Search for a Location
  Clear Recents
Metro
South West
Central West
North West
  Surf Cameras
  Safety Bay Camera
Metro
North
Mid North
Illawarra
South Coast
Metro
West Coast
East Coast
Brisbane
Far North
Central Coast
Sunshine Coast
Gold Coast
Hobart
West Coast
North Coast
East Coast
Recent
Western Australia
New South Wales
Victoria
South Australia
Queensland
Northern Territory
Tasmania
  My Favourites
  Reverse Arrows
General
Gps & Speed Sailing
Wave Sailing
Foiling
Gear Reviews
Lost & Found
Windsurfing WA
Windsurfing NSW
Windsurfing QLD
Windsurfing Victoria
Windsurfing SA
Windsurfing Tasmania
General
Gear Reviews
Foiling
Newbies / Tips & Tricks
Lost & Found
Western Australia
New South Wales
Queensland
Victoria
South Australia
Tasmania
General
Foiling
Board Talk & Reviews
Wing Foiling
All
Windsurfing
Kitesurfing
Surfing
Longboarding
Stand Up Paddle
Wing Foiling
Sailing
  Active Topics
  Subscribed Topics
  Rules & Guidelines
Login
Lost My Details!
Join! (Its Free)
  Search for a Location
  Clear Recents
Metro
South West
Central West
North West
Surf Cameras
Safety Bay Camera
Metro
North
Mid North
Illawarra
South Coast
Metro
West Coast
East Coast
Brisbane
Far North
Central Coast
Sunshine Coast
Gold Coast
Hobart
West Coast
North Coast
East Coast
Recent
Western Australia
New South Wales
Victoria
South Australia
Queensland
Northern Territory
Tasmania
  My Favourites
  Reverse Arrows
All
Windsurfing
Kitesurfing
Surfing
Longboarding
Stand Up Paddle
Wing Foiling
Sailing
Active Topics
Subscribed Topics
Forum Rules
Login
Lost My Details!
Join! (Its Free)

Forums > Land Yacht Sailing General

International Mini 5.6.........split

Reply
Created by Gizmo > 9 months ago, 9 Dec 2014
landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
4 Jan 2015 10:38AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
kiwi307 said..
There are other reasons why some of us drift away Paul. In my case the bagging that I got for "pushing the envelope" and also the realisation that spending a load of time and money to travel to events where there was no wind and race officers insisting on running races
made me realise it wasn't the fun it used to be.
For me it got very close to throwing a Mini together, then I took a good hard look at the "rule" and figured it could very quickly go pear shaped.
Remember that I was on the International committee that met in the UK and re-wrote the 5 rules after listening to all input. It actually made my own yacht of the time illegal, but for the overall good compromises had to be made. My only regret on those rules, pretty much what the are now, is that we did not push harder for a diameter restriction 650mm to stay in place.
Is it too late for the mini. IMHO it is not, but there must be a will to want to have a workable outcome. Right now it's a hotch potch of little bits which were aired on this forum, 2 divisions might work, but again it would be very nice to see what the "spirit" division has in mind. How dou define lay down for example when the cloth seat of a Blokart allows you to snuggle down or sit up as required? Boom height could perhaps deal with that??
Anyway, recriminations will achieve nothing. Only way forward, as I said above is with a will to come up with a workable solution. Even the LLM would not fit what Andy has in mind I suspect, and IMHO it hardly "pushes the envelope".
FWIW I predate both you and 772! (Possible Gizmo too :) )


if i recall correctly , you still owe me a long push at altitude!!!!! on a light wind day.
I do find it odd myself that the spirit class would basically consist of designs , which although nice , didnt really get anybody excited about minis.
it was only when we started playing with the yachts within a small wheelbase and "pushing that envelope" that the mini class blossomed. now we are gagging it . go figure?
as a builder the small sit up idea has no appeal to me . you are right about laying in a blowie to. i like to have my feet almost touching the front wheel wheel when sailing in light wheels( theres a hint for production competitors).
i did consider the seat hieght restriction the US was talking about but found it was a bit too low, making a full length seat that was light AND strong in the right places too hard ive ended with new seat that is 220mm on the rails and higher again in the bow..
seats with little or no back are not really so good on salt. in fact id put them down as dangerous.
my last major injury was getting shot out the back of a yacht with no back .
. and no the LLM wouldnt fit and theres no way im changing that awesome little design.
for all the design changes weve made in the last few years , at our last meet 2 of the best yachts in the fleet with really strng winds were the esperence lads in LLM's with the standard seats. the only reason they didnt win was due to `1 jumped start
and that happens to us all

