Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk

timber/carbon fins

Reply
Created by decrepit > 9 months ago, 27 Aug 2012
keef
NSW, 2016 posts
2 Sep 2012 10:50AM
Thumbs Up

Ian K said...

decrepit said...

For different rakes I just measure across the foil at the angle I want. The curves stay the same.


Good move getting a profile gauge Keef, "a bit sick " is not good enough. The foil need to be fully sick.



ian sick means it looks like sh-t fully sick means it looks sh-t hot, im doing another fin at the moment and im trying to get the foil the same as my n/p evo 111 5.5,
a bit fuller at the base and tapering down supa thin at the tip and the trailing edge ( with decreps concaves ) at this stage its looking fully sick
you know the rewarding part about making something you dont know anything about is if it works you get a big surprise , take my last fin i'm soooooooooooo happy and the fin reminds me of a Swiss army knife, sooooooooo versatile, if you need a spade youve got one , if theres no wind you can use it as a bomarang and keep you occupied till the wind comes up, if you need a camp fire you could chop up some fire wood(thats the next project to make a all purpose handle for the sukka)

"edit" ian just remembered , ive got the frofile gauge but the fin i need to take the profile from is in bulli




decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
2 Sep 2012 6:42PM
Thumbs Up

Ian K said...


So, just confirming, you do measure the foil along along the flow line?


Yep I do


I'm asking because it's been previously claimed here that the "water" sees the foil at right angles to the leading edge. Maybe that's just mathematical jiggery pokery that gives the same answer.


Yes I've seen that and it makes no sense at all to me. I don't have the maths though to give any definite reason.
But I've also see it written elsewhere, that raking a foil backwards decreases it thickness to chord ratio.
I just do what "feels right" to me.


So all your percentages thicknesses are quoted along the flow line?


yep.


Which raises another point. Why do we rarely see fins with any significant length of span where the leading edge is parallel to the training edge? A section of constant chord I suppose you could also describe it as.



2 reasons why I don't do it, a parallel fin puts all the load and flex at the base, not a good construction strategy. And induced drag becomes a big problem with parallel fins


I'm thinking that tapering a foil throughout the full length is maybe a hangup from aeronautical applications where wing strength vs weight needs to be more finely tuned.



Don't forget those pics of fin flex, there are large loads on a fin.
And this thread is about timber fins, although the carbon skin has huge tensile strength, the timber can still compress at the base where all the load is.








decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
2 Sep 2012 6:54PM
Thumbs Up

Finished cleaning up the bead and foiling the 25 timber, same method as before, took a couple more pics to make the process a bit clearer.




so I've marked the sheet on the right with a fin profile at 30deg, then put flow lines across it at the same widths as my foil print out, (A to G).






Here the fin is on top of the marked profile, I can then press the gauge on to the fin across the A to G lines and compare to the printout.
Here I'm checking C.

Lots of green arrows coming up so progress may be slow.
Hope the timber doesn't absorb too much moisture and turn into a banana, before I get it sealed.

yoyo
WA, 1646 posts
3 Sep 2012 1:58PM
Thumbs Up

Looking at the Seabreeze graph for Mandurah....looks great



I hope the X2 did the job on the 43 :-))

redsurfbus
304 posts
3 Sep 2012 6:33PM
Thumbs Up

Amazing thread, If you don't mind I will link it n to an article on my blog when I finally throw off this writers block! (hoping autumnal winds up here in gb will help that). Thanks for all the detail and pics

Te Hau
479 posts
3 Sep 2012 6:56PM
Thumbs Up

As barrel nuts are very hard to obtain, I'll see how well this stuff taps.

I use Acetal rod for barrell nuts.
Get it from the local plastics supply.
It seems to be similar to the stuff they use in Nylock nuts. Never going to lose a bolt.
I use 1/2" (12.7mm) rod.
I drill the fin head holes to size leaving a 4mm section in the centre drilled at at 12.2 and press the rod in then drill and thread for the bolts after its fitted.
The bolts are always tight in the thread.
Great stuff, never stripped any in dozens of fins and it's cheap.

