Forums > Windsurfing Foiling

Advise needed how to eliminate Slingshot wing wobble.

Reply
Created by sl55 > 9 months ago, 13 Apr 2020
sl55
128 posts
13 Apr 2020 9:47AM
Thumbs Up

As I mentioned elsewhere on this forum, I have a very annoying wobble in the wing-to-fuselage connection. I am able to decrease it by wrapping two strips of soda can aluminum over the flat parts of the fuse but it does not eliminate it completely and it makes it hard to pull the wing off the fuse. So I am looking for a more or less permanent solution to this problem. I am thinking about pouring some epoxy mixed with I do not know what exactly into the barrel of the wing and sticking the fuse in there. Extra epoxy will hopefully get squeezed out. Big question is what release agent should I use on the fuse so that I can still pull it out after the resin sets? Any advise would be appreciated.

AUS 808
WA, 453 posts
13 Apr 2020 11:31AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
sl55 said..
As I mentioned elsewhere on this forum, I have a very annoying wobble in the wing-to-fuselage connection. I am able to decrease it by wrapping two strips of soda can aluminum over the flat parts of the fuse but it does not eliminate it completely and it makes it hard to pull the wing off the fuse. So I am looking for a more or less permanent solution to this problem. I am thinking about pouring some epoxy mixed with I do not know what exactly into the barrel of the wing and sticking the fuse in there. Extra epoxy will hopefully get squeezed out. Big question is what release agent should I use on the fuse so that I can still pull it out after the resin sets? Any advise would be appreciated.


If it goes wrong you will have a permanent solution

You could wrap the fuse with clear sticky tape, maybe 2 layers & wax it as well.
Cover any holes in the wing with tape or fill with bluetack etc.
Pour some epoxy mixed with a filler into the wing & insert the fuse vertically & bump down on the bench a few times to ensure the resin in completely surrounding the fuse & oozing out the top.
Leave standing vertical until dried.
Hopefully it will come out, may need a couple of thumps with a rubber mallet.

Only a suggestion, I can't guarantee it will work

LeeD
3939 posts
13 Apr 2020 11:48AM
Thumbs Up

Green release agent can get sticky upon removal.
Better to combine with wax.

kobo
NSW, 1092 posts
13 Apr 2020 3:31PM
Thumbs Up

I just used a small paintbrush with long handle and put 2 coats of epoxy on the inside of the wing and it worked perfectly. Do 1 coat then tip the wing up so any excess drains to the outside and doesn't pool inside.test the fit after one coat sets and do more coats if needed. The end of the fuse has sharp edges and sliding it in and out will gradually shave the inside of the wing.You can use this to help get a good fit , but once you have it perfect then file the sharp edges off so it doesn't shave epoxy off every time you slide it in .one wing I had needed 2 coats and the other only one coat so be conservative because it is adding thickness to 6 sides.

micks1
NSW, 22 posts
13 Apr 2020 5:50PM
Thumbs Up

Have you tried adding a good supply of Lanolin grease on that part of the fuse and all connecting parts of this wing? Next time after wing breakdown / wash more lanolin. This method works for me.

WhiteofHeart
762 posts
13 Apr 2020 4:04PM
Thumbs Up

I use plastic wrap for working with epoxy, works amazing somehow as it doesnt stick to the epoxy.

SA_AL
271 posts
14 Apr 2020 12:59AM
Thumbs Up

Here is youtube guide for applying tape. I used it to eliminate wobbling on my mast and it worked.

sl55
128 posts
14 Apr 2020 1:23AM
Thumbs Up

Thank you all for your input. I think I will try epoxy. Will test some release agents on a mock up first.
I did try all kinds of tape and determined that soft tape does not work, hence, used strips of aluminium.