blake52
123 posts
5 Jan 2015 3:32AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
kiwi307 said..
Clem, yes you have a trailer and the place to store all your yachts and the trailer too.
Spare a moment to consider that not all the rest of the world is like that. Many of the Brits are very lucky to have a single car garage. Workshop area, no chance. The same applies to many in the US and Europe. If you can remember to when you were starting out you stayed with me in Auckland where I had a single car garage with the laundry in it too. That is not uncommon and why there are a number of people for who m the mini in whatever form is a good choice.
I agree with your thoughts over "horses for courses" I can also remember when you said the Blokart would never be a choice for you :).
Blake, is it possible to set up something smaller, as we sailed somewhere South LA (mid 80s) for an hour or two and invite those folks down for the time? Sadly most people need the sport taken to them rather than the other way round. Sure, you have many magnificent places to sail, the average Joe won't travel distances to get a go and most of those places I sailed in the US are hours out of town.
Many of those schools and rental outlets in particularly, France and Belgium are funding assisted but the original idea came from individuals and clubs with a will to share their sport.




Select to expand quote
Clemco said..
Ah yes I do remember those days. Built my first Class5 in the lounge of my two bedroom flat from materials from the local dump. And it was a very good one thanks to your excellent advice NZ307. Had no garage or trailer or much money for that matter. Carried the C5 in the back of my Transit van or on the roof of my girlfriends stationwagon. Yes those were fun days.


...You are right about travel...I know better than most with all the close venues politically unavailable, I typically drive all night (or more) before an event, but there is something else going on. Las Vegas is a fairly big city with 4 or 5 sailable lakes within an hour's drive and never far from civilization's comforts and yet there are only a handful of landsailors there. If I don't make arrangements in advance, I could easily sail all day at any of those lakes and never see another sailor. I've been to well-publicized mini events near LV where only 3 other people showed up. There are far more water sailors in the desert than landsailors. If I was sensible, I'd probably just give up the dirt and get a water boat. If the Mini class (US or International) ever stabilizes and commercial boats become easily available, maybe it could wake the sport up here, but decades of Manta production has left hundreds hanging in garages all over America, but the only time you see more than one or two is at big, national events. Similarly, BloKart sold a lot of boats here, but where are they?
I love this sport, so I have a hard time admitting that it has a limited appeal. I would love to believe that if we could just get the right class of boat organized for the "masses" that they would show up and come back again, but I kind of don't believe that's the problem.

aus230
WA, 1660 posts
5 Jan 2015 3:33PM
Thumbs Up


i guess I am lucky that I am a member of probably the most successful land yacht club in Australia. What has made it that way.
My thoughts.

they have a ridged race program that is set and stuck to each year .(if it was not organised I would have lost interest)
They repurchase yachts from people who leave the sport and on sell them to new members.
There is a core group that have stayed with the club for many years.
Up to recently they had a building committee to build new yachts as required

It is hard to attract new members but manage to attract and maintain some each year, seem to have around 10-15 class5 turning up to race each week and last week we had 7, 5.6 mini racing with several more under construction or waiting for parts to complete. All the minies are enclosed and a fair bit of moderfication to get the best out of them taking place. All the class5 and minis are home built , as for me I love building and tinkering as much as sailing. I have never been taught anything I do, Use you tube a lot to learn and guess willing to give it a go.

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
5 Jan 2015 7:35PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
blake52 said..




...You are right about travel...I know better than most with all the close venues politically unavailable, I typically drive all night (or more) before an event, but there is something else going on. Las Vegas is a fairly big city with 4 or 5 sailable lakes within an hour's drive and never far from civilization's comforts and yet there are only a handful of landsailors there. If I don't make arrangements in advance, I could easily sail all day at any of those lakes and never see another sailor. I've been to well-publicized mini events near LV where only 3 other people showed up. There are far more water sailors in the desert than landsailors. If I was sensible, I'd probably just give up the dirt and get a water boat. If the Mini class (US or International) ever stabilizes and commercial boats become easily available, maybe it could wake the sport up here, but decades of Manta production has left hundreds hanging in garages all over America, but the only time you see more than one or two is at big, national events. Similarly, BloKart sold a lot of boats here, but where are they?
I love this sport, so I have a hard time admitting that it has a limited appeal. I would love to believe that if we could just get the right class of boat organized for the "masses" that they would show up and come back again, but I kind of don't believe that's the problem.


you could just change a few words to the australian/NZ equivalents in that speech and you would sum it up for us all

barney831
110 posts
7 Jan 2015 7:45AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
blake52 said..

kiwi307 said..
Clem, yes you have a trailer and the place to store all your yachts and the trailer too.
Spare a moment to consider that not all the rest of the world is like that. Many of the Brits are very lucky to have a single car garage. Workshop area, no chance. The same applies to many in the US and Europe. If you can remember to when you were starting out you stayed with me in Auckland where I had a single car garage with the laundry in it too. That is not uncommon and why there are a number of people for who m the mini in whatever form is a good choice.
I agree with your thoughts over "horses for courses" I can also remember when you said the Blokart would never be a choice for you :).
Blake, is it possible to set up something smaller, as we sailed somewhere South LA (mid 80s) for an hour or two and invite those folks down for the time? Sadly most people need the sport taken to them rather than the other way round. Sure, you have many magnificent places to sail, the average Joe won't travel distances to get a go and most of those places I sailed in the US are hours out of town.
Many of those schools and rental outlets in particularly, France and Belgium are funding assisted but the original idea came from individuals and clubs with a will to share their sport.

