Forums > Stand Up Paddle General

tainted love

Reply
Created by laceys lane > 9 months ago, 24 Feb 2013
laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
24 Feb 2013 12:38PM
Thumbs Up

not being a noted fan of canoes i had a quick paddle on ali's ace 14' x 23.5.

it's pretty stable, has really good speed with not much effort and can accelerate from that good speed. thrives on any small bump.

the new models has massively improved paddlers comfort. thinner walls, flat standing area and recessed way back to the tail- as much as your going to need.

i didn't feel confined at all. nothing like being concreted in feeling of the previous models

the 25" would be my pick and very well could be my next 14'er at the end of the year .

word around the traps is a few brands are going to produce versions of the ace. its got to the stage where they have too


canoes look like being the future of all round and moderate dw racing whether paddlers like it or not. not having one could end up being like playing tennis with a wooden racket or surfing a single fin against a thruster- if you race seriously





RJK
QLD, 622 posts
24 Feb 2013 12:52PM
Thumbs Up

laceys lane said...

word around the traps is a few brands are going to produce versions of the ace. its got to the stage where they have too.





What other brands have u heard that from? Take any more volume from naish and there won't be any board left...

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
24 Feb 2013 12:57PM
Thumbs Up

RJK said...
laceys lane said...

word around the traps is a few brands are going to produce versions of the ace. its got to the stage where they have too.





What other brands have u heard that from? Take any more volume from naish and there won't be any board left...



hear say and not really my place to name, but i've heard no talk from naish


le naish boards have performed well but are limited to the freaks, well balanced and lightweights

RJK
QLD, 622 posts
24 Feb 2013 1:27PM
Thumbs Up

I hope it doesn't go down that line, aces are amazing but you lose that surfing feel IMO.

teatrea
QLD, 4177 posts
24 Feb 2013 1:30PM
Thumbs Up

Yeah I think starboard have been ahead of the curve for a while , the boards do look to glide more with less effort. Only paddled a couple of them and not the new ones , but they are definately on to something.

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
24 Feb 2013 2:54PM
Thumbs Up

RJK said...
I hope it doesn't go down that line, aces are amazing but you lose that surfing feel IMO.



yeah, i'm with you on that one, but ali's new model 'felt' pretty good. i'm not so sure thats a valid point anymore after paddling hers.i've been offered a paddle on a mates 25'er so at some stage i might see if i can sneak a dw run on it

Deano72
NSW, 540 posts
24 Feb 2013 4:31PM
Thumbs Up

laceys lane said...
word around the traps is a few brands are going to produce versions of the ace. its got to the stage where they have too


One of the other manufacturers has had a 'canoe' in production for a while.
Goes good too


stimo
WA, 874 posts
24 Feb 2013 1:36PM
Thumbs Up

laceys lane said...
RJK said...
I hope it doesn't go down that line, aces are amazing but you lose that surfing feel IMO.



yeah, i'm with you on that one, but ali's new model 'felt' pretty good. i'm not so sure thats a valid point anymore after paddling hers.i've been offered a paddle on a mates 25'er so at some stage i might see if i can sneak a dw run on it


Something coming from a shed close by
You will see it first on the east but coming here for the flat water marathon only difference you will be able to surf this one not that you can't surf the Ace. If you have your s--t together
Did you see that run beau got in the doctor not bad ( o that was last year model )

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
24 Feb 2013 3:42PM
Thumbs Up

stimo said...
laceys lane said...
RJK said...
I hope it doesn't go down that line, aces are amazing but you lose that surfing feel IMO.



yeah, i'm with you on that one, but ali's new model 'felt' pretty good. i'm not so sure thats a valid point anymore after paddling hers.i've been offered a paddle on a mates 25'er so at some stage i might see if i can sneak a dw run on it


Something coming from a shed close by
You will see it first on the east but coming here for the flat water marathon only difference you will be able to surf this one not that you can't surf the Ace. If you have your s--t together
Did you see that run beau got in the doctor not bad ( o that was last year model )



seen it stimo

stimo
WA, 874 posts
24 Feb 2013 2:46PM
Thumbs Up



Might be on the creek by the end of week

Nede
NSW, 38 posts
24 Feb 2013 7:06PM
Thumbs Up

Lacey, stay away from the dark side, These boards should be banned. I'm all for the dugout for stability but think that if this sport is to progress its got to set a standard design. It's a bit like surf lifesaving competitions all boards and ski's must meet a set standard. I think the Ace pushes that standard. I also think that the different widths is an issue. I know i'm probably going to open up a can of worms with this comment. I went with the Allstar 26" and love it. Still looks and performs like a board.

stimo
WA, 874 posts
24 Feb 2013 4:52PM
Thumbs Up

Nede said...
Lacey, stay away from the dark side, These boards should be banned. I'm all for the dugout for stability but think that if this sport is to progress its got to set a standard design. It's a bit like surf lifesaving competitions all boards and ski's must meet a set standard. I think the Ace pushes that standard. I also think that the different widths is an issue. I know i'm probably going to open up a can of worms with this comment. I went with the Allstar 26" and love it. Still looks and performs like a board.


