Forums > Windsurfing General

Do windsurfers do downwinders?

Reply
Created by BennyB12 > 9 months ago, 16 Sep 2013
BennyB12
QLD, 918 posts
16 Sep 2013 2:00PM
Thumbs Up

I've been kiting for many a moon and I love a good downwinder....
I was wondering why I never see windsurfers doing down wind runs?

mathew
QLD, 2045 posts
16 Sep 2013 2:09PM
Thumbs Up

yeah - but it is a bitch walking back after sailing downwind for 400kms... :)

But seriously, what happens when you blow out a kite, or the strings snap... rely on the emergency services to pick you up?

If you are going to mow-the-grass, you might as well land where you can get back to your vehicle.

BennyB12
QLD, 918 posts
16 Sep 2013 2:22PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
mathew said...
yeah - but it is a bitch walking back after sailing downwind for 400kms... :)

But seriously, what happens when you blow out a kite, or the strings snap... rely on the emergency services to pick you up?

If you are going to mow-the-grass, you might as well land where you can get back to your vehicle.


400 ks? Really?
I guess I'd get to shore, pack down and catch a bus back to my car....
Isn't mowing the grass just tacking back and forward as opposed to travelling a distance down wind?
Anyone else have just a normal answer?

Macroscien
QLD, 6806 posts
16 Sep 2013 2:48PM
Thumbs Up

maybe just few reasons :
- it is slow and ineffedtive > the faster you go the less wind you feel to the point that nothing to keep balance
- extremly risky any mistake or gust could finish in catapult
and tiring on small bard
-long walk then on the beach to the place you started

Carantoc
WA, 6650 posts
16 Sep 2013 12:57PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
BennyB12 said..

............

Anyone else have just a normal answer?



Select to expand quote
Macroscien spoke..


I guess the definition of normal changes depending on which planet you live.





Carantoc
WA, 6650 posts
16 Sep 2013 1:02PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
BennyB12 said..

I've been kiting for many a moon and I love a good downwinder....
I was wondering why I never see windsurfers doing down wind runs?


Do you ever go upwind first ?

I always prefer a downwinder where I go upwind first. Upwind for say an hour, then back down wind to get back to the same spot I started at so I don't have to hitch back to the car.

And how far out to sea do you go ? When I see kites going downwind they stay about 50m from shore. OK if you are surfing downwind, but if you aren't surfing down then what's wrong heading out a little ?

Subsonic
WA, 3118 posts
16 Sep 2013 1:08PM
Thumbs Up

I suppose it's got a bit to do with gear size, come time to head back up to the start point. Something you teabag gets have over us I guess, all being able to jump in one car with all your gear. Having said that, there's nothing really stopping us, it just means everyone has to do the trip back to the finish point with their car.

I have heard of a couple of windsurfers that organise downwinders, but not regularly like kiters do.

kiteboy dave
QLD, 6525 posts
16 Sep 2013 3:38PM
Thumbs Up

I guess the question is really whether windsufferers are more efficient at heading upwind in the surf.

Any non-noob tea-bagger generally stays upwind in flat water unless seriously underpowered (<12kts to generalise)

-however-

different ball game in the surf. Combine the usual downwind sweep with the fact that you're constantly breaking traction and/or in the air, plus doing short runs/frequent transitions (if staying within 100m odd of shore, playing with waves, etc) and it all adds up to going downwind.

Is it the same effect for you guys?

Mark _australia
WA, 22380 posts
16 Sep 2013 1:51PM
Thumbs Up

I think the main thing is the gear - never dawned on windsurfers to do it as 3 peoples' gear in one car is a PITA.
Do-able, but annoying.

Dave we are probably less efficient heading upwind in the surf as we have no lift to get over waves so often there is a voluntary schlogging in the break as bearing away to get planing loses you too much ground. use the water out the back to get upwind.
Once well powered though it is easier.
Once out of the surf I guess the upwind ability is similar...? Seems to be

I agree that the style of riding lends itself more to DW'ers .........so it just happened naturally due to wakestyle roots I guess.... whereas wndsurfers were doing what surfers do (just faster and better )
referring to waveriding only which is what your DW'ers are all about right?

