Forums > Stand Up Paddle General

GoPro Hero3 Silver or Sony Action Cam

Reply
Created by Adapt > 9 months ago, 16 Dec 2012
Adapt
QLD, 723 posts
16 Dec 2012 1:20PM
Thumbs Up

Looking at purchasing one of these for christmas or sometime after, any info on the pros and cons of using them in the water, purchasing mounts etc would be greatly appreciated.

Being a non camera person I've read all the specifics but it reminds me of chemistry back at school (doesn't make any sense)

Cheers

gregc
VIC, 1298 posts
16 Dec 2012 5:17PM
Thumbs Up

I would think they are much of a muchness to be honest, really I think with all the technology involved its almost a ford v holden question. I have a go pro and would probably buy another one. I guess some will like other types. I started looking at one called a drift innovation the other day it also seemed really cool. The little JVC is also worth a look.

Gorgo
VIC, 4982 posts
16 Dec 2012 8:24PM
Thumbs Up

Read this www.gizmodo.com.au/2012/12/the-best-action-camera/

Watch this

Downwinder
QLD, 2030 posts
16 Dec 2012 8:50PM
Thumbs Up

ION camera loves water sports very easy to use AND thats a big AND NO FOGGING


Downwinder
QLD, 2030 posts
17 Dec 2012 7:34PM
Thumbs Up

GoCam – Waterproof camcorder with Remote



Comes with Surfboard mound
Bike mound
Helmet mound

Photo Resolution: 5 Mega Pixels

• Video Resolution: 1080p 30fps/720p 60fps

• LCD Screen: 1.5” colour TFT

• Recording Angles: 125
• 1 in 1080p. 170o in 720p & WVGA

• Exposure: auto/manual (advanced users)

• Zoom: digitalx4(in 720p & wvga mode)

• Remote range: 0m-10m range

• Microphone: MONO

• Audio/Video Output: HD TV Out

• Battery: 1300mAh rechargeable lithium-ion

• Built-in Memory: 32MB, CMOS sensor

• Lens Focal: Range 0.5m to infinity

• Power: Camera-DC3.7V/ Remote-DV3V

• RF: 2.4GHZ (optional) OR FM

• Net Weight: Camera - 140g / Remote - 20g

• Operating Systems: Compatible with windows XP & Vista. Mac OS 10.2

• GPS: SiRf IV (optional)

Cuttlefish
QLD, 1332 posts
17 Dec 2012 8:42PM
Thumbs Up

Geez, the go pro fell short of the mark in that video comparison.

Adapt
QLD, 723 posts
17 Dec 2012 9:03PM
Thumbs Up

That's what I thought, so it's left me more confused. The only things I'm not sure about with the Sony is the mountings for your board and the fact that it needs to be turned on before being placed in the housing

jezza007
NSW, 300 posts
17 Dec 2012 10:36PM
Thumbs Up

www.cnet.com/

gregc
VIC, 1298 posts
17 Dec 2012 11:18PM
Thumbs Up

really I went and had a look at a heap of reviews and all of them still say the GoPro. I still reckon its probably a close run thing really.

Gassa
QLD, 272 posts
18 Dec 2012 5:18AM
Thumbs Up

Adapt said...
That's what I thought, so it's left me more confused. The only things I'm not sure about with the Sony is the mountings for your board and the fact that it needs to be turned on before being placed in the housing


The sony can be turned on once in cover I have one and the mounting issue isnt a problem, the pack comes with one flat and a curved one plus a go pro converter so u can use the pros mounts as well . the only problem I am having with it is fogging of the lens after extended time in the water

Piros
QLD, 6996 posts
18 Dec 2012 10:15AM
Thumbs Up

That tests really wasn't that revelant to us as it was all low light test. No sports cam is great in low light. That test needs to be done again in full sunshine and underwater you will get completely different results. It also doesn't address the rolling shutter issues of the contour , the Sony is very steady in this regard , but it gets bloody hot , the ion runs really cool , no fogging issue and very simple to use , the Sony was a nightmare to set up with wifi. On all the units you will lose your wifi connection when the camera is under water a real pain in the arse. Shape ease of use , cost , no fog & accessories ION wins but it is not the same picture quality of the Sony or go pro but still pretty good.

IMHO

teatrea
QLD, 4177 posts
18 Dec 2012 1:55PM
Thumbs Up

What about something like this , I know its not a action cam but would it be more versatile.?




