Forums > Windsurfing General

design your own board

Reply
Created by Gestalt > 9 months ago, 24 Jul 2010
Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
24 Jul 2010 5:08PM
Thumbs Up

is anyone using boardcad?

i started mucking around with it in win7 and it works really well. very impressed.
it's free, will calc volume, deals with 4d cnc etc.....

http://www.boardcad.com/news.php?sid=223bc45fa6f9b17459b6117eab00996e&cat=10&lang=eng

KenHo
NSW, 1353 posts
24 Jul 2010 8:27PM
Thumbs Up

I might get you to do one for me.
90-92L, thruster design, early planing wave board.
Go !!

Oh, and a serious;y FUNKY graphic. The sort of thing that will make all the BOF's and boring young dudes with no imagination will hate.
Like , really hate !!

Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
24 Jul 2010 8:33PM
Thumbs Up

i can do you a board mate. no worries, am working up a 100lt freewave currently that's early planning based on my freestyle board but smaller and with a little more tail and nose kick and it's a single/tri fin. can easily make it a few litres less. rocker is very good for qld


hehe,.

i did a graphic with that brief a few years ago. yes, that is an 80's leopard print. with 80's cure eyeballs.



p.s. you were asking about my current voodoo.... here is the review i wrote with pics.
http://www.kiteboarder.com.au/forums/topic.asp?topic_id=59469

Haircut
QLD, 6481 posts
24 Jul 2010 8:45PM
Thumbs Up

if you put a V in front of your oodoo, you could have a voodoo, and that would be cool

you can thank me later

Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
24 Jul 2010 9:53PM
Thumbs Up

ooooooddddddoooooooV

evlPanda
NSW, 9202 posts
24 Jul 2010 10:59PM
Thumbs Up

How much do they cost Gestalt? It looks like you can go nuts with the graphics, that alone is a drawcard. And of course how do they ride? Are they actually machine shaped. What am I asking you for, I still have Peter's number about the other thing.

Dreaming about a board with blue field and big, orange octopus draped around it, gulf colours, i.e. http://forums.finalgear.com/general-automotive/gulf-colors-33013/

Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
24 Jul 2010 11:36PM
Thumbs Up

he has them for around $1890 on his website, but please don't quote me as i don't know what retail is.

the hand shaped versus machine cut is a bit of a myth. it stems from when boards were polyester and built from preshaped blanks like surfboards. because preshaped blanks were used all boards were done from start to finish by eye which meant tolerences weren't as accurate.

boards are not built that way anymore. they are cut from a block of foam with a hot wire run along a template. so the rocker and outline is the same from board to board. rails are measured with stencils and shaped also. then the board is hand finished.

the only area i can see where cnc is more accurate is where the deck curves down to the rail and if the board has complicated concaves. however an experienced shaper will not struggle with this at all. at the end of the day even cnc boards need to be hand finished and if the finisher isn't an experienced shaper you will get a dodgey outcome.

where cnc is very benificial is speed. a cnc machine will shape a board faster than a master shaper ready for hand finishing. also when designing, 3d is easier as you can calc volume and get a better understanding of volume distribution prior to construction.

graphics can be whatever i guess. i've spent a lot of time talking to pete about ways to get my designs onto his boards the easiest way possible. he sprays all of his boards so i provide him with laser cut templates that i produce in cad after tracing my coloured designs. we have also tried printed thin vynil but that is expensive. can easily add a couple of hundred dollars for the small quanitity needed. recently i found a company in the us that will do a board size graphic for a good price but i am yet to get anything happening.

you could always paint your own graphics if you are artistic or get a mate to do it for you if they are artistic. skies the limit, other than that you can design it and give it to the shaper to spray.

edit* i forgot to answer your question about ride.

i like them. he has very good rockers. materials wise i get mine in timber veneer so they have a bit of flex which i like. you could get them in full carbon or whatever if you like light and stiff.

