Forums > Windsurfing General

right of way

Reply
Created by saltiest1 > 9 months ago, 28 Mar 2011
P.C_simpson
NSW, 1489 posts
2 Apr 2011 12:49AM
Thumbs Up

I know the proper rules and if anyone gets in my way or tries to steal my waves i'll just yell at you, just like the Caveman i am..

And there should be a rule that if you are on a sick wave and going straight and sitting on the shoulder you deserve to have it taken off you..

Or are sailing an Ezzy wearing a Gath Helmet, they seam to be the main offenders of not having a clue on the water, i don't know why that is, it just is..

racerX
462 posts
1 Apr 2011 9:56PM
Thumbs Up

Earlier on

barn said...
Rules are sposed to be uniform... Sailor heading out through the break always has right of way.

These are maritime rules, anybody turning has to give way.. If there is an injury and it goes to the courts, then it gets down to the maritime rules...



I googled the international regulations the (COLREGs) as I was interested and found a copy on the Western Australian Legislation website here:

http://www.slp.wa.gov.au/pco/prod/FileStore.nsf/Documents/MRDocument:4113P/$FILE/PreventionOfCollisionsAtSeaRegs1983_01-a0-03.pdf?OpenElement

and a good summary here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Regulations_for_Preventing_Collisions_at_Sea#cite_note-full_text_COLREGS-3

and could NOT find anything that suggested a turning vessel (i.e. on a wave) needs to give way one that is not. So is that really true?

There is a rule for a vessel that is restricted in it's ability to manoeuvre which I guess would cover the person going out in many situations going out through the break, e.g. slogging on a matchstick on the way out, or conversly the need to go DTL or end up on the rocks.

I just got back from a trip to Cape Verde, and the scenario there was one where the guy in the most precarious position varied from the wave rider to the one going out, and it was also obvious who that was. In this scenario there was not much jumping going on in the wave riding zone, as it was pretty difficult to plane, in that zone. I am pretty sure no one new who had 'the right of way' at any particular time, I certainly didn't! But everyone new when your were in a tight spot, or they could see when a guy was having some fun, including the kiters!

To me


Rule 2 - Responsibility
(a) Nothing in these Rules shall exonerate any vessel, or the owner,
master or crew thereof, from the consequences of any neglect to
comply with these Rules or of the neglect of any precaution which
may be required by the ordinary practice of seamen, or by the special
circumstances of the case.
(b) In construing and complying with these Rules due regard shall be had
to all dangers of navigation and collision and to any special
circumstances, including the limitations of the vessels involved,
which may make a departure from these Rules necessary to avoid
immediate danger.


Which to me translates into, use your common-sense, respect the local rules, no point being dead right...




fullmoon
WA, 314 posts
1 Apr 2011 10:25PM
Thumbs Up

I would reckon that rule 18. b. ii. would cover it if you did collide but you never can be sure.

nobbie
WA, 44 posts
2 Apr 2011 6:43AM
Thumbs Up

P.C_simpson said...

I know the proper rules and if anyone gets in my way or tries to steal my waves i'll just yell at you, just like the Caveman i am..

And there should be a rule that if you are on a sick wave and going straight and sitting on the shoulder you deserve to have it taken off you..

Or are sailing an Ezzy wearing a Gath Helmet, they seam to be the main offenders of not having a clue on the water, i don't know why that is, it just is..


Like this guy?

lotofwind
NSW, 6451 posts
2 Apr 2011 9:52AM
Thumbs Up

I saw one of the old boys wearing a gath helmet riding a mobility scooter yesterday,LOL

Would he be an Ezzy sailor??

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
2 Apr 2011 8:13AM
Thumbs Up

Fkn ell, do you need a rule book to avoid people when you're walking along the footpath?

It's not rocket science. If i asked 50 people what rules they followed when walking around I'd get 50 different responses. You'd get special give way rules for blind people, for grannies, for kids on a razor with a big grin on their face, you'd get exceptions for when you're feeling tired or energetic, you'd get special rules for if the guy coming along looks like a bikie or a policeman.

In the end just use common sense and courtesy.

Stuff it I'm off to catch some wind

saltiest1
NSW, 2497 posts
2 Apr 2011 11:21AM
Thumbs Up

lotofwind said...

I saw one of the old boys wearing a gath helmet riding a mobility scooter yesterday,LOL

Would he be an Ezzy sailor??




and he was smokin' up them white wheels too?

R1DER
WA, 1463 posts
2 Apr 2011 8:50AM
Thumbs Up

R1DER said...

To Hell with rules and safety and guidelines I'm changing everything.