Bender
WA, 2223 posts
14 Apr 2020 10:31AM
Thumbs Up

Hi guys i solved the wobbly wing issue for good with an easy modification. I added another 6G screw to the wing/fuse and fitted helicoils to the small fillet that the foil bolts go into as they alway strip as there is only a few threads to tighten the bolts on. Now the bolts go all the way through and i have them cut so they are flush.




thedoor
2278 posts
14 Apr 2020 10:42AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Bender said..
Hi guys i solved the wobbly wing issue for good with an easy modification. I added another 6G screw to the wing/fuse and fitted helicoils to the small fillet that the foil bolts go into as they alway strip as there is only a few threads to tighten the bolts on. Now the bolts go all the way through and i have them cut so they are flush.




Another guy put a screw further up the wing didn't too right?

lwalker
69 posts
17 Apr 2020 10:07PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
thedoor said..



Bender said..
Hi guys i solved the wobbly wing issue for good with an easy modification. I added another 6G screw to the wing/fuse and fitted helicoils to the small fillet that the foil bolts go into as they alway strip as there is only a few threads to tighten the bolts on. Now the bolts go all the way through and i have them cut so they are flush.







Another guy put a screw further up the wing didn't too right?




Yeah, it's in this thread:
www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Windsurfing/Foiling/Slingshot-Hover-Glide-Infinity-84-wing-review

He drilled the hole to match up with the existing hole in the fuse. But, that's difficult. Just adding a new hold in the fuse seems like it would be much easier.

AUS 808
WA, 453 posts
18 Apr 2020 7:25AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
sl55 said..
Thank you all for your input. I think I will try epoxy. Will test some release agents on a mock up first.
I did try all kinds of tape and determined that soft tape does not work, hence, used strips of aluminium.


If you use tape wrapped around the fuse make sure you start at the front & work backwards with the overlap.
If you go the other way you will create a barb effect & make it hard to remove the fuse from the wing when the epoxy dries.
Cling wrap works but in this case may be too thin, you still want a bit of clearance.
I think normal sticky tape will be the right thickness with the overlap.

Remember, if you are using a release agent don't use the Green one

sl55
128 posts
18 Apr 2020 10:33PM
Thumbs Up

Found a good read about release agents and stuff:
www.epoxyworks.com/index.php/what-you-can-do-if-you-dont-want-epoxy-to-stick/

I am wondering now what kind of resin is used in wing fabrication, and what kind of resin I should use. Definitely not one of the fast curing ones.

I also like the idea of helicoils in the fillet thingy. It is so easy to strip the threads in it. Ruined a couple of them in the past.

LeeD
3939 posts
19 Apr 2020 2:01AM
Thumbs Up

Epoxy resin, hi quality slow cure like Resin Research ot West Marine.
Fast cure for cosmetic.
Slow cure for structural.

Fast505
26 posts
27 Apr 2020 8:54PM
Thumbs Up

I tried the foil tape. This worked well in terms of eliminating wobble but I had to apply it very flat and only halfway around (applied tape longitudinally). I added a thin layer of grease then carefully slid it on. It fits very tight and no real wobble now. However, I couldn't get the damn thing off to change wings out at the beach! When I do get it off I'm sure that I'll need to reapply tape. So, it's really not the best fix unless you are leaving it on, and even then you need to take it off occasionally to keep from seizing.

allesad
64 posts
28 Apr 2020 8:08AM
Thumbs Up

Here is a new way to address the wobble. The brass mast cap inserts seem to loose their grip and get easier stripped. I've gone thru 2 of them in 2 seasons. For those who were earlier adopters of the FWIND1 and mulitple masts (short to long), you have a chance to remedy the mast cap problem.

Just take the 15 inch mast (who uses it?) and "slice it" on a band saw or hacksaw, about the same thickness as the orginal. The Slingshot masts are threaded really deep. I got 5 mast caps from my 15 inch mast and still have room for more.

The new mast cap (sliced), has stronger thread's than the brass one. It helped alot.

Like Fast505, I use tape as well. Good luck.



