Forums > Sailing General

Boats at Shute Harbour

Reply
Created by Jode5 > 9 months ago, 27 Mar 2017
Jode5
QLD, 853 posts
27 Mar 2017 5:05PM
Thumbs Up

This photo was taken two hours ago. No wounded insurance companies do not want to insure boats moored here. I know another cat that did a quick run to Mackay marina and got in. Much safer than sitting at anchor in Shute Harbour. They have had plenty of warning.

southace
SA, 4776 posts
27 Mar 2017 5:46PM
Thumbs Up

Yep that's where the uninsured boats remain usually boats that are worth nothing and can't enter marinas When Yasi came through they where there in the evening but gone in the morning sunk or smashed on the rocks. My guess is Airlie beach is going to get smashed with this incoming cyclone.

PhoenixStar
QLD, 477 posts
27 Mar 2017 5:21PM
Thumbs Up

Gusts to 65 knots at Hamilton now. Bit unkind to say the boats are worth nothing. There are plenty of good boats in Airlie and Schute. There are a couple of good funk holes for cats, not so much monos. Maybe Cid.

southace
SA, 4776 posts
27 Mar 2017 5:58PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
PhoenixStar said..
Gusts to 65 knots at Hamilton now. Bit unkind to say the boats are worth nothing. There are plenty of good boats in Airlie and Schute. There are a couple of good funk holes for cats, not so much monos. Maybe Cid.


Not being unkind times may have changed but there use to be quite a few unseaworthy boats with people just squatting on them. Can only be insured if your boat is seaworthy and tied up in the marina during cyclone.

Gdog6
62 posts
27 Mar 2017 6:14PM
Thumbs Up

Nuts to stay in Shute Harbour. I'd be in Gulnare Inlet, or the very end of Nara Inlet. Much more secure.

Donk107
TAS, 2446 posts
27 Mar 2017 9:45PM
Thumbs Up

Best of luck to anyone in the area

Just looked on the BOM site and she is now a cat 4

Stay safe

Regards Don

Bruski068
VIC, 457 posts
28 Mar 2017 12:52AM
Thumbs Up

It would be safer out at sea than it is moored in Shute Harbour

Dexport
303 posts
27 Mar 2017 10:06PM
Thumbs Up

Wow, it will be a lottery for those boats. My boat is in Bowen harbour and I'm feeling rather nervous to say the least. I'm in Switzerland right now so there is nothing I can do, just wake up in the morning and see what happened.
Fingers crossed that the damage to the local community is not too bad.

BlueMoon
866 posts
28 Mar 2017 6:53AM
Thumbs Up

Really hope your yacht isn't damaged Dexport. All the best wishes for you and other boat owners there. Do you have anyone keeping an eye on your yacht?.

BlueMoon
866 posts
28 Mar 2017 7:02AM
Thumbs Up

Best you don't look Dexport, but for everyone else, wow look at the Hamilton Is wind graph on SB, just stepped up a notch.
www.seabreeze.com.au/weather/wind-forecast/qld-central-coast

southace
SA, 4776 posts
28 Mar 2017 9:37AM
Thumbs Up

Aussie cyclone chasers just showed a bit of the Bowen boat harbour on there face book feed. That's not so good news your boat is there dexport, hopefuly you have good insurance. The better outcome will be if she survives th Storm.

PhoenixStar
QLD, 477 posts
28 Mar 2017 10:51AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Gdog6 said..
Nuts to stay in Shute Harbour. I'd be in Gulnare Inlet, or the very end of Nara Inlet. Much more secure.


Nope. There were boats lost in both anchorages. too may bullets and Nara a bit deep to get enough scope in a blow and Gulnare has very soft mud, Ok normally but not in a blow with the bullets down the length of the inlets. There is a bolt hole opposite the north end of Long Island for a couple of boats and a really good one if you have a cat in the mangroves north of Sawmill Bay.

MorningBird
NSW, 2662 posts
28 Mar 2017 1:27PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
BlueMoon said..
Best you don't look Dexport, but for everyone else, wow look at the Hamilton Is wind graph on SB, just stepped up a notch.
www.seabreeze.com.au/weather/wind-forecast/qld-central-coast


145 gusts. 103 steady. Wow!