2nd edit** i forgot to say also. yes he has cnc cut boards. there is a local guy who also has years of experience with windsurfers who has a cnc mill for sups/windsurfers etc.

currently petes boards are being measured. my voodoo has been measured so can be cnc milled. as has his slalom and speed boards. with the boards i am tinkering with for myself, once built they would be measured to if they work.

KenHo
NSW, 1353 posts
25 Jul 2010 10:35AM
Thumbs Up

UggggggHH !! No 80's please !! The 80's blew chunks when I lived through them, and they are worse now.
Saying "the best of the 80's style" is an oxymoron.

Yeah, a single with thrusters is an OK compromise. Lots of those around this year.
Performance wise, I'm specifically thinking about getting back out through the shore-break at Palm Beach when sailing Currumbin. Quick onto the plane with enough bubbles to float my fat ass.
Who's Pete ?
I liked the look of the Nude boards, half thinking about one of those. Would have to sell the JP quad, but it may not be quick enough to get out at Palmy anyway. Have to wait and see.

longwinded
WA, 344 posts
25 Jul 2010 9:09AM
Thumbs Up

KenHo said...

UggggggHH !! No 80's please !! The 80's blew chunks when I lived through them, and they are worse now.
Saying "the best of the 80's style" is an oxymoron.




Have to agree, a board with Bill Crosby knitted sweater style graphics would not be cool.

Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
25 Jul 2010 11:25AM
Thumbs Up

hehe.... the red thumbs prove the point of the graphic above.


work in progress. needs refining and swallow tail modelled and rails improved. the software is excellent. it gives instant feedback to volume variations so you can see what the rail flow and thickness changes do.




choco
SA, 4037 posts
25 Jul 2010 12:19PM
Thumbs Up

how did u save the pics of the board your designing?

vando
QLD, 3416 posts
25 Jul 2010 1:17PM
Thumbs Up

Nice one gesty

Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
25 Jul 2010 5:56PM
Thumbs Up

@choco - the program has an export spec sheet function that gives the template views i uploaded. it also allows you to reduce the templates by the thickness of the layup prior to export as well as template export features for hot wire cuts. the 3d image i had to do a printscreen.

@vando - cheers mate.

Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
26 Jul 2010 9:47PM
Thumbs Up

the software doesn't deal with swallow tails very well and i would be reluctant to push models through to cnc unless they are simple ie. pin or rounded tail. when you create a swallow tail it alters the rocker at the tail but this is not an issue with pin type tails.

but fantastic program. the design below took about 10 hours and i've never used the program before. i left out the swallow for obvious reasons. from here i can cut templates ready for shaping or get the blank cnc milled.


barn
WA, 2960 posts
26 Jul 2010 8:58PM
Thumbs Up

i downloaded the program but gave up as soon as i saw it open, to much grey! .. ive been playing with AKU shaper previously linked somewhere on seabreeze, just vector curves with tags (similar to adobe illustrator), calculates volume and gives out measurements for any point, it seems to work best to use as little guide points as possible, just lets the maths make the nice curves... (but thats as far as i got!)..

anyway, Get salt.

is it just me or does your new board have a really loooong flat section,.. then loads of nose kick.. im no board shaping expert but all the new boards, even waveboards seem to be very flat without much extra kick at the nose.. just a gradually increasing rocker. (my survey consisted of my twinser and flare)

and the deck is pretty flat, i used to own a tabou freestyle 80 (for the windier days) and it had a flat deck which was very uncomfortable and burned the legs trying to keep it flat, because there was nothing to bank my heel on..

i realise thats the whole idea of a custom, to do something different.. but like evolution, the greater the board mutation, the greater the chance the mutation will be injurious. to quote darwin himself.

just a thought, feel free to correct..



speaking of mutations unfavourable to selection




swoosh
QLD, 1927 posts
26 Jul 2010 11:03PM
Thumbs Up

barn.... that looks like a boat bro.

barn
WA, 2960 posts
26 Jul 2010 9:09PM
Thumbs Up

hahaha yeah ill strap an outboard to it, stay tuned..

choco
SA, 4037 posts
26 Jul 2010 11:27PM
Thumbs Up

my 15 min creation clinker hull slalom board

Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
27 Jul 2010 12:09AM
Thumbs Up