CAN17
575 posts
28 Apr 2020 8:49AM
Thumbs Up

^^^
Cool idea, never thought of that! How many could you make out of that 15" mast?
I wounder if it's stonger aluminum then the SS forged aluminum caps. I have thought of drilling through the top of the alu cap and re taping so you can't bottom out the bolts and maybe get a extra couple threads
But don't think this would solve the wobble some are experiencing since this just stops the wing from sliding back and forth.

allesad
64 posts
28 Apr 2020 8:11PM
Thumbs Up

I agree, it just provide more threads and eliminates the bottoming out issue.
Still needed some tape for the wobble.
15 inch mast makes +/-6 caps.

wsurfn
82 posts
10 May 2020 5:10AM
Thumbs Up

I noticed a wobble after de-rigging yesterday. I tried to tighten the front cap bolt and is was stripped. It looks like the bolt only grabs a few threads in aluminum cap. Wonder if it is a corrosion issue. I did not think I had overtightened the bolt. Usually when you strip something you know it right away.


Grantmac
2042 posts
10 May 2020 5:23AM
Thumbs Up

Yes it grabs perhaps 2 threads which is why I've threaded mine through and gotten longer bolts.

antonmik
145 posts
10 May 2020 2:47PM
Thumbs Up

Throw this aluminum in the trash(I screwed up the bolts a couple of times and the thread has already deteriorated). it is necessary to use the foot of carbon fiber or as I have a hybrid stainless steel and carbon fiber.

stehsegler
WA, 3464 posts
10 May 2020 3:01PM
Thumbs Up

Watch out for galvanic corruption when combining carbon fiber with stainless steel. I've seen it happen in carbon extensions.

sl55
128 posts
28 May 2020 12:23AM
Thumbs Up

Well, finally I found some time to get to it. Rubbed a lot of wax on the fuselage. Packed the bolt holes with wax as well. Wrapped the mast plug insert with thin plastic tape and popped it in. Mixed a tea-spoonful of epoxy without thickener and poured it into the wing tunnel. Slowly inserted the fuselage to proper depth and made sure it is positioned straight. Next day checked how it turned out. Fuse-wing connection is rock solid. Tapped the wing off the fuse with a wooden block. They separated but "unwillingly". I think the tolerances turned out to be too tight for frequent wing changes. Fortunately I have a couple of fuses for other wings. If I have to do it again, I would use a bit of tape over the wax on the fuse prior to insertion into the wing to have a touch more wiggle room. My other wings do not have so much play as this I-84 had.
Next I plan to make a few new mast caps as "alllesad" suggested.

CAN17
575 posts
29 May 2020 7:10AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
lwalker said..



thedoor said..






Bender said..
Hi guys i solved the wobbly wing issue for good with an easy modification. I added another 6G screw to the wing/fuse and fitted helicoils to the small fillet that the foil bolts go into as they alway strip as there is only a few threads to tighten the bolts on. Now the bolts go all the way through and i have them cut so they are flush.










Another guy put a screw further up the wing didn't too right?







Yeah, it's in this thread:
www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Windsurfing/Foiling/Slingshot-Hover-Glide-Infinity-84-wing-review

He drilled the hole to match up with the existing hole in the fuse. But, that's difficult. Just adding a new hold in the fuse seems like it would be much easier.




I added a new hole in the wing like JJ did. I used the second last hole that's already tapped in the fuse. Not gonna lie it took me over 2hrs to drill this hole. The time consuming part was taking the wing on and off the fuse to check it. I still need to find a drill bit big enough to finish the countersunk part. Anyone know what size to use? I guess I can always grab a few and test for fit in the existing countersink hole.
In the end the holes lined up great and it was raining out....so who cares how long it took

Foilnut
174 posts
29 May 2020 7:29AM
Thumbs Up

CAN17 - post a couple photos

CAN17
575 posts
29 May 2020 7:44AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Foilnut said..
CAN17 - post a couple photos



Will do Chuck I'll post a few after I finish countersinking. I think this solution will help keep all the bolts tight. I find after a long session the bolts get fairly loose especially when carving hard and riding waves . Somehow I didn't really notice much affect from this when foiling. I also might try some aluminum foil tape aswell for a lock soiled fit. I actually don't know why slingshot doesn't just give you that extra hole in the wing.