AUS1111
WA, 3619 posts
16 Sep 2013 1:58PM
Thumbs Up

www.lancelinoceanclassic.com.au/

Mark _australia
WA, 22380 posts
16 Sep 2013 2:00PM
Thumbs Up



At which I do believe the windsurfers were way faster - even with a longer course.

mr love
VIC, 2352 posts
16 Sep 2013 4:02PM
Thumbs Up

Really just a matter of getting organised to do it and having mates to do the car shuttle. The reason I have never done one, got no mates
Would be cool and we have been talking about doing one on Port Phillip for a while as an event. We should!!!
There is one in WA , the L to L.

Sailhack
VIC, 5000 posts
16 Sep 2013 4:15PM
Thumbs Up

The downwinder would have to be on a reach? To go directly downwind as SUPs do would be ridiculously uncomfortable. I sail on plenty of onshores & although with strong winds, it doesn't take much to get out, it's an effort to go back in. You need to unhook, sheet out & hold your body in a twisted shape - not much fun...much more fun going across the wind imo.

Jethrow
NSW, 1240 posts
16 Sep 2013 4:15PM
Thumbs Up

We used to do it a bunch during Hawaii trips back in the late 80's & 90's. From the vids I've seen we were doing the Maliko run the SUP guys do now, from a bay a couple of miles upwind from Hookipa and down to Kanaha beach park. It was a hoot but we were mainly on slalom gear and one size bigger than normal rig. I remember one fantastic run where I snapped my mast about 30 meters from the final stop. Pretty lucky that day I guess.

dusta
WA, 2940 posts
16 Sep 2013 2:20PM
Thumbs Up

Mark _australia said..



At which I do believe the windsurfers were way faster - even with a longer course.


if i remember it was alot calmer as well :0

clarence
TAS, 979 posts
16 Sep 2013 4:28PM
Thumbs Up

Good question BennyB.

I wonder this myself all the time.

I have done a few myself last summer, one of 30 odd km. All on a long sailboard. I find the raceboard is good as if the wind drops you don't sink, and if you need to lay a tight headland you can put the centreboard down and point up for a bit.

I couldn't seem to rustle up much interest from anyone else when I posted the suggestions on seabreeze. My partner would come and pick me up at the other end- we could even make a bit of a day out with the kids following my progress, pulling in at a beach here and there.

In my humble opinion there is not any very good reason not to. Guys will drive for well over an hour to get to good wind (eg Sydney to Gerroa) so the distance/travel with gear thing doesn't seem like a good reason.

There is more organisation and understanding of gear and winds etc that is certainly an issue.

If the wind is cross onshore (as it is in Perth, Sydney, SE Qld and northern Tas in summer to the best of my knowledge), the worst that happens is you get blown back to shore (might be different of a small kiteboard). With these conditions a 45 degree bearaway can go for several kilometres at a time.

I'd find that when I get more than a mile offshore I'd gybe back in so I'm not too far out.

I think another big issue is that with mixed coastal terrain (headlands, bluffs etc) that the wind can behave somewhat differently from one location to another (eg strengthens significantly round a sharp headland) which requires a good choice of gear /sail size to be a happy medium for the duration of the trip.

A good safety kit (drybag with phone, flares, epirb, tape, rope, knife etc) is a good idea too.

Back in the day the local raceboard crew in Wollongong would sail about 20km every week, out around the tankers off Port Kembla and back.

I will try to organise a few more this summer down here in Tas. Swansea to Coles Bay would be an option that might encourage a few people to have a crack.

In the NSW thread there was a bit of talk on this topic by Mr Powersloshin (from memory)- quite a character it seems.

Clarence

Simon100
QLD, 490 posts
16 Sep 2013 6:02PM
Thumbs Up

id say because its not that hard to get back up wind on the windsurfer and there is only so long you can go hard off the wind before you get totally worn out . Why do you d them on kites anyway

BennyB12
QLD, 918 posts
16 Sep 2013 6:14PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Simon100 said...
id say because its not that hard to get back up wind on the windsurfer and there is only so long you can go hard off the wind before you get totally worn out . Why do you d them on kites anyway


90 percent of the fun in kiting for me is done down wind. I ride a surfboard so I'm not into boosting, just surfing waves. I guess riding with the wind is more efficient with a kite because you can generate power by diving or looping.
So the fun of towing into little runners or powering up and belting sections without having to constantly tack back up for another go Is why we down wind...
Thanks for the answers, except the first guy...
Have fun....

ggh
VIC, 190 posts
16 Sep 2013 7:31PM
Thumbs Up

I think you guys enjoy down winders as the Kite has similiar characteristics to a spinniker ( often refered to as a kite ) which is for down wind sailing .

