Forums > Stand Up Paddle General

Flat Turn VS Hard On A Rail

Reply
Created by OG SUP > 9 months ago, 9 Mar 2013
OG SUP
VIC, 3516 posts
9 Mar 2013 12:02PM
Thumbs Up

I was watching some suppers down the coast and since people are going to wide short thicker boards 8'6 ish the tendency for most is to do pretty flat ugly turns. Yes it does throw water but frankly it looks bloody awe full.

One of these guys used to shred on a 9.0 hard on the rail all the time, but by going so short has lost all the style and explosive power he once had.

When watching the ISA event it even looked like the judges were scoring the flat turns in a similar range to the rail turns.

Has the critera shifted to make up for the change in style?

I hope not!

Phill

antonfourie
NSW, 140 posts
9 Mar 2013 12:10PM
Thumbs Up

I don't that it is so much the board as what "everyone" is doing and what the judges are scoring

Look at pro surfing to see where SUP surfing will end in up in a few years, those flat turns will go out of fashion

hilly
WA, 7272 posts
9 Mar 2013 9:49AM
Thumbs Up

OG SUP said...

I was watching some suppers down the coast and since people are going to wide short thicker boards 8'6 ish the tendency for most is to do pretty flat ugly turns. Yes it does throw water but frankly it looks bloody awe full.

One of these guys used to shred on a 9.0 hard on the rail all the time, but by going so short has lost all the style and explosive power he once had.

When watching the ISA event it even looked like the judges were scoring the flat turns in a similar range to the rail turns.

Has the critera shifted to make up for the change in style?

I hope not!

Phill





Bit of an old chestnut Phill I think we all agree you will never rail turn anything over 30 inches

More here www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Stand-Up-Paddle/SUP/A-powerful-hack/

hilly said...
Simondo said...



Post some "Powerful Hack" photos here!!


Thats a blinder

Best I have seen on a sup is Blane.

Simondo posted this



I like this one



Edit or my average effort




appsy
NSW, 198 posts
9 Mar 2013 1:26PM
Thumbs Up

OG Sup, Yeah I do agree with you. I still have an interest in the small sups because they are fun in the right conditions. But the guys around where I live have gone back up in length. My main sup partner Scott Downing has gone back up to 10 ft sup's which suits he's style and approach. He's tried going smaller but he found the dish panning disease hit him. The critera has changed with comps which is why guys are now riding 7ft sup/s. The 10 foot section of the Noosa Festival will be highlight.

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
9 Mar 2013 1:07PM
Thumbs Up

OG SUP said...

I was watching some suppers down the coast and since people are going to wide short thicker boards 8'6 ish the tendency for most is to do pretty flat ugly turns. Yes it does throw water but frankly it looks bloody awe full.

One of these guys used to shred on a 9.0 hard on the rail all the time, but by going so short has lost all the style and explosive power he once had.

When watching the ISA event it even looked like the judges were scoring the flat turns in a similar range to the rail turns.

Has the critera shifted to make up for the change in style?

I hope not!

Phill





well i've got a 7'4 and my aim is to turn on rail. i surf it with a reasonable set of fins and for a 31" board the tail is fairly well pulled in.


i'm looking at getting the nsp 9'2 that a mate of mine was involved in to keep me honest so to speak when i get some brass


flame on time. i think surf comp sups should be 10 ft. the way it is now with guys are paddling boards under water trying to shortboard but its slow and ugly compared too.

these guys are awesome surfers no doubtabout it thou

comp sup surfing will die if it keeps heading this way imo

Zeusman
QLD, 1363 posts
9 Mar 2013 1:36PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote


comp sup surfing will die if it keeps heading this way imo


Agreed!

Leroy13
VIC, 1174 posts
9 Mar 2013 2:42PM
Thumbs Up

Comp supping, having fun, reliving our youth, having fun, everything I do on a wave looks bloody ugly compared to Keahi, Kelly, Jason Polakow etc. (for that matter just about anybody!) I'm 50 plus, most on this forum are at least 40 plus. I'm going to go out supping and have fun whenever I get the chance, and I'm not going to tell anybody what they are doing is ugly, because today's ugly is tommorow's cutting edge. I vaguely remember 'Airs' being considered a skateboard trick 25 years ago. This is just an observation on my part, not an indictment of others opinions

Scott79
QLD, 209 posts
9 Mar 2013 1:52PM
Thumbs Up

Nothing wrong with yours Hilly!

