Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

Structural Engineering question

Reply
Created by GavGav > 9 months ago, 24 Jul 2014
GavGav
VIC, 193 posts
24 Jul 2014 6:08PM
Thumbs Up

I hope someone can give me a bit of advice / reassurance. (Won't hold you to it)

I want to cantilever some Ezystrut to my workshop I Beam to pick up a static weight.

Like below, section view.








Using some of these clamps. (Rated at 407kg when used in pairs with a 2:1 safety factor)
www.ezystrut.com.au/products/beam-clamps/e2786/e2786h/

I just don't have the skills to work it out and could not find simple help with Google.

Any of you smart people that work with these calcs all day work it out for me?

Thanks.
Gav.

Craig66
NSW, 2457 posts
24 Jul 2014 6:13PM
Thumbs Up

just make it up and swing on it your self (guessing your 70kg +)

if you land on your a$$ it wont hold,

(Won't hold you to it)

SandS
VIC, 5904 posts
24 Jul 2014 6:21PM
Thumbs Up


SFA

GavGav
VIC, 193 posts
24 Jul 2014 6:43PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Craig66 said..
just make it up and swing on it your self (guessing your 70kg +)

if you land on your a$$ it wont hold,

(Won't hold you to it)


Yeah, I could try that (I'm 90kg) but I was hoping for an educated response...

More of an opportunity to learn something.


Select to expand quote
SandS said..

SFA




or is it 9/10ths of SFA

GreenPat
QLD, 4083 posts
24 Jul 2014 6:50PM
Thumbs Up

I'm not a structural engineer but I think you'd solve this by assuming the far side of the I beam is a pivot, calculate the torque there and then calculate the effective loading at the clamp in tension.

Say it was another 100mm from there and you had 70kg * 0.53m = 37.1 kg.m of torque (a new unit I made up since we're going back out to kg at the end anyway).

Take that 100mm and calculate the force at the end of it from that torque: 37.1 / 0.1 = 371kg.

So you'd need an I-Beam at least 92mm wide to take that load at that distance (I think...)

Ian K
WA, 4048 posts
24 Jul 2014 4:55PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
GavGav said..

Craig66 said..
just make it up and swing on it your self (guessing your 70kg +)

if you land on your a$$ it wont hold,

(Won't hold you to it)



Yeah, I could try that (I'm 90kg) but I was hoping for an educated response...

More of an opportunity to learn something.



SandS said..

SFA





or is it 9/10ths of SFA


((430 + width of Ibeam)/width of the Ibeam ) X 70kg

GavGav
VIC, 193 posts
24 Jul 2014 7:00PM
Thumbs Up

Zuke said..
Hi Gav, to be accurate: What is the width of the red "I" beam?

What is the length and weight of the beam being attached to it?




I Beam is : (Sorry, I did not draw it to scale)
630 UB 113
Overall Width:228.0 mm
Overall Height:607.0 mm
Flange Thickness:17.3 mm
Web Thickness:11.2 mm
Root Radius:14.0 mm

Cantilevered ezystrut E1001 combination channel is a total length of 825mm and is 82.6 high
www.ezystrut.com.au/products/channels-and-accessories/combination-channel/e1001-combination-channel/e1001/e1001h/

I'm not concerned about the I beam so much, just wondering about the clamps rating.

Thanks!

GavGav
VIC, 193 posts
24 Jul 2014 7:06PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Ian K said..

GavGav said..


Craig66 said..
just make it up and swing on it your self (guessing your 70kg +)

if you land on your a$$ it wont hold,

(Won't hold you to it)




Yeah, I could try that (I'm 90kg) but I was hoping for an educated response...

More of an opportunity to learn something.




SandS said..

SFA






or is it 9/10ths of SFA



((430 + width of Ibeam)/width of the Ibeam ) X 70kg


((430+228)/228*70=202.01

So the clamps rated at 407kg 2:1 will have around a 4:1 safety.
Roughly...

Zuke
901 posts
24 Jul 2014 5:07PM
Thumbs Up

(430 + 228) / 228 x 70 = 202kg.

That's not taking into account the mass of it.

Edit: Just beat me!

