Forums > Stand Up Paddle General

Naish 12'6" LE v Fanatic 12'6" Falcon

Reply
Created by cel23 > 9 months ago, 19 Oct 2012
cel23
QLD, 175 posts
19 Oct 2012 7:34AM
Thumbs Up

Which board is faster on the flat, the Naish 12'6" x 24" LE or the Fanatic Flacon 12'6" x 25" carbon?

Cheers

Marcel

DavidJohn
VIC, 17517 posts
19 Oct 2012 8:49AM
Thumbs Up

cel23 said...

Which board is faster on the flat, the Naish 12'6" x 24" LE or the Fanatic Flacon 12'6" x 25" carbon?

Cheers

Marcel


What is faster.. Ford or Holden?..

DJ

cel23
QLD, 175 posts
19 Oct 2012 7:57AM
Thumbs Up

oh that ones easy, Ford of course!

DavidJohn
VIC, 17517 posts
19 Oct 2012 9:11AM
Thumbs Up

I think if you go by race results the yellow board is the faster board but racing is more about the paddler than the board..

I know red is normally faster but the yellow one is narrower and usually the narrower the faster.. That's if you don't fall off..

DJ

cel23
QLD, 175 posts
19 Oct 2012 8:13AM
Thumbs Up

DavidJohn said...
I think if you go by race results the yellow board is the faster board but racing is more about the paddler than the board..

I know red is normally faster but the yellow one is narrower and usually the narrower the faster.. That's if you don't fall off..

DJ


hmmmm.... im only light, however the yellow seem to have a relatively high rocker line...

PTWoody
VIC, 3982 posts
19 Oct 2012 10:32AM
Thumbs Up

The trouble with this comparison is that these boards are built for BOP racing where results at the highest level depend largely upon who manages to catch the wave rather than which board is fastest through flat water.

I've paddled the Naish and a proto of the Fanatic on flat water, and without having any timing data to back this up, I would say the Naish has a faster burst speed whereas the Fanatic is easier to maintain top speed.

RJK
NSW, 622 posts
19 Oct 2012 10:51AM
Thumbs Up

its a joke to think you can compare race results and link it to boards!

JBFletch
QLD, 1287 posts
19 Oct 2012 11:32AM
Thumbs Up

Do a demo, and see which suits you.

I previously owned a FANTIC 12'6 X 27.

I was planning on getting a 14fter but after paddling the 12"6 it felt so nice i went with that.

Keep an eye on the forums, there are a tonne of demos form all the major brands coming up.

cheers

cel23
QLD, 175 posts
19 Oct 2012 11:36AM
Thumbs Up

RJK said...
its a joke to think you can compare race results and link it to boards!


agree! Racing has so much more to do with race skills, fitness and tactics then how fast your board is...
however a faster board is always nice! haha

PTWoody
VIC, 3982 posts
19 Oct 2012 1:11PM
Thumbs Up

RJK said...
its a joke to think you can compare race results and link it to boards!


Well, aside from having to factor in variables such as tactics, conditions, fitness and luck, the other point to consider is whether the team riders are really on a production board or whether they have a custom team rider special.

supman123
WA, 17 posts
19 Oct 2012 11:44AM
Thumbs Up

RJK said...
its a joke to think you can compare race results and link it to boards!


But that is not what the board makers are telling me.

NNSUP
NSW, 1263 posts
19 Oct 2012 3:56PM
Thumbs Up

Another 4-6 weeks should answer this question. Containers of boards about to arrive all over the country.

JSUP
7 posts
10 Dec 2012 5:13AM
Thumbs Up

Given that it has been a few weekes since this initial post.

Does anyone have any views on which board seems to the preferred all round board for flatwater, chop, downwind & BOP style events, including the Starboard Allstar 12'6 x 25 carbon in the mix?

iSUP
QLD, 15 posts
10 Dec 2012 10:35AM
Thumbs Up

PTWoody said...
The trouble with this comparison is that these boards are built for BOP racing


i'm new to sup and trying to learn a new language.

What's BOP mean?

Thanks, Peter

Mollzy
QLD, 6 posts
10 Dec 2012 10:47AM
Thumbs Up

iSUP said...
PTWoody said...
The trouble with this comparison is that these boards are built for BOP racing


i'm new to sup and trying to learn a new language.

What's BOP mean?

Thanks, Peter


BOP - Battle of the Paddle
ps - LOVE the Naish 12.6 LE, bit tippy to get used to but you get the hang of it and surfs a breeze :)

PTWoody
VIC, 3982 posts
10 Dec 2012 12:06PM
Thumbs Up

iSUP said...
PTWoody said...
The trouble with this comparison is that these boards are built for BOP racing


i'm new to sup and trying to learn a new language.

What's BOP mean?

Thanks, Peter


BOP is Battle of the Paddle, which means that it's a race in and out through surf. A board designed for BOP racing will be optimised to be able to catch a wave and also capable of dealing white water and breaking waves on the way out. Flat water race boards don't tend to be so good at these challenges.

iSUP
QLD, 15 posts
10 Dec 2012 11:52AM
Thumbs Up

Ok, got it, thanks

cel23
QLD, 175 posts
10 Dec 2012 7:00PM
Thumbs Up

Defiantly the Naish LE

petedorries
QLD, 700 posts
10 Dec 2012 7:46PM
Thumbs Up

We have both at our sessions. Team riders and the buyer all paddling together and its really been no real diifference in speed as the paddlers swap around.
It comes down to what you prefer.
For me been 93kgs plus the Fanatic is able to sustain the speed. As stated the Naish does getup and riding but dosnt sustain my weight.

teatrea
QLD, 4177 posts
10 Dec 2012 8:22PM
Thumbs Up

Forget about whats fastest , get a board that you feel comfortable on Its the jockey that makes the difference. in my opinion if you are a bigger guy go for a board with a pin tail , you only have to look at the wake generated by square tail boards , expeciaslly when bigger dudes are riding them , no point in dragging your arse

LAZZA1964
VIC, 107 posts
10 Dec 2012 10:26PM
Thumbs Up

petedorries said...
We have both at our sessions. Team riders and the buyer all paddling together and its really been no real diifference in speed as the paddlers swap around.
It comes down to what you prefer.
For me been 93kgs plus the Fanatic is able to sustain the speed. As stated the Naish does getup and riding but dosnt sustain my weight.


That would make sense considering the Naish Le has a vol of 202 ltr and a max rider weight of 86 kg. On a 90 kg plus rider the water line would be close to the deck .



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle General


"Naish 12'6" LE v Fanatic 12'6" Falcon" started by cel23