I have got a 9'2 Allwave, and whilst the 31.5 inch width and big rail volume is your friend a lot of the time, it definitely makes those turns on the rail difficult to pull off with any style. For me anyway...

Scott.

AA
NSW, 2159 posts
9 Mar 2013 4:32PM
Thumbs Up

Zeusman said...


comp sup surfing will die if it keeps heading this way imo


+1

Customs could be the death of Comp surfing.
Average Joe is not going to go through 2-3 customs a year to be competitive.
10' works and is the future for Comp surfing if that side of the sport is to grow IMO. If production boards are competitive, brands will back the events and more people will compete. If you need a custom to win, watch the sponsorship $'s dry up. Customs are very important for the development of the sport, but if that is what you need to win your average Club round then most crew will eventually lose interest. Just look at the original crew on this forum who were all pumped on Comp surfing. Most have moved on or gone quiet and rarely post any more.
This might bring them back though

teatrea
QLD, 4177 posts
9 Mar 2013 5:49PM
Thumbs Up

I think maybee 10 is a bit to big , better limiting boards to 9 and over. But i agree the ultra short sups look sillyExcept of course when guys like Keahi , Zane amd the wonder kid ride them. Just amateur comps should restrict board size not the pro,s , they need to push the limits.

62mac
WA, 24860 posts
9 Mar 2013 4:03PM
Thumbs Up

teatrea said...
I think maybee 10 is a bit to big , better limiting boards to 9 and over.


Boy you blokes are slow, I've been telling you for ages,follow us longboarders

Serious note,have a look at the new generation shortboards wider and shorter,here's one of my sons.





laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
9 Mar 2013 7:24PM
Thumbs Up

teatrea- ten foot is the go for sups. did you checkout the dogman's latest vid. noseriding, tricks and some good old fashioned hacks.

i can see numbers having a go at that.

i can see sponsors being interested in that



paul.j
QLD, 3318 posts
9 Mar 2013 7:35PM
Thumbs Up

Really most of the top guys are riding production, I would say at the ISA over 50% were on production boards and ripping on them. Sean won the comp on production and beau Nixon was a stand out with full rail to rail surfing. Limiting boards will kill the progression of the sport IMO. If love riding bigger boards that is cool and it's great fun but for the top comps no way.

hilly
WA, 7272 posts
9 Mar 2013 5:41PM
Thumbs Up

paul.j said...
Really most of the top guys are riding production, I would say at the ISA over 50% were on production boards and ripping on them. Sean won the comp on production and beau Nixon was a stand out with full rail to rail surfing. Limiting boards will kill the progression of the sport IMO. If love riding bigger boards that is cool and it's great fun but for the top comps no way.


Agree with that.

A 9 or 10 foot class would be attractive to bigger guys as we cannot compete with the young fit fellas. Would add appeal to comp surfing for the average joe.

62mac
WA, 24860 posts
9 Mar 2013 6:02PM
Thumbs Up

laceys lane said...
teatrea- ten foot is the go for sups. did you checkout the dogman's latest vid. noseriding, tricks and some good old fashioned hacks.

i can see numbers having a go at that.

i can see sponsors being interested in that






Sounds like you've been spending too much time in the LB forum,good to see your education is coming along beit slow

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
9 Mar 2013 8:28PM
Thumbs Up

62mac said...
laceys lane said...
teatrea- ten foot is the go for sups. did you checkout the dogman's latest vid. noseriding, tricks and some good old fashioned hacks.

i can see numbers having a go at that.

i can see sponsors being interested in that






Sounds like you've been spending too much time in the LB forum,good to see your education is coming along beit slow



nah, i've been thinking this for a long time

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
9 Mar 2013 8:37PM
Thumbs Up

paul.j said...
Really most of the top guys are riding production, I would say at the ISA over 50% were on production boards and ripping on them. Sean won the comp on production and beau Nixon was a stand out with full rail to rail surfing. Limiting boards will kill the progression of the sport IMO. If love riding bigger boards that is cool and it's great fun but for the top comps no way.



what the same comps with the same top five guys for the next five years progressing to where- a poor man,s version of shortboarding with dwindling numbers every year- no it will not last.


the problem is comp sup is trying to be like something else. it lacks it own identity, class, soul and style

SupaTrooper
QLD, 243 posts
9 Mar 2013 8:47PM
Thumbs Up

2 cents worth to add- I have a 10'2 laguna & a 8'10" starboard as part of the quiver for the very reason of different boards for different conditions + I love to surf both styles- short & long, I'm only hoping the local club- SUPSA eventually breaks the surfing comp into 2 divisions re 10 foot over or under as I think both will have great support.

