Forums > Stand Up Paddle General

Moulded or Foam

Reply
Created by rollo90 > 9 months ago, 1 Mar 2010
rollo90
QLD, 221 posts
1 Mar 2010 9:28AM
Thumbs Up

Why aren't guys making downwind boards in Australia producing a moulded versions.
Like SIC,C4 etc?
these moulded boards are lighter and preform better when going downwind.
I know it is a very new sport but by now there must be a all round shape to make into a plug to take a mould off.
You could have different weight models.
Surf Skis and Racing Skis are not made from foam.
I might be wrong and people maybe already doing it here.

Just thought I would ask.

Sam

Simondo
VIC, 8020 posts
1 Mar 2010 10:41AM
Thumbs Up

Are you talking about hollow boards?? For my money, give me foam.... If you try and go too light weight, I would worry about snapping it on a big ocean paddle, and it would sink... (?? I think ??)....

Stringers also provide a little bit of extra stiffness.... But many SUP's are stringerless....

rollo90
QLD, 221 posts
1 Mar 2010 9:54AM
Thumbs Up

skis do not snap mid ocean or moulded boards they are very very strong.
Also skis surf quite well

DavidJohn
VIC, 17463 posts
1 Mar 2010 11:12AM
Thumbs Up

IMO there's no doubt that molded boards will come but it's still early days in design.

Once we have proven designs and confirmed racing rules I think it will happen.

Robby Naish told me that the new 17 would be hollow but it's not.. There must be a reason for that.

Maybe they weren't strong enough.. too flexy.. or too heavy.. or maybe it's the risk of sinking if they get holed.

DJ

rollo90
QLD, 221 posts
1 Mar 2010 10:31AM
Thumbs Up

they all have shells inside like a skeleton to give floatation.
true we need to get rules in place to give people a good idea of what model to buy.
Race skis are 19 or 21 foot and are so strong. Not sure of OC1 length

mickfullarto
NSW, 21 posts
1 Mar 2010 6:31PM
Thumbs Up

Hi Guys

If you were buying a DW board potentially to do the odd race on is there a length that has been settled on to define a class length ie:12 ' 6 and under and unlimited above or something similar?

I know OC racing when through a long period of transition trying to work this out with weights etc.

Usually though there is a premier class where all of the good guys try and compete within in some sort of frame work so that it is as much about the skill of the paddler as the board its self is this happening with in the SUP sport or is it still in the free for all stage?

Cheers

Mick

SimonDodd
NSW, 80 posts
1 Mar 2010 6:48PM
Thumbs Up

mickfullarto said...

Hi Guys

If you were buying a DW board potentially to do the odd race on is there a length that has been settled on to define a class length ie:12 ' 6 and under and unlimited above or something similar?

I know OC racing when through a long period of transition trying to work this out with weights etc.

Usually though there is a premier class where all of the good guys try and compete within in some sort of frame work so that it is as much about the skill of the paddler as the board its self is this happening with in the SUP sport or is it still in the free for all stage?

Cheers

Mick


Hi Mick!

Unfortunately yes....there are a number of different organisations running the dw events here in australia and the classes vary event-to-event. IMHO The long term goal would be to have the following:
12'6 > shortcourse sprints e.g BOP
14'0 > downwinders production boards only (affordable and competitive to the general public).
14'1+ > Open slather and open chequebook!

I have owned numurous open unlimited boards and can honestly say I will never buy another one due to the poor re-sale value.

Hollow or foam? I would say hollow cause at least you can easily drain the water out of them!

Simondo
VIC, 8020 posts
1 Mar 2010 8:59PM
Thumbs Up

EPS foam does not suck up water though...

There is potential for a handicap system also... But line honours is always line honours !!

I support the 14' production class as I'm about to get one ; )

Simondo
VIC, 8020 posts
1 Mar 2010 9:16PM
Thumbs Up

I gave the Hollow Board a little thought, and the biggest problem would be standing on it. It would need to withstand point loads of around 150kg or so... 85kg person coming down on one heel, would be approx equivalent loading of 150kg in 3 square inches, or about 100 pounds per square inch, which seems to be up around 700kPa !! That's a fair bit of force....

Although deck padding over another sheet layer, would help to dissipate / spread that point load....