Clemco said..
Ah yes I do remember those days. Built my first Class5 in the lounge of my two bedroom flat from materials from the local dump. And it was a very good one thanks to your excellent advice NZ307. Had no garage or trailer or much money for that matter. Carried the C5 in the back of my Transit van or on the roof of my girlfriends stationwagon. Yes those were fun days.


...You are right about travel...I know better than most with all the close venues politically unavailable, I typically drive all night (or more) before an event, but there is something else going on. Las Vegas is a fairly big city with 4 or 5 sailable lakes within an hour's drive and never far from civilization's comforts and yet there are only a handful of landsailors there. If I don't make arrangements in advance, I could easily sail all day at any of those lakes and never see another sailor. I've been to well-publicized mini events near LV where only 3 other people showed up. There are far more water sailors in the desert than landsailors. If I was sensible, I'd probably just give up the dirt and get a water boat. If the Mini class (US or International) ever stabilizes and commercial boats become easily available, maybe it could wake the sport up here, but decades of Manta production has left hundreds hanging in garages all over America, but the only time you see more than one or two is at big, national events. Similarly, BloKart sold a lot of boats here, but where are they?
I love this sport, so I have a hard time admitting that it has a limited appeal. I would love to believe that if we could just get the right class of boat organized for the "masses" that they would show up and come back again, but I kind of don't believe that's the problem.



I'm with Sabydent on this one. What is all the fuss about? If only 3 minis show up for a well-publicized event near LV, why is there ANY discussion of splitting the mini class when there is not enough minis now for a proper race?

Regarding the NALSA event at Ivanpah in March, will there be I5.6 mini races held there?

US772
332 posts
8 Jan 2015 12:33AM
Thumbs Up

At last years ALC event at Ivanpah they ran the American Mini class and International mini class. I am assuming the same will happen again.

barney831
110 posts
8 Jan 2015 2:35AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
US772 said..
At last years ALC event at Ivanpah they ran the American Mini class and International mini class. I am assuming the same will happen again.



Thanks, John. Are you going?

Were the two mini classes run together or separately? If together, which class dominated the results? How many mini were in each class?

kiwi307
488 posts
8 Jan 2015 3:19AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
landyacht said..

kiwi307 said..
There are other reasons why some of us drift away Paul. In my case the bagging that I got for "pushing the envelope" and also the realisation that spending a load of time and money to travel to events where there was no wind and race officers insisting on running races
made me realise it wasn't the fun it used to be.
For me it got very close to throwing a Mini together, then I took a good hard look at the "rule" and figured it could very quickly go pear shaped.
Remember that I was on theInternational committee that met in the UK and re-wrote the 5 rules after listening to all input. It actually made my own yacht of the time illegal, but for the overall good compromises had to be made. My only regret on those rules, pretty much what the are now, is that we did not push harder for a diameter restriction 650mm to stay in place.
Is it too late for the mini. IMHO it is not, but there must be a will to want to have a workable outcome. Right now it's a hotch potch of little bits which were aired on this forum, 2 divisions might work, but again it would be very nice to see what the "spirit" division has in mind. How dou define lay down for example when the cloth seat of a Blokart allows you to snuggle down or sit up as required? Boom height could perhaps deal with that??
Anyway, recriminations will achieve nothing. Only way forward, as I said above is with a will to come up with a workable solution. Even the LLM would not fit what Andy has in mind I suspect, and IMHO it hardly "pushes the envelope".
FWIW I predate both you and 772! (Possible Gizmo too :) )



if i recall correctly , you still owe me a long push at altitude!!!!! on a light wind day.
I do find it odd myself that the spirit class would basically consist of designs , which although nice , didnt really get anybody excited about minis.
it was only when we started playing with the yachts within a small wheelbase and "pushing that envelope" that the mini class blossomed. now we are gagging it . go figure?
as a builder the small sit up idea has no appeal to me . you are right about laying in a blowie to. i like to have my feet almost touching the front wheel wheel when sailing in light wheels( theres a hint for production competitors).
i did consider the seat hieght restriction the US was talking about but found it was a bit too low, making a full length seat that was light AND strong in the right places too hard ive ended with new seat that is 220mm on the rails and higher again in the bow..
seats with little or no back are not really so good on salt. in fact id put them down as dangerous.
my last major injury was getting shot out the back of a yacht with no back .
. and no the LLM wouldnt fit and theres no way im changing that awesome little design.
for all the design changes weve made in the last few years , at our last meet 2 of the best yachts in the fleet with really strng winds were the esperence lads in LLM's with the standard seats. the only reason they didnt win was due to `1 jumped start
and that happens to us all


