Forums > Stand Up Paddle General

PFD in a backpack?

Reply
Created by mikeman > 9 months ago, 24 May 2010
mikeman
QLD, 692 posts
24 May 2010 12:03PM
Thumbs Up

Does anyone know if there are pfd kits that are built into hydration backpacks out there?

If we cannot find anything does anyone know anyone who can custom build these for downwind/ocean paddles?

DavidJohn
VIC, 17438 posts
24 May 2010 12:19PM
Thumbs Up

It shouldn't be hard to attach one of the inflatable bum-bag type to a Camelbak.. It sounds like a good idea.

DJ

rambooc1
QLD, 326 posts
24 May 2010 2:40PM
Thumbs Up

The bum bag PFD is very light duty, the next level up inflatable horseshoe (gas and manual) are better built, and if you put them into a waterproof marine bag and place that in your backpak/hydro it stays dry and lasts longer. That's what i use and never have to wash it every time. Pricing as about the same.

It folds in half so is quite small un-inflated.

R

This is the one


mikeman
QLD, 692 posts
24 May 2010 2:43PM
Thumbs Up

What I am looking for is an all in one system ie a pdf and hydration backpack. If things are seperate it is too easy/tempting to leave the pfd behind.

angie pangi
QLD, 1779 posts
24 May 2010 2:46PM
Thumbs Up

Make one?

X angie

rambooc1
QLD, 326 posts
24 May 2010 2:48PM
Thumbs Up

Not likely to exist as type 1, maybe not pass Aust Marine Safety Std

The negative buoyancy of the hydro pack will work against it.

paul.j
QLD, 3332 posts
24 May 2010 2:55PM
Thumbs Up

A hydration backpack is a pfd yes?? could you not just modify it so if you need it as a floating device that you could just blow air back in to it and fill the bag with air?? That's just of the top of my with out really thinking or looking to see if it would work....

Jacko

rambooc1
QLD, 326 posts
24 May 2010 3:08PM
Thumbs Up

You will find it's actually the other way around. There are after market hydration packs made specifically for mounting on PFD's, but nothing integral i can find

mikeman
QLD, 692 posts
24 May 2010 3:13PM
Thumbs Up

A hydration pack is certainly useful to use as a floatation device, as Jacko says. I am looking for something that goes a little further than this. A type 1 PFD needs to be able to have bouyancy behind the head and this is what I woulkd like to see built into a hydration backpack.

rambooc1
QLD, 326 posts
24 May 2010 3:23PM
Thumbs Up

Go read the PFD standards and see if it's possible to comply.

Your best bet is to start with a PFD of choice and attach required hydration.

The most comfortable are the Mocke Surf Ski life jackets that the Ski racers wear in all World Cup races. http://www.themockes.com/pic_detail.php?pic=148

Not type 1 but you can wear it all day and doesn't interfere with paddle stroke.

DavidJohn
VIC, 17438 posts
24 May 2010 3:27PM
Thumbs Up

My little bum-bag PFD is so small it can be worn around your waist and also wear a Camelbak without effecting each other.

DJ





rambooc1
QLD, 326 posts
24 May 2010 3:45PM
Thumbs Up

DavidJohn said...

My little bum-bag PFD is so small it can be worn around your waist and also wear a Camelbak without effecting each other.

DJ


DJ , they are great for using in a race situation when the rules insist you have a PFD, but when you actually go to use it they are unreliable, very light duty. We have had a number of incidents where they needed deployment in emergency situations and they have failed. One i was involved in as assistee and ended up tossing it and supporting the person manually. As they're exposed all the time to the elements every time you SUP they get wet, the salt water kills it. That's my experience anyway.

Farquo
NSW, 108 posts
24 May 2010 4:33PM
Thumbs Up

MM
SOS Marine Australia do a PFD which fits a hydra pack in the back and comes with a padded drinking tube and pockets as well.


I tried to upload a pic and am new at this, hope it works. You would need to wear a rashy underneath it. upon pulling the toggle they are gas activated. They are classed as PFD 1 as well. They are very comfy and tough.
better pic on this link
http://www.sosmarine.com.au/Pages/Defence/Police/Police%2010%20Water%20Police%20PFD-1%20Safety%20Vest.htm

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
24 May 2010 9:47PM
Thumbs Up

Adapt said...

Hey Mikeman,

There are heaps of these PFD's on the market, just not sure if its what you are after.

Riptide Hydro Pocket
http://www.canoeingdownunder.com.au/category.php?CatID=22

Ultra trek
www.ultrapfd.com.au/default.asp?PageID=64


thx's for that. we were thinking a more fluid holder type of rig with a gas inflated pfd. i would have to take rambo's word on the gas not being reliable.so i found this on that site.i will probably get this one.