hb
QLD, 12 posts
9 Mar 2013 10:09PM
Thumbs Up

maybe to be fair to all,short or tall the size of the board for a sup comp should be relative to the size of the surfer. i e say 3 ft greater than the surfer. a 5'6ft person can surf 8'6ft a 6'2 person a 9'2 board. food for thought

Zeusman
QLD, 1363 posts
9 Mar 2013 10:12PM
Thumbs Up

hb said...
maybe to be fair to all,short or tall the size of the board for a sup comp should be relative to the size of the surfer. i e say 3 ft greater than the surfer. a 5'6ft person can surf 8'6ft a 6'2 person a 9'2 board. food for thought


Not a bad idea that!

PeterP
823 posts
9 Mar 2013 9:48PM
Thumbs Up

5 out of 8 boards in Semis at ISA where production - 3 out of 4 in ISA final where production. The production boards are up to scratch now, customs will be for the absolute minority looking for something that the brands don't have as yet.

Wrt competition SUP surfing I think a reasonable way to control the underwater brigade is is too put a limit on how many paddle-strokes you are allowed to take kneeling or proning. This way you force the guys to have a minimum amount of flotation and keep it SUP.

Having said that, looking at Mo Freitas and Kai paddle boards with water tickling their knee-caps when standing still is still out of the realm for anyone with average fitness.

OG SUP
VIC, 3516 posts
10 Mar 2013 1:50AM
Thumbs Up

Hi PeterP,

I dont know about ISA I wasn't there but I have seen a lot of team riders at Nationals in Australia on so called production boards and really what they are is a production prototype hmmm me thinks thats a CUSTOM. Even if its likely to go into production next year it still is a CUSTOM this year. Then next year yup you guessed it there will be another prototype also a Custom.

Exactly the same happens with race boards.

Then there is the infamous situation with Connor riding various SICs and surfing JLs stickered up as Starbys and that isn't an isolated situation by any means many others do the same but its just not publicised.

If your a kid mostly you only have one choice and thats you guessed it a CUSTOM.

If you have gone to a custom and then go back to a production board there is little comparison on weight and performance and depending on how you have them glassed longevity can be comparable.

It would be great to say it dosen't work that way but thats the reality.

Phill




Mixup
NSW, 52 posts
10 Mar 2013 7:56AM
Thumbs Up

AA said...
Zeusman said...


comp sup surfing will die if it keeps heading this way imo


+1

Customs could be the death of Comp surfing.
Average Joe is not going to go through 2-3 customs a year to be competitive.
10' works and is the future for Comp surfing if that side of the sport is to grow IMO. If production boards are competitive, brands will back the events and more people will compete. If you need a custom to win, watch the sponsorship $'s dry up. Customs are very important for the development of the sport, but if that is what you need to win your average Club round then most crew will eventually lose interest. Just look at the original crew on this forum who were all pumped on Comp surfing. Most have moved on or gone quiet and rarely post any more.
This might bring them back though



IMO customs are helping to push comps along. If there's a choice of seeing Keahi and Jackson pulling airs on prototypes or watching someone walk the nose on a 10', I know what the majority would like to watch and what kind of surfing the sponsors would back. Maybe guys are leaving the contest scene because it costs $150 to enter!

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
10 Mar 2013 8:20AM
Thumbs Up

Mixup said...
AA said...
Zeusman said...


comp sup surfing will die if it keeps heading this way imo


+1

Customs could be the death of Comp surfing.
Average Joe is not going to go through 2-3 customs a year to be competitive.
10' works and is the future for Comp surfing if that side of the sport is to grow IMO. If production boards are competitive, brands will back the events and more people will compete. If you need a custom to win, watch the sponsorship $'s dry up. Customs are very important for the development of the sport, but if that is what you need to win your average Club round then most crew will eventually lose interest. Just look at the original crew on this forum who were all pumped on Comp surfing. Most have moved on or gone quiet and rarely post any more.
This might bring them back though



IMO customs are helping to push comps along. If there's a choice of seeing Keahi and Jackson pulling airs on prototypes or watching someone walk the nose on a 10', I know what the majority would like to watch and what kind of surfing the sponsors would back. Maybe guys are leaving the contest scene because it costs $150 to enter!



but how many keahi's and jackson's are there that can surf these really small boards

what if they move on to something else can sup just rely on a few lightweights and freaks

and as dam good as they are my local board riders weekend comp round has more of that type of action done bigger, harder and faster.

and where are these so called sponsors right now

sup really needs to look at how and where they are going with the contest scene because its dying atm

OG SUP
VIC, 3516 posts
10 Mar 2013 9:22AM
Thumbs Up

Casso said...
Imagine telling Joel Parko he had to compete on a board over 7 foot? Ridiculous.

