Forums > Windsurfing Wave sailing

Who has right of way in this vid?

Reply
Created by Gonewindsurfing247 > 9 months ago, 23 Aug 2011
Gonewindsurfing247
WA, 966 posts
23 Aug 2011 1:14PM
Thumbs Up

I think it is obvious but I could be wrong and it could be entertaining to hear the opinion of others. Who has right of way at 1.05 minutes?

#!

ozpricey
WA, 333 posts
23 Aug 2011 1:51PM
Thumbs Up

Guy on wave stuffed up going too hard. Should have given guy groveling out a bit of room... he's clearly struggling with the wind; clewfirst, pretty wobbly.

Here in WA this would definitely result in some form of reactionary legislation with lollypop ladies taking to the water. Maybe a sneaky finger up the date "stop and search" once you hit the shore.

barn
WA, 2960 posts
23 Aug 2011 1:52PM
Thumbs Up

People get on a wave, Immediately think they are Polakow, and loose their bloody marbles..

This is why I don't trust strangers to use common sense when waves are involved..

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
23 Aug 2011 2:28PM
Thumbs Up

On a track this would be known as a "Racing incident" imho

Agree that the guy on the wave has a better chance of avoiding it than the guy going clew first though.

patsken
WA, 705 posts
23 Aug 2011 2:55PM
Thumbs Up

What incident ?????

Think I might buy a JEEP though ............

terminal
1421 posts
23 Aug 2011 5:55PM
Thumbs Up

The guy on the wave has to avoid him.

From the angle of the other guy's sail, he was slogging in almost zero wind on the way in, but maybe he had dropped off the previous wave and was just getting started.

northsail
NSW, 97 posts
23 Aug 2011 8:45PM
Thumbs Up

Yep, agree with Patskin. Lets all buy a Jeep with good quality headlights!

Madge
NSW, 471 posts
23 Aug 2011 10:42PM
Thumbs Up

In theory the sailor sailing out has right of way for three reasons.

First he's on starboard tack, lame but still a sailing legality.

secondly he's not planing so has less steerage than the planing sailor therefore cannot avoid an incident.

Thirdly he's on his way out, general rule again, the sailor heading out to sea has right of way.

I do agree about the jeep thing........That and getting more women involved in handing out free stuff at beaches...

busterwa
3777 posts
23 Aug 2011 8:49PM
Thumbs Up

Guy on the way out has right of way.. But looking at all the comments Who ever callls chicken !!!

barn
WA, 2960 posts
23 Aug 2011 8:53PM
Thumbs Up

mattstocks said...

In theory the sailor sailing out has right of way for three reasons.

First he's on starboard tack, lame but still a sailing legality.

secondly he's not planing so has less steerage than the planing sailor therefore cannot avoid an incident.

Thirdly he's on his way out, general rule again, the sailor heading out to sea has right of way.

I do agree about the jeep thing........That and getting more women involved in handing out free stuff at beaches...


waaaaat?

First, they are both on starboard tack, the guy dogging is also sailing into the beach..

Second, starboard tack is irrelevant in surf.. On the wave, he gives way..

Thirdly, if he was sailing out, he would be on port..

Madge
NSW, 471 posts
24 Aug 2011 6:09PM
Thumbs Up

Sorry if I got it a bit wrong but in the still picture it looks like one is heading out, I haven't studied it in minute detail. Does look like clew first too.

Anyway who really cares as long as they are both ok, nothing got too damaged, sometimes a collision is just something that happens.....

We cant all be right all of the time.....

ozpricey
WA, 333 posts
24 Aug 2011 5:05PM
Thumbs Up

Does sailing switch stance clew first on port count as starboard? lol

BTW We need to take hints from Peru windsurfing organisers...

barn
WA, 2960 posts
24 Aug 2011 6:10PM
Thumbs Up

mattstocks said...


We cant all be right all of the time.....


haha, yeah noworries, but I'd get that sorted before you hit the water on your new Angulo.. Of course Angulo's do come with inbuilt Divine Intervention..

Sailor on the wave gives way to sailors heading out or dogging in front of the wave.*

*unless you sail at Bizzaro Beach in WA, where everybody's knees are too old to jump, so they have decided the guy on the wave has right of way over planing sailors heading out..







Madge
NSW, 471 posts
24 Aug 2011 8:30PM
Thumbs Up

Hopefully the new Angulo is like a red bull, it might give me wings...???

There again it might not and I might get as trashed as those two blokes in the video.