The Race Pro is a top quality PFD, extremely comfortable and has all the features needed for racing or just training. It is easy to get on (over your head) and fast to get off (side zip) and in between you will hardly notice you are wearing it. It has a rear expandable pocket that can hold a 2 litre bladder and a bottle pocket on the front for electrolyte fluids or more water. Two tube guides on the front keeps the tubes in place and in easy reach of your mouth, so you can take in fluid without stopping. The "system X" adjustment system prevents the weight of the drink bladder from pulling the PFD backwards and preventing that choking feeling.

It comes equipped with a whistle and a handy knife pocket with a lash tab ( mandatory gear on most races) as well as a strobe light clip point on the back. The piping is reflective and the mesh front pockets hold food, and plenty of it.
Cost: $ 240.00
Size(s): S, M, L
Specs: 300D Nyon outer, 200D Nylon inner

DavidJohn
VIC, 17438 posts
24 May 2010 9:52PM
Thumbs Up

Hey Lacey.. Most of them sit very high and tight'ish under you're arms.

The one I use lets you lower it so you don't look like 'Harry high pants'.. and mine only costs $140.

The pocket on the back is for a hydration drink bladder.

DJ


Ultra trek
http://www.ultrapfd.com.au/default.asp?PageID=64

.

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
24 May 2010 10:05PM
Thumbs Up

DavidJohn said...

Hey Lacey.. Most of them sit very high and tight'ish under you're arms.

The one I use lets you lower it so you don't look like 'Harry high pants'.. and mine only costs $140.

The pocket on the back is for a hydration drink bladder.

DJ


Ultra trek
http://www.ultrapfd.com.au/default.asp?PageID=64

.



yeah, i can see that. but it is made for paddling and the tube holders and mouth guide and front drink holder looks very impressive to me for racing. the side straps don't look much more than a camel pack. but hey, i will check it out for comfort first
cheers
ps . i'm also thinking if you are paddling with a twist forward and using your obliques to pull back, a lower fitting pfd would get in the way

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
24 May 2010 10:25PM
Thumbs Up

something i have discussed with og sup is in qld, a full pdf would probaby cause you to overheat. a dark rashie is too hot in summer. hence, we are looking for minimal upper body coverage. thats probably not a concern for the southern states i'm guessing
cheers

LSD
VIC, 763 posts
24 May 2010 11:34PM
Thumbs Up

Guys...before you get too carried away with current gear, a new Aust standard 4758...regarding pfds....is now in.. check it out.
cheers

DavidJohn
VIC, 17438 posts
24 May 2010 11:44PM
Thumbs Up

LSD said...

Guys...before you get too carried away with current gear, a new Aust standard 4758...regarding pfds....is now in.. check it out.
cheers


Dean I looked into all this and although there is a change coming there will be a period of maybe years before the new standard to be required.. First there will be a period to let shops sell existing stock.. and then there will be a period (prob 10-15 yrs if not more) before we will need to upgrade to the new standard.. I'm sure in that time you'd be getting your moneys worth out of whatever you buy now.

DJ

Al Hunter
NSW, 367 posts
24 May 2010 11:54PM
Thumbs Up

lacey
I have the same pfd as DJ and honestly it does not bother me at all.
I am only 70 km below you on the map so it's not a matter of climate
In fact there are 2 layers of foam in the front and in the back
I did cut the thread and put some velcro instead so that I can quickly choose to use it as a camel pack with no flotation but enjoy the pockets in front to put things like a phone or put back the foam so it floats.
I don't like it with 2 layers of foam because it's too tight on my upper body but if you put only 1 layer in front 1 layer in the back it's very confortable and it floats enough for me

mikeman
QLD, 692 posts
25 May 2010 1:52PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks for everyone's feedback. With more of us looking we might just find what we need out there.

There are a few things that we need to look for:

1) Ideally it should be a PFD type 1, so that we cover all bases. A type 1 has neck support and is designed to keep you floating face upwards with your head above water. Some of these great options that have been sent in are Type 2 and 3

2) There has to be freedom of movement under the arms, due to the nature of our paddling stroke.

3) Ideally it should be 1 single system, but if we cannot find one we need to find 2 components that fit well together.

4) It needs to be light (some of these gas filled ones are simply too heavy)

5) It needs to be affordable.

Imo, the Pinnacle II is too expensive (A$1499) and looks like it could be restrictive on the sides



the Trek is too expensive (A$2260) and looks like it could also be restrictive on the sides



The combo of the combination of the SOS 5114 and SOS Hydropack looks ok. I will try and get some prices on these. As they build gear for the military they may have what we are looking for.





The gear from Canoeing Downunder looks pretty good (and reasonably priced) but I could not find a Type 1 system.

This is what they have:













I will keep looking...

Savage1
NSW, 63 posts
25 May 2010 7:32PM
Thumbs Up

Mikeman, what your looking at is the Model number, not the price.