The windsurfer has only a mainsail and therefore going directly down wind is its least favourable leg .

The same goes for Cats you will rarely see them go directly down wind , they will work there way down the course by gybing and siting on a shy reach .

I think that may be the normal answer your lookiing for .

I can appreciate your love of them from skiff sailing there is nothing better than running downwind on trapeze with the spinniker set

Gorgo
VIC, 4982 posts
16 Sep 2013 7:56PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
BennyB12 said..

I've been kiting for many a moon and I love a good downwinder....
I was wondering why I never see windsurfers doing down wind runs?


I'll weigh in on the other side. I can't see the point of a downwinder, unless it's somewhere like Waratah Bay where you can bash wave after wave after wave going downwind.

I much prefer an upwinder. Power upwind for half an hour to an hour then cruise back downwind and work all the breaks I've checked out on the way upwind. If the day is good then do it again.

Apart from being huge fun:
- I reckon I can ride upwind in the time it takes guys to get it together and do the car shuffle.
- riding upwind is massive fun when you know how to do it.
- it gets to the point where it's easier going upwind than down wind.

Subsonic
WA, 3118 posts
16 Sep 2013 6:42PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Carantoc said...
BennyB12 said..

I've been kiting for many a moon and I love a good downwinder....
I was wondering why I never see windsurfers doing down wind runs?


Do you ever go upwind first ?

I always prefer a downwinder where I go upwind first. Upwind for say an hour, then back down wind to get back to the same spot I started at so I don't have to hitch back to the car.

And how far out to sea do you go ? When I see kites going downwind they stay about 50m from shore. OK if you are surfing downwind, but if you aren't surfing down then what's wrong heading out a little ?


Yep plenty of windsurfers in Perth who'll tack upwind the length of Melville water from peli point, then do the downwinder back.

Simon100
QLD, 490 posts
16 Sep 2013 9:17PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
BennyB12 said..

Simon100 said...
id say because its not that hard to get back up wind on the windsurfer and there is only so long you can go hard off the wind before you get totally worn out . Why do you d them on kites anyway


90 percent of the fun in kiting for me is done down wind. I ride a surfboard so I'm not into boosting, just surfing waves. I guess riding with the wind is more efficient with a kite because you can generate power by diving or looping.
So the fun of towing into little runners or powering up and belting sections without having to constantly tack back up for another go Is why we down wind...
Thanks for the answers, except the first guy...
Have fun....


we can go really deep off the wind its just that it goes really fast and your jumping over all the swell it gets to be hard work i think you guys do it as more of a light wind thing dont you i guess in that situation you probably works out with the looping the kite and all that

ikw777
QLD, 2995 posts
16 Sep 2013 9:59PM
Thumbs Up

A windsurfing downwinder is over too soon. I guess with the painfully low speed of kites it makes it worthwhile.

phenton
QLD, 15 posts
16 Sep 2013 10:29PM
Thumbs Up

Downwinders are definitely the go for wave riding in marginal wind on beach breaks. No worries about trying to gain ground out the back, just gybe on the face of a set and cruise down the line and then head straight out and hook on to the next wave. Can sail in way less wind, or with smaller gear, waves are cleaner also. Just add up all the time you spend slogging upwind, or doing the long run out the back to get back upwind, it is more than half a session.

Down side is definitely the extra driving, multiple cars (forgetting keys or something in the other car), long walks if the wind drops out totally or someone breaks something in between the parked cars. Out of all the organized down winders I've been involved in someone has always had some form of misfortune that has resulted in a very long walk in wet boardies.

Kites are built for downwinders, you guys would be even more stupid if you didn't do them.

Carantoc
WA, 6650 posts
16 Sep 2013 8:32PM
Thumbs Up

BennyB12, BennyB12, BennyB12

It seems you have confused many an old windsurfer here.

A 'downwinder' isn't sailing 180 degrees downwind, as if you were hoisting a spinnaker pulling up the centreboard.

It simply means setting off from point A and finishing at point B, some distance down wind of where you started. During that trip, generally of a couple of hours (although it could be many hours or even many days) you may well sail upwind, straight reach, broad reach, long gibes, ride a wave etc. etc. Just, on average, after the fat lady has sung you end up further down wind than when you started. At which point you walk / hitch / catch your pre-arranged lift back to point A (or stay at point B if that takes your fancy).

