Forums > Wing Foiling General

Your advice about my next Armstrong foil?

Reply
Created by BubbaNZ 1 month ago, 16 Oct 2024
BubbaNZ
2 posts
16 Oct 2024 5:53AM
Thumbs Up

Keen to hear from folks with Armstrong new MA and HA foils. I am 61, 82kg (180 lbs), 60+ sessions, winging on a large harbour with prevailing gusty NW/N 14-20 knots in 50cm-2m (20-78 inches) chop, occasionally flat water Southerlies, gusty 16-~25 knots. I'm a slow learner & a bit cautious but I can mow the lawn confidently all conditions and starting to gybe. Feel like I'm about to click from a beginner to an intermediate? Now on an Armstrong Wing FG 90L (recent buy), 1550 S1 front foil, 70cm fuse, Flow 235 stab, 82cm mast. All Armstrong. Top speed is consistently near 16 knots according to my Garmin. Would like a faster foil setup with longer glide for fun and to make turns easier. But not too twitchy in the chop? Do you think the new Armstrong MA or instead HA is the way to go? Any thoughts on size and the right stab? Keen to hear your thoughts and experiences and will then ask a local dealer for demos. Thanks!

beached57
83 posts
16 Oct 2024 6:59AM
Thumbs Up

with the ease of the new HAs, i would avoid the MAs altogether. Probably HA 780 or 880 for you. I prefer 60cm fuse, but regardless, make sure your fuse/mast is A+, you'll need that for the new HAs.

eppo
WA, 9540 posts
16 Oct 2024 7:00AM
Thumbs Up

680 / 880 HA combo with 180/140 speed tails is your go. 980 / 780 if you want to go conservative.

Start with 880 / 180 if only buying one setup. Dont underestimate how important the tails are.

HA v2 are superb wings. I've ridden every size. They are very user friendly perfect for where you are at.

No need for MA in your conditions. Pointless unless surf is cranking. Stall speed is useless on them. Not a fan.

simonp
210 posts
16 Oct 2024 7:53AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
eppo said..
No need for MA in your conditions. Pointless unless surf is cranking. Stall speed is useless on them. Not a fan.


Do you mean the MA stall speed is too high, or so low that it is pointless? I would have though MA stall speed < HA.

Oahuwaterwalker
236 posts
16 Oct 2024 8:02AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
simonp said..

eppo said..
No need for MA in your conditions. Pointless unless surf is cranking. Stall speed is useless on them. Not a fan.



Do you mean the MA stall speed is too high, or so low that it is pointless? I would have though MA stall speed < HA.


The MA take more wind and speed to get going than the new HA. They new HA are definitely the ticket. I'm with Eppo, get an 880 and 180 tail and you will be good to go. I'm not a fan of the 140 (about same size as you). Makes things more twitchy than they need to be.

johndg
WA, 214 posts
16 Oct 2024 1:33PM
Thumbs Up

I heard a top rider talking about the Armie MAs saying that are really good a surfing the pocket on waves, but the average rider prefers a lot more glide. He was saying that on waves they dont give a lot of lift so they are easier to control. I dont ride Armie so have no personal experience. The new HA foil advice seems to be on the money.

choosywinger
72 posts
17 Oct 2024 4:42AM
Thumbs Up

Hey Bubba,

I'm relatively early in my winging journey (finishing my third season but I log only 20-30 sessions/year) and I ride Armstrong foils. Season one I rode the HS 1850 and 1550. Season two I purchased MA 1250 and 1050. This season I acquired HA (V2) 1180, 980, and 780. And yes, I have a virulent case of gear acquisition syndrome.

We are almost the same weight. I'm further along on jibing and foot switching than you are but otherwise we are closely matched.

Taking a high level view I agree with the other posters that the HA line is far more user friendly than the MA line (due to lower stall speed and less twitchiness). But I have a few other thoughts to share.

First, regarding top speeds. My top speeds are close to yours on the HS 1550. I was really surprised that they didn't 'magically' shoot up on the HA 980 or 780. They are a little faster but not much. Maybe I lack the moxie to really power up the faster foils. I figure this is something to work on.