LostDog
WA, 445 posts
24 Jul 2014 5:10PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Zuke said..
(430 + 228) / 228 x 70 = 202kg.

That's not taking into account the mass of it.



I second this.

GavGav
VIC, 193 posts
24 Jul 2014 7:12PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Zuke said..
(430 + 228) / 228 x 70 = 202kg.

That's not taking into account the mass of it.



Mass for the 825mm length of channel is 4.125kg

GavGav
VIC, 193 posts
24 Jul 2014 7:32PM
Thumbs Up

So, I think the answer is, it will be fine and have over a 2:1 safety factor.

Thanks for your help guys.

If anyone needs any advice on:
Sending SDI-HD or HDBaseT video long distances
Stage lighting DMX control
Audio DSP configuring.
CRESTRON control systems
+ more.

(No home theater )

I'm your man!

Gav.

Craig66
NSW, 2457 posts
24 Jul 2014 7:46PM
Thumbs Up

Hey Gav Gav,
thats what i said hours ago and im very edegmuamucated

And Ill bet you swing of it

GavGav
VIC, 193 posts
24 Jul 2014 7:54PM
Thumbs Up

Craig66 said..
And Ill bet you swing of it


You seem to know me well!

I just like the confidence of doing the maths..
Sort of like the confidence I get with these.



For those LBL moments...

snot
NSW, 157 posts
24 Jul 2014 7:56PM
Thumbs Up

What are you hanging of it?

sn
WA, 2775 posts
24 Jul 2014 6:05PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
GavGav said..
So the clamps rated at 407kg 2:1 will have around a 4:1 safety.
Roughly...


CLAMPS??

rather un-orstrayan there Gav'

Whats wrong with a couple of turns of fencing wire and twitching it up


stephen

GavGav
VIC, 193 posts
24 Jul 2014 8:13PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
snot said..
What are you hanging of it?


My junk, one is hanging a bit low compared to the other..

GreenPat
QLD, 4083 posts
24 Jul 2014 8:15PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
GavGav said..
So, I think the answer is, it will be fine and have over a 2:1 safety factor.

Thanks for your help guys.

If anyone needs any advice on:
Sending SDI-HD or HDBaseT video long distances
Stage lighting DMX control
Audio DSP configuring.
CRESTRON control systems
+ more.

(No home theater )

I'm your man!

Gav.



Any clues how to get a DVB-T tuner into a television with only an ATSC one? Or converting and ATSC signal to DVB-T? I've already put a set-top-box inline from the antenna and it's still sending an incompatible signal through the HDMI...

GavGav
VIC, 193 posts
24 Jul 2014 8:20PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
GreenPat said..


GavGav said..
So, I think the answer is, it will be fine and have over a 2:1 safety factor.

Thanks for your help guys.

If anyone needs any advice on:
Sending SDI-HD or HDBaseT video long distances
Stage lighting DMX control
Audio DSP configuring.
CRESTRON control systems
+ more.

(No home theater )

I'm your man!

Gav.




Any clues how to get a DVB-T tuner into a television with only an ATSC one? Or converting and ATSC signal to DVB-T?



Just buy a new TV designed to work in OZ? Probably cheaper.
Sorry.. Almost Home theater..

No other inputs on the TV?
HDMI? Composite video? Component?

Edit: Just saw your edit..

Maybe the ATSC TV is only standard Def and the STB is outputting HD?
Sorry, im not a home theater guy..

GreenPat
QLD, 4083 posts
24 Jul 2014 9:08PM
Thumbs Up

Ha! Ok, too much home theater. New tv looks like the last remaining option. Still $$$ as the cheapest option, now that set-top-box failed as option.

FormulaNova
WA, 14641 posts
24 Jul 2014 7:20PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
GreenPat said..
GavGav said..
So, I think the answer is, it will be fine and have over a 2:1 safety factor.

Thanks for your help guys.

If anyone needs any advice on:
Sending SDI-HD or HDBaseT video long distances
Stage lighting DMX control
Audio DSP configuring.
CRESTRON control systems
+ more.

(No home theater )

I'm your man!

Gav.



Any clues how to get a DVB-T tuner into a television with only an ATSC one? Or converting and ATSC signal to DVB-T? I've already put a set-top-box inline from the antenna and it's still sending an incompatible signal through the HDMI...