Panasonic HX-WA2 High Definition Waterproof Vertical Video Camera


Enjoy taking fantastic Full HD videos and 14 megapixel photos in or out of the water with the versatile Panasonic HX-WA2 waterproof camcorder. Able to be submerged up to 3m you can go snorkeling and capture the underwater world; or feel secure filming in rainy weather. The WA2's unique ergonomic design makes it very comfortable to shoot even one-handed for long periods. Its 2.6 inch LCD screen rotates through 285o making it easier to shoot from low-or-high angle positions. The WA2 also sports 5x optical zoom plus a host of smart features such as Intelligent Auto and Intelligent Scene Selector that make using the camera simple. And when you're done shooting the included software allows easy editing and web upload.

dtm
NSW, 1610 posts
18 Dec 2012 3:09PM
Thumbs Up

Hate the fogging my go pro loves to do on me everytime I use it .... Though I'm impatient and don't do all the tips etc your surpost to?? But I do use anti fog still no good

Downwinder
QLD, 2030 posts
18 Dec 2012 6:30PM
Thumbs Up

teatrea said...
What about something like this , I know its not a action cam but would it be more versatile.?




Panasonic HX-WA2 High Definition Waterproof Vertical Video Camera


Enjoy taking fantastic Full HD videos and 14 megapixel photos in or out of the water with the versatile Panasonic HX-WA2 waterproof camcorder. Able to be submerged up to 3m you can go snorkeling and capture the underwater world; or feel secure filming in rainy weather. The WA2's unique ergonomic design makes it very comfortable to shoot even one-handed for long periods. Its 2.6 inch LCD screen rotates through 285o making it easier to shoot from low-or-high angle positions. The WA2 also sports 5x optical zoom plus a host of smart features such as Intelligent Auto and Intelligent Scene Selector that make using the camera simple. And when you're done shooting the included software allows easy editing and web upload.




I'm after one of those Waterproof Movie Cameras but they are not compatible with Apple Mac

Downwinder
QLD, 2030 posts
18 Dec 2012 6:34PM
Thumbs Up

dtm said...
Hate the fogging my go pro loves to do on me everytime I use it .... Though I'm impatient and don't do all the tips etc your surpost to?? But I do use anti fog still no good


Hi dtm
Keep the GoPro for land use only or throw it in the bin like I did. Get an ION if you want crystal clear water footage - Yes Please Mr Wizard.

Scott79
QLD, 209 posts
18 Dec 2012 11:29PM
Thumbs Up

How does the ION mount to your board?
The kit online looks as though it has no added buoyancy if it comes off?

Thanks,
Scott.

Downwinder
QLD, 2030 posts
19 Dec 2012 7:30AM
Thumbs Up

Scott79 said...
How does the ION mount to your board?
The kit online looks as though it has no added buoyancy if it comes off?

Thanks,
Scott.


Find a Aluminium fabrication welder they will make a bracket so the ION screws onto it and it will then fit into the FCS plug. Yes Please Mr Wizard.

JohnnyMaya
196 posts
19 Dec 2012 7:25PM
Thumbs Up

Hey guys,

Forget that Panasonic thing.
The only good thing about that camera is the lcd display.

Battery life and poor usb plugs quality are a major issue since the charger will no longer charge after a few months of intensive use.

NNSUP
NSW, 1263 posts
19 Dec 2012 10:46PM
Thumbs Up

dtm said...
Hate the fogging my go pro loves to do on me everytime I use it .... Though I'm impatient and don't do all the tips etc your surpost to?? But I do use anti fog still no good


Dan,
I never get fogging when I use the fog inserts. I dry them out regularly and never have a problem.

gregc
VIC, 1298 posts
20 Dec 2012 12:09AM
Thumbs Up

the dive housing also reduces fogging

SUPfreak12
5 posts
20 Dec 2012 4:27AM
Thumbs Up

I have heard good things about the contour, and I like that there are some great options out there now. The Go Pro HERO 3 is pretty killer tho.

Cluffy
NSW, 414 posts
5 Feb 2013 2:44PM
Thumbs Up

guys I use sea drops on the inside of the housing of my sony action cam and it definately helps scubadiving.com.au/

roddyb
QLD, 39 posts
5 Feb 2013 10:50PM
Thumbs Up

I use the anti fog inserts with my Hero 3 Silver works fine. Great footage for the average bloke.
These are almost bulletproof cameras. Just make sure you have a floaty back door or tether!
I like the modular design of the Go Pro that allows many parts to be replaced or upgraded, also lots of genuine and after market accessories.
Syncs well with Mac's iMovie and iPhoto
Only gripe is the battery life, abysmal in cold weather ( a second battery is a good investment) and the clunky iPhone app, hopefully a new version soon....



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle General


"GoPro Hero3 Silver or Sony Action Cam" started by Adapt