Gee I wish this site (like most others) would let you extract just the bit you want to quote!
Long push at altitude Paul indeed. Obviously the endless debate about your silly duck waddling still persists! A few seconds of running push will always have a better outcome than endless waddling, and you know it. Unless of course you have people who don't know what a "sailable direction" means and push dead upwind in the middle of an orange zone. :)

barney831
110 posts
8 Jan 2015 4:51AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
barney831 said..

US772 said..
At last years ALC event at Ivanpah they ran the American Mini class and International mini class. I am assuming the same will happen again.


Thanks, John. Are you going?
Were the two mini classes run together or separately? If together, which class dominated the results? How many mini were in each class?



Sorry, John, the information that I wanted is on the NALSA site. I should have looked before I leaped.

US772
332 posts
8 Jan 2015 5:01AM
Thumbs Up

Barney, what happens is there will be more minis in the original 5.6 mini class and fewer in the US mini class because the original mini class has less rules. The same thing will happen in class 2 this year for the same reason.

Windcrazy
89 posts
8 Jan 2015 5:54AM
Thumbs Up

Well here goes nothin. Mini 5.6 another class, another set of rules, another pain in the butt for new people. Remember, to many cooks always spoil the soup. I first got interested in land sailing when I was about 10 yrs old. Took a bed sheet off the clothes line, put it on my push cart and had a hell of a good time for about 3 hrs. Caught holy hell when I got home but it was worth it. That was 57 years ago. 15 yrs ago I bought my 1st landsailer, sirooco sprint. It was a major purchase for me and my wife thought I was nuts. I haven't sailed any thing since I was ten years old. Went to the local high school parking lot and sailed (not well) till it got dark. I was now hooked. The person I bought the boat from said they had freindly get togethers at ivanpah twice a year and if we would like to join them we could. Since the year 2000 we have went to the dry lake twice a year for a freindly get together. Been over to nalsa event once and was not felt very welcome. I now own 3 sailers, 2 sprints, 1 twin and soon to have another midsize to my collection. My personal novice opinion of the 5.6 class it will end up like the rest. I think you need to put novice sailers in a class of their own and exsperiance sailers in a class by themselves. Anyhow, that's my 2 cents for what it's worth.

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
10 Jan 2015 7:45PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
kiwi307 said..




Gee I wish this site (like most others) would let you extract just the bit you want to quote!
Long push at altitude Paul indeed. Obviously the endless debate about your silly duck waddling still persists! A few seconds of running push will always have a better outcome than endless waddling, and you know it. Unless of course you have people who don't know what a "sailable direction" means and push dead upwind in the middle of an orange zone. :)


extracted just like that
. . im refererring to one of those pushes where a desperate to win sailor has run pushed his yacht so far hes collapsed on a claypan and an friendly aussie has put him in his standart and pushe him off in a sailable direction(instead of staright to the mark
the poor soul has then got some speed up and completed his race

kiwi307
488 posts
11 Jan 2015 7:41AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
landyacht said..



kiwi307 said..




Gee I wish this site (like most others) would let you extract just the bit you want to quote!
Long push at altitude Paul indeed. Obviously the endless debate about your silly duck waddling still persists! A few seconds of running push will always have a better outcome than endless waddling, and you know it. Unless of course you have people who don't know what a "sailable direction" means and push dead upwind in the middle of an orange zone. :)





extracted just like that
. . im refererring to one of those pushes where a desperate to win sailor has run pushed his yacht so far hes collapsed on a claypan and an friendly aussie has put him in his standart and pushe him off in a sailable direction(instead of staright to the mark
the poor soul has then got some speed up and completed his race




So, why was he not disqualified from attempting to push in an unsailable direction? The folly of wearing full face helmets in 30 plus degrees. Is that considered as pay back for an unpaid apartment in a certain English town that was settled on an aussies behalf?

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
16 Jan 2015 10:05PM
Thumbs Up

I recall that cockroach infested wardrobe in blackpool vividly , not fondly. the smell of my socks that had melted when the heater flared up filling the room with an aroma of burning nylon ,which helped as the CO had no odour. i also recall that the rent had been paid so it may appear the owner diddled an gullible aussie and a trusting kiwi

Sylk
WA, 215 posts
17 Jan 2015 8:41AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
kiwi307 said..

Gee I wish this site (like most others) would let you extract just the bit you want to quote!


It does just click quote then delete the bits that are not relevant.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Land Yacht Sailing General


"International Mini 5.6.........split" started by Gizmo