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
3 Sep 2012 7:51PM
Thumbs Up

redsurfbus said...

Amazing thread, If you don't mind I will link it n to an article on my blog when I finally throw off this writers block! (hoping autumnal winds up here in gb will help that). Thanks for all the detail and pics


I don't mind at all, in fact I was thinking of your site the other day.
These seabreeze threads vanish after a while, so I don't mind if the relevant bits are extracted and posted on your site. If you don't have a memory problem and they would have a longer life span.
It just needs to be clear that I'm no expert in hydro dynamics or speed sailing. I just enjoying making stuff for myself

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
3 Sep 2012 7:52PM
Thumbs Up

Te Hau said...

As barrel nuts are very hard to obtain, I'll see how well this stuff taps.

I use Acetal rod for barrell nuts.
Get it from the local plastics supply.

>>


Thanks, I'll see how easy it is to get it here and give it a try.

Waiting4wind
NSW, 1871 posts
4 Sep 2012 7:42PM
Thumbs Up

Very informative and great thread. I was thinking about making a weed fin. Now that I know what's involved I'll just go out and buy one!

keef
NSW, 2016 posts
4 Sep 2012 9:40PM
Thumbs Up

Waiting4wind said...

Very informative and great thread. I was thinking about making a weed fin. Now that I know what's involved I'll just go out and buy one!

Des you dont have to make a weed fin all you need to do is rebox an old slalom, sometimes the older the better because to old fins were wider at the base and make perfect weed fins reboxed , you mite need to take 5ml off the leading edge box at 45 to 50 and presto ,
after saying that you've got 3 days to make it and ill cya at illawarra on saturday, the words out, a couple mexicarno's and a gringo is makeing the trip from south of the border

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
4 Sep 2012 8:31PM
Thumbs Up

Agree with Keef, the easiest way is to rebox an old fin. The thicker and stiffer the better, if you can't find an old stiff one, a layer or 2 of carbon will help enormously.

Waiting4wind
NSW, 1871 posts
4 Sep 2012 11:38PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks guys. I do have a weekend project ready for some on the water testing... Just waiting for my knee to heal before I can give it a test run.

I found an old, fat and ugly Finworks A box weedy. I put one of those Multi fit bases on and if it works I'll get a proper base on it.

Ian K
WA, 4048 posts
4 Sep 2012 9:41PM
Thumbs Up

decrepit said...

Agree with Keef


I'll go half way between. i've reboxed the odd fin, stiffened up a few with carbon. Buying a fin for $200 is an attractive alternative. But give it a go, you'd get more time-efficient and wouldn't stick so many fingers together with a few under the belt I suppose.

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
4 Sep 2012 10:06PM
Thumbs Up

Depends how much spare time and spare cash you have, being retired I have much more time than money.
spending several hours and a few dollars makes sense from where I sit.

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
6 Sep 2012 7:58PM
Thumbs Up

Sorry but here's a brief diversion.

HOW TO MAKE A HYGROMETER!

Take a piece of dry 6mm thick timber (pine or cedar) laminate one side with a few layers of carbon.
Fix one end to a pedestal so the other end is free to move, attach a simple lever system to the free end, (10:1 should do), short end to timber, behind the long end place a scale, one end humid the other dry.

It'll definitely work, that's the 2nd time I've got fins to a one sided laminate, then had a few stormy days when I abandoned the project for a windsurf.
Both times the nice straight fins have developed a bend, easily fixed though leave them in front of a warm sunny window for several hours. (You just have to wait for some sun!)
Both fins were back to being straight and ready for the next stage after lunch today.

Yoyo is happy with the 9% foil the 25cm has turned into, but I really wanted the 20cm to be 8%, (I think it will have less tendency to spin out at speed downwind, and want to test the theory).