What do a mean short SUPs don't turn on rail or bigger blokes need bigger boards:



^^^ Woogie at Noosa the other day, shot by Deems.




Nice Laguna CUSTOM lol

OG SUP
VIC, 3516 posts
10 Mar 2013 9:24AM
Thumbs Up

laceys lane said...
Mixup said...
AA said...
Zeusman said...


comp sup surfing will die if it keeps heading this way imo


+1

Customs could be the death of Comp surfing.
Average Joe is not going to go through 2-3 customs a year to be competitive.
10' works and is the future for Comp surfing if that side of the sport is to grow IMO. If production boards are competitive, brands will back the events and more people will compete. If you need a custom to win, watch the sponsorship $'s dry up. Customs are very important for the development of the sport, but if that is what you need to win your average Club round then most crew will eventually lose interest. Just look at the original crew on this forum who were all pumped on Comp surfing. Most have moved on or gone quiet and rarely post any more.
This might bring them back though



IMO customs are helping to push comps along. If there's a choice of seeing Keahi and Jackson pulling airs on prototypes or watching someone walk the nose on a 10', I know what the majority would like to watch and what kind of surfing the sponsors would back. Maybe guys are leaving the contest scene because it costs $150 to enter!



but how many keahi's and jackson's are there that can surf these really small boards

what if they move on to something else can sup just rely on a few lightweights and freaks

and as dam good as they are my local board riders weekend comp round has more of that type of action done bigger, harder and faster.

and where are these so called sponsors right now

sup really needs to look at how and where they are going with the contest scene because its dying atm



Lacey i have been setting up to do junior development for kids in Vicco as there is a group of kids between 8 an 12 that want to have crack. What your faced with:

In racing there is only one board that even goes close to what a child needs and thats a custom Lahui Kai 9'6, I believe they are going to make it as a production board this year and it shows great fore thought that they will do this, the cost is about $1250 and then freight to the southern states.

If they are really serious and want to do down winding as well then you need a second board and you can probably add about the same $1200.

Note these are epoxy not carbon and your at min $1200 to $2400 ++

For carbon say $3600 - $4000 ++

On the surfing side there is only one option and that again is custom and min would be about $1200 up to about $1800 + freight.

If you have super deep pockets then go carbon and again double up the numbers.

Again if your serious you need 2 x boards one for HP surfing on good clean days and a more stable one for rough days as here we get onshore 150 -200 days per year.

You need to realise that once you buy these kids boards you can basically expect to between $00 eg cant sell them or maybe at best %50 resale.

Put this up against getting your son / daughter into surfing for a second hand shorty you can probably get one for say $2-300 probably less and sell it in 12 months for almost the same and pick up another one.

What is limiting junior development is simple COST.

NO JUNIORS NO FUTURE




laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
10 Mar 2013 8:32AM
Thumbs Up

yeah it's a task phil. however those lahui kai's 9'6 will do everything a kid needs to do.

but points taken aboard

paul.j
QLD, 3318 posts
10 Mar 2013 8:37AM
Thumbs Up

OG SUP said...
laceys lane said...
Mixup said...
AA said...
Zeusman said...


comp sup surfing will die if it keeps heading this way imo


+1

Customs could be the death of Comp surfing.
Average Joe is not going to go through 2-3 customs a year to be competitive.
10' works and is the future for Comp surfing if that side of the sport is to grow IMO. If production boards are competitive, brands will back the events and more people will compete. If you need a custom to win, watch the sponsorship $'s dry up. Customs are very important for the development of the sport, but if that is what you need to win your average Club round then most crew will eventually lose interest. Just look at the original crew on this forum who were all pumped on Comp surfing. Most have moved on or gone quiet and rarely post any more.
This might bring them back though



IMO customs are helping to push comps along. If there's a choice of seeing Keahi and Jackson pulling airs on prototypes or watching someone walk the nose on a 10', I know what the majority would like to watch and what kind of surfing the sponsors would back. Maybe guys are leaving the contest scene because it costs $150 to enter!



but how many keahi's and jackson's are there that can surf these really small boards

what if they move on to something else can sup just rely on a few lightweights and freaks

and as dam good as they are my local board riders weekend comp round has more of that type of action done bigger, harder and faster.

and where are these so called sponsors right now

sup really needs to look at how and where they are going with the contest scene because its dying atm



Lacey i have been setting up to do junior development for kids in Vicco as there is a group of kids between 8 an 12 that want to have crack. What your faced with:

In racing there is only one board that even goes close to what a child needs and thats a custom Lahui Kai 9'6, I believe they are going to make it as a production board this year and it shows great fore thought that they will do this, the cost is about $1250 and then freight to the southern states.

