Forums > Wing Foiling General

Wing foil brands copying America's Cup desings ?

Reply
Created by FranP 3 months ago, 17 May 2024
FranP
76 posts
17 May 2024 3:46AM
Thumbs Up

check those foils:

www.youtube.com/@americascup

Advanced boat foils are pretty similar on America's Cup edition in Barcelona, but no wing foil brand released something like that.

I'm conscious the program is different: while AC boards don't need to turn (ruder does it) and lift (flappers impulse the foil up ) their focus is on speed and glide.

why not copying AC foils ? are there physical differences like scale or speed (2-3x faster than wings) ??

Thatspec
354 posts
17 May 2024 9:16AM
Thumbs Up

Those foils look remarkably like a Code R series and Armstrong DWP but even higher AR. I suppose they have control surfaces though.

SpokeyDoke
130 posts
17 May 2024 10:06AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
FranP said..
check those foils:

www.youtube.com/@americascup

Advanced boat foils are pretty similar on America's Cup edition in Barcelona, but no wing foil brand released something like that.

I'm conscious the program is different: while AC boards don't need to turn (ruder does it) and lift (flappers impulse the foil up ) their focus is on speed and glide.

why not copying AC foils ? are there physical differences like scale or speed (2-3x faster than wings) ??



Do we know what their foil sections look like?

Piros
QLD, 6986 posts
17 May 2024 1:23PM
Thumbs Up

Armie Armstrong is best mates with NZ America's cup team so yeah tons of AC design concepts have been implemented in Armstrong foils.

FranP
76 posts
17 May 2024 3:01PM
Thumbs Up



Their desing priority is speed and they struggle to avoid cavitation because of the high speed (ultra low pressure in the foil surface--> boiling water --> attached air & bubbles --> + drag and reduced lift)

Just check at those foil outlines, completely different than ours:




Svendson
50 posts
17 May 2024 3:57PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
FranP said..


Their desing priority is speed and they struggle to avoid cavitation because of the high speed (ultra low pressure in the foil surface--> boiling water --> attached air & bubbles --> increases drag and less lift)

Just check at those foil layouts, completely different than ours:

www.instagram.com/p/C7DsHENrqGq/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&igsh=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==

Exactly this!


Select to expand quote
Piros said..
Armie Armstrong is best mates with NZ America's cup team so yeah tons of AC design concepts have been implemented in Armstrong foils.

And I very strongly suspect this is why the original Armstrong HA foils are considered very high performance but not user friendly. That is exactly the design tradeoff corner the AC, A class catamarans, Moth, etc push in to.

Foxi
125 posts
17 May 2024 4:27PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
FranP said..


Their desing priority is speed and they struggle to avoid cavitation because of the high speed (ultra low pressure in the foil surface--> boiling water --> attached air & bubbles --> + drag and reduced lift)

Just check at those foil outlines, completely different than ours:







Current Levitaz Race Winning Frontwing:




cornwallis
148 posts
17 May 2024 9:08PM
Thumbs Up




benyaman
2 posts
18 May 2024 5:45AM
Thumbs Up

The Starboard x 15 one design foils are very similar outline makes sense since they are designed by Martin Fischer who is an americas cup foil designer

Thatspec
354 posts
19 May 2024 12:31PM
Thumbs Up

One big difference, the big boat foils operate parallel with the surface, never healed over as in wingfoiling.

Jethrow
NSW, 1239 posts
19 May 2024 4:46PM
Thumbs Up

Actually the foils on the new AC boats aren't parallel to the surface, visually they're at about 30 degrees!

FranP
76 posts
19 May 2024 2:55PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Thatspec said..
One big difference, the big boat foils operate parallel with the surface, never healed over as in wingfoiling.


This is not relevant, related to foil outlines, IMHO.Wingfoil inclination as you pointed (roll tipically when sailing upwind or in surfing) doe not slow down speed (same drag than when sailing flat) and although glide might look lower, the "foil force vector" (pointing up, parallel to the mast) still compensates sailor inclinated force.

Shlogger
433 posts
20 May 2024 2:32AM
Thumbs Up

And then there's our bulky inflatable wings vs their beautiful foiled sails. ??

miamiwngr
63 posts
20 May 2024 7:15AM
Thumbs Up

www.sail-world.com/photo/346441

Target speeds for the smaller ac40 training boats. Impressive numbers

TooMuchEpoxy
293 posts
20 May 2024 8:07AM
Thumbs Up

Sailing-foiling is absolutely idiotic. The foiling moths are effectively controlled by mechanical computers and the AC boats are controlled by actual computers. Kiter/Wingers/SurfFoilers are the only sailers actually controlling the foil with our brains. I could care less what the AC is doing i quit sailboat racing 10 years ago for a reason!



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Wing Foiling General


"Wing foil brands copying America's Cup desings ?" started by FranP