Forums > Sailing General

live-aboard coastal cruiser?

Reply
Created by davox666 > 9 months ago, 26 Apr 2010
davox666
4 posts
26 Apr 2010 5:45PM
Thumbs Up

hi all, i am looking for some advise on the best live-aboard coastal cruisers. its time to say goodbye to trailer sailers and it's my plan to live aboard for the next 2 years (at least). i am based around harvey bay and looking for a strong seaworthy yacht suitable for east coast cruising. my budget is around the $45,000 mark, but cheaper would be better! i had been considering the adams 35 but recently have been looking at the westsail 32. maybe a roberts??? any suggestions or advice would be greatly appreciated.
thanks, dave.

garyk
QLD, 277 posts
28 Apr 2010 7:45PM
Thumbs Up

A Compass 28 or Clansman 30 are both great go anywhere cruisers "alot of bang for ya buck" and there easy to singlehand. If you spend mid 30k you will get an awesome little cruiser.
Heres a picture of a compass 28 on the hard stand that I recently sold

davox666
4 posts
29 Apr 2010 3:15AM
Thumbs Up

thanks cisco and garyk for the advice, very much appreciated. after doing a little research the s&s and the compass will definitely go on my 'to look at list'.
cisco you were saying that it would be hard to find a decent adams 35 for around the $45,000 mark, i have seen a few advertised for $50,000, these are multi chine steel hulls, what are your thoughts on such yachts?
garyk your old compass looks a real beauty, how much did you sell it for? is there any other advice you could offer on these? e.g.. any problems? what to look out for when buying? cabin space?
thanks again for your help.

Ramona
NSW, 7635 posts
29 Apr 2010 8:57AM
Thumbs Up

davox666 said...

thanks cisco and garyk for the advice, very much appreciated. after doing a little research the s&s and the compass will definitely go on my 'to look at list'.
cisco you were saying that it would be hard to find a decent adams 35 for around the $45,000 mark, i have seen a few advertised for $50,000, these are multi chine steel hulls, what are your thoughts on such yachts?
garyk your old compass looks a real beauty, how much did you sell it for? is there any other advice you could offer on these? e.g.. any problems? what to look out for when buying? cabin space?
thanks again for your help.




If your thinking steel then a comprehensive survey is recommended. I would have no qualms about purchasing a yacht built in other mediums with out a survey but steel can hide many sins. This week we had a steel cruiser sink at the mooring here. After being pumped out it was towed to the slips. After a clean up and inspection with a hammer, the problem was self evident. Several holes each side. MSB stated it could not go back in the water till correctly repaired. It was sold on the slips for $8000. Crane turned up with a semi trailer and hauled it away. This was a quality 40ft
rolled steel cruiser with heaps of gear.
There was a Westsail 32 in QLD for 50 grand, is that still for sail? The cheapest SS34 for sale at the moment is in Perth for 59 grand. Swanson 31 Carmen needs an interior clean up in Townsville for 34 grand or a nice old Swanson 32 in Mackay for 19 thousand. Keep an eye on Yachthub, buyers market and some awesome cruisers come up from time to time.

davox666
4 posts
30 Apr 2010 4:12PM
Thumbs Up

Yeah your right there Romona, i would definitely be getting a survey done on any boat i choose. I noticed a Westsail just sold in Qld for $40 grand- nice price considering one in good nick can fetch around $80,000. But i do worry about there lack of performance. Its more the interior space and there strength i find very appealing.
Cisco, im a joiner by trade, but mainly do house reno's these days. The VDS you pointed out would be a great (and logical) choice, but there is too much work and time involved for me at the moment.
What im really looking for is something with a sound hull, good rigging and a interior that needs a good work over. Something like the Swanson Carmen 31 that Romona pointed out fits the bill.
Thanks again for your reply's and great advice.

badinfluence
QLD, 538 posts
30 Apr 2010 7:25PM
Thumbs Up

Bit of a conflict of interest as she is mine and I am selling her, however, look at the Triton 721 Extended on Yachthub.

If it's just you alone, she would suit as a liveaboard.

Better headroom than the Compass/Clansman/even perhaps Swanson.

Very sound hull, have been out in Moreton Bay on too many occasions with horrible weather conditions...read 40+ knots with tall, sharp chop; and a particularly nasty occasion under duress and on anchor on a lee shore at Peel Island in a 35 knot southeasterly.

No slouch under sail,, very good to windward.

Just a suggestion. Really interested in finding her a new person to love and serve her well.

Cheers
Trace

whiteout
QLD, 264 posts
1 May 2010 11:28PM
Thumbs Up

Try the folkboat experience they are seaworthy and I have spent more on mine than I like to tell, solar panel. regulator agm battery bank , smart charger , new switchboard, 240 volt outlets, GPS and sounders the list goes on and lived aboard for 3 years and love every minute of it.



