Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk

The quest to make fast weed fins

Reply
Created by Bender > 9 months ago, 26 Oct 2008
Bender
WA, 2223 posts
26 Oct 2008 7:39PM
Thumbs Up

As it was not windy today i played around in workshop. I have wanted to start reboxing fins as you cant buy decent quick weed fins.

I knocked this unit up. I have the stuff to make the mould.

The arm that holds the leading edge is on a hinge so i can change the angle as i wish. The ali track that hold the fin is the mast track out a my long gone course racing borad from years ago(Windrush XP). The fins(well all of mine do) wedge in nice and tight so minimal clamping is required.

can anyone see and improvements i could make before i pour in the goo to make the rubberised mould(yes Sam i have ripped off your design).




evets
WA, 685 posts
26 Oct 2008 7:54PM
Thumbs Up

Cannot see what else you could add Bender..... maybe a computer controlled positioner to maintain the correct angle
What are you going to do to the fin in the picture?

Also do you modify the foil once you have altered the angle? I have a series of different sized images for a particular foil and use that and a profile gauge (pin gauge) plus car body filler to try to achieve what I hear is a good profile. I measure the fin parallel to the bottom of the board and fill/ rub down to try to get the profile. The result is not pretty as I have not taken to painting yet but seems to work.

Bender
WA, 2223 posts
26 Oct 2008 8:00PM
Thumbs Up

Evets, the fin in the picture will be used to make the mould for reboxing fins.
It should give me a perfect size and angle for the fin base

elmo
WA, 8721 posts
26 Oct 2008 8:07PM
Thumbs Up

The only prob which I can see Bendyman is that your jig is limited solely to 45º, if you want to rebox at other angles or redo a pointer it won't be able to do it.

Also have you a guide for the trailing edge of the fin, you may need that to allign the fin else you make find the board wanting to go in circles

Bender
WA, 2223 posts
26 Oct 2008 8:15PM
Thumbs Up

Good point Elmo. I might look at adding a trailing edge guide as well.

I will also make a jig for pointers. This project is mainly to get a good tuttle mould.

keef
NSW, 2016 posts
26 Oct 2008 11:21PM
Thumbs Up

evets said...

plus car body filler to try to achieve what I hear is a good profile..

looks great bender
events is this one of your fins , if you have lost it or its been stolen, ill post it to you free hows the name( LEADING EDGE)



snides8
WA, 1730 posts
26 Oct 2008 9:43PM
Thumbs Up

evets said...

Cannot see what else you could add Bender..... maybe a computer controlled positioner to maintain the correct angle
What are you going to do to the fin in the picture?

Also do you modify the foil once you have altered the angle? I have a series of different sized images for a particular foil and use that and a profile gauge (pin gauge) plus car body filler to try to achieve what I hear is a good profile. I measure the fin parallel to the bottom of the board and fill/ rub down to try to get the profile. The result is not pretty as I have not taken to painting yet but seems to work.


evets, the only foil mods that the bent one does on the foil as far as i know,................. is when he runs it into the rocks at hardies
seriously tho i cant speak for bender but i can tell you i just wack mine in the box at 45deg and leave the foil as is,the puritans and experts would probably say different but the things work ok leaning over imo.as long as elmo's snot doesnt hang on the end then its all good
what you describe above sounds too much like hard work,but if your happy with the results,then thats good.

slowboat
WA, 553 posts
28 Oct 2008 9:58AM
Thumbs Up

I wouldnt bother modifying the foil. When you add rake, all you do is reduce the flow speed component in the lifting direction (perpendicular to the leading edge), and increase the spanwise flow component. Its similar to a plane flying in a sidewind. The spanwise component does not effect lift, but it does create some drag. The reasons you generally need more surface area with a weed fin are
1) you are reducing the effective (lifting) velocity due to the rake by a factor of cos(rake), so the area has to go up to compensate.
2) you are likely increasing the twist (geometric twist where flex becomes twist with rake) so the tip region becomes ineffective at generating lift.
3) The centre of effort moves back meaning it balances differently with the board/body

Old pointers can work great for weed fins. The trick is to find one thats quite stiff to start with, otherwise the geometric twist will kill the performance. They can also be a bit thicker.

mineral1
WA, 4564 posts
28 Oct 2008 10:26AM
Thumbs Up

slowboat said...


Old pointers can work great for weed fins. The trick is to find one thats quite stiff to start with, otherwise the geometric twist will kill the performance. They can also be a bit thicker.


So the freeride jobs that are thicker should do the job then?

Bender
WA, 2223 posts
28 Oct 2008 10:42AM
Thumbs Up

mineral1 said...

slowboat said...


Old pointers can work great for weed fins. The trick is to find one thats quite stiff to start with, otherwise the geometric twist will kill the performance. They can also be a bit thicker.


So the freeride jobs that are thicker should do the job then?



