Forums > Sailing General

Best timber to use for stringers

Reply
Created by HG02 > 9 months ago, 15 Jul 2014
HG02
VIC, 5814 posts
15 Jul 2014 12:49PM
Thumbs Up

I. Am about to line the cabin roof and wanted some advise on what wood to use as roof stringers I'll be fibreglassing or epoxy

LooseChange
NSW, 2140 posts
15 Jul 2014 2:44PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
HG02 said..
I. Am about to line the cabin roof and wanted some advise on what wood to use as roof stringers I'll be fibreglassing or epoxy


Will the timber need to any load bearing? If yes then you need something with a bit strength, in your part of the world Mountain Ash or Tassie Oak if not load bearing then something nice and light, Cedar, Douglas Fir or even Paulonia.

fibreglassing or epoxy ... I don't understand what you are saying, because if you are just substituting epoxy resin for another type of resin, it's still "fibreglassing" and if you are fibreglassing over these stringers then you will have to use epoxy as neither polyester or vinylester will adhere to wood with any degree of strength.

aus005
TAS, 514 posts
15 Jul 2014 3:03PM
Thumbs Up

i assume stringers are to take the screws and or joints for lining boards ply what ever i would use something lite and cheap say treated pine it will take a course threaded screw well

HG02
VIC, 5814 posts
15 Jul 2014 8:12PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
LooseChange said..

HG02 said..
I. Am about to line the cabin roof and wanted some advise on what wood to use as roof stringers I'll be fibreglassing or epoxy



Will the timber need to any load bearing? If yes then you need something with a bit strength, in your part of the world Mountain Ash or Tassie Oak if not load bearing then something nice and light, Cedar, Douglas Fir or even Paulonia.

fibreglassing or epoxy ... I don't understand what you are saying, because if you are just substituting epoxy resin for another type of resin, it's still "fibreglassing" and if you are fibreglassing over these stringers then you will have to use epoxy as neither polyester or vinylester will adhere to wood with any degree of strength.


I am lining the cabin fiberglass roof with western red cedar V joint 85 wide x 10 mm thick

LooseChange
NSW, 2140 posts
15 Jul 2014 8:47PM
Thumbs Up

You would get better stiffness and integrity using ply wood rather than using planks and a neater looking finish.

SandS
VIC, 5904 posts
15 Jul 2014 9:09PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
HG02 said..

LooseChange said..


HG02 said..
I. Am about to line the cabin roof and wanted some advise on what wood to use as roof stringers I'll be fibreglassing or epoxy




Will the timber need to any load bearing? If yes then you need something with a bit strength, in your part of the world Mountain Ash or Tassie Oak if not load bearing then something nice and light, Cedar, Douglas Fir or even Paulonia.

fibreglassing or epoxy ... I don't understand what you are saying, because if you are just substituting epoxy resin for another type of resin, it's still "fibreglassing" and if you are fibreglassing over these stringers then you will have to use epoxy as neither polyester or vinylester will adhere to wood with any degree of strength.



I am lining the cabin fiberglass roof with western red cedar V joint 85 wide x 10 mm thick


curving both ways ? if so will be a struggle !!!!!

HG02
VIC, 5814 posts
15 Jul 2014 10:12PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
SandS said..

HG02 said..


LooseChange said..



HG02 said..
I. Am about to line the cabin roof and wanted some advise on what wood to use as roof stringers I'll be fibreglassing or epoxy





Will the timber need to any load bearing? If yes then you need something with a bit strength, in your part of the world Mountain Ash or Tassie Oak if not load bearing then something nice and light, Cedar, Douglas Fir or even Paulonia.

fibreglassing or epoxy ... I don't understand what you are saying, because if you are just substituting epoxy resin for another type of resin, it's still "fibreglassing" and if you are fibreglassing over these stringers then you will have to use epoxy as neither polyester or vinylester will adhere to wood with any degree of strength.




