Forums > Windsurfing General

cowes extreme sailing series

Reply
Created by Gestalt > 9 months ago, 8 Aug 2010
Gestalt
QLD, 14393 posts
8 Aug 2010 2:46PM
Thumbs Up

some food for thought in this interview.

boards.mpora.com/videos/featured-videos/whitey-talks-rossco-skye-cribby-cowes.html

www.sailing.org/33615.php

ploppy
QLD, 167 posts
8 Aug 2010 6:17PM
Thumbs Up

good find,brings back memories as i lived on the isle of wight until two years ago,nice place actually gets wind there all year round.

brad1
QLD, 232 posts
8 Aug 2010 6:31PM
Thumbs Up

^ Yep, Great memories, spent 5 summers in Cowes myself. Love the place!!

Gestalt
QLD, 14393 posts
8 Aug 2010 8:26PM
Thumbs Up

looked like a great event.

h20
VIC, 456 posts
8 Aug 2010 9:23PM
Thumbs Up

That's awesome in 5-15 knots gotta be more fun than a 7- 8 m with a Wally board. If anyone in Melbourne buys one I would be more than happy to crew. I recon you wouldn't get much change out of $150- $200k

Ah. How wrong was I. Sugar.
www.scanboat.com/ErrorPages/errorpage.html?aspxerrorpath=/en/BoatSaleAdvert.asp

Almost $700k. ?400k. Wow.

Chris 249
NSW, 3334 posts
8 Aug 2010 9:38PM
Thumbs Up

h20 said...

That's awesome in 5-15 knots gotta be more fun than a 7- 8 m with a Wally board. If anyone in Melbourne buys one I would be more than happy to crew. I recon you wouldn't get much change out of $150- $200k

Ah. How wrong was I. Sugar.
www.scanboat.com/ErrorPages/errorpage.html?aspxerrorpath=/en/BoatSaleAdvert.asp

Almost $700k. ?400k. Wow.



Depends on exactly how you like your fun.

I spent a few seasons sailing cats, and they can be great fun, but there are so many different ways of having fun that surely there's no way anyone can say what's "got to be more fun".

High performance boats, as you noted, cost a lot - not just in cash, but also in rigging hassle, transport hassle, crew hassle, yada yada yada. They're fantastic, but it's hard to say that anything is "better" - just different.

Chris 249
NSW, 3334 posts
8 Aug 2010 9:58PM
Thumbs Up

Gestalt said...

some food for thought in this interview.

http://boards.mpora.com/videos/featured-videos/whitey-talks-rossco-skye-cribby-cowes.html

www.sailing.org/33615.php




The VX 40s are causing a stir, but to what end?

It seems significant that this is the third time around for 40 foot multis. In around 1986, the Formula 40 class started up. The F40 were a response to the problems in Europe's "Formula 1" multihull scene, which had 85 footers that were just too expensive for the biggest sponsors.

The boats generally looked very similar to the VX40s, save for alloy masts, but the class also allowed tris in and they ended up dominating.

The Formula 40 class had much the same impact as the VX 40s. People started saying that this sort of spectator-friendly racing close inshore in fast boats was the way of the future.

So what happened? It all died. Costs went up, the model became unsustainable, and it all crashed in about 1990.

Then the Yanks took some of the Formula 40 cats and made it into a one-design series (Prosail 40s). Costs were reduced because boats no longer became obsolete - and still the series crashed after a year or so.

Some of the Formula 40s ended up on Swiss lakes, where they beat the Formula Libera monos, which were like giant 44 foot 18 Foot Skiffs, complete with a dozen guys trapezing off wings. The Libera class, which in the mid '80s was seen like the VX 40s are now, is pretty much dormant, with just a tiny handful of boats. And the Swiss lake scene is still dominated, numbers-wise, by comparatively conventional monos.

Much of the energy in the F40 scene went into the 60 foot multis, which were amazing performers that would probably make a VX40 look stodgy. The 60 foot ORMA class died about three years ago. I had the luck to talk to one of the top designers, who said that the class got too much into performance and ignored practicality.

It's significant to see a pro windsurfer talking, because windsurfing crashed like few sports ever have about the same time it became all about high wind high speed sailing.

The VX40s look cool, but the Formula Libera boats looked cool, the Formula 40s looked cool, the Formula 1s looked cool, the ORMA 60s looked cool, the Prosail 40s looked cool.

Maybe the VX40s will work, but on the other hand after something like 12 high-performance pro-sailing inshore circuits have either been stillborn or died, maybe the idea is just unworkable. Significantly, the biggest-selling and fastest-growing classes in sailing are comparatively cheap, simple and practical boats. Those who are actually selling lots of boats are ignoring the hype.