So I've cheated, put another couple of layers of carbon on the trailing edge and bogged it up so it came back to 8%, then when shaping the other side, moved the trailing edge over a bit.




this shows the extra carbon and bog on the trailing edge.




This shows the foil ready for carbon, you can see where I've sanded thru the old trailing edge into the extra layer.

Laminated the carbon, exactly the same as before, they're both under the anvil now.
More bogging tomorrow.

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
7 Sep 2012 8:17PM
Thumbs Up

Got the first layer of bog on today.




Used a thick mix of q-cell and epoxy, spread it on the fins with the squeegee then smoothed out with a thin piece of plastic cut from an ice cream container.
That's the yellow rectangle on the box. Holding both ends of the plastic tight against the fin edges, using a smooth dragging action from head to tip, can produce a finish that doesn't need huge amounts of sanding.




Next step is cooking in black plastic to fully cure the epoxy, then more sanding and comparing with the printouts.

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
10 Sep 2012 7:44PM
Thumbs Up

Sanded the bog down to the foil printout, then squeegeed on another light layer to fill any low spots.
Just a light sand and they should be ready for boxing.


keef
NSW, 2016 posts
10 Sep 2012 10:25PM
Thumbs Up

decrepit said...

Sanded the bog down to the foil printout, then squeegeed on another light layer to fill any low spots.
Just a light sand and they should be ready for boxing.





its going well decrep wheres the bog

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
10 Sep 2012 8:43PM
Thumbs Up

Well a lot of the previous layer has been sanded of.
The new bog layer doesn't show up well because it's fairly thin, especially over the carbon area.
I made the mistake of allowing for the thickness of 3 carbon layers, then putting 5 on, so I've actually sanded into the carbon a bit here.

keef
NSW, 2016 posts
10 Sep 2012 11:25PM
Thumbs Up

decrepit said...

Well a lot of the previous layer has been sanded of.
The new bog layer doesn't show up well because it's fairly thin, especially over the carbon area.
I made the mistake of allowing for the thickness of 3 carbon layers, then putting 5 on, so I've actually sanded into the carbon a bit here.


grteat job carbon is stiffer than bog

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
14 Sep 2012 7:32PM
Thumbs Up

Finally got round to molding the bases. (good job yoyo isn't in a hurry)




Because the fin is so small, there's a big area between the trailing edge and the rear of the base. Instead of filling this entirely with resin I'm using a block of high density foam to save a bit more weight. To tie it all together and take the load from the rear bolt, I'm using 3 layers of carbon and a layer of glass on the sides of the base.

First thing is to cover the face of the mold halves in release agent, not just the box part, the whole face, in case resin penetrates the join and glues the 2 halves together.
This is what the vaseline is for.

This time I've remembered to mask out the fin, note that the newspaper is only to keep resiny fingers off the fin, anything more will stick the paper to the fin. The masking tape will stop any excess from the pour off the fin.

Next I wet out the carbon/glass 1 piece at a time and smooth it out in the mold.

Then the mold is bolted together.
Mix up some resin and add some micro fibres, not too much I want a runny mix.

The first time I did this I poured the resin mix in first, then the fin, but this forced the carbon up out of the mold, which blocked the view of the mold edges, making it hard to check fin alignment.

This time I've poured a small amount of resin in first, enough to make sure the timber at the bottom of the fin is covered by resin. The block of foam and fin then go in and are aligned, after that resin is poured in until mold is full, check every 1/4hr or so and top up as necessary.



decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
16 Sep 2012 8:53PM
Thumbs Up

Today was time for the bolt holes and threads.




From the left, fin out of mold, drill to fit board fin holes, set square vaseline, fin bolt and clearance drill, pencil, dowelling jig with small drill adapter, taps with wrench.

There are several methods of getting a thread in the fin, barrel bolts are probably the most common, but due to a severe shortage of barrel bolts, I'm trying two other methods.
Where there is a solid substrate I'm tapping a hole in the existing material. Where there's only high density foam I'm having a go at molding the thread in.