If they are really serious and want to do down winding as well then you need a second board and you can probably add about the same $1200.

Note these are epoxy not carbon and your at min $1200 to $2400 ++

For carbon say $3600 - $4000 ++

On the surfing side there is only one option and that again is custom and min would be about $1200 up to about $1800 + freight.

If you have super deep pockets then go carbon and again double up the numbers.

Again if your serious you need 2 x boards one for HP surfing on good clean days and a more stable one for rough days as here we get onshore 150 -200 days per year.

You need to realise that once you buy these kids boards you can basically expect to between $00 eg cant sell them or maybe at best %50 resale.

Put this up against getting your son / daughter into surfing for a second hand shorty you can probably get one for say $2-300 probably less and sell it in 12 months for almost the same and pick up another one.

What is limiting junior development is simple COST.

NO JUNIORS NO FUTURE







SUP has being going pretty good up to date with out to many juniors? Pretty sure it's the fastest growing water sport and this is without juniors. Maybe a junior in our sport fir now is someone in their mid 20's?

paul.j
QLD, 3318 posts
10 Mar 2013 8:39AM
Thumbs Up

OG SUP said...
Hi PeterP,

I dont know about ISA I wasn't there but I have seen a lot of team riders at Nationals in Australia on so called production boards and really what they are is a production prototype hmmm me thinks thats a CUSTOM. Even if its likely to go into production next year it still is a CUSTOM this year. Then next year yup you guessed it there will be another prototype also a Custom.

Exactly the same happens with race boards.

Then there is the infamous situation with Connor riding various SICs and surfing JLs stickered up as Starbys and that isn't an isolated situation by any means many others do the same but its just not publicised.

If your a kid mostly you only have one choice and thats you guessed it a CUSTOM.

If you have gone to a custom and then go back to a production board there is little comparison on weight and performance and depending on how you have them glassed longevity can be comparable.

It would be great to say it dosen't work that way but thats the reality.

Phill







None of the production surfing sups at the Isa were customs all current production boards.

PeterP
823 posts
10 Mar 2013 6:48AM
Thumbs Up

OG SUP said...
Hi PeterP,

I dont know about ISA I wasn't there but I have seen a lot of team riders at Nationals in Australia on so called production boards and really what they are is a production prototype hmmm me thinks thats a CUSTOM. Even if its likely to go into production next year it still is a CUSTOM this year. Then next year yup you guessed it there will be another prototype also a Custom.

Exactly the same happens with race boards.

Then there is the infamous situation with Connor riding various SICs and surfing JLs stickered up as Starbys and that isn't an isolated situation by any means many others do the same but its just not publicised.

If your a kid mostly you only have one choice and thats you guessed it a CUSTOM.

If you have gone to a custom and then go back to a production board there is little comparison on weight and performance and depending on how you have them glassed longevity can be comparable.

It would be great to say it dosen't work that way but thats the reality.

Phill







Not sure about all the Starby's but the 3 Naish's in Semi's and 2 in wave-SUP-finals were production from what I was told from local Naish Peruvian importer (one of them was Chris Bertish and I gave him that board so thats one confirmed) - I'm sure Jacko can also confirm the others. On the race side I know Casper was on production (1st and 2nd). Kai was on a proto at Sunset Beach though. Dylan was on a production All Star 12'6 and came 3rd - also confirmed production.

Wrt kids boards it is a small market, but an 80 liter 8'0 from Naish high performance short board should suffice for all but the 8-10yo's.....I stand by my remarks that custom is an ever narrowing market place.

And disclaimer - yes, I pimp Naish.



Casso
NSW, 3768 posts
10 Mar 2013 9:56AM
Thumbs Up

Imagine telling Mick Fanning he had to compete on a pop out from China? Ridiculous.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle General


"Flat Turn VS Hard On A Rail" started by OG SUP