I am lining the cabin fiberglass roof with western red cedar V joint 85 wide x 10 mm thick



curving both ways ? if so will be a struggle !!!!!


No its really only curved port to starboard Im running the cedar from the stern to the forward cabin



mangrovefrog
VIC, 80 posts
16 Jul 2014 12:04AM
Thumbs Up

Each board/s would have to be firmly clamped until epoxy cures. If thats what you mean.
Id start from the sides and then custom fit the middle board/s. Maybe?
My roof is a half inch plywood sandwich, so much easier if you could screw each board on.

aus005
TAS, 514 posts
16 Jul 2014 7:33AM
Thumbs Up

how about you tell us you ideas on how you are going about this hg seems to be a bit of confusion

Ramona
NSW, 7570 posts
16 Jul 2014 8:44AM
Thumbs Up

If you put up battens then 1/2 inch planks is this going to give enough headroom. Some of your guests may be taller! Friend of mine years ago built a Swanson 42 from the moulds and installed a timber deck. He was short and the deck beams caught me about mid forehead!

HG02
VIC, 5814 posts
16 Jul 2014 10:48AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Ramona said...
If you put up battens then 1/2 inch planks is this going to give enough headroom. Some of your guests may be taller! Friend of mine years ago built a Swanson 42 from the moulds and installed a timber deck. He was short and the deck beams caught me about mid forehead!


I'll take that into my build thanks Ramona
Bunnings have a acrylic sheet have been thinking of a 300cm wide
Strip down the middle then the western red cedar either side apply the sheet directly to the cabin roof maybe with sikaflex to break it up. And also to give
Good height while walking through the cabin

Maybe .500cm Wide

LooseChange
NSW, 2140 posts
16 Jul 2014 12:43PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Ramona said..
If you put up battens then 1/2 inch planks is this going to give enough headroom. Some of your guests may be taller! Friend of mine years ago built a Swanson 42 from the moulds and installed a timber deck. He was short and the deck beams caught me about mid forehead!


Murray never thought he was short .... at least not till you told him ....

whiteout
QLD, 264 posts
16 Jul 2014 3:09PM
Thumbs Up




Lamipanel is good for boat interiors with cedar battens is good to use to screw into and you use mega proxy to glue it or liquid nails

Ramona
NSW, 7570 posts
16 Jul 2014 6:17PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
LooseChange said..

Ramona said..
If you put up battens then 1/2 inch planks is this going to give enough headroom. Some of your guests may be taller! Friend of mine years ago built a Swanson 42 from the moulds and installed a timber deck. He was short and the deck beams caught me about mid forehead!



Murray never thought he was short .... at least not till you told him ....


That's right, and his mate Bruce was the same height. Probably not thinking resale at the time.

LooseChange
NSW, 2140 posts
16 Jul 2014 6:20PM
Thumbs Up

Looking at the picture of the ceiling in question seems to be an easy enough job to roughly sand then screed it with fairing compound, sand to a smooth finish and finally paint with high gloss paint ... job done. No loss of interior height, easy to maintain and keep clean and as bright as daylight. Why make the inside look like a dark hole?

Karsten
NSW, 331 posts
16 Jul 2014 8:14PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
LooseChange said..
an easy enough job to roughly sand then screed it with fairing compound, sand to a smooth finish and finally paint with high gloss paint ...



(chuckle chuckle) ... I've tackled those "sanding, fairing, sanding and painting" little two-hour jobs before; and two weekends later I'm still sanding and filling little divots. Maybe I should just have used matt paint.

Still, Loosechange's is a good idea. Only caveat would be to keep in mind that GRP boats flex quite a bit in heavy seas, and you'd want to keep the fairing layer thin enough so it doesn't crack on you.

Talking about fairing compounds - has anyone here used a fairing or filling compound that can flex instead of being brittle?

