Forums > Sailing General

Maxi 20 What??

Reply
Created by No Worries > 9 months ago, 3 Jan 2014
No Worries
WA, 23 posts
3 Jan 2014 6:03AM
Thumbs Up

Hope someone can help me here! I noticed several Maxi 20ft sailboats for sale, but cannot find any info on the big old www?

Who manufactured them?
Are they still in business?
How do these boats perform, say compared to the Red Witch?
What is the appetite for 20 - 25 knot winds?
How stable are they and are they self rightning?
Is there a difference between performance of fixed and swing keels?

They certainly look like neat little boats!

felixdcat
WA, 3519 posts
3 Jan 2014 9:54AM
Thumbs Up

Have seeng some too! Do not know much about them but be sure anything would be better than a redwitch! there is no much good about the witches except for the price when below 1k.

WA125er
98 posts
3 Jan 2014 1:47PM
Thumbs Up

Pretty sure maxi20 was a John Swarbrick design from the early 80s so structurally should be good. Lots of better performed and proven options around though....Redwitches, space sailor 18s and 20s being a few.
Aliens, now they are fun, not many about.

LooseChange
NSW, 2140 posts
3 Jan 2014 7:11PM
Thumbs Up

Not the Maxi range of boats from Pelle Petterson perhaps?

Ramona
NSW, 7571 posts
3 Jan 2014 7:23PM
Thumbs Up

I think the Maxi range were fully imported from Scandinavia. In Australia we had the 20 and the 26. They were known for the quality of their fit outs. I'm sure we had a forum member from Victoria that owned one.

Donk107
TAS, 2446 posts
3 Jan 2014 8:41PM
Thumbs Up

Hi KotzeAB

I don't suppose you are in Tassie and interested in buying Spacesailer 20 fin keel

Regards Don

No Worries
WA, 23 posts
3 Jan 2014 7:37PM
Thumbs Up

Hi Donk

No, I am in the other side of Aus in Perth WA.

How much have you got it going for, just as a matter of interest?

I am also looking at a MB21, and possibly a MB24. What do you guys recon will be the typical difference in asking price between these two?

Cheers
Andre

Ramona
NSW, 7571 posts
4 Jan 2014 9:04AM
Thumbs Up

There was an MB21 for sale on a mooring at Lake Macquarie I think recently for about 3 or 4 thousand. I was dead keen on them in the early seventies. All Van de Stadt yachts are good. I ended up with a Status 19, the MB21 was just a bit too expensive at the time. I have only seen them with fixed keels. As your in WA the Sorcerer is another good trailer sailer that has become reasonably priced too.

WA125er
98 posts
4 Jan 2014 1:16PM
Thumbs Up

You should be able to get an MB21 for less than 7-8k in Perth, and the 24 for 10ish.
Where will you sail from? Some clubs have others that sail same boats in division 3 or 4 and it makes it more interesting. For example east Fremantle yacht club have small fleets of M27s and Farr727s, Sopyc have fleets of Spacesailor 22s, 27s, S80s.

freopaul
WA, 1 posts
4 Jan 2014 2:34PM
Thumbs Up

Like many people I spend time watching the passing sales, prices have dropped and continue to amaze me, A spacey 22 will set you back around $5k - $7k depending on age of sails and rigging etc. We have several at EFYC and many more at SoPYC. This is my second yacht and so far it has been great although a pen or mooring is essential. Benefit of a larger "Class community" is the experience and willing helpers as well as others to pitch yours skills against. My SS22 takes two to sail but three if we want to do anything fancy like fly the kite.

No Worries
WA, 23 posts
4 Jan 2014 6:32PM
Thumbs Up

Geez, Thanks Guys

Thank you for all the feedback. Every bit of feedback gives me better perspective of the sailing environment.

I am down in Rockingham WA and I would prefer a Trailer Sailer, but will not turn my head the other way for something useful that is reasonably priced that will outweigh the advantages of a TS. I have not been in the sailing community for very long, but I have also realised that currently it might be a bit of a buyers market.

The fact that I do not know too much about what kind of boats are out there or what their pro's and cons are, does not make it easy to know what models I should consider to invest in. All I know is that I recently started to enjoy racing, that I sometimes will have to do it single handed and it be comfortable enough to cater for my family to enjoy the day. (Wife and 2 small kids)

No pens where I am, hence my preference for a TS so I can shy away from being moored during stormy winter months, and even keep it at home if the trailer is registered.

Currently the Maxi 20 and Red Witch are TS's available that I will be able to afford with my very tight budget.

Keelboats available which will have to be moored will be the MB21, MB24. I do not know the Endeavour 24, which if good might potentially also be an option?

Regards

Donk107
TAS, 2446 posts
5 Jan 2014 2:25AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
KotzeAB said..

Hi Donk

No, I am in the other side of Aus in Perth WA.

How much have you got it going for, just as a matter of interest?

I am also looking at a MB21, and possibly a MB24. What do you guys recon will be the typical difference in asking price between these two?

Cheers
Andre


I would like to get about $9000 for her (asking prices in Tassie are a bit dearer than the mainland)

Regards Don

Ramona
NSW, 7571 posts
5 Jan 2014 10:07AM
Thumbs Up

KotzeAB said..