I need divine intervension with my sailing skills. I just hope it works.

bobdaboarder
NSW, 184 posts
24 Aug 2011 8:38PM
Thumbs Up

Guy going out has rigt of way.

swoosh
QLD, 1926 posts
24 Aug 2011 9:22PM
Thumbs Up

I think terminal is the only one who has actually watched the vid? The only way that guy could be sailing out is if he was going clew first, and from the angle of the sail it would have had to be mega onshore.

Doesn't look even remotely onshore to me.

Anyway, commonsense should prevail, the guy on the wave should have stayed clear of the guy slogging as the guy slogging had no way of avoiding the collision.

Mark _australia
WA, 22284 posts
24 Aug 2011 9:46PM
Thumbs Up

barn said...

mattstocks said...


We cant all be right all of the time.....


*unless you sail at Bizzaro Beach in WA, where everybody's knees are too old to jump, so they have decided the guy on the wave has right of way over planing sailors heading out..








and other places, but we don't need to go there again :-)

TerryNorth
WA, 55 posts
29 Aug 2011 8:16AM
Thumbs Up

They are both coming in so the guy on the wave needed to avoid that. The other guy was dogging, fell backwards over the front of his board when he knew he was about to be smashed.

The problem I have here is everyone saying the guy on his way out has the right of way ordinarily. WTF..... Ok sure we all go in waves for two reason (wave riding and maybe jumps) and i think that gay rule which i have heard before depends on the location too.

If u are sailing at a good wave ridin spot (Gnaraloo, spot x, margies etc) and you thing that blasting out through the line up is going to give u right of way to get a jump over the guy coming in on a wave and blasting down the line, you kinda gotta be prepared to cop a mouthful of abuse and the treat of your head being smacked in from the guy on the wave that u just fcked up his wave. It's the guy going out that should be doing everything to make sure he is not anywhere near the waveriding section on the way out if there is someone on the wave.

I think the only exception to this is if someone has caught a wave before u and fell off etc...just where u want to hit the lip then as long as they showed some attempt to not completely stuff your wave, sure, obviously dont run them over but basic rule is person on the wave should be given every opportunity to ride that without interference. It's just a respect thing I think yeah?

Gorgo
VIC, 4960 posts
29 Aug 2011 1:46PM
Thumbs Up

The hittee has right of way over the hitter ... once. Maybe twice. [}:)]

The more manouverable rider has to avoid the less manouverable rider.

If the less manouverable rider is making a habit of getting in the way and screwing things up for everybody then reasonable consideration goes out the window.

FilthyAmatuer
WA, 877 posts
29 Aug 2011 12:12PM
Thumbs Up

TerryNorth said...

They are both coming in so the guy on the wave needed to avoid that. The other guy was dogging, fell backwards over the front of his board when he knew he was about to be smashed.

The problem I have here is everyone saying the guy on his way out has the right of way ordinarily. WTF..... Ok sure we all go in waves for two reason (wave riding and maybe jumps) and i think that gay rule which i have heard before depends on the location too.

If u are sailing at a good wave ridin spot (Gnaraloo, spot x, margies etc) and you thing that blasting out through the line up is going to give u right of way to get a jump over the guy coming in on a wave and blasting down the line, you kinda gotta be prepared to cop a mouthful of abuse and the treat of your head being smacked in from the guy on the wave that u just fcked up his wave. It's the guy going out that should be doing everything to make sure he is not anywhere near the waveriding section on the way out if there is someone on the wave.

I think the only exception to this is if someone has caught a wave before u and fell off etc...just where u want to hit the lip then as long as they showed some attempt to not completely stuff your wave, sure, obviously dont run them over but basic rule is person on the wave should be given every opportunity to ride that without interference. It's just a respect thing I think yeah?


I think Terry North has a good point. If you are riding you should be able to ride the wave, however you should still be mindful of those heading out, who might not be trying to jump, just trying to get out and avoid being smashed (places like scarbs, or any where with large waves and not so good wind).

The other problem with the person on the way out having right of way (if this is the rule) is that the rider on the wave is not looking at the beach, he is looking at the next section or the lip he is about to (try and) hit.

Maybe we need a friendly word someone on the way out can yell out if they need to be avoided?

Situation maybe - yes I might be planing, but I cant go behind you because there is 3/4 mast of white water there and I am going to get trashed. Call out "Coming through" or whatever, and the rider can make a bit wider turn or whatever, sailer on the way out makes it through, and everyone is ok. (Though it goes without saying the sailor on the way out does not charge the breaking section and go for a massive backie).