@barn,

well i can't confirm or deny. you could be right.

it's a lightwind wave board so i gave it some nose kick but kept the entry rocker down. there isn't a flat area as such though, it's a continuous rocker. it will have a 300mm flat in it between the rear and front strap once shaped. i also have this thing about thin boards so at 110mm thick it becomes an exercise on where to place the volume to achieve 110 lt.

tail kick is 30mm so it has a fairly flatish rocker for a wave board but i need it to get up and go in light winds and crap surf.

i am concerned there is a little to much volume in the rails.

i'm going for thin and flat because i'm hoping it makes the board feel more like a surfboard and thin feels more lively under the feet. flat decks don't bother me so much. my current board has a flat deck. just makes it easier to get around in light winds.

i had a look at akushaper. there are a couple of features in boardcad that i think give it the edge. first is that you can pan along the board and the sections change so you can do it in realtime to see the flow of the rails and the other thing is that boardcad has a volume distribution graph it overlays on the outline so you can see what the volume is doing. the other items is that boardcad overlays flowlines on the sections and outlines so you can see the relationship of your rail/deck apex points. plus it shows the tuck under line on the outline so you can check rail details. all of these things really help keep the lines flowing. at the end of the day though, you can just change the background colour.

Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
27 Jul 2010 12:12AM
Thumbs Up

spec sheet choco

Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
1 Aug 2010 8:06PM
Thumbs Up

so 1 session in 4 weeks had me dreaming of light wind alternatives.

the fatbat formula! avec secret tail shape

curac
WA, 1145 posts
1 Aug 2010 6:55PM
Thumbs Up

best board i have ever had. hand shaped by me.
but with someone else's graphics

Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
1 Aug 2010 9:39PM
Thumbs Up

are you shaping for patrik d

curac
WA, 1145 posts
1 Aug 2010 8:11PM
Thumbs Up

nah he showed me how to shape and i used his tools so we put his graphics on it..

Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
1 Aug 2010 10:19PM
Thumbs Up

sweet, sounds like fun. i've never been that good on the tools myself but have helped build a few boards in the past.

there's some thruster surfboards floating around somewhere with my sweat on them as well. of course i did all of the numptie jobs.

whenever i go to a mates place the first thing we do is head to the shaping room and check out all the boards.

icesurf
QLD, 113 posts
2 Aug 2010 10:02AM
Thumbs Up



Used BoardCad last year & found its is very unstable program in Vista OS, works little better in W7 OS, great for creating the basic mesh surface of a board quickly.

Wouldn't trust the CNC processor in boardcad.
The boardcad program should only be used as a "BASE" for designing boards.
With surfboard programs like this you can't see the inaccuracy in the surface mesh until its too late.

Once you create the basic shape of your board in boardcad, for best result save the file & import into a program like Rhino or Alias.

Once in these programs the mesh & curvature can be analyze (see picture below), here the mesh can be moved around until until the curves flow uniformly, after this off to the CNC machine. With this methodological my Creations come off the CNC machine exactly as designed.

Would be great to hear how Slowboat designs his boards!


Gestalt
QLD, 14428 posts
2 Aug 2010 12:31PM
Thumbs Up

Hi Icesurf.

that is the one thing that worries me about the software. exporting to cnc seems a bit grey. if it doesn't work my fall back is templates which it does very well. then the proto can be scanned for reproduction. at the end of the day though the cnc mill is owned by a company that produces boards already and uses it's own cnc software. we will be able to check the data in the their software prior to cutting to see that all is ok. so it isn't boardcad that i intend to use to send the model to the mill.

a couple of questions....

were you using version 1.1a? in version 1.1a i've found it very quick to form the shape, check volume distribution etc as you say. the time consuming part is adjusting the curves via the curvature controls which analyse the mesh/curvatures. i'm not sure if early version had this but like rhino it gives a graphical representation of the relationships of the curves for the rail/rocker/outline so that you can adjust the radii and make sure the shape flows and has no bumps etc.