EPS foam is about 16-35kg/m3 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polystyrene
If you have a 250 litre down wind board, assume 10-20 litres is the case/carcass. Leaves say 235 litres of foam (approx) or 5-8kg of foam, but I would assume you would add back 3-6kg into the carcass (if hollow)?? I would not expect the weight saving to be massive....

I still like the thought of foam in the middle for an everyday durable board.... Even if a hollow board was 1-3% faster.... And I guess we would only be talking 1-3% faster....

rollo90
QLD, 221 posts
1 Mar 2010 8:54PM
Thumbs Up

i know Hawaii is different conditions but these hollow boards are race proven there.
and there are a lot bigger runners.

husq2100
QLD, 2031 posts
1 Mar 2010 8:57PM
Thumbs Up

what have you ever paddled Ron Burgandy!

maybe go talk to the guys making skis and get their ideas???? i know you know a few of them

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
1 Mar 2010 10:52PM
Thumbs Up

rollo90 said...

i know Hawaii is different conditions but these hollow boards are race proven there.
and there are a lot bigger runners.


i think you will see some moulded action from a few makers around the place not too far away. me personally, i loved the feel of the vortice as i had never tried a hollow board before. i would get a good moulded one no worries, actually told simon to let me know anything about the new vortice when it happens
cheers
ps. are sic boards every going to be readily available in oz

mickfullarto
NSW, 21 posts
2 Mar 2010 12:10AM
Thumbs Up

So getting back to the crux of the matter is it about time there was some sort of Decision made in the best interests of the sport both manufactures and participants to agree on a length of DW board so that the shapers ect know that they are designing something that has market appeal and consumers are buying something that is as relevant today as it is tomorow?

I only raise this as I have seen the total Sh** fight that OC paddling went through to achieve some sort of uniformity and I want to buy a board that is the same or similarly designed as every one elses

Cheers

Mick

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
1 Mar 2010 11:19PM
Thumbs Up

mickfullarto said...

So getting back to the crux of the matter is it about time there was some sort of Decision made in the best interests of the sport both manufactures and participants to agree on a length of DW board so that the shapers ect know that they are designing something that has market appeal and consumers are buying something that is as relevant today as it is tomorow?

I only raise this as I have seen the total Sh** fight that OC paddling went through to achieve some sort of uniformity and I want to buy a board that is the same or similarly designed as every one elses

Cheers

Mick


it will be 12'6 fixed, 14' fixed and open, that's the general rule. it's just there are not enough paddlers doing it to warrant race organizers to have the 3 classes every time.
me personally, i think 12'6 ocean racing is a waste of time

DavidJohn
VIC, 17463 posts
2 Mar 2010 1:20AM
Thumbs Up

This is the new hollow/moulded F16.. It looks awesome.

DJ

rollo90
QLD, 221 posts
2 Mar 2010 8:27AM
Thumbs Up

I know that the OC1's had a lot of weight issues too. Some were being made at 16-20kilos and some were coming in at 8-10kilos.
People may think weight does not have to much to do with it but it does.
3 classes.
I think that up to 12'6 gives everyone a chance to have a race, and this class would be fantastic for 10kms and under race like BOP.
fixed 14 ft is downwind proven for all distances.
And unlimited class for all distances

cRAZY Canuk
NSW, 2528 posts
2 Mar 2010 9:50AM
Thumbs Up

DavidJohn said...

This is the new hollow/moulded F16.. It looks awesome.

DJ




The SIC Boards look awsome - last I checked the Unlimited (18'er) was still made with a 1lb/ft³ (15kg/m³) eps core.

I don't think moulded boards will really take off till more companies are happier with there designs as it would take some where in the relm of 30-40 boards just to pay off the moulds, not to mention the price of a board would go up.

CMC
QLD, 3954 posts
2 Mar 2010 9:28AM
Thumbs Up

I am in no way qualified to be any kind of authority on the topic of DW BUT:

Here's what I do know:

The C4 Vortice is designed in conjunction with Dave Parmenter, Karel Tresnack and Todd Bradley along with Brian Kealana etc. Who is Dave Parmenter? Dave is arguably one of the worlds great influential surfboard shapers and with designs such as the 'Widow Maker' and 'Stub Vector' have greatly influenced surfboard design in ways you would have to research to understand. He was also a WCT surfer and is extremely highly regarded in surfing circles.