SandS
VIC, 5904 posts
16 Jul 2014 8:26PM
Thumbs Up


my two bobs worth , i would go lami panel direct stick . then at least when decide to add a item to the cabin top you can bolt straight through . nothing worse than a double skin ceiling imo .....................................

mangrovefrog
VIC, 80 posts
16 Jul 2014 8:48PM
Thumbs Up

Mine's lined with spongy foam underlayed suede vinyl with teak battens..
Condensations a big problem in our climate, all the gelcoated areas, windows and hatches drip like rainforests..

HG02
VIC, 5814 posts
16 Jul 2014 9:01PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
SandS said..

my two bobs worth , i would go lami panel direct stick . then at least when decide to add a item to the cabin top you can bolt straight through . nothing worse than a double skin ceiling imo .....................................


I am doing lami panel if I can find it down in Melbourne either 600 wide the same as the hatch opening or one meter that the rest with the cedar. As Ive blown my port light money on this little adventure Ill remover the old original port light and re glaze and reseal them and trim the cabin sides with cedar as well them as adding the white lami panel to the roof gives me a lot more cedar left over




aus005
TAS, 514 posts
17 Jul 2014 8:54AM
Thumbs Up

i would do it all the same a strip down the middle hardly gains anything and will look like a runway

Ramona
NSW, 7570 posts
17 Jul 2014 9:15AM
Thumbs Up

I'm with LooseChange except I would glue cedar battens across the deckhead and one down the centre to simulate deckbeams. I would rather see bolts than have them hidden.

My deckhead is brown cork on thin panels. I would prefer white paint.

andy59
QLD, 1153 posts
17 Jul 2014 10:47AM
Thumbs Up

Pyramid Paints sell a textured, semi gloss 2 pack marine grade white paint that hides a multitudes of sins and looks quite nice. Just prep the surface and roll or spray it on, job done.

CoolRunnings
NSW, 159 posts
17 Jul 2014 12:11PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote




Karsten said..


LooseChange said..
an easy enough job to roughly sand then screed it with fairing compound, sand to a smooth finish and finally paint with high gloss paint ...




(chuckle chuckle) ... I've tackled those "sanding, fairing, sanding and painting" little two-hour jobs before; and two weekends later I'm still sanding and filling little divots. Maybe I should just have used matt paint.

Still, Loosechange's is a good idea. Only caveat would be to keep in mind that GRP boats flex quite a bit in heavy seas, and you'd want to keep the fairing layer thin enough so it doesn't crack on you.

Talking about fairing compounds - has anyone here used a fairing or filling compound that can flex instead of being brittle?


Karsten-I have used Norflex by Norglass and seems to be good in terms of flex.

CoolRunnings
NSW, 159 posts
17 Jul 2014 6:53PM
Thumbs Up

Sorry Guys-For some reason the previous post went out before I got to explain the flagpole and filler thing.
Anyway this was an old timber pole with topmast and yardarm out of Oregon timber.After 40 years it was well weathered and the Cockatoos had got into it as well.
All the cracks,holes and divots were filled with the Norflex,which worked a treat and is easy to sand with no porosity. Given this thing moves around a lot with temperature changes and flexes in the wind there have been no problems thus far.
HG, on your interior deck lining, why not direct stick the new composite aluminium sheeting as a finish. About $90.00 per sheet from Mister ply+Wood or other outlets.It can be also purchased in marine grade ally and forms curves real well and you'll only lose 4mm in interior height.

Regards CR

HG02
VIC, 5814 posts
17 Jul 2014 7:32PM
Thumbs Up

www.forest1.com/info/wallart/
Bunnings sell this item with or with or a tile pattern
I chose a snow white the panel is 2400 x 1200 so two panels will cover the roof its much the same as lami panel
use a adhesive on the back and prop it up till its cured
Bunnings call it Wet area paneling " Linear series wet area paneling"

Donk107
TAS, 2446 posts
17 Jul 2014 8:49PM
Thumbs Up

Hi HG

Are you going to do it in two pieces with a join in the centre or can you do it in one piece

Are you going to run the cedar up to the top on the vertical sections that the windows mount in or will you sheet this section as well

Also will you sheet the front section of the cabin where the deck steps down

Do you think that condensation in cold climates will be a issue

The product looks good and I will be interested to see the finished product

Regards Don



HG02
VIC, 5814 posts
17 Jul 2014 10:23PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote




Donk107 said..