No pens where I am, hence my preference for a TS so I can shy away from being moored during stormy winter months, and even keep it at home if the trailer is registered.

Currently the Maxi 20 and Red Witch are TS's available that I will be able to afford with my very tight budget.

Keelboats available which will have to be moored will be the MB21, MB24. I do not know the Endeavour 24, which if good might potentially also be an option?

Regards


Much is going to depend on what facilities you have. The Maxi and Red Witch will require a good boat ramp and a trailer with extendable bar and the possibility of some one getting very wet each time you decide to sail. The Sorcerer or any of the other WA designed boats not quite the same drama. All will require the mast lifting drama and with a wife and two small kids this may wear thin very fast. If your lucky you may have a ramp along side a wharf or floating pontoon which will certainly help. Fixed keel MB21 only draws a bit over 2 feet so can get in close to the beach. May have to consider a small fixed keeler like the MB21 on a mooring and take it home on a trailer for the winter. Then you have to have a tender and a mooring to worry about! Its a tough call but I can tell you from experience it is all going to depend on the wife and kids. Getting the wife to stand in the water holding the trailer sailer while you get the car and trailer will be a test. Especially if its just after an invigorating sail in fresh conditions!
But if you have to have a mooring why bother with a tiny fibreglass keeler. Try the family inside a small boat and see how they feel. Something like the Black Soo Cisco linked to may be a better solution. Something that you are prepared to lose if need be. Tough call.
This is a Sorcerer in my home town.
[URL=.html] [/URL]

WA125er
98 posts
5 Jan 2014 8:43AM
Thumbs Up

As Ramona says much will depend on your helpers...
Sailing from Rockingham a true TS would be best, ie swing or drop keel model as its easier/quicker to launch. There is hard standing at the TCYC pen/yard.
Have you looked at a Swarbrick 20 (S20) day sailer?

No Worries
WA, 23 posts
5 Jan 2014 9:23AM
Thumbs Up

Yes, I already have a Red Jacket which I launch from the TCYC hard stand.

I certainly agree that a true TS will be best and there are 2 x 25ft and a 27ft for sale ranging from $20k - $25k, but this unfortunately is beyond my financial means. I did put up my hand for a MB21 with brand new sails. The decision to sell this is not definite yet and I will only know towards the end of this month whether it is.

Currently a variety of Witches and 2 Maxi20's are available which I will be able to afford. There is one Maxi 20 with a drop keel in Mandurah for $7000 which I consider to be ideal, but the $7000 might be a but much. I also do not know much about the Maxi's and cannot find anything on the net. I also was advised that I will not be able to move it along later on, but again this the opinion of one individual and do not know if this is really the case?

I have heard about the S20's to be good little boats, this is if it is the Spacesailer 20, but I did not notice any for sale recently.

WA125er
98 posts
5 Jan 2014 1:26PM
Thumbs Up

Swarbrick 20 Daysailer (first launched in the mid 80s) is more suited to daysailing and is quicker around a course. nice light rig too. There was one for sale at Nedlands YC. Try their website notice board...
Spacesailor 20s (first launched in late 70s) are also excellent in fixed or swing keel and drop keel for newer models. Better for shorthanded and stays at rotto etc. mast head rigs and there were lots built so should always be a few around for sale...tried gumtree?

Fiesta
QLD, 122 posts
5 Jan 2014 9:20PM
Thumbs Up

KotelAB,

We have a 20 ft Spacesailer Swing Keel that I sail on Moreton Bay with a young family and a wife new to sailing. Its easy to single hand (it has the small rig set up for getting under swan river bridges). We have been out in 25knts which is common here in summer and the boat handles really well. We have overnighted several times with our 4 year old and had a great time, as long as you accept that its basically camping on the water.

If I was in the West I would seriously consider a Spacesailer 22 which seems to have a good class association and shares the seaworthy characteristics. See feopauls comments above.

We started on a Mirror with 3 of us and the experience of boat ramps convinced me that, sail boats + boat ramps + young families = trouble. Ramonas comments above on the put in and take out issues are spot on.

Enjoy the search.



felixdcat
WA, 3519 posts
6 Jan 2014 10:16AM
Thumbs Up

looking at your (budget) options, I would go for the Swarbrick Alien 21, but that is just my opinion and it would suit my sailing style better as I am not a great fan of floating cravans and small queel boats.

No Worries
WA, 23 posts
6 Jan 2014 6:50PM
Thumbs Up

It seems I have now pretty much made up my mind on what to go for.

If the deal of the MB21 fails, I have decided to stick to the principle of a TS and shy away from mooring dependency. The Red Witch has still got very good representation in WA with at least 40 going on the river. I have also found several parked in backyards.

I will then basically option for the Red Witch as this should satisfy my needs.

Thank you so much for all the advice and input gentleman, and ladies where applicable.

Now, do you know of a decent Red Witch somewhere that is in good nick and has good racing sails, an outboard and a registered trailer for less than $3300 in WA, as this is what I currently can make an offer on?

