Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

How did Australia become so expensive ?

Reply
Created by pierrec45 > 9 months ago, 15 Dec 2011
pierrec45
NSW, 2005 posts
16 Dec 2011 2:06AM
Thumbs Up

Guys, guys, guys, most of the points made here are generic, nothing special to Australia.

Big houses, greed, world economy, immigration, pop growth, taking vacations. The same happened in all developed countries, yet Australia has passed the same countries for cost of living in the last 20 years. I find Americans and Canadians have bigger houses on the whole than Aussies. And yeah, right, there is no greed in Europe and N.A, only in Australia...

I sort of see the link between the 17% interest rates during the Hawke era and the subsequent rush to over-commit for over-sized houses. But that cannot explain the whole picture. For instance rates were high in North America at the time as well.

Plus people being strapped into mortgages would not spend as much on other goods, so the prices should not have gone up in other areas.

Perhaps some sort of a coincidence thing between the housing scam and disastrous relaxation related to foreign investments, leading to monopolies, etc.
Not sure.

russh
SA, 3025 posts
16 Dec 2011 8:57AM
Thumbs Up

You sound like my dad 30 years ago

Huge country - transport everything - fuel

Small population - spread over that huge country

Import everything electrical - and have to have the latest

Some of the highest relative wages and workcover costs

Too many layers of government

Export and Make maximum profit for major corps and send profits overseas

Grin and bare it - it aint gonna get cheaper

Its probably worse for those in Sydney - one of the worlds most expensive places to live

If its too much buy a shack in the back of bourke hunt and grow your own food and sell some rabbits for some coopers brew kit




pierrec45
NSW, 2005 posts
16 Dec 2011 10:54AM
Thumbs Up

russh said...

You sound like my dad 30 years ago

Huge country - transport everything - fuel

Small population - spread over that huge country

Import everything electrical - and have to have the latest

Some of the highest relative wages and workcover costs

Too many layers of government

Export and Make maximum profit for major corps and send profits overseas

Grin and bare it - it aint gonna get cheaper

Its probably worse for those in Sydney - one of the worlds most expensive places to live

If its too much buy a shack in the back of bourke hunt and grow your own food and sell some rabbits for some coopers brew kit

Huh, I can afford quite well, I bought my abodes when it was cheaper long time ago, but it still brings the question.

The points you make make no sense: Australia was just as big 30 years ago, look it up. And there were the same layers of gov't when Australia was comparatively cheaper - go ask your daddy.

Have to have the latest - this is common to all western countries. Import everything: always was the case. Australia was also an island then.

Anyone else ?

Gizmo
SA, 2865 posts
16 Dec 2011 10:54AM
Thumbs Up

Comparisons of then and now should always be done as a percentage of your income rather than just $$ amount, yes prices have increased but so have wages.

Its amazing how people can skew things to suit there point of view.
Eg, the road toll... compare the rate 10 years ago to today, if its the same number the toll has actually dropped as the cars on the road have increased.

What is regarded these days as a standard house is a lot different than 10 or 20 years ago.

How much was a home CD player 20 years ago and how much are they now?

Hendrix
VIC, 3 posts
16 Dec 2011 12:06PM
Thumbs Up

A doc once said to me "the world is full of dickheads, idiots and arseholes" pretty close to the truth, good people are a dieing breed! natural selection has changed with mans evolution.

pierrec45
NSW, 2005 posts
16 Dec 2011 12:29PM
Thumbs Up

Gizmo said...

Comparisons of then and now should always be done as a percentage of your income rather than just $$ amount, yes prices have increased but so have wages.

Its amazing how people can skew things to suit there point of view.
Eg, the road toll... compare the rate 10 years ago to today, if its the same number the toll has actually dropped as the cars on the road have increased.

What is regarded these days as a standard house is a lot different than 10 or 20 years ago.

How much was a home CD player 20 years ago and how much are they now?

Nobody's comparing now and then individual prices, of course it doesn't make sense. I mean expandable money, mortgage 10 years that became 25-30 years, that sort of stuff.

Most surveys put Australia as one of the most expensive place in the world to live in now. There was a crossover point at some point in time... Not just housing, but overall.