If I'm on my 3 year old water proof core indestructible blue pig board I have right of way all the time in any situation
BUT
If I'm on my brand new pristine freshly made board, you all have right of way anytime in any situation.


Ah come on no red thumbs for that comment It's not fair, how come Mark Australia always gets all the red thumbs

PlioMax
WA, 20 posts
2 Apr 2011 9:03AM
Thumbs Up

nebbian said...

Fkn ell, do you need a rule book to avoid people when you're walking along the footpath?

It's not rocket science. If i asked 50 people what rules they followed when walking around I'd get 50 different responses. You'd get special give way rules for blind people, for grannies, for kids on a razor with a big grin on their face, you'd get exceptions for when you're feeling tired or energetic, you'd get special rules for if the guy coming along looks like a bikie or a policeman.

In the end just use common sense and courtesy.

Stuff it I'm off to catch some wind


I'd just like to punch slow walking people in the back of the head

barn
WA, 2960 posts
2 Apr 2011 9:38AM
Thumbs Up

racerX said...


*snip
and could NOT find anything that suggested a turning vessel (i.e. on a wave) needs to give way one that is not. So is that really true?
*snip
Which to me translates into, use your common-sense, respect the local rules, no point being dead right...




Can you imagine the ocean commotion if a vessel changing course had right of way over somebody going in a straight line?!...

Also a sailing vessel heading directly down wind has to give way to boats sailing across the wind..


I would not feel safe if I went on the water with the 'rulebook' disregarded and everybody using just their 'common sense'.. When Ezzys/Noobs get on a wave, they loose their mind in the sheer ecstasy and adrenalin of pretending to be Mike Waltz.. I am not doubting that the non-EZZY experienced guys from WA sail responsibly and hold back that bottom turn if somebody's in their path.. Its the guys with no clue I'm worried about, those are the guys who need to know the 'rules'..





nebbian
said...



Fkn ell, do you need a rule book to avoid people when you're walking along the footpath?

It's not rocket science. If i asked 50 people what rules they followed when walking around I'd get 50 different responses. You'd get special give way rules for blind people, for grannies, for kids on a razor with a big grin on their face, you'd get exceptions for when you're feeling tired or energetic, you'd get special rules for if the guy coming along looks like a bikie or a policeman.

In the end just use common sense and courtesy.


There's that elusive common sense again! I was told from a young age to walk on the left of the footpath.. So I walk on the left, wonder what the other 49 rules are!!

There are a few other rules more important, but I'm the kinda guy who uses my common sense and It's perfectly safe for me to drive past kindergartens at 110kph while high on Meth, cause I'm a sick driver, and my Commodore has been lowered so it has better performance.. fck tha police

saltiest1
NSW, 2497 posts
3 Apr 2011 1:07AM
Thumbs Up

so, if someone is heading through the surf zone heading out, they have top priority, until they reach clear water whence the guy with wind on stb then has priority.

saltiest1
NSW, 2497 posts
3 Apr 2011 1:08AM
Thumbs Up

it all clear as mud.

saltiest1
NSW, 2497 posts
3 Apr 2011 1:08AM
Thumbs Up

im going with decrepit.

king of the point
WA, 1836 posts
2 Apr 2011 10:36PM
Thumbs Up

barn said...

Zachery said...


Really easy-
Maritime rules apply until you are in the break.
Then going out has right of way, but not to the point of being discourteous (ie: if you are heading out, and you can let the guy enjoy his waveride and still get out just fine, don't make him give way to you just cos he has to give way according to the rules.)

I think this has been considered the Australian rules as Mark has stated, setting yourself up for the perfect DTL can be ten times harder than running out for a jump unless underpowered!


I agree with this 1st bit, well worded... All I'm saying/adding is the guy on the wave can't expect this privilege, and he can't initiate any DTL antics until the guy heading out has made his intentions obvious.. Otherwise all hell will break loose..

But this whole thing about once they are planing they give way ra ra ra is not on..


By the way I think it would be entirely arrogant of me to think my waveride was more important that John Smiths perfect ramp for his backie attempt that might be the highlight of his session/trip/summer..


Is it normally white guys who can't jump who reckon jumping is 2nd fiddle to waveriding?





Now i can use the quote button .............that was to easy.... computers are harder than that arnt they

Just wanted to make the point barn its not that you would be arrogant and ruin a blokes jump.

As PREVIOUSLY mentioned the SECOND self preservation rule also applys when someones charging out (THEY MUST HOLD THERE LINE AT THE A FRAME or white water) i,e holding there line on the way out.