Ramona
NSW, 7635 posts
2 May 2010 6:04PM
Thumbs Up

whiteout said...

Try the folkboat experience they are seaworthy and I have spent more on mine than I like to tell, solar panel. regulator agm battery bank , smart charger , new switchboard, 240 volt outlets, GPS and sounders the list goes on and lived aboard for 3 years and love every minute of it.



That's one of the nicest fit outs of a folkboat I have seen. One on the slips here at the moment, its a shame they are so tiny. Hard to imagine living in a boat with out headroom. Its a shame we never got boats like the Marieholme 33 in Australia, its the "grown up" folkboat.

Nice Twister for sale in Queensland, bit expensive at 45 grand but its a larger folkboat derivative.

Just checked the Twister again and its dropped $5000 in the last week.

Ramona
NSW, 7635 posts
3 May 2010 8:24AM
Thumbs Up

cisco said...

If I am not mistaken, the later fibreglass production Folkboats like Anthony's have head room in the main cabin. Great live aboard for one or two people.

Four of the five recently sold ones listed on Boat Point went for less than $1,5001.




The Marieholm 26 does. The photo in Anthony's avatar looks like an International folkboat.I'm sure Anthony will be along shortly to put us right.

whiteout
QLD, 264 posts
3 May 2010 10:34AM
Thumbs Up

Whiteout is a International Folkboat and It doesn't have a lot of headroom but if you want you can standup outside ha ha ha. You have to be willing to sacrifice something when you live on boats and this is the basis of sailing you always want a bigger boat at some stage but you have to sail it yourself without crew at some stage and you want a boat that is seaworthy, wateritght and functional.

maxm
NSW, 864 posts
3 May 2010 11:31AM
Thumbs Up

Yup, the Marieholm 26 (aka M26) has standing headroom (just). I'm about 5'8" and can stand up in mine with head bowed.

The M26 is easiest to spot by looking at the cockpit placement - it is further aft and is almost hard up against the transom. That enabled the cabin to be a bit longer as well. They usually seem to have inboard diesels which can be good or bad depending on how you look at it (eg I'd love to have all that storage space that Whiteout's got where his engine isn't!) I think the hull is the same though. There aren't as many of M26s around and the asking price is usually a bit higher as well.

There's also the original Nordic version for the purists which has even an even smaller cabin and less headroom than all other variants. If you've got deep pockets, you can still buy those brand new! Or if you like timber boats, there's the Stella which again is essentially the same boat but usually with standing headroom.

Any of them make tough, capable little boats, easily handled by one or two people.

Ramona
NSW, 7635 posts
3 May 2010 5:57PM
Thumbs Up

maxm said...

Yup, the Marieholm 26 (aka M26) has standing headroom (just). I'm about 5'8" and can stand up in mine with head bowed.

The M26 is easiest to spot by looking at the cockpit placement - it is further aft and is almost hard up against the transom. That enabled the cabin to be a bit longer as well. They usually seem to have inboard diesels which can be good or bad depending on how you look at it (eg I'd love to have all that storage space that Whiteout's got where his engine isn't!) I think the hull is the same though. There aren't as many of M26s around and the asking price is usually a bit higher as well.




I seem to recall the Marieholm 26 has an extra 2 inches of freeboard in the hull which makes them slightly longer as well. Some of the Internationals have a pop tops to give headroom at anchor. The Internationals have headroom with the overhead hatch open! My quarter tonner is much larger inside than a folkboat but no headroom and no overhead hatch.

My next yacht will be larger if only to get standing headroom and its going to have a sliding overhead hatch.

garyk
QLD, 277 posts
3 May 2010 6:26PM
Thumbs Up

Yes thats Burnett Heads Cisco nice spot and has cheap haul out and hardstand area also has a great bunch of locals

The compass has similar lines to the folkboat but has more space inside and you have a much more sound hull and alot less maintenance being fibreglass. The fitout is really good but dosent have a comfy couch which I think is a must have on any boat that you spend alot of time on.

"Somthings to keep in mind" I think if your single the smaller boats are great if you want to single hand all the time but its hard to get a lady on board for any length of time or just any sort of company. It can get pretty lonely out there on a small boat and there are sooooooooooooooooooo many lonely single blokes out there living on there grubby little boats

I like little boats for many reasons but for live-aboard Im over little boats for reasons greater then reasons for having one. Im currently building a 42 and it is so much more liveable has more everything and heaps of deck space for the toys!
and the crew wont do the runner

A good private head is important for the ladys too and It has to be clean!!!!!
and they also need an unusual amount of storage space for all there "stuff"
and did I mention the must have couch

Good luck Davox on finding your "dream" beware on buying a fixitupera unless you have ALOT of time and money because your dream could be shatered and turn into a nightmare! and be carefull you dont buy a lemon that has shiny paint!!!!!!!!!!

davox666
4 posts
5 May 2010 3:20PM
Thumbs Up

Some more great advice there, especially regarding the lady factor! I have a wonderful and understanding woman by my side, but i think ( i know) i would be testing her understanding in something like the triton or folkboat! Nice looking boats but as you said, better for a single man.
As far as my lady is concerned the westsail is still winning hands down, nice and beamy in the cabin, and easy to get around on deck. Also 32 feet is not too big for the 2 of us to handle.
As far as im concerned, im liking the look and price of the compass but maybe the 29. Is there much difference between the 28 and 29 (besides 1 foot)?
any way thanks again for all your replys.