YEP!!

evets
WA, 685 posts
29 Oct 2008 10:02PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks for the info Slowboat.
The fin on which I have increased the foil thickness was quite thin and did not produce sufficient lift to get comfortably up wind. Result was very few speed runs as getting upwind took ages.
It is also all I have in that size (about 22cm) so until I get another I wish to try to make it as good as possible.
So far it has given me my pb of 32.5..... hope it will go faster yet!
As for twist, Decrepit demonstrated what you mean with the fin in question....... nothing I can do about it until I get another fin.

keef
NSW, 2016 posts
30 Oct 2008 8:58AM
Thumbs Up

Bender said...

. can anyone see and improvements i could make before i pour in the goo to make the rubberised mould
hows it going bender have you poored the goo yet and what sort of goo are you useing, if its a two part urathane you will have to vaccume the air out, or if its a one part latex you will have to do a slow build with a brush to avoid airbubbles


.





Bender
WA, 2223 posts
30 Oct 2008 4:50PM
Thumbs Up

keef said...

Bender said...

. can anyone see and improvements i could make before i pour in the goo to make the rubberised mould
hows it going bender have you poored the goo yet and what sort of goo are you useing, if its a two part urathane you will have to vaccume the air out, or if its a one part latex you will have to do a slow build with a brush to avoid airbubbles


Yep the mould has come up a treat. it was a worry as i mixed up the brew and poured it in and found out my maths were wrong as it was a 10mm low tide. i just pushed in a bit of round foam, (sausage like) this diplaced enough goo to bring the level up nicely. i have since shaved the foam off level. All is good.

Now i just need to pluck up the courage to take a jig saw to my new 48cm JP slalom fin and turn it into a weedy. I cant remember what the goo is called. It's like latex rubber stuff(white). Elmo got it for me. it cost $65.

i wil report back after my first attempt


keef
NSW, 2016 posts
30 Oct 2008 10:00PM
Thumbs Up

Bender said...

keef said...

Bender said...

. can anyone see and improvements i could make before i pour in the goo to make the rubberised mould
hows it going bender have you poored the goo yet and what sort of goo are you useing, if its a two part urathane you will have to vaccume the air out, or if its a one part latex you will have to do a slow build with a brush to avoid airbubbles


Yep the mould has come up a treat. it was a worry as i mixed up the brew and poured it in and found out my maths were wrong as it was a 10mm low tide. i just pushed in a bit of round foam, (sausage like) this diplaced enough goo to bring the level up nicely. i have since shaved the foam off level. All is good.

are there any air bubbles, if not can you ask elmo what the name of this goo is and let me know





pirrad
SA, 850 posts
30 Oct 2008 11:31PM
Thumbs Up

heres a pic of my jig bender,good luck with your project.i've used mine for reheading fins and the two in the pic i've made from scratch.i'm keen to find out what you used [goo] for your moulds,made mine[tiga , power]from polyester resin,there a bit rough but.also keen to find out what is recomended for the fin heads,i used the polyester risin,poked in some matting but concerned they are a bit brittle.

decrepit
WA, 12070 posts
30 Oct 2008 10:10PM
Thumbs Up

Pirrad, what do you use for release agent?
Have you had any trouble getting the fins out of the mold?

If I remember correct Elmo's first mold was something like yours, he ended up getting his last fin out with an axe!

Bender's using a flexible latex, in the hope that will solve this problem.
I'd like to make a split mold, to make even more certain.

I don't think the base material is all that critical most of the load is compression, polyester resin with cloth in it should be OK, as long as you don't tend to use your fins as hammers!

elmo
WA, 8721 posts
30 Oct 2008 10:22PM
Thumbs Up

The Goop which bender is using is the Silicone moulding agent which Sam put us onto

The product is called “Elastosil M4503” and I buy it by 1 Kg for 50 bucks (you make 2 moulds medium size with it)

You can find it at *Fibreglass & Resin Sales* they are in Welshpool

111 Kew St, phone 9470 2571 /
web: www.fibreglass-resin-sales.com.au

The release agent which they recommend is in a little pump pack which actually is supposed to condition the silicone as well as act as a release agent, bender recons it's pretty good.

How I mould my fin bases is in some eyes a bit of overkill.

I always keep as much of the fin as possible so that the fin runs along the bottom of the base, this may loose a little length but I think it makes it stronger.
Generally use 3-4 layers of clothe (don't know whether it's 4 or 6 oz).
I use West Systems epoxy with 206 hardener (the slower one)
I mix in 3 heaped teaspoons of glass fibre pulp, into about 50ml of resin.

I've been using fibreglass split moulds which I made after the "axe removal incedent" but they are starting to look a bit sad, seeing the results of Sam's work I will be starting to make silicone moulds this weekend.

pirrad
SA, 850 posts
30 Oct 2008 11:58PM
Thumbs Up

mr. google[fibre glass release agent]told me pva,the only thing i knew of as pva is aqadhere glue,mr. wikipedia then told me of numerous uses for pva[poly vinyl alcohol].i just happened to have a couple of litres of cem stick in the shed and it goes through the spray gun nicely,i spray it on my plastic when i'm vac bagging.

elmo
WA, 8721 posts
30 Oct 2008 10:59PM
Thumbs Up

Sorry for got to put down

For the F'glass moulds I use 2 coats of release wax then the PVA release agent



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk


"The quest to make fast weed fins" started by Bender