Isn't that dug out a bit

If you carnt beat them you have to join them (well that's in my case ,they will still probably beat me at least then I will confirm I am crap )

JustCruising
74 posts
24 Feb 2013 5:02PM
Thumbs Up

Although I am not a big fan of the dugout I wouldn't want the innovation in SUP to by limited by rules and regulations. If it ever gets to be a big enough issue it could be dealt with by classes. Although I ended up buying my coreban edge recently the Ace was stiff competition and it would have been a shame to deny me the choice. Truth is if I had unlimited funds and space I would have both.

I wonder if we are already reaching optimum shapes now and any future innovations will be chasing ever smaller gains.

Also I thought I saw somewhere that Conner Baxter races a custom Starby without the dugout. Am I making that up? I am to lazy to check right now.

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
24 Feb 2013 7:31PM
Thumbs Up

Nede said...
Lacey, stay away from the dark side, These boards should be banned. I'm all for the dugout for stability but think that if this sport is to progress its got to set a standard design. It's a bit like surf lifesaving competitions all boards and ski's must meet a set standard. I think the Ace pushes that standard. I also think that the different widths is an issue. I know i'm probably going to open up a can of worms with this comment. I went with the Allstar 26" and love it. Still looks and performs like a board.



yeah plenty of talk about this but i can't see anything happening. again if your a serious racer its a no brainer to get one or have your sponsor looking into a similar design.

i'm for some standards personally.

i found this older model sic x12 to dw much like the ace. not the volume like the ace but a wide stubby dishy nose

PTWoody
VIC, 3982 posts
24 Feb 2013 8:40PM
Thumbs Up

Nede said...
Lacey, stay away from the dark side, These boards should be banned. I'm all for the dugout for stability but think that if this sport is to progress its got to set a standard design. It's a bit like surf lifesaving competitions all boards and ski's must meet a set standard. I think the Ace pushes that standard. I also think that the different widths is an issue. I know i'm probably going to open up a can of worms with this comment. I went with the Allstar 26" and love it. Still looks and performs like a board.


In racing, perhaps it's the flat decks that should be banned. If you read Steve West's excellent book Stand Up Paddle: A Paddler's Guide, you will be confronted with a compelling argument that SUP racing is in fact a paddle sport derivate and not a surfing derivative. In other words, the roots are in canoe racing, not surfing. So you might just as well ban the paddle as ban the dugout. Neither has its genesis in surfing.

PeterP
842 posts
24 Feb 2013 5:41PM
Thumbs Up

I believe they are considering a minimum thickness to avoid the full on canoe-look in the US.

Personally I feel the sport is better off if boards resemble something that surfs, it will just have a broader appeal. Plenty of canoes out there and nothing wrong with people sitting in them.....

Rode the 24" wide 12'6 and 14 Sprints on pure flat water and found the 12'6 somewhat more tippy. Compared to 14 LE I'd say the 14' Sprint is equally stable/unstable.

Standing inside the board didn't bother me but flooding decks on buoy turns is a bit of a challenge.

I sell Naish so take my comments with a pack of peanuts......

teatrea
QLD, 4177 posts
24 Feb 2013 8:11PM
Thumbs Up

laceys lane said...
Nede said...
Lacey, stay away from the dark side, These boards should be banned. I'm all for the dugout for stability but think that if this sport is to progress its got to set a standard design. It's a bit like surf lifesaving competitions all boards and ski's must meet a set standard. I think the Ace pushes that standard. I also think that the different widths is an issue. I know i'm probably going to open up a can of worms with this comment. I went with the Allstar 26" and love it. Still looks and performs like a board.



yeah plenty of talk about this but i can't see anything happening. again if your a serious racer its a no brainer to get one or have your sponsor looking into a similar design.

i'm for some standards personally.

i found this older model sic x12 to dw much like the ace. not the volume like the ace but a wide stubby dishy nose




I was going to buy this model after I first paddled it , in hindsight I should have.They do go really wellNoticed a few second hand ones getting around bargain I rekon. Also good board for the Heavier rider

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
24 Feb 2013 8:25PM
Thumbs Up

teatrea this board flies downwinding. best dw ing 12'6 i've been on. handles the rough and the nose just keeps it skipping along, less corrections more paddling strokes. surfs pretty good and stays straight going in when doing ins and outs which means a good rest rather than having to keep straightening it. going out isn't as good as dedicated bop board because of the nose. you have to stand back a bit the pop it over the foam.

a few second hand ones getting around on the breeze

maxeaus
NSW, 326 posts
25 Feb 2013 12:06AM
Thumbs Up

I am in awe of how fast boards progress in SUP.