The point of a downwinder ? Presumably either :
a) Travel a distance see the world, experience new places and have a nice time
b) Ride ****ty beach breaks front side (or down wind on a kite) without having to worry about either riding backhand / upwind or tacking back up wind to catch the next wave.

Most windsurfers perspective is probably either :
a) For sure go downwind, see new places, but why a downwinder and not an upwinder (you can do the same), and then why not an up / down or down / up winder and save the bit about hitching / arranging lifts etc.
b) If you are riding a decent peaking , walling wave, why leave it to go somewhere else, why not just sail back up to the peak and ride the next one ?


I too now recall the gun-run as it was called on Maui back in the old days. Hookipa to Kanaha. And many years ago I sailed many downwind trips, upwind trips and down wind surfs. There is a place in the old country that rips at about 14 knots on a big incoming tide. You can broad reach for 6 hours and never move from the same spot. Downside is that the outgoing tide is unsailable.

These days I find it just as rewarding to go up / downwind (or down / upwind if you are brave and more confident) than just going down wind and have to start organising other things.

But yes, a good downwinder is probably under rated and ill appreciated by many a sailor.



saltiest1
NSW, 2495 posts
16 Sep 2013 11:35PM
Thumbs Up

love a good long downwind run and rarely are they long enough. dawesville to halls head is a good one on a good breeze in summer with a vehicle, a couple of mates and a patient wife.

Subsonic
WA, 3118 posts
16 Sep 2013 10:41PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
saltiest1 said...
love a good long downwind run and rarely are they long enough. dawesville to halls head is a good one on a good breeze in summer with a vehicle, a couple of mates and a patient wife.


Very patient wife I'm guessing?

Mark _australia
WA, 22380 posts
16 Sep 2013 10:50PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
BennyB12 said..

. I guess riding with the wind is more efficient with a kite because you can generate power by diving or looping.

....


No, we can go faster / more efficiently downwind also, and your sining the kite is same as us pumping a sail (albeit much more physical for us.)
So going downwind is not more efficient for kiters... it is simply
(1) because of the wakestyle trick roots, where waveriding was being dragged down the wave, so it was just easier to do that
(2) laziness - easier to just go with the flow than work hard upwind and wait your turn for every.single.wave.ride
(3) less gear so 5 people and gear in a hatchback for the ride back upwind is do-able



Hooksey
WA, 556 posts
16 Sep 2013 10:56PM
Thumbs Up

We do a couple every year as warm up for the LtL / ocean classic. We usually do them from leighton / dutchies to scrab.

I remember doing on last year with Tom and robbie. I think they were on 7somthing and I was on a 9.4 KA race. As we headed off from dutchies I was well powered up and they were slugging along. As we passed city beach the wind had picked up and they were powering along and I was waay overpowered - I could not hold on heading down wind and could only sail up wind. Ended up on the beach half way between city beach and Scarborough .. Very tired! Luckily I could hitch a ride with one of the dog walkers and she dropped me at Scarborough..

I would deff recommend making sure that you bring flares, mobile telephone etc in case you get separated!

sboardcrazy
NSW, 8019 posts
17 Sep 2013 9:49AM
Thumbs Up

I used to do them on Lake Macquarie. Sail upwind on our boat then get dropped off and sail the length of the lake.Don't have a boat now + gear more fragile and complicated to carry these days.
I think we did one with a car shuffle from Nobby's to Dixon Park once back in the 90's- not a lot of distance but the wind was generally stronger at Nobby's than Dixon Park which would make things more difficult.

John340
QLD, 3123 posts
17 Sep 2013 11:46AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
sboardcrazy said...
I used to do them on Lake Macquarie. Sail upwind on our boat then get dropped off and sail the length of the lake.Don't have a boat now + gear more fragile and complicated to carry these days.
I think we did one with a car shuffle from Nobby's to Dixon Park once back in the 90's- not a lot of distance but the wind was generally stronger at Nobby's than Dixon Park which would make things more difficult.


I've done the downwinder from nobbies to dicko many times, mainly in the late 80s. A 3/4 reach is really good fun, especially in the open ocean. Also in the 87 I did a down wonder over 7 days from Mackay to Airlie Beach, via Brampton, Goldsmith, Lindeman, Hamilton and Daydream Island. These days I often work upwind on my longboard and enjoy a great downwinder coming home.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"Do windsurfers do downwinders?" started by BennyB12