Forums > Stand Up Paddle General

Some more Sunset Vids

Reply
Created by goatman > 9 months ago, 1 Mar 2010
goatman
NSW, 2151 posts
1 Mar 2010 11:59AM
Thumbs Up

Scroll down a bit and there are some more vids form the Sunset SUP comp.

Also an interesting discussion re the design limitations of some of the boards (See the previous page).

Seems like it is taboo (for some) to question the design of SUP in larger waves.

www.standupzone.com/forum/index.php?topic=6203.105

What do you guys think?

DavidJohn
VIC, 17460 posts
1 Mar 2010 12:51PM
Thumbs Up

Great vid..



Yeah the board thing is interesting.. I wouldn't want to paddle onto those waves on a 10' mana.. These guys know the drill.. and they have their quivers.

DJ

paul.j
QLD, 3341 posts
1 Mar 2010 11:55AM
Thumbs Up

Theres a shot of kai lenny on one of those movies and he looks to have the best control of his board it looks very smooth and seem to hold the speed better than some of the others. But then again it could have been a smoother wave with not as much wind.

goatman
NSW, 2151 posts
1 Mar 2010 1:00PM
Thumbs Up

I agree Jacko and I reckon it has to do with the curvier rocker he would have on that SUP of his.

Personally I can't understand why some of the guys are riding what look like blown up longboards on waves like Sunset and Chopes. I also don't get the flatter rockers on some of the designs either.

hilly
WA, 7323 posts
1 Mar 2010 12:18PM
Thumbs Up

goatman said...

I agree Jacko and I reckon it has to do with the curvier rocker he would have on that SUP of his.

Personally I can't understand why some of the guys are riding what look like blown up longboards on waves like Sunset and Chopes. I also don't get the flatter rockers on some of the designs either.


Lots of different things come in to play in a comp with guys taking out boards that will turn better to get points.
I would have had my Gun out in that. That has a flat rocker which gives you speed. Too much rocker and you cannot make the sections. They were taking off DEEP. I hate hitting terminal velocity on a big wave and you need more speed
How would the 8 8 go in that John?

goatman
NSW, 2151 posts
1 Mar 2010 3:34PM
Thumbs Up

Hey Hilly, the 8 8 would be crap in surf like that, have tried it at 2nd Bombie Long Reef, which is not dissimilar to Sunset in some ways.

I have surfed Sunset at a similar size (not on a SUP) and it is a damn tricky wave to surf, hard to bottom turn on out the back.

The theory behind guns though is that they should have slightly more rocker and it seems to me that with a lot of SUP design, the emphasis is on paddle speed and glide to the detriment of performance.

Anyways I am no expert in SUP design just throwing it out there for discussion.

hilly
WA, 7323 posts
1 Mar 2010 12:39PM
Thumbs Up

paul.j said...

Theres a shot of kai lenny on one of those movies and he looks to have the best control of his board it looks very smooth and seem to hold the speed better than some of the others. But then again it could have been a smoother wave with not as much wind.


There is a guy on a white board just before Kai on the Slater Trout vid(4.30) who ripping onshore Sunset


Anyone know who he is?

hilly
WA, 7323 posts
1 Mar 2010 12:44PM
Thumbs Up

goatman said...

Hey Hilly, the 8 8 would be crap in surf like that, have tried it at 2nd Bombie Long Reef, which is not dissimilar to Sunset in some ways.

I have surfed Sunset at a similar size (not on a SUP) and it is a damn tricky wave to surf, hard to bottom turn on out the back.

The theory behind guns though is that they should have slightly more rocker and it seems to me that with a lot of SUP design, the emphasis is on paddle speed and glide to the detriment of performance.

Anyways I am no expert in SUP design just throwing it out there for discussion.


My 10er has more rocker than my 12er and it feels like it gets to a hull speed due to the rocker and width way sooner than the 12er and is way harder to paddle into anything over 2x head due to the water/wind coming up the face.

Narrower would be the go that is why the light weights like Kai will do well.

Sunset looks tough.

allrounder
VIC, 157 posts
1 Mar 2010 3:45PM
Thumbs Up

i think its bonga..

goatman
NSW, 2151 posts
1 Mar 2010 4:06PM
Thumbs Up

hilly said...


My 10er has more rocker than my 12er and it feels like it gets to a hull speed due to the rocker and width way sooner than the 12er and is way harder to paddle into anything over 2x head due to the water/wind coming up the face.

