .


Well put Paul. $3,215 is the ex factory cost. To that needs to be added promotional costs (brochures, advertising etc), distribution costs (central warehousing, stock management, spare parts) and dealer margins.

Blokart retails their product within $100 of your factory cost. Without diminishing your PROMOS or Lefroy Minis in any way, anybody can see that the level of sophistication in manufacture of a blokart is way beyond them.

Anybody who says a blokart is overpriced, in my opinion doesn't understand what they are looking at, wind sports in general or what they are talking about.

Last time I went into a surf shop (3 years ago), price of a kite surfing board was $1,000 and a rig for it $1,500. What is overpriced??

Dave Webster in Brisbane is about to release his Phoenix Swift. Performance, price and purchaseability (supply) will be the determining factors for the success of this or any other new land yacht.

When I was the blokart dealer here in Bundaberg and I had them on display at the show and other venues, people would ask me "What are they worth?". After quoteing the price and the cries of "What a rippoff." or "I could make one for a third of that!", I changed my tack.

When posed with the "Worth" question, I would respond with a statement and a question. (salesmanship) My response was "If you really want to go land sailing these things are worth more than they cost. Do you really want to go land sailing?" (Do you want to fish or cut bait?)

With all of the previous in mind I pose these two questions to those having read this far.

1.Do you really love land sailing or is it just a passing fad?

2.If you really love doing something, isn't it worth spending top shelf on it?

No more complaining about the price of this or that, please!!

Adios Amigos, Cisco.
why not plenty of one off home specials have competed at the top level and been very succesful with out spending mega bucks , one for example bert munros fastest indian it was done on the absolute minium of cash and there are plenty of other examples if you look around

iand
QLD, 243 posts
26 Jul 2008 2:10PM
Thumbs Up

As far as doing a "realistic comparison" for a one of (Quote-"The yacht the boys built is VERY basic, I doubt it would be a nationaly acceptable/saleable model)- how about pride of accomplishment.
ie.Blokart-$$$(payed for by working)
Homemade-$300-$500 testing your abilities, the sense of achievement, the ability to find solutions to problems you encounter, the testing and tuning, the pride in saying to the person who stopped to look "I built it"
I'm sure aga is very proud of Jesse's achievement and would perfer him to be pointing that can of paint at the landyacht and not at someone's fence or in a plastic bag.
Once again congads Jesse on a job well done.
PS. With your dad's OK I'll post a design of a H2O gattling gun for dog fights.

cisco
QLD, 12337 posts
26 Jul 2008 3:35PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
My post was mainly in response to Paul's cost break down of his PROMOS, and to say that when making comparisons, let's make sure we are comparing eggs with eggs and not chalk with cheese.

Re:- If you really love doing something, isn't it worth spending top shelf on it?

If the only way I could get into land sailing was by spending $10,000 on a Standart, I would spend the 10.

For me the primary purpose of money is to spend it on what gives me and mine pleasure. I am going to be dead for a long time.

why not plenty of one off home specials have competed at the top level and been very succesful with out spending mega bucks , one for example bert munros fastest indian it was done on the absolute minium of cash and there are plenty of other examples if you look around


I agree with this sentiment completely. I always look for the most economical way of achieving my aims. To reduce monetary costs I often spend another currency which is my time. It is always possible to make more money but it is never possible to make more time. This often makes me question the wisdom of some of my decisions.

The Bert Munroe story is inspiring but I wouldn't take the movie as gospel. Bert didn't spend a lot of money but undoubtedly spent a lot of another currency be it time, health, relationships whatever.

Cheers Cisco.

cisco
QLD, 12337 posts
26 Jul 2008 3:43PM
Thumbs Up

[b]iand said
- how about pride of accomplishment,payed for by working, testing your abilities, the sense of achievement, the ability to find solutions to problems you encounter, the testing and tuning, the pride in saying to the person who stopped to look "I built it"


If home building has these added benefits on top of the sailing fun, I am all for it. I will be doing the same myself.

agamackay
QLD, 58 posts
26 Jul 2008 5:44PM
Thumbs Up

hills said...

I'm not sure in the context of this thread anyone is complaining about the price of a blokart. If Aga wants to build a super cheap dumpster, then Lachlan is saying there's no point me comparing the price of my PM to the price of a blokart. I think he's saying for my point to be valid in this context I should be comparing the price of my PM to that of Aga's dumpster. A point, in hindsight, I agree with.

EDIT: (I'm adding this after Split's repsonse below) Further to your post Cisco, I personally don't have an issue with the price of a blokart and may well own one, one day, as they're not much more than the amount I've just spent on my latest bike. But, when I got into cycling I was able to buy a $500 cheapy so that I could make sure it wasn't just a fad as you described. Once I decided it wasn't I upgraded. I think its this entry level cheapy that the people who gave you greif are looking for and unless you build your own, doesn't exist. Lets face it, granted they're good value for money (as detailed above) but its a lot for a person to outlay before they have been given the chance to determine if this sport is a fad or something they wish to persue.
My initial point was, if you're building your own dumpster, I don't think it would cost much more to make it comply with a class, if any at all. That way if this great sport entices you, like it has us, then you can start competing before you upgrade to the blokarts, promos or swifts. All of which are good value for money once you've decided its not a fad. If it doesn't entice you you can still have great fun on the beach as Aga and his team do and you haven't really lost anything.