Ramona
NSW, 7635 posts
5 May 2010 6:33PM
Thumbs Up

davox666 said...

Some more great advice there, especially regarding the lady factor! I have a wonderful and understanding woman by my side, but i think ( i know) i would be testing her understanding in something like the triton or folkboat! Nice looking boats but as you said, better for a single man.
As far as my lady is concerned the westsail is still winning hands down, nice and beamy in the cabin, and easy to get around on deck. Also 32 feet is not too big for the 2 of us to handle.
As far as im concerned, im liking the look and price of the compass but maybe the 29. Is there much difference between the 28 and 29 (besides 1 foot)?
any way thanks again for all your replys.


There is a Westsail 32 for sale in Bali at the moment. Very well built boat but they are not called Westsnails for nothing. Nice one about 100 metres from my boat that changed hands a few months ago. I would agree they have nice interiors.

garyk
QLD, 277 posts
5 May 2010 8:45PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
davox666 the compass 28 wins hands down on performance over the 29 for a small gain in space and heaps more windage
Ramona is right there is a Wetsail I mean Westsail in bali worth a look at
You can pickup cheap yachts in asia if you keep an eye out



Well I was talking with Terry today and he spoke highly of "Huahine". He reckoned you got that deck prism way too cheap especially since the "Bundaberg Seagulls and Ancient Mariners Society" had their eyes on it for something to light up their club rooms being as how they can't afford to have the electricity on.


Terry and dianne have a great yacht and have had a huge influence on me with the direction in which I go with vessel choice and construction acually Terry put me on to Tom Colvin designs
Its a beauty that prism its going in the forepeak to lighten things up as its a bit dark up there and its a bit of bling.
The 42 is very easy to single hand and light displacment mine weighs only 10t net
"long and lean" and she has chinese lug sails, so you can reduce sail while running and theres no going forward to man handle sail down they just fall down into the lazyjacks on any angle to the wind. Also has a 9" bowsprit so shes very manuverable when weighing anchor and also setting up the windlass so its easy to weigh anchor single handed which is a must for me.
The original was designed with a cargo hold but these days its the smelly engine room

garyk
QLD, 277 posts
6 May 2010 7:40PM
Thumbs Up

cisco, I saw compass rose just before christmas when I was delivering Huahine to port douglas and Terry was debuging everything then,its a shame about the engine trouble he's having. I can get a realy good deals on new engines so im bitting the bullet and buying a brand new volvo 40hp for mine
How are thing going with your S&S

garyk
QLD, 277 posts
7 May 2010 7:34PM
Thumbs Up

cisco said...



As they say, you will always have a job if you own a boat.


And a big hole in the pocket But its worth every penney

Marutji
QLD, 3 posts
25 May 2010 7:15PM
Thumbs Up

Hi cisco and davox!

Muy girlfriend and I also liveaboard a multi-chine VDS 34 and really like it. We never find it too small and have not once wished it was bigger. This is our first boat as we are pretty new to this cruising lark, so we don't have much to compare it to, but i thought I would let you know how happy we are with its perfomance and liveability.

The only thing we currently need to make her perfect is a wind vane self steering of some kind.... so if anybody out there has one for sale, please get in touch.

Bye the way cisco, excuse me for being a bit paranoid, but why did you say that your VDS would definitely be at the bottom now? That sounds a bit scary!

Ramona
NSW, 7635 posts
26 May 2010 8:33AM
Thumbs Up

Marutji said...

Hi cisco and davox!

Muy girlfriend and I also liveaboard a multi-chine VDS 34 and really like it. We never find it too small and have not once wished it was bigger. This is our first boat as we are pretty new to this cruising lark, so we don't have much to compare it to, but i thought I would let you know how happy we are with its perfomance and liveability.




Multi chine steel one in Greenwell Point a couple of weeks ago, beige colour. Always been a fan of Van de Stadt designs. I was keen on a cold moulded version for sale in Qld awhile back but no money at the time. There was a steel Vita here a few years ago hold up with bad weather. Couple of blokes going to Qld. They reckoned it was a nice boat but slow. Noticed it for sale in Qld a few weeks later.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Sailing General


"live-aboard coastal cruiser?" started by davox666