Narrower would be the go that is why the light weights like Kai will do well.

Sunset looks tough.


Narrower is definately the go, I want 27" for my semi gun (lucky I am a light weight 82 kg)

Yeah the strong offshore would be a big factor in getting in to them - something we don't get a whole lot of over here. You wouldn't want it too light either!

tha dogman
NSW, 2912 posts
1 Mar 2010 5:06PM
Thumbs Up

nice footage

more we need more

hilly
WA, 7323 posts
1 Mar 2010 3:27PM
Thumbs Up

allrounder said...

i think its bonga..


I think he is on a PSH

PT SUP
117 posts
1 Mar 2010 5:27PM
Thumbs Up

Judging from the footage ,Bongo was the only one doing critical snaps and rail turns.
Any one agree??
Great vid.
PT

Deisel
13 posts
2 Mar 2010 5:34AM
Thumbs Up

PT SUP said...

Judging from the footage ,Bongo was the only one doing critical snaps and rail turns.
Any one agree??
Great vid.
PT



I agree. I am a new member chiming in from Oahu. Bonga was ripping and made SUP look like it belonged at Sunset. Some of the other guys, not so much. Some guys looked happy to just make the drop as I would be if I was there. We have to be patient. Sunset is one of the toughest waves on the planet and makes a lot of good surfers look not so good. Bottom line, the guys were charging so everyone will get better by the month. This sport is still a baby.

Daneli
QLD, 1538 posts
2 Mar 2010 8:32AM
Thumbs Up

goatman said...

Scroll down a bit and there are some more vids form the Sunset SUP comp.

Also an interesting discussion re the design limitations of some of the boards (See the previous page).

Seems like it is taboo (for some) to question the design of SUP in larger waves.

www.standupzone.com/forum/index.php?topic=6203.105

What do you guys think?


I agree it's an interesting discussion.

I'm only new but I'm getting confused over 2 different consenses so I'm hoping someone can put this straight.

1) Boards with more rocker (assuming same width & tail shape) can surf/turn better in the steeper more critical part of the wave. I can agree with this.

2) Boards with more rocker won't be as fast as flatter boards (assuming same width) on a steeper section of the wave. Not sure about this.

Thanks

hilly
WA, 7323 posts
2 Mar 2010 6:57AM
Thumbs Up

Rocker and steep sections are fine. Have a look at the vid it is not always steep lots of pretty flat sections to negotiate. Fine balancing act the shaper is following.

Deisel
13 posts
2 Mar 2010 7:07AM
Thumbs Up

Daneli, this is what I think. Flatter boards are faster. Rockered boards can negotiate the steeper drops and do manuevers in the steeper part of the wave better. Rockered boards need to be surfed more in the pocket of the wave because they slow down faster. You can think of the rounded shape of a breaking wave and see that a rounded, rockered board can fit better going up and down in the wave. Sunset is tricky because there are super steep drops and pocket but slopier, flatter shoulders. There seems to be a lot of flatter sections to negotiate to get into the juice depending on the wave. It is a good challenge for the shapers to make boards for sunset.

goatman
NSW, 2151 posts
2 Mar 2010 10:27AM
Thumbs Up

Daneli said...

I agree it's an interesting discussion.

I'm only new but I'm getting confused over 2 different consenses so I'm hoping someone can put this straight.

1) Boards with more rocker (assuming same width & tail shape) can surf/turn better in the steeper more critical part of the wave. I can agree with this.

2) Boards with more rocker won't be as fast as flatter boards (assuming same width) on a steeper section of the wave. Not sure about this.

Thanks


My understanding is this: Bigger wave means you need to control the incredible speed generated by the large drops you will be taking when turning, plus you have to be able to paddle in to them.

Characteristics common in big wave surfboards include longer, thicker, narrower, slightly more rocker, pulled in nose and tail, often V bottoms combined with double concaves.

Sunset is a tricky wave to surf because it has a very sloping bottom shape in lots of sections - this makes bottom turning more difficult, then it will hit the inside and suck up like crazy. To be honest I wouldn't have thought speed was an issue unless the board had a crazy amount of rocker or was too short, the bigger problem is being able to crank a powerful enough bottom turn to generate the drive required to make the next section.