I should add I'm not suggesting there's anything Aga should do differently as I suspect all he has to do is trim his axles and use his smallest sail and he'll probably be classV compliant (although I haven't gone through his specs that closely so don't quote me on that )



SPOT ON !!

As for the boys "DUMPSTER" Axle-Axle=2.1 (<2.5) Width=1.5 o/a (<2m)
The width turned out a bit narrow as Jes was just learning to weld and had a couple of goes at the taper & nut cobination.
The fiberglass mast is out of spec. but could be replaced at any time (it`s not welded in)
Getting back to sails:we have a good wardrobe; 2.9m--8.5m, though windsurfer sails are not of the best cut for landsiling, so wouldn`t be internationally compedetive (speed raceing) Oh by the way these are also replaceable as they are not a welded part.
The seat would also need changing and again is not a welded part.
The "DUMPSTERS" are CV inspiered and could be upgraded should land yachting become more than a passing fad for my 12 & 13 year old boys.
SPOT ON Hillsy

Would it be such a bad thing if clubs around the whole of Oz had a similar $500 cheapy ??

(I`m not saying the desing my boys built,
an agreed design you more experienced piolts come up with together,
here on this forum or through ALAS).

An unoficial club / inter-club / inter-state / national ENTRY LEVEL Class might be fromulated.
If as a national group the $500 cheapy (could be made by club members as a rainy day hobby / beer money)
using new material rather than the 10 year old rusting trampoline.
New wheels rather than the conreet encrusted toss outs at the local dump.
Might a national group be able to order 1000 identical sails at a much lower price than the current on-off price? Simle triangle, no battens, just eyes and sleve.

The yacht would NEED to be of good quality :
no they would not be internationally compedetive speed wise,
but should look like something worth owning, be reliable and SAFE.

aga

agamackay
QLD, 58 posts
26 Jul 2008 5:53PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
landyacht said...

The vibration " would of course have been absorbed by the nylon bushes that have long been a feature of my front ends.


Thanks landyacht, the nylon bush absorbtion in your front ends makes a whole lot of sence!
I`m sure your designs & building are great, glad you didn`t take offence to my questions

aga


agamackay
QLD, 58 posts
26 Jul 2008 5:57PM
Thumbs Up

iand said...


PS. With your dad's OK I'll post a design of a H2O gattling gun for dog fights.


PLEASE DO[}:)]

AGA

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
26 Jul 2008 4:17PM
Thumbs Up

placing nylon washers and or rubber bushes,washers will make a difference in the comfort, and i believe performance of the yacht. any small vibration reduction between wheels and sail will allow the the sail to perform cleaner..
Interesting question being raised is the cost of an "entry level yacht. the Club 88 is built by the SANDGROPERS club . I believe the present cost is around $1600 Ie close to the PROMO I honestly think that is as cheap as you will get a yacht if you go the new sail,wheels,mast ,fibrglasss seat path.
A couple of years ago I thought that I was being pretty clever recycling sailboard gear for yachts and the price to build a yacht became readily do-able for a lot new sailors. I am so gratified to discover that there are so many other people doing exactly the same as me and getting the same pleasure.
peace on earth fellow sailors

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
26 Jul 2008 4:28PM
Thumbs Up

agamackay said...

Select to expand quote
hills said...
Would it be such a bad thing if clubs around the whole of Oz had a similar $500 cheapy ??

(I`m not saying the desing my boys built,
an agreed design you more experienced piolts come up with together,
here on this forum or through ALAS).

An unoficial club / inter-club / inter-state / national ENTRY LEVEL Class might be fromulated.
If as a national group the $500 cheapy (could be made by club members as a rainy day hobby / beer money)
using new material rather than the 10 year old rusting trampoline.
New wheels rather than the conreet encrusted toss outs at the local dump.


The yacht would NEED to be of good quality :
no they would not be internationally compedetive speed wise,
but should look like something worth owning, be reliable and SAFE.

aga


sounds like a great idea

agamackay
QLD, 58 posts
26 Jul 2008 6:53PM
Thumbs Up

I like it
Link to -plans-name-video of it in action-
Transport -trailer-requiered / folding / dissmantle (tools / no-tools)

If ordering a 1000 at a time, would it be possible/costable to blomould plastic the seat
OR leave a mould with a tame fiberglass workshop as a nothing-better-to-do-job / mixed-up too-much-poor it in here-job

aga

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
26 Jul 2008 5:09PM
Thumbs Up

agamackay said...