Who is Karel? Karel is the owner of a company called Outrigger Connection. These canoes are the world standard for outrigging and the Mirage OC6 has won more races than any other, it is 'the' choice for racing. The OC1's and OC2's are also prized possessions. Todd Bradley is a world champion outrigger also. Brian K speaks for himself, if you don't know if him, his brother and his dad and their Makaha heritage you could probably be ashamed of yourself.

The SIC F-14, 16, 18 etc

Once again designed by an extremely well regarded OC paddler Mark Raaphurst, SIC also makes OC1's, OC4's etc. These guys have a very strong background in moulding etc. They do it all inhouse and test, refine, test, refine using skills gained over many years to design the best boards they can make.

My point, with so many years of experience in the ocean both of these guys have more than enough confidence to put designs to mould for production.


Here in Australia our best designers are from a surfboard and/or surf life saving equipment background. Apart from Ski's, OC1's etc everything they make is still EPS so it makes sense to use a familiar material that can be changed from board to board in the full steam pursuit of something that works better than the last.

God knows at this stage what works better and I surely don't, all I know that is that if you want to be confident or competitive it is probably a good idea to get boards from guys that have a lot of experience paddling craft in the ocean. IMHO that's why I would always lean towards a Surfboard or OC background for the designer.

To quote the blackboard at my local butcher "If you don't know meat you'd better hope you know your butcher" the same thing applies here.

LaPerouseBay
63 posts
2 Mar 2010 2:07PM
Thumbs Up

^ That is exactly why I feel so lucky to be on Maui. The S.I.C shop is constantly pushing the envelope in downwind boards.

The pic DJ posted above is an F-16 that is autoclaved overseas.

My latest F-16 is what we are calling 'semi-hollow'. Not sure what Mark calls it. It's actually a sandwich of styro and carbon, like plywood, wrapped around a mold. It's strong as hell. Stronger than a molded F-16 or a styro carbon custom - and that's saying a lot. The autoclaved pre-preg may be even stronger, not sure about that.

We had our first wild downwinder of the season yesterday - the new board is just unreal. Rock solid stable in steep drops, side chop etc. Surfs like a dream on big rolling swells. Lots of rocker. Designed for wild maliko nuking windswell.

www.standupzone.com/forum/index.php?topic=5673.0

Piros
QLD, 6996 posts
2 Mar 2010 8:14PM
Thumbs Up

I think it's a while before you see moulded boards in Aus.Going by what I have seen in Dale Chapmans factory a new improved design comes out weekly.The sport is still pretty young here and we don't have the volume to commit to a set shape (yet). Lacey's 14 is something pretty special. Watch this space..... and I'm sure the 17's will follow suit and it will look nothing like the F16 or 18.

Rob

hux
QLD, 69 posts
3 Mar 2010 3:33PM
Thumbs Up

SIC f16 are being made in china by autoclave process apparently so i would say they may export them from china to every where that wants one oneday.

Downwinder
QLD, 2031 posts
3 Mar 2010 7:43PM
Thumbs Up

All I can say is my F-16 is BULK FAST when the wind is SSE 15 knots plus with 3ft of south swell I go from Snapper Rocks to Seashell Ave Lifeguard tower 24 = 17km in 80 minutes now that's fast. I've surfed ocean swell in surf stance mode for 200 meters & have clocked myself doing 4 minute 15 second a kilometre, all you need is wind & swell & you're just surfing out there. I also have the F-18 for flat days when the wind is under 15 knots. See ya in da ocean.




rollo90
QLD, 221 posts
3 Mar 2010 8:16PM
Thumbs Up

nice looking board

MickV
VIC, 188 posts
3 Mar 2010 9:35PM
Thumbs Up

Did you end up getting a new 18 footer Phil ?

Downwinder
QLD, 2031 posts
4 Mar 2010 5:39AM
Thumbs Up

Yes MickV my 2nd new F-18 its 18'6''will be here in June I cant wait I'm throthing these boards are sooo fast in the flat but no good when the wind is over say 15 knots that when I'll paddle the custom F-16



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle General


"Moulded or Foam" started by rollo90