i also wondered what format you sent to the cnc machine? was it gcode or nurbs? nurbs seem inaccurate and require additional 3d editting and additional 3d points to be added beyond the default to ensure a more accurate 3d shape. the gcode 3d models are meant to be an accurate reflection of the design. i am yet to test this but reading through the manual and the boardcad website it suggests gcode for exporting and they have re written the cutter profiles to get better flow also.

the items that i really don't trust boardcad with is the concaves. there is no way of making sure that a doble concave is flat along the length of the board from start to finish points as the concave controls are done in cross section. it is also impossible to do a single concave as you can't adjust the centreline curve. the work around is to pull the rail rocker down to achieve a single concave but this is not how boards are shaped. i was thinking all concaves would need to be hand shaped.

mr love
VIC, 2358 posts
2 Aug 2010 1:54PM
Thumbs Up

I have had a bit of a play with Board CAD but haven't spent enough time on it to really comment. Once being spoilt on a high end CAD system like Alias, which I am lucky to have access to, it is hard to use something else.
As Icesurf says I think the surface quality from something like Alias,UG or Rhino is really accurate and you have so many evaluation tools to assist in seeing exactly what your shape is doing.



Here's my latest speed board, the Love Muss V2. It is only roughed in and I need to completely remodel it now to get it really fair. No fun tickets available to build it, I am just playing.






Wet Willy
TAS, 2317 posts
2 Aug 2010 3:13PM
Thumbs Up

longwinded said...

KenHo said...

UggggggHH !! No 80's please !! The 80's blew chunks when I lived through them, and they are worse now.
Saying "the best of the 80's style" is an oxymoron.




Have to agree, a board with Bill Crosby knitted sweater style graphics would not be cool.


Okay fellas, that's quite enough blasphemy for one day, thank you

slowboat
WA, 554 posts
2 Aug 2010 1:32PM
Thumbs Up

icesurf said...



Would be great to hear how Slowboat designs his boards!



with a lot of tedium is the straight answer. I've been refining models to link the rocker to the outline and bottom shape based on achieving a stable lift distribution. I dont use a conventional CAD package at all. I tend to write programs in C/C++ using a growing library of code that I've written over the years. It allows me to define the math behind the curve rather than just letting the program join the dots of what looks good using interpolation. I even use Excel a lot. With every new design I seem to be writing a new program to add extra bits. It has no graphical output. The output files are 2D for making templates.

If you want the board to work as expected, and repeatably with subsequent production, then the bottom shape has to be perfect.

The rocker jig and bagging process is the key to accuracy here, not the initial shape of the blank. Its so flexible you can bend it by 10cm in the jig if you need to, and without the jig it will do this on its own. Then theres the hand shaping at the end to get it to spec. You need good templates for this. The PVC needs to be trimmed and shaped by hand. Then theres the final rail shaping and bottom shaping after the PVC has gone on, then theres the final fairing after the filler coat is on.

CNC doesnt help here. And these are the steps that determine whether the board goes well or not.

The outline and profile is easy to cut from a block of foam by hand with templates and the right tools. Its faster than CNC to do it by hand and arguably just as accurate (or more if the blank isnt clamped perfectly on the CNC machine when its flipped over). Plus you get the bonus of a rocker jig with the leftover foam from hotwiring.

Shaping the deck curves... CNC helps if your design has loads of funky curves on it. A good shaper working from measurements can shape the deck curves if a simple clean design within a mm or two over the whole board in about the same time as a CNC machine. Probably not quite as accurate as a CNC machined blank done properly, but is 1-2mm accuracy good enough on the deck? I think so. Deck curves are based on what looks smooth on the CAD program, not some underlying science and formula.

So in my book hand shaping with templates is at least as appealing as using CNC. You need to make most of the templates anyway if you are expecting a good result.

CAD is useful in either case to make the jigs and templates from something.

sausage
QLD, 4873 posts
2 Aug 2010 5:07PM
Thumbs Up

mr love said...






Noice - reminds me of....................



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"design your own board" started by Gestalt