While I'm not pointing fingers at anyone here, it does get a bit depressing to read in other areas that people are saying "high performance pro sailing is the way of the future and open-minded people accept that". Maybe those who keep on trying to push a formula that has died a dozen times are those who are too stuck in a rut to realise when something isn't working, and maybe those who accepted that these classes don't work are the open-minded ones.

Gestalt
QLD, 14393 posts
9 Aug 2010 12:30AM
Thumbs Up

i think you took my comments the wrong way there chris,

i said food for thought meaning the interview where they talked about racing close to the shore. that is something i used to push in qld. it struck me odd that most of the racing was done out away from the shoreline where no one can see the action.

turns out i was in the minority with that thought.

i wasn't saying highwind sailing or extreme 40's are the way forward.

to be honest i don't care how windy it is. i'll still go sailing. took a OD for a short spin last weekend. love short boards, formula, longboards or whatever. still go out on the short board in 5-10 knots for fun. it's all windsurfing in the end.

now if i were at cowes i'd just be drunk. watching the action with a pint in one hand a scotch egg in the other.

Haircut
QLD, 6481 posts
9 Aug 2010 7:33AM
Thumbs Up


i lived in cowes and used to drink at the isle of wight, but i don't ever remember seeing a yacht race like that?

mkseven
QLD, 2314 posts
9 Aug 2010 8:29AM
Thumbs Up

But Gestie you dont race, maybe you should attend an event at Wynnum this year- racing is pretty close in- there has been a fair bit of spectator interest in recent years.

Not quite as close as some of the old beachstart events though such as Caloundra or Elliott Heads, but alot more traffic seeing 30+ sails heading round the buoys.

Gestalt
QLD, 14393 posts
9 Aug 2010 12:33PM
Thumbs Up

might start calling you the shadow mark.

it wasn't the starts i was referring to, i meant the inside gybe mark or marks should be placed close to the beach. like as close as possible without injuring swimmers.

Assymetic
14 posts
9 Aug 2010 4:42PM
Thumbs Up

Haircut said...


i lived in cowes and used to drink at the isle of wight, but i don't ever remember seeing a yacht race like that?


that pub burnt down recently

Chris 249
NSW, 3334 posts
9 Aug 2010 8:05PM
Thumbs Up

Gestalt said...

i think you took my comments the wrong way there chris,

i said food for thought meaning the interview where they talked about racing close to the shore. that is something i used to push in qld. it struck me odd that most of the racing was done out away from the shoreline where no one can see the action.

turns out i was in the minority with that thought.

i wasn't saying highwind sailing or extreme 40's are the way forward.

to be honest i don't care how windy it is. i'll still go sailing. took a OD for a short spin last weekend. love short boards, formula, longboards or whatever. still go out on the short board in 5-10 knots for fun. it's all windsurfing in the end.

now if i were at cowes i'd just be drunk. watching the action with a pint in one hand a scotch egg in the other.




Sorry, it was more of a general rant of mine, based on the way the sailing media and some sailors keep on hyping up the pro sailing stuff as a new idea that's the future of the sport, when in fact it's been tried and failed many times.

Yeah, I think you're right about having stuff close to shore. Apparently even in a "normal" Cowes Week, where most people are racing "old style" day racing keelboats and standard cruiser-racers, there are many spectators along the shore because boats dodge in very close to cheat the tide.

There are hyper-detailed books to guide on how close you can get into the shore - literally there are diagrams showing how you can take a bearing off the third bedroom window in one house and line it up with a lamp-post, so you can get right in away from the tide.

mkseven
QLD, 2314 posts
9 Aug 2010 10:09PM
Thumbs Up

Gestalt said...

might start calling you the shadow mark.

it wasn't the starts i was referring to, i meant the inside gybe mark or marks should be placed close to the beach. like as close as possible without injuring swimmers.


Nah it's just there are 10 of your posts for me to comment on as opposed to 1 of anyone else

I do see where you are coming from, but as you'd know from planing an event there are so many variables to consider.

At any rate here it was better than it was, you really should come along sometime and have a crack- your freestyle gear would plonk you pretty well in the freeride fleet

Gestalt
QLD, 14393 posts
9 Aug 2010 11:05PM
Thumbs Up

i'll leave to others.

racing is not what drives me anymore. i'd be strapping on a gps before a watch.

mkseven
QLD, 2314 posts
9 Aug 2010 11:24PM
Thumbs Up

Gestalt said...

i'll leave to others.

racing is not what drives me anymore. i'd be strapping on a gps before a watch.


great, we can sign you up to the bronze fleet in the new speed series



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"cowes extreme sailing series" started by Gestalt