Barn this is there intention

You would be mistaking if you thought the bloke coming out can EFFECTIVELY slow down and or manouvour PLUS /AS there sole intention is to get out through the break planning or not

The second self preservation rule is YOU ALWAYS WAVERIDE AROUND SOME ONE HEADING OUT or boot scoot down the line before he arrives.
because if you dont and decide to hit the lip right in front of someone coming out you will be the one getting a board nose right up under the rib cage (Theres no protection for you what so ever
.


99% of the time your mates chaging out he hits the A FRAME AND JUMPS and then you (WAVE RIDING ) slay it after him.

The other 1% are near misses or crashes and are the wave riders fault for not seeing and giving right of way to the person coming out.




hardpole
WA, 578 posts
2 Apr 2011 10:50PM
Thumbs Up

king of the point said...

barn said...

Zachery said...


Really easy-
Maritime rules apply until you are in the break.
Then going out has right of way, but not to the point of being discourteous (ie: if you are heading out, and you can let the guy enjoy his waveride and still get out just fine, don't make him give way to you just cos he has to give way according to the rules.)

I think this has been considered the Australian rules as Mark has stated, setting yourself up for the perfect DTL can be ten times harder than running out for a jump unless underpowered!


I agree with this 1st bit, well worded... All I'm saying/adding is the guy on the wave can't expect this privilege, and he can't initiate any DTL antics until the guy heading out has made his intentions obvious.. Otherwise all hell will break loose..

But this whole thing about once they are planing they give way ra ra ra is not on..


By the way I think it would be entirely arrogant of me to think my waveride was more important that John Smiths perfect ramp for his backie attempt that might be the highlight of his session/trip/summer..


Is it normally white guys who can't jump who reckon jumping is 2nd fiddle to waveriding?





Now i can use the quote button .............that was to easy.... computers are harder than that arnt they

Just wanted to make the point barn its not that you would be arrogant and ruin a blokes jump.

As PREVIOUSLY mentioned the SECOND self preservation rule also applys when someones charging out (THEY MUST HOLD THERE LINE AT THE A FRAME or white water) i,e holding there line on the way out.

Barn this is there intention

You would be mistaking if you thought the bloke coming out can EFFECTIVELY slow down and or manouvour PLUS /AS there sole intention is to get out through the break planning or not

The second self preservation rule is YOU ALWAYS WAVERIDE AROUND SOME ONE HEADING OUT or boot scoot down the line before he arrives.
because if you dont and decide to hit the lip right in front of someone coming out you will be the one getting a board nose right up under the rib cage (Theres no protection for you what so ever
.


99% of the time your mates chaging out he hits the A FRAME AND JUMPS and then you (WAVE RIDING ) slay it after him.

The other 1% are near misses or crashes and are the wave riders fault for not seeing and giving right of way to the person coming out.








That actually makes sense - are you all right King ?

lotofwind
NSW, 6451 posts
3 Apr 2011 1:57AM
Thumbs Up

^^^^^yep, makes a bit of scence, spelling and punctuation is half decent(not that I can spell and punct.) and we can understand what he is trying to say.
I guess he isnt stonned or drunk tonight.

king of the point
WA, 1836 posts
2 Apr 2011 10:57PM
Thumbs Up



Note
White car just drops in.
Truck locks up and swerves.
Lolly pop operator fails to have sign around the right way and is on the
wrong side of traffic
Truck operator doesnt see sign in distance
Kids scatter after laughing at lollie pop operator
Lollie pop operator is squashed
Truck wins

lotofwind
NSW, 6451 posts
3 Apr 2011 2:00AM
Thumbs Up

^^^^ârrrrh,,,,,his drugs just kicked in and he is back to normal.

racerX
462 posts
3 Apr 2011 10:27AM
Thumbs Up

barn said...

racerX said...


*snip
and could NOT find anything that suggested a turning vessel (i.e. on a wave) needs to give way one that is not. So is that really true?
*snip
Which to me translates into, use your common-sense, respect the local rules, no point being dead right...


Can you imagine the ocean commotion if a vessel changing course had right of way over somebody going in a straight line?!...

Also a sailing vessel heading directly down wind has to give way to boats sailing across the wind..


I still can't find anything in the COLREGs (i,e, the international regulations) that says if you turning you have to give way, doing a bit more googling I can see its a rule used in racing sailing boats.

Got bored looking up the 'sailing vessel heading directly down wind has to give way to boats sailing across the wind..' but could not find that in the COLREGs either. The windward gives way to leeward rule is not going to apply when going DTL conflicts with a jumper as your on opposing tacks. Still can't see any international authoritative rule on the matter, that requires the wave rider to give way.

For me its follow the local conventions and look were your going!

