Forums > Windsurfing General

Do we really need dedicated foil and fin racing sails ? Or is it time for a revolution

Reply
Created by Kasper79 3 months ago, 3 Jun 2024
Kasper79
102 posts
3 Jun 2024 2:42AM
Thumbs Up

I am tired of moving around with nine rigs for Racing and I haven't counted my iq gear. I think it is time for an agreement between the sailmakers to only have one racing sail line and that should be work for fin and foil. The new foils are so stable that a little backhand pressure don't send you directly in the drink. In the video I elaborate on my points. But I will like to hear what you think? Is it time for a small revolution, in order to make racing a bit more simple and cheaper.

?si=pd_0qf1Op4Mhnh6r

Gestalt
QLD, 14393 posts
3 Jun 2024 7:16AM
Thumbs Up

Try Patrik sails

berowne
NSW, 1301 posts
3 Jun 2024 5:54PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Gestalt said..
Try Patrik sails



Specifically the Patrik SF slalom Foil from last year or the medium aspect ratio from this year?!?

I have the cross over sails in 5.0 and 6.2 (for sale!) and I found that on the fin the sail felt 100% like a fin sail. Good power and flex in the chop. But on the foil the draft moved too much and when pushing for 30 knots on foil this was a marginal deterrent. So I went to the sail maker and we swapped out the battens around the boom for stiffer ones. On the water this made a huge difference. So maybe we just need a few differently battens to tweak the sail?!

Or stick to foils!









PhilUK
965 posts
3 Jun 2024 4:37PM
Thumbs Up

Brand X drops their dedicated fin and foil sail ranges in favour of 1 line so a few PWA sailors can carry less kit around.
They market their new sail range with the strapline of 'Its not perfect but isnt bad. Its perfectly adequate'.

Gestalt
QLD, 14393 posts
3 Jun 2024 7:08PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
berowne said..

Gestalt said..
Try Patrik sails




Specifically the Patrik SF slalom Foil from last year or the medium aspect ratio from this year?!?

I have the cross over sails in 5.0 and 6.2 (for sale!) and I found that on the fin the sail felt 100% like a fin sail. Good power and flex in the chop. But on the foil the draft moved too much and when pushing for 30 knots on foil this was a marginal deterrent. So I went to the sail maker and we swapped out the battens around the boom for stiffer ones. On the water this made a huge difference. So maybe we just need a few differently battens to tweak the sail?!

Or stick to foils!










Wasn't sure by your post. Are you on the new medium?

BSN101
WA, 2286 posts
4 Jun 2024 6:01AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Gestalt said..

berowne said..


Gestalt said..
Try Patrik sails





Specifically the Patrik SF slalom Foil from last year or the medium aspect ratio from this year?!?

I have the cross over sails in 5.0 and 6.2 (for sale!) and I found that on the fin the sail felt 100% like a fin sail. Good power and flex in the chop. But on the foil the draft moved too much and when pushing for 30 knots on foil this was a marginal deterrent. So I went to the sail maker and we swapped out the battens around the boom for stiffer ones. On the water this made a huge difference. So maybe we just need a few differently battens to tweak the sail?!

Or stick to foils!










Wasn't sure by your post. Are you on the new medium?


Race Low Aspect, Medium A, High A are the new and easy to identify sails in the Patrik range. Check out Ben Proffit interviews with Patrik at Defi for a run down of them.

mr love
VIC, 2352 posts
4 Jun 2024 8:05AM
Thumbs Up

The problem is that at PWA level you are looking for whatever tiny improvement in speed and control you can get. Are you going to compromise with a sail that not quite as good for each dicipline as it could be? I think the pros will say no. For us mortals, absolutely one sail could do both.

kato
VIC, 3400 posts
4 Jun 2024 8:07AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
BSN101 said.Race Low Aspect, Medium A, High A are the new and easy to identify sails in the Patrik range. Check out Ben Proffit interviews with Patrik at Defi for a run down of them.

Excellent interview with Patrik

Maddlad
WA, 864 posts
4 Jun 2024 11:08AM
Thumbs Up

I can feel a massive difference between foil sails and slalom sails on my foils. I wont use anything else except my foil sails on foils, unless its blowing 30 knots and i have to race, then i will grab whatever i have thats small enough to get me around the course.

DI7
10 posts
7 Jun 2024 1:36AM
Thumbs Up

Why should I use foil sails on the fin (slalom board)?

Hybrid sails have messed up the party for quite some years. The requirements are just very, very different.

PhilUK
965 posts
7 Jun 2024 2:08AM
Thumbs Up

I think its quite funny when sponsored sailors complain about having to carry around 9 sails.
Fin and foil are quite different sports. If you want peak performance you need the kit. I dont need peak performance, Ezzy Lions on foil work ok for me, I just rig them totally differently.

duzzi
1055 posts
7 Jun 2024 3:25AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Kasper79 said..
I am tired of moving around with nine rigs for Racing and I haven't counted my iq gear. I think it is time for an agreement between the sailmakers to only have one racing sail line and that should be work for fin and foil. The new foils are so stable that a little backhand pressure don't send you directly in the drink. In the video I elaborate on my points. But I will like to hear what you think? Is it time for a small revolution, in order to make racing a bit more simple and cheaper.
?si=pd_0qf1Op4Mhnh6r



It all depends at what you are doing. PWA competition? Speed events? Every second counts: you need foil and fin specific sails. Anywhere else? You don't. All people I see foil freeriding use their wave sails ...

And I do not really get the point of the video. You use Point-7. They actually have a hybrid foil/fin sail line, but their competition sails have no such hybrids. Are you saying that the team that came less than inches away from winning the PWA last year should forget about having two lines of PRO level sails? Or, to put it another way, they do not know what they are doing?

But anyway, another easy solution? Pick your specialty: fins and foil do not really mix ...



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"Do we really need dedicated foil and fin racing sails ? Or is it time for a revolution" started by Kasper79