Second, regarding jibe progression. You will read that a "glidey-er" foil makes transitions easier and that is certainly true. However, the HS1550 has plenty of glide for easy downwind transitions, provided you enter the turn with enough speed. The upside of sticking with the HS1550 a little longer? The extra stability at lower speeds compared to HA foils makes learning footswaps waaaay easier.

Cheers!

eppo
WA, 9540 posts
17 Oct 2024 5:31AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
choosywinger said..
Hey Bubba,

I'm relatively early in my winging journey (finishing my third season but I log only 20-30 sessions/year) and I ride Armstrong foils. Season one I rode the HS 1850 and 1550. Season two I purchased MA 1250 and 1050. This season I acquired HA (V2) 1180, 980, and 780. And yes, I have a virulent case of gear acquisition syndrome.

We are almost the same weight. I'm further along on jibing and foot switching than you are but otherwise we are closely matched.

Taking a high level view I agree with the other posters that the HA line is far more user friendly than the MA line (due to lower stall speed and less twitchiness). But I have a few other thoughts to share.

First, regarding top speeds. My top speeds are close to yours on the HS 1550. I was really surprised that they didn't 'magically' shoot up on the HA 980 or 780. They are a little faster but not much. Maybe I lack the moxie to really power up the faster foils. I figure this is something to work on.

Second, regarding jibe progression. You will read that a "glidey-er" foil makes transitions easier and that is certainly true. However, the HS1550 has plenty of glide for easy downwind transitions, provided you enter the turn with enough speed. The upside of sticking with the HS1550 a little longer? The extra stability at lower speeds compared to HA foils makes learning footswaps waaaay easier.

Cheers!



What tails are you using and what shim ? But yes you wouldn't call the new HAs "fast" but they can be pushed fast enough.

BubbaNZ
2 posts
17 Oct 2024 6:02AM
Thumbs Up

Really appreciate all your replies - many thanks. Great advice here.

Windoc
402 posts
17 Oct 2024 7:27AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
eppo said..


choosywinger said..
Hey Bubba,

I'm relatively early in my winging journey (finishing my third season but I log only 20-30 sessions/year) and I ride Armstrong foils. Season one I rode the HS 1850 and 1550. Season two I purchased MA 1250 and 1050. This season I acquired HA (V2) 1180, 980, and 780. And yes, I have a virulent case of gear acquisition syndrome.

We are almost the same weight. I'm further along on jibing and foot switching than you are but otherwise we are closely matched.

Taking a high level view I agree with the other posters that the HA line is far more user friendly than the MA line (due to lower stall speed and less twitchiness). But I have a few other thoughts to share.

First, regarding top speeds. My top speeds are close to yours on the HS 1550. I was really surprised that they didn't 'magically' shoot up on the HA 980 or 780. They are a little faster but not much. Maybe I lack the moxie to really power up the faster foils. I figure this is something to work on.

Second, regarding jibe progression. You will read that a "glidey-er" foil makes transitions easier and that is certainly true. However, the HS1550 has plenty of glide for easy downwind transitions, provided you enter the turn with enough speed. The upside of sticking with the HS1550 a little longer? The extra stability at lower speeds compared to HA foils makes learning footswaps waaaay easier.

Cheers!





What tails are you using and what shim ? But yes you wouldn't call the new HAs "fast" but they can be pushed fast enough.



That's what I often tell friends as well: the new Armie HAs are "fast enough" and can be pushed hard, but they prefer being in 3rd/4th gear rather than pushing constantly for speed. The MAs are very quick and love aggression but really lack glide. I'll echo the 880 option. I love the DART, 180, and 205 depending on what feel I want.

SlowlyButSurely
102 posts
17 Oct 2024 1:11PM
Thumbs Up

can somebody comment on the DWP for free riding? I own the HA780 but I am intrigued by the DWP 755 for days when I want to go faster. With the HA780 I can arrive roughly at 23kt but feels quite frenzy up there.
The DWP seem faster, but how more unfriendly they are vs the HAv2? Thanks

choosywinger
72 posts
17 Oct 2024 1:15PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
eppo said..

choosywinger said..
Hey Bubba,

I'm relatively early in my winging journey (finishing my third season but I log only 20-30 sessions/year) and I ride Armstrong foils. Season one I rode the HS 1850 and 1550. Season two I purchased MA 1250 and 1050. This season I acquired HA (V2) 1180, 980, and 780. And yes, I have a virulent case of gear acquisition syndrome.