Whichever method you use, the hole positions need to be accurately marked for the holes in your board.
(I don't trust tuttle standards, there seems to be a lot of variation between manufacturers ).

Here I use a clearance drill for the holes in my board to mark the fin. Don't use an electric drill, just a bit of hand pressure twirling the bit.




once I have a clear mark on the fin base, I use the set square to draw a line across the bottom and down the side of the fin.
The dowelling jig can then be aligned on the pencil line, set the jig to half the thickness of the base.





for the tapping hole I use the small drill adapter in the jig, wrap the drill with some masking tape at a depth that doesn't go all the way thru the fin. As these threads are going to be weak, I want them fairly deep so I can use longer bolts and get a lot of thread engagement. I remove the small drill adapter and use the jig to hold the tap square.

Fortunately the standard hole in my jig is a nice clearance hole for the fin bolt, use a neat fitting drill in the jig and drill the rear hole.

Thoroughly coat a fin bolt in release agent, (vaseline here), work a microfibre mix, (not too thick) into the rear hole. slowly push the bolt into the hole.





Tomorrow will be the test, how well the release agent worked!!!!

I'm not worried, if I can't get the bolts to screw out, I'll heat the bolt with a soldering iron, that softens the resin, trouble is it'll probably ruin the threads as well.
If that happens I'll have to make barrel bolts out of a large stainless steel bolt shaft, unless I can source acetal rod.

An easier way if you're doing lots of fins, is a dedicated drilling jig, fits neatly over the base and has tubes where the 4 holes go. If you have barrel bolts it's just drill 4 holes, a nice press fit for the barrel bolts and you're away.

A bit more tidying up a coat of sanding filler paint and fine wet and dry will finish then off.

Windxtasy
WA, 4014 posts
16 Sep 2012 10:00PM
Thumbs Up

Now I know why fins are so expensive!

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
16 Sep 2012 11:20PM
Thumbs Up

Windxtasy said...

Now I know why fins are so expensive!


I sure production fins are made very very much faster, my methods minimise material costs but are heavy in labour, suits my time rich retirement.
And so far all my fins have been 1 offs, no two are the same, so production methods are more problematic any way.

samOZ
WA, 86 posts
17 Sep 2012 9:59AM
Thumbs Up

JJJJJ Mike, crazy work!! My technic is faster but the fins cost me more and are heavier (also they not carbon!)!! Very master crafty the way you do them, also very well explain, great post ;)))

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
17 Sep 2012 7:21PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks Sam,

Well the vaseline did it's job, bolts undid as if they'd been done up fairly tight.
Sanded the front and back of bases for a good fit in the boxes and tidied up a few holes in them today. Tomorrow it's out with the spray paint.

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
19 Sep 2012 7:04PM
Thumbs Up

OK both finished!!!!

Here's the first coat of paint.




One of my reasons for painting is to show up any faults. A clear finish over carbon, makes it very hard to see what's going on, a coat of paint instantly shows up any pit holes or rough spots.
I sand this back with 200 to 300 wet and dry.




I quite like this paint, it's high build, so fills imperfections well, it also wet and dries to a slippery feeling surface

After another coat of paint and a 600 wet and dry, my fin is finished, (I let Yoyo wet and dry his own fin)






Threw them in a bucket of water and they float!! Not so worried about weak threads now, much easier to find fins on the surface than on a muddy bottom.

pepe47
WA, 1380 posts
19 Sep 2012 9:57PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote

, much easier to find fins on the surface than on a muddy bottom.



Hmmm, yep

decrepit
WA, 12053 posts
19 Sep 2012 10:17PM
Thumbs Up

Sorry pepe couldn't resist it.

stroppo
WA, 728 posts
19 Sep 2012 10:35PM
Thumbs Up

Mike that looks super great posting and a great job



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk


"timber/carbon fins" started by decrepit