Cheers Everyone

WA125er
98 posts
6 Jan 2014 7:18PM
Thumbs Up

Try the Nedlands YC website, classifieds/notice board, they have a heap parked in their boat yard.
Also check out the association website: www.redwitch.asn.au and click on the witchbits tab, the are a couple for sale there...
Gumtree sometimes has one pop up.
I assume you realise Redwitches are majority fixed keel (if not all) boats? The don't draw very much though, about 3ft/900mm.

No Worries
WA, 23 posts
6 Jan 2014 7:57PM
Thumbs Up

Yes WA125er

I have studied the Witch well and visited Nedlands today even to have a look at WARLOK, but it does not fit the bill. I also met with the chairman (A very nice and helpful individual, that just lives for the Witch) of the association just before Christmas and am that abreast with what is available from SOPYC and the association.

The best deal currently comes from one of my fellow club members that has moved on from the Witch, but I am not to make a decision immediately as I first have to sell off my Red Jacket. I am quite sad to let her go! :-(

Thank you for that!!

felixdcat
WA, 3519 posts
7 Jan 2014 9:53AM
Thumbs Up

Aren't red jackets and red witches very similar type of yachts?

Ramona
NSW, 7571 posts
7 Jan 2014 8:38PM
Thumbs Up

Red Jackets are 17 feet, Red Witch 20, Red Baron cat 20 and the Sorcerer all from the same stable. Red Witch is a lot bigger than the Red Jacket.

Anyone remember the Red Jacket that sailed down after the Sydney Hobart racers in about 1969. Had an extra shoe of lead bolted to the keel! Lots of publicity at the time but not sure if he got to Hobart!

No Worries
WA, 23 posts
7 Jan 2014 9:28PM
Thumbs Up

Hi

Yes, it did indeed make it to Hobart. Until recently the website "SUNSITE" was active and had the whole article about the owner and two friends that wanted to join the race, but were not allowed to participate, so they followed the race instead.

No Worries
WA, 23 posts
8 Jan 2014 1:29AM
Thumbs Up

A RL24 MKIII caught my eye but I have read a poster claiming that the RL24 tend to turn turtle? I might be interested in one, but I certainly would not like to take my Wife and 1 & 3 year old sons on a RL if there is distinct possibility of capsize?

Do they?
How do they handle Wind?
How do they handle Swell?

Ramona
NSW, 7571 posts
8 Jan 2014 9:26AM
Thumbs Up

They are popular on the East coast. They do have a sensible rig for a trailer sailer, small headsail and a larger mainsail which makes them more manageable. The design is allegedly taken from a Flying Dutchman set of lines with a couple of inches added to the frames and the free board raised! No idea if they can capsize. Only trailer sailer I have seen capsize was a Young 20, they forgot the water ballast! Trailer sailers have to race with the keel pinned down. The ballast ratios are still low and they depend on hull shape for stability. I think you could capsize any of them if you tried hard enough.

No Worries
WA, 23 posts
8 Jan 2014 6:59AM
Thumbs Up

Thank you once again Romana

LooseChange
NSW, 2140 posts
8 Jan 2014 11:03AM
Thumbs Up

Why not ask Ruckus about RL 24's he's posting the results of the RL nationals at Lake Macquarie currently.

felixdcat
WA, 3519 posts
8 Jan 2014 9:47AM
Thumbs Up

Don't quote me but I believe that the rules of racing (trailer sailer) demand that the yacht must have the keel secured down and must be self righting. I have had my Farr main very close to the water and I was racing (pushing to the limit) and she came back as soon as I let a bit of sheet out.
My boat sister sheep went in a wild surf (30 knt) wind and cart wheeled but still came out. The Farr is very well built and if you were to cut it in 2 parts both half would still float. Maybe that a feature you should check before buying a yacht.

cisco
QLD, 12326 posts
8 Jan 2014 11:44PM
Thumbs Up

KotzeAB said..

A RL24 MKIII caught my eye but I have read a poster claiming that the RL24 tend to turn turtle? I might be interested in one, but I certainly would not like to take my Wife and 1 & 3 year old sons on a RL if there is distinct possibility of capsize?

Do they?
How do they handle Wind?
How do they handle Swell?


The RL 24 is an excellent yacht. That is why not many come up for sale. They appear quite skinny but they are fast, sail very well and have good accommodation for 4 for weekend overnighting.

Another great yacht in the size range is the Windrush Wildfire. There are two here in Bundaberg and at least one of them can be bought for quite a reasonable price I believe.

http://members.iinet.net.au/~laws/wildfire/index.html

RC which I used to own and Just Cauz are the two yachts here.

They originated in WA so you should be able to find one there for sale, but another yacht that is so good people rarely sell them. They have a midships watertight bulkhead and I would rate them as one of the fastest and safest trailer sailers ever built. They will handle 30 knot winds quite well from my experience.

No Worries
WA, 23 posts
8 Jan 2014 9:54PM
Thumbs Up

Come on, cannot be!!! I was offered a Wildrush Wildfire this morning!!

Why do you not tell me more about them please?



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Sailing General


"Maxi 20 What??" started by No Worries