My boards are 12 months and 10 months old and they are old school already.

HumanCartoon
VIC, 2098 posts
25 Feb 2013 10:51AM
Thumbs Up

stimo said...

Isn't that dug out a bit




got a link to that vid?

HumanCartoon
VIC, 2098 posts
25 Feb 2013 10:54AM
Thumbs Up

PTWoody said...

In racing, perhaps it's the flat decks that should be banned. If you read Steve West's excellent book Stand Up Paddle: A Paddler's Guide...


one man's opinion on the "origins" of SUP.

good book but...if only he'd hired a decent editor .

surfer56
146 posts
25 Feb 2013 8:28AM
Thumbs Up

Most of the international and stateside races are won on flatdeck boards over dugouts just seems to be more of them down our way . The engine determines the win over design I reckon

Nede
NSW, 38 posts
25 Feb 2013 12:37PM
Thumbs Up

If engine beats design, why was the wing keel so controversial in the America's Cup all those years ago. Yes tactics and engine are key factors but design does play an important part as well. I've had 3 boards so far and all completely different in design, handling and glide speed. If we are to see all the top guys & girls race wouldn't it be nice to see them compete on a level playing field imo?

Snowie
NSW, 149 posts
25 Feb 2013 1:22PM
Thumbs Up

Here is a pic of me and my flatmate lining up our OC2 with the other canoes at the start of the Hawkesbury Canoe Classic. By chance, I just got the pics of this sent to me this morning by a friend.

I had a brief go of a 14' / 25" Allstar last week and it was nice and stable considering. I would need to adjust to the slope behind though.

Snowie
NSW, 149 posts
25 Feb 2013 2:57PM
Thumbs Up

Here is another picture a few minutes later.

PTWoody
VIC, 3982 posts
25 Feb 2013 3:17PM
Thumbs Up

Nede said...
If engine beats design, why was the wing keel so controversial in the America's Cup all those years ago. Yes tactics and engine are key factors but design does play an important part as well. I've had 3 boards so far and all completely different in design, handling and glide speed. If we are to see all the top guys & girls race wouldn't it be nice to see them compete on a level playing field imo?


Yes but whenever anyone brings up the "level playing field" argument, the implicit point is "as long as it's my playing field everyone conforms to."

They tried a level playing field in international open wheel racing as a direct competitor to Formula 1, they called it A1 Grand Prix. It died a miserable death.

Everyone is free to buy a dugout raceboard or design and build their own. There's no issue with it being an exclusive design for the lucky few.

Deano72
NSW, 540 posts
25 Feb 2013 3:45PM
Thumbs Up

stimo said...
Isn't that dug out a bit



Hope they don't paint that thing orange!!
It could be mistaken for the Walk on Water RDO

teatrea
QLD, 4177 posts
25 Feb 2013 4:19PM
Thumbs Up

Hey Lacey what do you think of these designs by HUKI.
The first three are the all conditions board , the orange one flat water speed machine.






laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
25 Feb 2013 7:16PM
Thumbs Up

the orange one i wouldn't touch. looks way to tippy and i reckon wakes would be a nightmare.

the first board is hard to see properly, but it kinda look like a dug out fanatic, well the nose anyway .


the new fanatic's have definitely shortened up their displacement noses and i'm to understand they plan to go blunter again. the prototypes jacko and angie have been paddling around point to that.

got off track there but would have to see the yellow one teatrea. they are a rated ski brand for sure but whether they understand you have to stand on these things is in question

gregc
VIC, 1298 posts
26 Feb 2013 4:56PM
Thumbs Up

Im not fast enough so I would notice the difference I reckon. I love my 14ft Fanatic I think I will leave the design of race boards to those that know about it. Quick question and this shows my ignorance, with the dropped decks, you would need to a way to drain the water wouldnt you, I mean I see it in somme of those designs and not in others. The other question I have is how do you do a pivot turn if like the starboards the cockpit doesnt go all the way to the tail? I know in sailboarding most of the really stupid fast slalom boards have a dropped deck to get the mast base closer to the water and improve drive, does this have the same effect on a SUP noting that we dont go that fast. I hope one of the more knowledgable types can answer some of these questions

stimo
WA, 874 posts
26 Feb 2013 3:52PM
Thumbs Up

Deano72 said...
stimo said...
Isn't that dug out a bit



Hope they don't paint that thing orange!!
It could be mistaken for the Walk on Water RDO


My boards have being that colour for a while now going to spray tonight
When you see the bottom of the board there will be no mistaking the two [:



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle General


"tainted love" started by laceys lane