Anyhow, Mark and KDog had a few good points other than "houses got bigger".

cantswm4sht
VIC, 411 posts
16 Dec 2011 12:47PM
Thumbs Up

Mine only cost $12.oo on ebay


K Dog
VIC, 1847 posts
16 Dec 2011 1:21PM
Thumbs Up

Sandy again says: Abolish neg gearing on housing prorata - only tax concessions for low income housing projects... not for anything else... REGULATE banking and open up more OS banking providers to encourage competition, assist local credit unions with less red tape.... break up the "Too big to fails" so the risk is mitigated across 10 entities and not just one...... DISALLOW controlling foreign ownership of key national assets and services....

evlPanda
NSW, 9202 posts
16 Dec 2011 1:39PM
Thumbs Up

It's expensive because we are used to it. That's it. That's your answer.

I can order anything over the web, get it shipped to me across the world as an individual package, for half the price I can buy it in a shop here, or less. I've ordered a part from Hong Kong that got sent to me for a grand total of 50c, shipping and all. That's cheaper than sending an empty envelope next door.

If I owned a shop here and could sell it for double I would. And they do. They're mad not to if we'll keep on buying it, and we do.

I've watched my local Farmers' Markets go from being really cheap to expensive as it became more popular. Because it could.

Don't go blaming the latest electro gadgets, they are cheap. A TV is still the same price it was in the 80's (could you even buy a 46"?), and we earn a lot more nowadays.

The only reason things are expensive here is because we are used to it, it's what we'll pay, and the business owner is obliged to make as much profit as they can, that's what businesses are for, remember.

I suspect the internet will drastically change things over the next 5 years, as it was supposed to since the mid 90's.

K Dog
VIC, 1847 posts
16 Dec 2011 2:29PM
Thumbs Up

evlPanda said...
I suspect the internet will drastically change things over the next 5 years, as it was supposed to since the mid 90's.


Governments all around the world are starting to see this, or have felt it.... good news for winning for the people..... go the censorship way... and well, may not be so much winning.....

I'd like to think of 2011 the year of revolutions thanks to the internet..twitter, fb... a great medium for communication and to topal old corrupt institutions....

russh
SA, 3025 posts
16 Dec 2011 2:38PM
Thumbs Up

pierrec45 said...

russh said...

You sound like my dad 30 years ago

Huge country - transport everything - fuel

Small population - spread over that huge country

Import everything electrical - and have to have the latest

Some of the highest relative wages and workcover costs

Too many layers of government

Export and Make maximum profit for major corps and send profits overseas

Grin and bare it - it aint gonna get cheaper

Its probably worse for those in Sydney - one of the worlds most expensive places to live

If its too much buy a shack in the back of bourke hunt and grow your own food and sell some rabbits for some coopers brew kit

Huh, I can afford quite well, I bought my abodes when it was cheaper long time ago, but it still brings the question.

The points you make make no sense: Australia was just as big 30 years ago, look it up. And there were the same layers of gov't when Australia was comparatively cheaper - go ask your daddy.

Have to have the latest - this is common to all western countries. Import everything: always was the case. Australia was also an island then.

Anyone else ?



well stop being such an arrogant d!ck and please enlightenus all - its obvious you have all the answers

K Dog
VIC, 1847 posts
16 Dec 2011 3:27PM
Thumbs Up

Lulz.... I love forums.

evlPanda
NSW, 9202 posts
16 Dec 2011 7:07PM
Thumbs Up

This is a perfect example. There is no excuse for the price difference. Nothing.

Albums on iTunes for Australians: $17
For Americans: $10

Solution:

Sign out of your iTunes shop account (Store > Sign Out)
Setup a new account with your address in America.

You can switch back and forth between the accounts. You won't lose anything.



pro tip: you can even use the same gmail account; joe.bloggs@gmail.com = joebloggs@gmail.com = j.o.e.bloggs@gmail.com, gmail ignores the dot.

FormulaNova
WA, 14808 posts
16 Dec 2011 6:56PM
Thumbs Up

MrRubberbely said...

1. Negative Gearing
2. Negative Gearing
3. Negative Gearing

Dumbest tax policy ever. But now impossible for any gov't to change


The answer to fixing this is to keep negative gearing and allow it for owner occupiers as well. This will make it more cost effective for locals to buy houses as they can deduct some of the costs.

This will actually increase the cost of houses, but make it more affordable by allowing tax breaks.

Investors won't complain too much as they get to keep their tax breaks too.