I like it
Link to -plans-name-video of it in action-
Transport -trailer-requiered / folding / dissmantle (tools / no-tools)

If ordering a 1000 at a time, would it be possible/costable to blomould plastic the seat
OR leave a mould with a tame fiberglass workshop as a nothing-better-to-do-job / mixed-up too-much-poor it in here-job

aga

No need for a link for the plans. your at the link! its a lefroy mini its a sticky in the construction section all the plans ,tools. Please email before posting me a video camera. Gift would be well recieved
the problem with leaving the mold with someone is that eventually makes thier own mold and the 75 hrs of labour the group put into the seat plus money are lost. the angles are there for anybody to use if they want to build thier own mold. it would be a worthwhile project


agamackay
QLD, 58 posts
26 Jul 2008 7:50PM
Thumbs Up

Not interested in copy rights.
Interested in THE SPORT

aga

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
26 Jul 2008 6:02PM
Thumbs Up

me niether but I once got a string of rude phone calls complaining about an aspect of some plans I had drawn. one of his complaints was that the person who had SOLD him the plans wouldnt return his calls.
Molds in fibreglass are so easy to copy and you need to keep in mind that the original seat was financed by others.
you always run the risk of all the yachts becoming the same and design and experimentation coming to a halt. this is one of the reasons that very few top end racing machines are seen in Australia.
the introduction of the PROMO class to the FISLY claases is a great opportunity for Australia to get back into the World stage

agamackay
QLD, 58 posts
26 Jul 2008 8:37PM
Thumbs Up

The plans in question would NOT be YOUR`S.
The plans in question would belong to the conlomorant/amalgamation/whatever.
Complanits about workmanship might need to be directed to an overseer/ALAS?
May be each chassis fabricater be issued a number that is atamped on the cahassis

LLM plans in construction are hard to follow, there are aleast 2 different front ends in the photos. Tools include midi-evil axes? and UF"O"s?

Not interested in copyrights or egos. Interested in THE SPORT
aga

hills
SA, 1622 posts
26 Jul 2008 9:30PM
Thumbs Up

Aga, you should probably know that Paul has designed a huge number of yachts (including my PM) and always made the plans available to anyone who wants them for absolutely no personal gain. He just does it for the love of the sport, which sounds pretty much aligned with your thoughts. If a "dumpster" design was chosen for this entry class landyacht I think we'd be wise to choose one of Paul's designs as they include a huge amount of landyachting experience.

PS The axe was just for humour and the couple of different front designs would be because the design was evolving while Paul was documenting it.

FAZE5
SA, 55 posts
27 Jul 2008 1:31AM
Thumbs Up

Just an observation to all,

I've sailed a blokart (brilliant, satisfying)
I've sailed a lake lefroy mini (brilliant, satisfying)

Now, after 35 years or so, of sailing, racing & having built somewhere around 150 landyachts; what is the best deal?

Well actually, I've always found its when people get together & have a great time sailing.

It doesn't matter whether the yachts are big, small or cheap or expensive. (I reckon I've built a landyacht to cover most categories!) What helps are good design aspects that work & easy to rig/sail.

It does help to have similar performing yachts whatever your doing, be it exploring or racing or just having fun.

Yes, you will get people who want to build their own & people who can afford to buy.....

For heavens sake! This is brilliant! The above 2 yachts are both great for their purpose and you end up in both cases with people who may not otherwise be in the sport. They are obviously not the only yachts around, but I have not seen for many years a better chance for new landsailers to get into it, with the advantages that small well designed yachts can offer.

Forget egos, just be aware that a landyacht may look simple, the dynamics are complex, and good designers who really know how to get it right have spent many $$$ & many years to get there. I know, I've tried.

Please understand & appreciate what Paul is giving to Landsailing with his LL mini.

Happy sailing

agamackay
QLD, 58 posts
27 Jul 2008 9:29AM
Thumbs Up

I understand that & I`m not saying that Paul does not deserve credit for his designs. But he should not have to bear the brunt of abusive phone calls on his own in the case of a nationally recognised and endorsed yacht.
It would not be fair on any one to be blamed for soneone else`s workmanship/design interpritation.
aga

hills
SA, 1622 posts
27 Jul 2008 11:01AM
Thumbs Up

Ah, I see where you're coming from now. No, you're absolutely correct!

The good thing about selecting a common entry class design is there would be a lot of people building them (hopefully!!) so they could all share tips, knowledge and improvements amongst themselves and the designer via forums like this. I think this is something that was lacking in the past when those issues occurred.

Gizmo
SA, 2865 posts
27 Jul 2008 12:14PM
Thumbs Up

Just had to go to the shops and guess what was on the side of the road?......
a trampoline !!!!! do I, dont I, do I, dont I, do I, dont I,?

hills
SA, 1622 posts
27 Jul 2008 12:32PM
Thumbs Up

DO IT!! You don't get raw materials like that everyday!!

Actually, Nah just leave it, but tell me where it is!



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Land Yacht Sailing General


"Cheap & easy to built (Class 5) land yacht" started by agamackay