I just picked up the Trek for $130.

Looks like good quality for a fair price...

Cheers

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
25 May 2010 10:24PM
Thumbs Up

Savage1 said...

Mikeman, what your looking at is the Model number, not the price.

I just picked up the Trek for $130.

Looks like good quality for a fair price...

Cheers


i was speaking today to the guy that owns/runs canoeing downunder. he uses the race pro and the ocean pro. the race pro doesn't have spare pockets for gear, but would be good for races. the ocean pro is a bit bigger, but comfy and has more pockets and features etc then you can poke a stick at.he thinks the trek is one of the best and value for money. the photos are of the vest siting flat so there is no bulk on the sides. he says some of these jackets aren't rated to oz standards, but have been rated in other countries.it takes time and a lot of money to get them rated in australia
cheers

OG SUP
VIC, 3516 posts
25 May 2010 10:44PM
Thumbs Up

Hey Lacey,

I agree with DJ have a good long look at the Trek, I have used it quite a few times and found it did and excellent job.

Phill

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
25 May 2010 11:07PM
Thumbs Up

OG SUP said...

Hey Lacey,

I agree with DJ have a good long look at the Trek, I have used it quite a few times and found it did and excellent job.

Phill


phill, they do look good. however, i'm being fussing and i know a lot of people aren't that keen to be wearing them. ideally, i think a water pack, some storage and most of the pfd on the back would be perfect, but there doesn't appear to be anything around. if it's compact, reasonably light weight and out of the way, a lot more people will or would wear them. so the search/ aim to find or get somebody to make em is high for sure
cheers

jenkz
WA, 793 posts
25 May 2010 9:23PM
Thumbs Up

Mikeman, I have the Pinnacle ultra and I find it to be fine. What you can't see in the picture is that the sides are mesh at 17cm high and 32cm long. You can adjust these with two straps. I tend to paddle with these two loose and the bottom one firm but comfortable. There is also heaps of adjustment in the shoulder straps. I use a 3L bladder from a camelbak in the hydration pocket. Due to padding in the front to make you float on your back it may seem to be bulky but it doesn't restrict my paddling style. This vest is the PFD type two. I think you may need a neck support on a life jacket to get it to rate as a PFD type 1 but I could be wrong.



laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
25 May 2010 11:31PM
Thumbs Up

jenkz said...

Mikeman, I have the Pinnacle ultra and I find it to be fine. What you can't see in the picture is that the sides are mesh at 17cm high and 32cm long. You can adjust these with two straps. I tend to paddle with these two loose and the bottom one firm but comfortable. There is also heaps of adjustment in the shoulder straps. I use a 3L bladder from a camelbak in the hydration pocket. Due to padding in the front to make you float on your back it may seem to be bulky but it doesn't restrict my paddling style. This vest is the PFD type two. I think you may need a neck support on a life jacket to get it to rate as a PFD type 1 but I could be wrong.


jenkz, for me, if all else fails, the pinnacle looks the best all round package
cheers

mikeman
QLD, 692 posts
28 May 2010 8:37AM
Thumbs Up

Thanks, everyone. Sorry about getting the pricing structure of the Pinnacle and Trek wrong.

That Pinnacle Ultra certainly looks pretty close to what we need. Although it is Type 2 we might get away with it. Perhaps we could convince the manufacturers to add in a neck support system to make it a Type 1. Mayby this could be self inflated (or fold downwards) to keep it out of the way.

mikeman
QLD, 692 posts
28 May 2010 8:57AM
Thumbs Up

DavidJohn said...

I can't see myself ever wearing a type 1 PFD.

Aren't they more for kids to keep their head up?.. I'd hate to have that collar on my PFD while I'm paddling.

DJ




Sorry to disappoint you but you just might have to start learning soon. The regulations are tightening up on all of us ocean paddlers, especially after a recent event down south.

JonathanC
VIC, 1021 posts
28 May 2010 9:11AM
Thumbs Up

mikeman said...

DavidJohn said...

I can't see myself ever wearing a type 1 PFD.

Aren't they more for kids to keep their head up?.. I'd hate to have that collar on my PFD while I'm paddling.

DJ




Sorry to disappoint you but you just might have to start learning soon. The regulations are tightening up on all of us ocean paddlers, especially after a recent event down south.


Do you know if regulations are are actually tightening up Mikeman or is that just a guess. What recent event down south? If there is actually something happening regarding regulations it would be interesting to know so that we can be part of the process.

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
28 May 2010 9:19AM
Thumbs Up

i will have a look at a ultra pinnacle today. a place called aqua sports and dive on the goldie are listed as having them.i'm not that fussed on wearing them, but have been told they are no problems, so it will be good to try one on myself
cheers



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle General


"PFD in a backpack?" started by mikeman