We are almost the same weight. I'm further along on jibing and foot switching than you are but otherwise we are closely matched.

Taking a high level view I agree with the other posters that the HA line is far more user friendly than the MA line (due to lower stall speed and less twitchiness). But I have a few other thoughts to share.

First, regarding top speeds. My top speeds are close to yours on the HS 1550. I was really surprised that they didn't 'magically' shoot up on the HA 980 or 780. They are a little faster but not much. Maybe I lack the moxie to really power up the faster foils. I figure this is something to work on.

Second, regarding jibe progression. You will read that a "glidey-er" foil makes transitions easier and that is certainly true. However, the HS1550 has plenty of glide for easy downwind transitions, provided you enter the turn with enough speed. The upside of sticking with the HS1550 a little longer? The extra stability at lower speeds compared to HA foils makes learning footswaps waaaay easier.

Cheers!




What tails are you using and what shim ? But yes you wouldn't call the new HAs "fast" but they can be pushed fast enough.


I was riding the 980 and 780 with the 140 tail, no shim.

FarNorthSurfer
162 posts
17 Oct 2024 11:54PM
Thumbs Up

I have not used the new HA so can't comment but have a lot of time in winging on the HS and MA foils. At 93kgs and probably closer to 100kg in Scottish conditions wetsuits I mostly use the MA1225 and find it really good for winging in flat water, swell and DW.
But yes, it would be nice if it had just a bit more glide. I also use the MA1000 and MA1750 depending on wind strength and waves.
My HS1850, 1550v2, 1250 and 1050 just don't get used much anymore unless I am SUP foiling. Recently though I was out winging on the 1550v2 and had a really good session, carving about, easy to ride not really much slower than the MA foils.
Not sure I totally agree about the poor stall speed I can go pretty low on mine and still dig them out of the hole. But maybe it doesn't compare well to the new HA.
One of the big benefits of buying MA is that they are readily available second hand here in the UK for low prices. Guess its due to the new HA being so good but honestly the MA isn't a bad foil and is good fun to ride, its breach recovery is excellent.
So for not a lot of money it might be worth picking up an MA1225 or 1000 and the rear stab you fancy and taking it for a few sessions.
Of course if you can demo that's the way to go, but I live hundreds of miles away from any shops that stock Armie kit so thats not an option for me.

I recently bought the latest FG Wing board, 90 litre and was curious to find that it cruises about a couple of knots faster than the board I have been using for a few years on the same MA1225 foil. I haven't worked that one out yet but have been right at the front of the track on the old board for a while. The MA1225 worked fine at position 8 on the FG with a Glide220.
All the comments above about the stab choice importance are spot on. It is great to be able to tailor the ride to the conditions just by changing stabs though.

And. yes, when I get some cash or see a secondhand one I doubt that I will be able to resist buying HAv2.

HSJ
NT, 33 posts
21 Oct 2024 7:48AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
SlowlyButSurely said..
can somebody comment on the DWP for free riding? I own the HA780 but I am intrigued by the DWP 755 for days when I want to go faster. With the HA780 I can arrive roughly at 23kt but feels quite frenzy up there.
The DWP seem faster, but how more unfriendly they are vs the HAv2? Thanks


I winged dwp 935 first two sessions this weekend both end of day wind usually fades out so was on 7'4 125L with Ventis 7m. Hp795 mast 50 fuse 180 stab red +blue shim.

sess 1 was 7-11kt and I was impressed how fast it went. Good upwind too as wind close to direct on. Ventis helps heaps for upwind.

sess 2 the wind picked up from 8-10 at the start to 13-15 at sunset. So pretty maxed out on my final return to launch site. I stacked 3 times in as many k's from breaching in gusts while chasing chops.

It was a messy water weekend. People bucked off paddleboards and clubbies off their skis. The 935 handled this messy chop with ease. Even when cruising at speed. True to its intended design it loves gliding on the bumps and this is what lights up the session.

i don't have a watch so no idea of speed but felt faster (or maybe just smoother) than 780 which I use on 82L board with 140 stab 60 fuse on a+ mast with 6m Unit. 780 maxes out but 935 had heaps more in the tank but I'd want straps to try sheet in a 7m at 15 knots. Me 77kg.