The way I see it, this is the design problem for SUP shapers - to be able to make a craft that has a large surface area (ie wide and long) - that is able to be turned hard off the bottom of a very 'sloping' surface at high speed. This has to be balanced with enough volume to be able to paddle the thing into a 20 foot face with a 20 knot offshore blowing at ya.

Pardon my crapping on - I am mucking around with shaping software and have been thinking about it for months now (making a gun that is) - its all just theory of course till ya get out amongst it.

Simondo
VIC, 8020 posts
2 Mar 2010 10:42AM
Thumbs Up

Sunset Boards - whilst it will be a slight challenge for some shapers, I think a place like Sunset should be left alone to the shortboard surfers.

Running an SUP comp at Sunset was a slightly dangerous move.... imagine an American or Australian kid rocking up to Sunset on an SUP.... even at 6-10 foot Hawaiian you can paddle straight out from the deep water bay on the beach, and get into the line-up with dry hair.... where you will be greeted by some local boys !!

One problem at Sunset is getting cleaned up by rouge sets, and big SUP boards would nearly rip you leg out of its socket !! It would be easy to endanger others also. Plus the big boards bounce around a lot on the wave face, and sometimes does not look pretty.

But..... Bells would be a good place for an SUP Comp. 16 Pre-selected riders, 4 man heats.... You could have it "run and won" in a 5-6 hour window.....

tha dogman
NSW, 2912 posts
2 Mar 2010 10:45AM
Thumbs Up

very interesting thread dudes

and some great points on design

keep em rolling

goatman
NSW, 2151 posts
2 Mar 2010 10:50AM
Thumbs Up

Simondo said...


Running an SUP comp at Sunset was a slightly dangerous move.... imagine an American or Australian kid rocking up to Sunset on an SUP.... even at 6-10 foot Hawaiian you can paddle straight out from the deep water bay on the beach, and get into the line-up with dry hair.... where you will be greeted by some local boys !!

One problem at Sunset is getting cleaned up by rouge sets, and big SUP boards would nearly rip you leg out of its socket !! It would be easy to endanger others also. Plus the big boards bounce around a lot on the wave face, and sometimes does not look pretty.

But..... Bells would be a good place for an SUP Comp. 16 Pre-selected riders, 4 man heats.... You could have it "run and won" in a 5-6 hour window.....


I can't imagine rocking up to any of the 'name' breaks on the North Shore with a SUP to be honest. Most of the crew in the comp are respected locals so I don't think there would have been too much of an issue for the comp.

Bonga wasn't bouncing around and looked like he was ripping.

Bells would be good for a SUP comp although I can't imagine the locals would be too chuffed

Deisel
13 posts
2 Mar 2010 8:07AM
Thumbs Up

I am pretty sure nobody surfs SUP at sunset except for a few of the local boys like Kala and those guys. Those guys surf where they want and back it up with skills. As far as I know, only Ikaika, Kianoa Mcgee and Kala surf Pipe on SUP. These spots are heavily localized and sort themselves out pretty well from what I have seen.

tha dogman
NSW, 2912 posts
2 Mar 2010 11:15AM
Thumbs Up

Deisel said...

I am pretty sure nobody surfs SUP at sunset except for a few of the local boys like Kala and those guys. Those guys surf where they want and back it up with skills. As far as I know, only Ikaika, Kianoa Mcgee and Kala surf Pipe on SUP. These spots are heavily localized and sort themselves out pretty well from what I have seen.


sounds like every well know break in australia as well

probably a good thing??????????

PT SUP
117 posts
2 Mar 2010 1:37PM
Thumbs Up

Back to judging criteria,was Bongo scoring the highest wave scores??
Not detracting from the place getters in any way.Just a question.

robdog
VIC, 611 posts
7 Mar 2010 8:53PM
Thumbs Up

goatman said...
Bonga wasn't bouncing around and looked like he was ripping.


Gotta agree with you there Goatman. Anyone know what he was riding, dimensions etc?

Deisel
13 posts
8 Mar 2010 10:38AM
Thumbs Up

It looked like Bonga was on a PSH ripper but I can't be sure. Someone from the shop said he came in before the contest but not sure.

rodriguez
VIC, 883 posts
8 Mar 2010 4:16PM
Thumbs Up

for sure ,Bonga looked very composed and slotted

PT SUP said...

Judging from the footage ,Bongo was the only one doing critical snaps and rail turns.
Any one agree??
Great vid.
PT




Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle General


"Some more Sunset Vids" started by goatman