Forums > Land Yacht Sailing Construction

Class 5 front suspension MkII

Reply
Created by Sylk > 9 months ago, 11 Apr 2016
Sylk
WA, 215 posts
11 Apr 2016 8:24PM
Thumbs Up

I was never happy with my old suspension system and finally made a go at some changes.

The old version pivoted at the base of the mast, this always felt like too much leverage on the shock absorber and the pivot point had flogged lose allowing an uncomfortable amount of sideways play. Further the shock absorber was purchased for $14 of e-bay and had no damping only a spring. The lack of damping lead to the whole front end chattering at speed or in sharp turns.

The plan was to move the pivot point further forward closer to the sort of geometry I see on a mountain bike rear end and to resize the front forks to fit a 20" bmx wheel for light weight and low cost replacement.

A quick sketch in Inventor to play with the geometry and get the measurements figured out.



This first version reuses the same shock absorber from the old system. I figured I would start with the old and see how it felt.
The pivot point is now 2 x 6001 bearings in a machined housing, nice and firm all the sideways slop is gone.



Note the steering rod connection now pivots horizontally this puts much less stress on the flexible tendon and should increase service life.


I took this version for a 70km test sail on the weekend and am very happy with the result.
Feels like a brand new yacht, there is still a it of chatter when turning at speed.

I have ordered a better quality air damped shock so when that arrives Ill swap the old one out and report back on how it feels.

Hiko
1229 posts
12 Apr 2016 9:57AM
Thumbs Up

Chatter seems to be a part of having a narrow front wheel on class five? I wonder if those who are using a wheelbarrow wheel or a wider tyre experience this
I made a wider 20 inch wheel fitted with a 3inch tyre for my class five and never got to try it out properly before I sold the yacht
I dont think the new owner has tried it All the class fives I have seen here all seem to have that chattering hop on hard turns sprung front forks or not
My minis dont do it even when I had narrow tyres fitted so maybe its something else thats doing it like wheel loading

JohnHS
WA, 34 posts
12 Apr 2016 10:35AM
Thumbs Up

I started with a barrow wheel then progressed to a home made 16x2.5" both had significant chatter it was definitely exacerbated by the lack of damping and the length of the front swing arm.

It might be less in minis because there is more weight over the front wheel.
But I'm shore better suspension geometry and proper damping should reduce chatter a fair bit.

PS: this is Sylk from my work account.

The air damped shock just arrived. Hope here is enough wind for a good test this weekend.





Sylk
WA, 215 posts
14 Apr 2016 6:51PM
Thumbs Up

New air damped shock absorber fitted..






wokelliott
WA, 179 posts
15 Apr 2016 10:56PM
Thumbs Up

Hi Sylk. When the front wheel rises as it hits a bump it will swing the whole front end and steering pushrod rearward. If you are not exactly compensating for that pushrod movement with your feet on the steering shaft then it will turn the front wheel to the right. The opposite will occur if the wheel drops into a hollow ie, the wheel will turn left. That will happen no matter what size wheel or damper is used.

So the effect as you travel over uneven ground is going to cause the front wheel to swing left and right unless you are able to hold it straight by compensating with the feet pedals. Seems a very different geometry is needed with the suspension and steering arrangement.

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
16 Apr 2016 8:54PM
Thumbs Up

keep in mind wok that on lefroy we dont really need any fromt suspension. we mainly use it on walyungup,for smashing through the bottom turn. It was so rough this easter that my new suspension gradually torqued up the tube and needs realigning. I think the chattering is the flexing causing the pivot angle to get away from the centr of contact sweet spot ,so I steepen my steering by2-3 degrees to compensate.ie the steering is spot on when under load ,not when released

Hiko
1229 posts
17 Apr 2016 3:38AM
Thumbs Up

Is this chattering then related to the layover steering on class 5 ?
Do designs like the pacific magic have the same tendencies ?
Class 3 Yachts generally have more upright steering pivot angles Do they have similar chattering issues ?
Chattering wheel hop can be a safety issue
Unresponsive turning has resulted in broken bones fairly recently here

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
17 Apr 2016 9:23PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Hiko said..
Is this chattering then related to the layover steering on class 5 ?
Do designs like the pacific magic have the same tendencies ?
Class 3 Yachts generally have more upright steering pivot angles Do they have similar chattering issues ?
Chattering wheel hop can be a safety issue
Unresponsive turning has resulted in broken bones fairly recently here


could well be,but on salt we also get sliding steering ,where all that happens is the wheel just slides. on really nice clay or asphalt it all works perfectly

yankeesailor
56 posts
13 Oct 2016 10:18AM
Thumbs Up

Im not sure if layover is the cause of wheel chatter. I have no lay over steering and still have wheel chatter. always when tacking upwind, gybing downwind no problem.it has done this since i build my yacht. I always assumed i had the geometry off or tire to skinny and not enough tire surface to grip, or not enough weight on front tire.



my plan was to add suspention or try a wider tire to see if that helps, but never got around to it. Just learned to live with it. I never feel like i will loose control and not make the turn. just annoying chatter. Im glad this seems to be a common problem and not just my yacht



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Land Yacht Sailing Construction


"Class 5 front suspension MkII" started by Sylk