As to a 755 for speed I would say **** yeah it would be epic. Waves 780. Bumps 755.

Gilderfish
WA, 8 posts
21 Oct 2024 2:31PM
Thumbs Up

I had a very similar foil transition recently. I'm 85kg, have foiled for 2 years now and have an 85 ltr board. I started out on the HS1550 and liked it as a first foil, on a 105 ltr board. A year later I decided I wanted more glide so purchased a MA1225 thinking this would help - but was a little disappointed. I found it fractionally faster but harder to initiate turns and I just never really liked it much and found myself going back to the HS1550 regularly as I learned. I then purchased a new HA780 this year and have been very happy with it selling all my other foils. It needs a tiny bit more wind to get going, and stalls at fractionally faster speed than the others - but honestly it is pretty remarkable at getting and keeping going for it's size. Once up it is so easy to use, it is faster (but not as much as I might like), and turns very easily. The biggest and most noticeable improvement is the glide which is in a different league to either HS1550 or MA1225.

HSJ
NT, 33 posts
22 Oct 2024 8:05AM
Thumbs Up

I reckon the dwp935 feels more like the original HAs, I also have the 1325, than the HAv2s do.

And i found the ma1225 to have similar low end to ha780. using on 795/ 50 fuse/180 or 140 red shim. Light winds and 6m Unit. The 780 turns a bit better but I wouldn't be too disappointed if you can pick up a 1225 for half or less the price of a 780. The 1225 accelerates well when heading back out and jumps nicely too.

skood
7 posts
1 Nov 2024 5:16PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
BubbaNZ said..
Keen to hear from folks with Armstrong new MA and HA foils. I am 61, 82kg (180 lbs), 60+ sessions, winging on a large harbour with prevailing gusty NW/N 14-20 knots in 50cm-2m (20-78 inches) chop, occasionally flat water Southerlies, gusty 16-~25 knots. I'm a slow learner & a bit cautious but I can mow the lawn confidently all conditions and starting to gybe. Feel like I'm about to click from a beginner to an intermediate? Now on an Armstrong Wing FG 90L (recent buy), 1550 S1 front foil, 70cm fuse, Flow 235 stab, 82cm mast. All Armstrong. Top speed is consistently near 16 knots according to my Garmin. Would like a faster foil setup with longer glide for fun and to make turns easier. But not too twitchy in the chop? Do you think the new Armstrong MA or instead HA is the way to go? Any thoughts on size and the right stab? Keen to hear your thoughts and experiences and will then ask a local dealer for demos. Thanks!


One small thing: have you tried shimming your tail? I'm on the same s1 and tail on 60cm fuse and it is so much nicer to ride with ?? shim...

eppo
WA, 9540 posts
1 Nov 2024 7:23PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
BubbaNZ said..
Keen to hear from folks with Armstrong new MA and HA foils. I am 61, 82kg (180 lbs), 60+ sessions, winging on a large harbour with prevailing gusty NW/N 14-20 knots in 50cm-2m (20-78 inches) chop, occasionally flat water Southerlies, gusty 16-~25 knots. I'm a slow learner & a bit cautious but I can mow the lawn confidently all conditions and starting to gybe. Feel like I'm about to click from a beginner to an intermediate? Now on an Armstrong Wing FG 90L (recent buy), 1550 S1 front foil, 70cm fuse, Flow 235 stab, 82cm mast. All Armstrong. Top speed is consistently near 16 knots according to my Garmin. Would like a faster foil setup with longer glide for fun and to make turns easier. But not too twitchy in the chop? Do you think the new Armstrong MA or instead HA is the way to go? Any thoughts on size and the right stab? Keen to hear your thoughts and experiences and will then ask a local dealer for demos. Thanks!


Hey just an update: Mate of mine who's been riding a 1225 for a season and half. I put him on my 880 for a few sessions. He's buying one this weekend - totally stoked. More glide, more speed, more turnability.

Just sone info to help you with your decision.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Wing Foiling General


"Your advice about my next Armstrong foil?" started by BubbaNZ