Who would lose? Overseas investors that don't have the same tax breaks.... hmmmm....

pierrec45
NSW, 2005 posts
17 Dec 2011 12:37AM
Thumbs Up

russh said...

pierrec45 said...

russh said...

You sound like my dad 30 years ago

Huge country - transport everything - fuel

Small population - spread over that huge country

Import everything electrical - and have to have the latest

Some of the highest relative wages and workcover costs

Too many layers of government

Export and Make maximum profit for major corps and send profits overseas

Grin and bare it - it aint gonna get cheaper

Its probably worse for those in Sydney - one of the worlds most expensive places to live

If its too much buy a shack in the back of bourke hunt and grow your own food and sell some rabbits for some coopers brew kit

Huh, I can afford quite well, I bought my abodes when it was cheaper long time ago, but it still brings the question.

The points you make make no sense: Australia was just as big 30 years ago, look it up. And there were the same layers of gov't when Australia was comparatively cheaper - go ask your daddy.

Have to have the latest - this is common to all western countries. Import everything: always was the case. Australia was also an island then.

Anyone else ?

well stop being such an arrogant d!ck and please enlightenus all - its obvious you have all the answers

What makes you think I have answers? I was asking a dinkum question.

I was only pointing out to you that the size of Australia has not changed that dramatically in the last 30 years, that's all.

Anyhow, back to actual contributors on comparative CHANGES in the last 30 years, we're getting actual interesting clues, with a couple of posters (Formula above, Mark, couple others) relating negative gearing to housing to Hawke's changes, etc. Interesting stuff.

I'll bet you there's no real equivalent in the US, Canada, UK, Europe, therefore looks like good ideas...

Toots
WA, 271 posts
20 Dec 2011 4:00AM
Thumbs Up

evlPanda said...

It's expensive because we are used to it. That's it. That's your answer.

I can order anything over the web, get it shipped to me across the world as an individual package, for half the price I can buy it in a shop here, or less. I've ordered a part from Hong Kong that got sent to me for a grand total of 50c, shipping and all. That's cheaper than sending an empty envelope next door.

If I owned a shop here and could sell it for double I would. And they do. They're mad not to if we'll keep on buying it, and we do.

I've watched my local Farmers' Markets go from being really cheap to expensive as it became more popular. Because it could.

Don't go blaming the latest electro gadgets, they are cheap. A TV is still the same price it was in the 80's (could you even buy a 46"?), and we earn a lot more nowadays.

The only reason things are expensive here is because we are used to it, it's what we'll pay, and the business owner is obliged to make as much profit as they can, that's what businesses are for, remember.

I suspect the internet will drastically change things over the next 5 years, as it was supposed to since the mid 90's.


Too True.

Aussies are Ignorami to the max, Its a status symbol to pay $40 for something worth $2. Just ask Maddhison and Corhey, Joel and Jai love tellin the troof ;)

HugoH
WA, 17 posts
18 Jan 2012 1:10PM
Thumbs Up

Subsided first homes, booming prices on oil and minerals.



Combine that with a government that wont stop grant mining and drilling permissions until whole Australia looks like a Swiss cheese and the coastline is covered with oil and u have a pretty fast running economy that depends on China.


Australia is pretty much like Norway, everything is expensive but it does not matter since everybody earns ****loads and many of the lower paid jobs are done by immigrants.

Closed
VIC, 144 posts
18 Jan 2012 4:58PM
Thumbs Up

evlPanda said...

EVERYTHING is half price overseas.

It's still half price if you post it across, as an individual item. I don't know what excuse retail has that isn't bull****.


Many products are more than overprice and then sold a huge discounts to make the buyer feel pleased. The price paid after discount is only what the product should have been worth to start with.



Dazza65
QLD, 389 posts
18 Jan 2012 4:30PM
Thumbs Up

scott265 said...

evlPanda said...

EVERYTHING is half price overseas.

It's still half price if you post it across, as an individual item. I don't know what excuse retail has that isn't bull****.


Many products are more than overprice and then sold a huge discounts to make the buyer feel pleased. The price paid after discount is only what the product should have been worth to start with.