Hi HG

Are you going to do it in two pieces with a join in the centre or can you do it in one piece

Are you going to run the cedar up to the top on the vertical sections that the windows mount in or will you sheet this section as well

Also will you sheet the front section of the cabin where the deck steps down

Do you think that condensation in cold climates will be a issue

The product looks good and I will be interested to see the finished product

Regards Don





Condensation Id say most boats will suffer from this down south . I have to do some thing the carpet is not in good condition .
Tomorrow after work Ill drop into the boat and measure it up . if I buy two panels Id have the option of either a panel either side of the center line or
alternatively center one panel so 600 cm on each side of the center line and then utilize another panel cut in two one either of the center panel cut down to suit the balance both sides and trim with timber along the joins . I think this would be my best choice giving me a clear span.
Bunnings have a reasonable amount of stock so I could in the first instance fit one panel in the center on Saturday and let it set over night and on Sunday measure up the other two panels to be cut see what the appearance looks like and go from there .
As far as the where the deck steps down Ill see after fitting the panels as to what I use based on the interiors brightness and appeal from the first panel after its in place. Ill post a photo saturday night when I get home and face the Seabreeze Music .

I think I will start the the center panel just behind the cabin step down at the front. This will make it a little easier to trim the variation from the center to the edges of the deck step and I can trim with timber and then make two side panels for the sides of the cabin step down. The rear of the center pane lgoes further than the hatch opening at the rear of the cabin and Ill have to trim around the hatch area where the panel fits.
All this might turn to crap if the hatch wont allow me the 1200 width to get the panel down below
Ill be measure that tomorrow after work thats for sure.
I will be making allowances for cockpit halyards just in case I ever want them later at the front bulk head sides and also either side of the hatch ( screw down panels)
Many thanks for your input Donk
Maybe as the width is 2 meters wide on the cabin roof two panels cut at 1 meter and joined and trimmed in the middle might work also .
Ill measure after work tomorrow and sort it out

cisco
QLD, 12325 posts
18 Jul 2014 1:47AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
andy59 said..
Pyramid Paints sell a textured, semi gloss 2 pack marine grade white paint that hides a multitudes of sins and looks quite nice. Just prep the surface and roll or spray it on, job done.


That is what I would be doing. So simple and easy with a great result.

aus005
TAS, 514 posts
18 Jul 2014 11:56AM
Thumbs Up

dont forget u need to get the sheet in there it may be too big in one piece this may influence how you do it

aus005
TAS, 514 posts
18 Jul 2014 12:05PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
aus005 said..
dont forget u need to get the sheet in there it may be too big in one piece this may influence how you do it


i would sheet it port to starboard using the flex of the sheet to help it stick to the roof.
if you sheet from bow to stern it is a tighter radius and may be more difficult also the joint may pucker if joined in the middle and any waves would be evident as you come down the hatch
use the plastic joiners

Karsten
NSW, 331 posts
18 Jul 2014 2:31PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
cisco said..

andy59 said..
Pyramid Paints sell a textured, semi gloss 2 pack marine grade white paint that hides a multitudes of sins and looks quite nice. Just prep the surface and roll or spray it on, job done.



That is what I would be doing. So simple and easy with a great result.



I wanted to see what type of two-pack this is, and found "Pyramid Paints" have changed name to "Seahorse Marine Paints" in Adelaide.
The web site is unusual in that it doesn't give any address or telephone contacts, just an email form.

Checked their product range but not sure I could spot the semi-gloss, super-thick 2-pack paint Andy referred to. Andy - which one is it?



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Sailing General


"Best timber to use for stringers" started by HG02