Gravy7
NSW, 242 posts
28 Mar 2017 1:36PM
Thumbs Up

Holy crap!



Have a look at what happened between 9:40 and 9:50 - 97 knots ESE to 95 knots WNW in 10 minutes followed by a gust of 142 knots! I hope everyone on Hammo, Hayman and the mainland is OK.

McNaughtical
NSW, 908 posts
28 Mar 2017 2:12PM
Thumbs Up

My brother's boat is on pile mooring at Bowen... I'm worried for it... a lot!

Andrew68
VIC, 423 posts
28 Mar 2017 5:06PM
Thumbs Up

Just saw on the TV a yacht called "Green Nomad" thrown up on the rocks. Looks like steel. She just bounced along with no sign of puncture, you could be forgiven for thinking she could just bounce off again and sail way without any damage.

au.yahoo.com?err=404&err_url=abu-live-oob.media.yahoo.com:4443/sunrise/video/watch/34825184/boat-crashes-into-sea-wall-during-cyclone-debbie/


A

Futurecruiser
VIC, 119 posts
28 Mar 2017 5:09PM
Thumbs Up

Yeah not a pretty sight up there, sad to see some of these clips...

www.facebook.com/7newssydney/videos/1607547929269334/

GlennGee
QLD, 38 posts
28 Mar 2017 4:37PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Futurecruiser said..
Yeah not a pretty sight up there, sad to see some of these clips...

www.facebook.com/7newssydney/videos/1607547929269334/


Way too much windage left on that yacht. Why wouldn't you at least take your furled headsail down.

theselkie
QLD, 555 posts
28 Mar 2017 5:16PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
PhoenixStar said..
Gusts to 65 knots at Hamilton now. Bit unkind to say the boats are worth nothing. There are plenty of good boats in Airlie and Schute. There are a couple of good funk holes for cats, not so much monos. Maybe Cid.


My mate who purchased the Duncanson 37 up there about a month ago has, almost without doubt, lost the boat.

His representative up in Airlie attempted to tow it into the little creek south of Boat Haven at Airlie - a proven bolt hole - only to find the narrow and very tidal mouth of the creek obstructed by a dirty great barge belonging to the owner of the boatyard up that same creek.

A few other boats were attempting to access the creek as well.

The concensus is that the owner of this boatyard did this deliberately to deter boats from anchoring in 'HIS' creek.

MSQ Airlie Beach were not interested. So bloody insular and parochial up there...small towns, small minds. The MSQ guy was adamant that Mr E.... was simply making preparations for his own vessels in preparation for the cyclone.

After the lockdown, NO vessels were permitted to move. However, the barge, lo and behold, had been moved back up the creek on Sunday morning.

Disasters can bring out the very best and WORST in people.

Hope I'm wrong, but R.I.P. Wyandra.

slammin
QLD, 994 posts
28 Mar 2017 6:44PM
Thumbs Up

Green Nomad was definitely steel we saw her around the traps up here.

Terrible news.

slammin
QLD, 994 posts
28 Mar 2017 6:49PM
Thumbs Up

southace
SA, 4776 posts
28 Mar 2017 7:43PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
theselkie said..

PhoenixStar said..
Gusts to 65 knots at Hamilton now. Bit unkind to say the boats are worth nothing. There are plenty of good boats in Airlie and Schute. There are a couple of good funk holes for cats, not so much monos. Maybe Cid.



My mate who purchased the Duncanson 37 up there about a month ago has, almost without doubt, lost the boat.

His representative up in Airlie attempted to tow it into the little creek south of Boat Haven at Airlie - a proven bolt hole - only to find the narrow and very tidal mouth of the creek obstructed by a dirty great barge belonging to the owner of the boatyard up that same creek.

A few other boats were attempting to access the creek as well.

The concensus is that the owner of this boatyard did this deliberately to deter boats from anchoring in 'HIS' creek.

MSQ Airlie Beach were not interested. So bloody insular and parochial up there...small towns, small minds. The MSQ guy was adamant that Mr E.... was simply making preparations for his own vessels in preparation for the cyclone.

After the lockdown, NO vessels were permitted to move. However, the barge, lo and behold, had been moved back up the creek on Sunday morning.