Edit: Obviously if you arent planing and not trying to stuff up someones wave then you should have right of way - unless you are dropping in.

aus301
QLD, 2039 posts
29 Aug 2011 2:42PM
Thumbs Up

according to a windsurfwa site the sailor heading out has right of way.

I have heard this same rule many times and is the one I have always stuck by. The guy on the wave has far greater speed and manouverability in many cases than the guy heading out, no matter what the location.

Not relevant to the vid seeing as both guys were heading in, so the guy in front had right of way. Seeing as we don't have rear vision it's impossible to have right of way from behind.

But when it all comes down to it, no matter what, keep everyone safe. Right of way is of little value from a hospital bed...or worse.

WA waverider
WA, 79 posts
29 Aug 2011 1:34PM
Thumbs Up

I hope I,m not grovelling out at gnaraloo in 12 knots and then have terry mow me down cause he has right of way not!!!If you are plannig on a wave face powered up u should keep clear of the sailor sub planning .

Mark _australia
WA, 22284 posts
29 Aug 2011 2:09PM
Thumbs Up

Glad Terry and Filthy weighed in.

Ad nauseum ....... going out has ROW as he may have to bear away to get planing and get out past the big nasty section.

BUT if you are planing out you do not enforce your ROW if it will fk up somebody's wave ride, just so you can get a nice jump off the section.


Both are just politeness - if you are riding a wave and some dude is grovelling out, let him get out so he doesn't get smashed. ie: he has no choices cos he is grovelling and just trying to get out. And he has ROW anyway.

But if it is a riding oriented spot and you are planing out easily and can go over the whitewater or the vertical section , or down to where it is nowhere near breaking (ie: you have CHOICES) you dont line up the vertical section for a big jump if a guy on the wave is going to hit that section.
Politeness.
If he is about to make the drop and does not go down the line he may get munched so soemtimes the guy on the way does not have all the manouevrability

and that is why u ask about any local rules cos spots vary in their riding or jumping focus. Not just say "what size" in some half legible euro accent and then head out expecting to have ROW on both tacks [}:)]

TerryNorth
WA, 55 posts
29 Aug 2011 2:59PM
Thumbs Up

WA waverider said...

I hope I,m not grovelling out at gnaraloo in 12 knots and then have terry mow me down cause he has right of way not!!!If you are plannig on a wave face powered up u should keep clear of the sailor sub planning .


Trust me i dont mow anyone down and to be honest it doesnt worry me one bit if someone stuff's the wave im on. I dont get too phased about all that and i'd much prefer to avoid a collision. I do enough damage to myself without anyone elses gear in the mix. I know people who do get annoyed though and i agree that it is just courteous to do as much as you can to make sure you are not in their way if it is a predominantly wave sailing location and they are on the wave.

ozpricey
WA, 333 posts
31 Aug 2011 6:35PM
Thumbs Up

jsnfok
WA, 899 posts
31 Aug 2011 7:26PM
Thumbs Up

ozpricey said...




ha lovin it

siny
NSW, 286 posts
31 Aug 2011 9:36PM
Thumbs Up

if that guy was white i would say it was mj

busterwa
3777 posts
1 Sep 2011 10:16AM
Thumbs Up

not sure if this is right?

j.j.
WA, 86 posts
8 Sep 2011 6:12PM
Thumbs Up

I can't believe some of what I have just read..... scary **** to be in water with some of you

barn
WA, 2960 posts
8 Sep 2011 8:27PM
Thumbs Up

busterwa said...

not sure if this is right?



Starboard rule doesn't matter in surf.. How do people not know this?

One guy isn't moving FFS, the other guy is being a flog 'wannabe polakow', who stacks it when he should have completely pulled out... He was on the wave so he gives way, no question.. He deserves to be curb stomped for that effort..

There is no discussion in this particular case, but it proves that once people get on a wave and have the smallest inkling that they have right of way, they turn into a complete muppets and start running people over... For this reason there can be no grey areas where the guy heading out is 'expected' to give way to the wave rider (unless everybody knows everybody and trust each other)...

stehsegler
WA, 3459 posts
9 Sep 2011 11:01AM
Thumbs Up

yeah... this is quite simple... you run over someone that's stationary you are wrong... period.

Reality is if you run someone over in any case and it goes to court because the other person is seriously injured be prepared to have a very good argument why you ran them over. I am guessing the old "it was my wave but he didn't get off so I ran him over wouldn't wash with any judge".

Apart from that... if you are running someone over un-purpose your are a dick head. There just is no justification.

In regards to the video... looks like the guys on the wave didn't know what he was doing.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing Wave sailing


"Who has right of way in this vid?" started by Gonewindsurfing247