AUS 808
WA, 453 posts
29 May 2020 10:00AM
Thumbs Up

You can't use a standard drill to countersink, the angle is wrong, usually 60 degrees, whereas a countersink is 90 degrees.
The other issue is the drill will grab & bite into the wing & probably drill right through before you can stop it

You can re-sharpen a drill to 90 degrees but clamp the wing down & use a drill press set to the correct depth so it can't grab & go right through.

CAN17
575 posts
29 May 2020 10:53AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
AUS 808 said..
You can't use a standard drill to countersink, the angle is wrong, usually 60 degrees, whereas a countersink is 90 degrees.
The other issue is the drill will grab & bite into the wing & probably drill right through before you can stop it

You can re-sharpen a drill to 90 degrees but clamp the wing down & use a drill press set to the correct depth so it can't grab & go right through.



Yes good point. Was doing some research and seems metric bolts are 90 degrees!
I was thinking a proper 1/2" countersink drill bit might work? Since the head of the the m6 is 12mm which is about 1/2". If anyone can remember the right size bit they used it would save me a bit of time.
Will use a peice of wood to make sure I got the right size first.

AUS 808
WA, 453 posts
30 May 2020 2:54PM
Thumbs Up

Not sure but I think the problem is with this system there is only 1 bolt actually threaded into the fuse whereas the other 2 go through the fuse into that spacer thingy which only locates the top of the wing.
If the spacer is not a tight fit into the wing you will get wobble.
If the spacer was slightly tapered it would help or wrap it with some tape maybe.
If there are plain holes through the fuse then these could be tapped out & helicoils inserted to give 3 proper connections & ditch the spacer.
I think that might be what JJ did in another thread from memory.

I may be wrong as I haven't looked at the setup in real life close up but from the above photos that's how I see it & explains why an extra bolt helps.

azymuth
WA, 2025 posts
30 May 2020 6:20PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
AUS 808 said..If there are plain holes through the fuse then these could be tapped out & helicoils inserted to give 3 proper connections & ditch the spacer. I think that might be what JJ did in another thread from memory.


Good memory Paul


Part of the magic of the Slingshot Hover Glide foil is the flexibility offered by the different fuselage positions

But if you don't need fuse position A installing M8 Helicoils in the mast cap holes gives a rock-solid wing to fuse fit.
You can screw M8 hex screws (same size as mast/fuse screws) into the stainless Helicoils tight.
I slightly countersink the holes in the wing so that the M8 screws are flush.

Removing the wing is quick, just unscrew the two M8 hex screws - and much less likely to round M8s than M6s.
I fill the mast cap slot in each wing with auto body filler.

Easy






M8 Kit - $35 AUD on EBAY



Samkyo
87 posts
1 Jun 2020 4:15AM
Thumbs Up

Hello,
to do it I will start by sanding the inside of the foil to remove any salt hand get clean surface.
after I will put some flash breaker(special composite tape that got calibrate thickness) or use metal shim to define the thickness of the gap to fill.
If you are less than 0.2 put Meguiar's wax release agent directly on the shaft + plasticine for the hole and and mix of epoxy resine with microspheres microballoons get it thick apply a thin surface on the shaft and inside the foil and assemble both use the cap with on bolt full of release agent to get in position.

If it is over 0.2 laminate one or more layer of 200g E-glass on the shaft thickness of one layer is around 0.2.
once you have the form mad, insert it inside the foil with epoxy mix with microsphere and microballoon



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing Foiling


"Advise needed how to eliminate Slingshot wing wobble." started by sl55