Disasters can bring out the very best and WORST in people.

Hope I'm wrong, but R.I.P. Wyandra.


Did he manage to get insurance? A lot of mud around that creek and a strong boat she still maybe fine .

theselkie
QLD, 555 posts
28 Mar 2017 7:16PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
slammin said..


No words can describe...??

theselkie
QLD, 555 posts
28 Mar 2017 7:19PM
Thumbs Up

No
Tried for a month to get insurance.
Youi would not transfer the policy from the vendor (citing new underwriter). Club marine was organised for third party to get the boat on the slip.

Hopefully she's in the mangroves and not on the rocks.

.

southace
SA, 4776 posts
28 Mar 2017 8:09PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Futurecruiser said..
Yeah not a pretty sight up there, sad to see some of these clips...

www.facebook.com/7newssydney/videos/1607547929269334/

I went through two cyclones in that marina, Yasi and Anthony no where near as bad as what they have just received but I removed the furling head sail and hitched the boom bag sail in both experiences .

First Cyclone I stayed aboard and experienced 60 to 70 knots but when Yasi came through we booked the hotel over looking this spot and my yacht and my mates yacht survived.

Some footage I have seen this morning over looking the same spot showed yachts close to my old berth with head sails unfurling and yachts healing over with gusts and sails shredding and one boat had a tender in the water! is this careless or uneducated cruises in the area or just bad timing?

SandS
VIC, 5904 posts
28 Mar 2017 8:44PM
Thumbs Up

That is a monster low pressure ! Hope no lives are lost ! Hang in all you crew up there !

The four day pressure chart shows it reforming into a nasty east coast low on Friday around northern NSW


southace
SA, 4776 posts
28 Mar 2017 8:45PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
theselkie said..
No
Tried for a month to get insurance.
Youi would not transfer the policy from the vendor (citing new underwriter). Club marine was organised for third party to get the boat on the slip.

Hopefully she's in the mangroves and not on the rocks.

.


What was the problem not to get insurance?

theselkie
QLD, 555 posts
28 Mar 2017 8:21PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
southace said..

theselkie said..
No
Tried for a month to get insurance.
Youi would not transfer the policy from the vendor (citing new underwriter). Club marine was organised for third party to get the boat on the slip.

Hopefully she's in the mangroves and not on the rocks.

.



What was the problem not to get insurance?


Youi wouldn't.
No-one else will without an out of water survey.

Futurecruiser
VIC, 119 posts
28 Mar 2017 9:40PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
southace said..

Futurecruiser said..
Yeah not a pretty sight up there, sad to see some of these clips...

www.facebook.com/7newssydney/videos/1607547929269334/


I went through two cyclones in that marina, Yasi and Anthony no where near as bad as what they have just received but I removed the furling head sail and hitched the boom bag sail in both experiences .

First Cyclone I stayed aboard and experienced 60 to 70 knots but when Yasi came through we booked the hotel over looking this spot and my yacht and my mates yacht survived.

Some footage I have seen this morning over looking the same spot showed yachts close to my old berth with head sails unfurling and yachts healing over with gusts and sails shredding and one boat had a tender in the water! is this careless or uneducated cruises in the area or just bad timing?


Yeah the one in the clip has a tender along behind as it goes into the breakwater. May have fallen off the davits but still wouldn't think it'd be the best way to leave your boat in the circumstances. Who knows what other situations the owner may have been facing though...

sirgallivant
NSW, 1531 posts
28 Mar 2017 9:41PM
Thumbs Up

Terrible weather, no doubt.
Wish all the best to all who were suffering from it!

Asking silly questions - y he did or didn't do this or that - is less than helpful.
See Dexport's case as he is at the antipodes.

southace
SA, 4776 posts
28 Mar 2017 9:31PM
Thumbs Up

I seen some live footage of the boats in the end berths right next to the breakwater that boat is heading into. I did see a yacht there with head sail schreading and tender in the water today on tv. As I lived there for 2 years I was supprised it was left like that. I know from previous experience that some come in once the harbourmaster and marina staff have gone home .



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Sailing General


"Boats at Shute Harbour" started by Jode5