Mark _australia
WA, 22539 posts
3 Apr 2011 9:59PM
Thumbs Up

lotofwind said...

I remember asking right of way rules on this site 5 years ago and got quoted sailing/maritime rules.
When I said that it dosent really work in the waves, I was told that it dosent matter if there are waves breaking or not, you ALWAYS stick to the sailing rules.

Now that Im saying,stick to the sailng rules,,the same one or two are saying I dont know what Im on about,its different in the waves,even though 5 years ago the sailing rules were not to be broken......How things of changed,,eh..

Thats why I was saying I didnt want marks opinion,
because he was the one back then argueing that maritime rules MUST be followed no matter what,,followed by some comment about kiters always being in the way because they dont know the sailing rules etc..
Or maybe he just likes to troll and disagree with a kiteboarder wheather he agrees or not?????

Interesting.






Seeing as though what I said on this site in 2007 (quoted above) was exactly the same as what I said in this thread, maybe you'd like to find that post from "about 5 years ago" where I said something completely different???

razzmatazz
NSW, 184 posts
4 Apr 2011 1:52PM
Thumbs Up

I reckonthis is a pretty anal thread. Just have fun and use one's common sense. I'll get starboard and the like mixed up a lot and am not always aware of it if I am having a handful with just staying upright. I just look ahead and try to avoid hiting anyone

saltiest1
NSW, 2497 posts
4 Apr 2011 10:06PM
Thumbs Up

razzmatazz said...

I reckonthis is a pretty anal thread. Just have fun and use one's common sense. I'll get starboard and the like mixed up a lot and am not always aware of it if I am having a handful with just staying upright. I just look ahead and try to avoid hiting anyone




i know what you mean but what happens if you are about to collide and both of you go the wrong way? ouch.

curac
WA, 1145 posts
4 Apr 2011 9:02PM
Thumbs Up

i think everyone would do well to remember that all waves belong to me so i have right of way all the time. so back the fk off

decrepit
WA, 12209 posts
4 Apr 2011 9:12PM
Thumbs Up

Yep, I've had that happen, a double zig zag path to collision.
We both changed direction about 3 times, towards each other, fortunately by the time we hit had just about stopped, but he still had a seperation.
It was in my 2nd year windsurfing and my fault, I was on starboard and kept giving way.

So from then on I've learned that when your right hand is forward on the boom, you're on starboard and have right of way, and to hold my line, it's up to port to give way, otherwise you could have a head on.

saltiest1
NSW, 2497 posts
5 Apr 2011 10:02AM
Thumbs Up

curac said...

i think everyone would do well to remember that all waves belong to me so i have right of way all the time. so back the fk off




at least we can see you approaching from a long way off. the aura of your ego shines for miles!

Bender
WA, 2225 posts
5 Apr 2011 9:32AM
Thumbs Up

FFS guys the way you are all carrying on you should take up kiting. I thought we were the wise and respectful ones

barn
WA, 2960 posts
5 Apr 2011 10:48AM
Thumbs Up

Bender said...

FFS guys the way you are all carrying on you should take up kiting. I thought we were the wise and respectful ones


As a whole, windsurfers are very far from wise and respectful, and common sense is scattered at best. I don't want to rely on 90kg Dolph from Estonia's common sense when we are heading towards each other at 20 knots.. Or Robbo on his Ezzy either.

saltiest1
NSW, 2497 posts
5 Apr 2011 8:40PM
Thumbs Up

Bender said...

FFS guys the way you are all carrying on you should take up kiting. I thought we were the wise and respectful ones




well i got to admit the guys going flat out on flat water are fantastic, definately the wise and respectful. most of the guys on the waves are the same, but there appears to be a little more ego and less concern for safe sailing with regards to others by the minority. bummer really.

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
6 Apr 2011 2:22PM
Thumbs Up

The big problem with right of way 'rules' is that not everyone knows them fully.

It's all well and good when you're racing, or in a PWA event (not that I'd know) where everyone is briefed on the rules beforehand.

When you're on the ocean there are all manner of newbies, numpties, arrogant people and just plain ignorant water users. When you're coming up to one on a collision course do you hold your line because you think you've got right of way?

What if it's a kiter who thinks that "Port has right of way"? (yes I've seen it happen). What if it's someone from a surfing background who thinks that it's OK to gybe onto your wave if he's closer to the peak? (Seen that one happen as well).

All the rules in your head won't make a bit of difference here. The best solution is to make a sharp and definite change of direction, so it's clear to the other guy exactly where you want to head. This is universally understood, even by people who don't have a clue about the proper right of way rules.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"right of way" started by saltiest1