So true, you reckon these morons who line up for hours outside Myer waiting for the 'Sales' are getting bargains...of course not. Myer, DJ's etc buy in a heap of cheap quality stuff for the sales, are able to price it lower than the normal stuff and buyers thinks they are getting a bargain but in reality are paying over the odds anyway

choco
SA, 4037 posts
18 Jan 2012 5:38PM
Thumbs Up

Move to SA highest Taxed state in OZ for number of years running

My thought, just don't buy anything and save your money!

Stuthepirate
SA, 3590 posts
18 Jan 2012 7:32PM
Thumbs Up




pierrec45
NSW, 2005 posts
18 Jan 2012 9:13PM
Thumbs Up

Pretty sure it started way before her though
(as compared to other countries).

kiteboy dave
QLD, 6525 posts
18 Jan 2012 9:56PM
Thumbs Up

HugoH said...

Subsided first homes, booming prices on oil and minerals.


WTF you mean my first home is going to SINK !!!?!?! What do I do about it?

btw this thread had wheezed it's last, why resurrect it a month later?

Simondo
VIC, 8020 posts
18 Jan 2012 11:06PM
Thumbs Up




A message from Rural Australia to Julia !

Subsonic
WA, 3151 posts
18 Jan 2012 8:47PM
Thumbs Up

IMO there's heaps of reasons above why the overall cost of living has risen, inflation etc, but I do really hate that nowdays there's people that own 5+ negatively geared houses and others who cant afford 1 area of living space to live in.

It's just plain greedy!

ginger pom
VIC, 1746 posts
19 Jan 2012 8:17AM
Thumbs Up

It's only expensive if you buy stuff.

Gunna1
154 posts
19 Jan 2012 9:26AM
Thumbs Up

Another reason could be that we allow all our assets to be flogged off and we "locals" get the scraps. On 6PR talkback yesterday they had the head of the farmers federation explaining why we are paying so much for local produce and why these costs will skyrocket in the near future. The government, in their wisdom, allows any foreign purchase of land under $231 million (per purchase) virtually unregulated so any country can buy Ozzy farms freehold, put in their own workers, plant crops, harvest and send the produce back to their country for nothing. This is happening all over Oz and farms are being purchased at an alarming rate. Can't blame the battling Oz farmer who has been taxed and regulated out of business and takes the money and retires. In a very short time we will have a lot of our farmland sending good produce overseas for next to nothing and the demand increasing here which will send the prices through the roof.

evlPanda
NSW, 9202 posts
19 Jan 2012 12:44PM
Thumbs Up

Gunna1 said...

Another reason could be that we allow all our assets to be flogged off and we "locals" get the scraps. On 6PR talkback yesterday they had the head of the farmers federation explaining why we are paying so much for local produce and why these costs will skyrocket in the near future. The government, in their wisdom, allows any foreign purchase of land under $231 million (per purchase) virtually unregulated so any country can buy Ozzy farms freehold, put in their own workers, plant crops, harvest and send the produce back to their country for nothing. This is happening all over Oz and farms are being purchased at an alarming rate. Can't blame the battling Oz farmer who has been taxed and regulated out of business and takes the money and retires. In a very short time we will have a lot of our farmland sending good produce overseas for next to nothing and the demand increasing here which will send the prices through the roof.


If the prices go through the roof here why would these foreign farmers send the produce overseas when they could simply sell them here for more? Eh?

Ados
WA, 421 posts
19 Jan 2012 11:00AM
Thumbs Up

Gunna1 said...

Another reason could be that we allow all our assets to be flogged off and we "locals" get the scraps. On 6PR talkback yesterday they had the head of the farmers federation explaining why we are paying so much for local produce and why these costs will skyrocket in the near future. The government, in their wisdom, allows any foreign purchase of land under $231 million (per purchase) virtually unregulated so any country can buy Ozzy farms freehold, put in their own workers, plant crops, harvest and send the produce back to their country for nothing. This is happening all over Oz and farms are being purchased at an alarming rate. Can't blame the battling Oz farmer who has been taxed and regulated out of business and takes the money and retires. In a very short time we will have a lot of our farmland sending good produce overseas for next to nothing and the demand increasing here which will send the prices through the roof.


do you have any examples of this?

Just asking.

Skid
QLD, 1499 posts
19 Jan 2012 1:41PM
Thumbs Up

choco said...

Move to SA highest Taxed state in OZ for number of years running
....


I moved from SA a while ago. Give my regards to Tim Marcus-Clark...



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"How did Australia become so expensive ?" started by pierrec45