I'm surprised that a TV won't accept the signal from a DVB-T set top box. The ATSC bit is only the tuner, so it shouldn't matter I would think.

If you want to go another way, build a mythtv machine, use a DVB-T tuner in it, and connect it to the TV with VGA (or HDMI depending on your card). The only risk with this is that you end up recording everything and watching too much TV. Although, if you know what to buy, it can be a relatively cheap way to go, assuming you wanted a PVR in the first place.

Why did you bring an ATSC TV home? Did you know it was different?

Pitbull
WA, 1267 posts
24 Jul 2014 8:39PM
Thumbs Up

Ich habe keine verdammte Ahnung, was du redest.

FormulaNova
WA, 14641 posts
24 Jul 2014 8:48PM
Thumbs Up

Hey, that's a good way to get by the filters

Macroscien
QLD, 6806 posts
25 Jul 2014 10:36AM
Thumbs Up

I had very similar question regarding force loading so I decided to use paid internet service JustAnswer.
So far I pair $22 as requested but didn't received a single answer yet for two weeks.

www.justanswer.com/engineering/8k4r4-looking-somebody-help-design-robotic-arm.html

It looks like SB free advice served GavGAv much better

kiterboy
2614 posts
25 Jul 2014 8:41AM
Thumbs Up

I for one am surprised that our resident structural genius, Bono, wasn't the first one to answer this for you.

Conspiracy?

GreenPat
QLD, 4083 posts
25 Jul 2014 11:32AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
FormulaNova said..

If you want to go another way, build a mythtv machine, use a DVB-T tuner in it, and connect it to the TV with VGA (or HDMI depending on your card). The only risk with this is that you end up recording everything and watching too much TV. Although, if you know what to buy, it can be a relatively cheap way to go, assuming you wanted a PVR in the first place.


Looks interesting. A bit complex though, and I'd need a new computer to set it up on, so there go $$$ anyway. Greenwife wouldn't like the idea of me getting caught up in another hare-brained project either, so I think that's a negative.

Select to expand quote
FormulaNova said..

Why did you bring an ATSC TV home? Did you know it was different?



Because I'm an idiot. I knew the electricity was different and set up a transformer for it. I didn't know that digital tv had the same incompatibility with the rest of the world that their analog did.

FormulaNova
WA, 14641 posts
25 Jul 2014 1:08PM
Thumbs Up

Yes, I think the USA, and I am guessing by your questions, Canada too, went their own way. I think everyone else went DVB-T. I guess the USA have to have everything just their way.

I only know the difference because of the reading I did on Mythtv.

If you did go Mythtv, there are HP DC7700 PCs that you can buy for around $100 on ebay that do the job nicely. Quiet, and enough grunt to play HD.
You would also need a DVB-T tuner for it, and you can use ASUS 3100 USB tuners or a Sony PlayTV if you want.

The annoying thing about Mythtv is you can spend ages working it out until you hit the right combination of things to use. For me, I have settled on an old distribution of Mythbuntu (10.04) that I make sure can't update itself (and break itself), and the thing just works.

I am surprised that the HDMI to set top box doesn't work. HDMI can pass data across the channel, but you wouldn't think a TV would object to viewing input from a set top box.

I know some TVs are generic enough where they had different boards for different regions, but I think even finding a guy that wants to repair a flat screen TV these days is a challenge, let alone getting them to swap boards.


For your TV, does it really need a transformer? A lot of things nowdays accept 100-240v just because its easier, and with switchmode powersupplies, its not terribly difficult to do.

GreenPat
QLD, 4083 posts
25 Jul 2014 4:32PM
Thumbs Up

I'm pretty sure it does, the little info thing on the back says "110V-120V", not "110V-240V" like the typical dual voltage appliance.

FormulaNova
WA, 14641 posts
25 Jul 2014 3:16PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
GreenPat said..
I'm pretty sure it does, the little info thing on the back says "110V-120V", not "110V-240V" like the typical dual voltage appliance.



That sucks .. Americans, is there nothing they can change to be 'better'?





Subscribe
Reply

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"Structural Engineering question" started by GavGav