Forums > Sailing General

on boat power

Reply
Created by BENNYP > 9 months ago, 29 Jun 2011
BENNYP
QLD, 32 posts
29 Jun 2011 10:44AM
Thumbs Up

what are the best and cheapest way to have on board power for things like fans, lights, radio, tv

cisco
QLD, 12337 posts
29 Jun 2011 1:07PM
Thumbs Up

The words "best" and "cheapest" don't really fit in the same sentence.

You can have the "best" or you can have the "cheapest" but you can't have both together.

This www.cruisersforum.com/ is a good resource for information based on your question.

By the way, does anybody know how long a piece of string is or what time the half past eight bus leaves.

Disralei
NSW, 127 posts
29 Jun 2011 11:04PM
Thumbs Up

Cisco

Your loosing the plot here, the string is as long as you cut it and the 8.30 bus always leaves at 8.45

SandS
VIC, 5904 posts
30 Jun 2011 10:19PM
Thumbs Up

Disralei said...

Cisco

Your loosing the plot here, the string is as long as you cut it and the 8.30 bus always leaves at 8.45


yes but , the 8.30 bus will leave at leave at 8.45 only if you get to the bus stop at 8.20.

if you get to the bus stop at 8.31 the bus will leave at 8.30

dkturnbull
40 posts
30 Jun 2011 8:46PM
Thumbs Up

If you are planning on solar power there power ratings arnt accurate as they are tested on the equator laying flat at midday so they are getting maximum sun when its at its closest. If you are looking at solar you will need to account for this as a 80 watt system might only be good for 50 watts on a boat.

saltiest1
NSW, 2496 posts
30 Jun 2011 11:29PM
Thumbs Up

where are you? where are you going and how log? how big is your boat? what sort of amps are you going to be chewing and when? live aboard? lots of motoring? shore power available? is there a genset? budget? and so on.....

cisco
QLD, 12337 posts
1 Jul 2011 12:17AM
Thumbs Up

saltiest1 said...

where are you? where are you going and how log? how big is your boat? what sort of amps are you going to be chewing and when? live aboard? lots of motoring? shore power available? is there a genset? budget? and so on.....


Geez mate!! All the bloke did was ask for some information and now you want to know what time he lets his first fart go in the morning.

planesailing
WA, 380 posts
30 Jun 2011 11:29PM
Thumbs Up

A piece of string is 2 times its length when folded in half.
I have 200W solar (flat) and Wind Generator.
The solar runs fridge and lights and radios constantly, even
in winter. but i guess less sun means less heat means less fridge runs.
I have nothing good to say about wind generators (except ***eholes)
mine is noisy and needs at least 20knots to become useful.(the generator BTW)
My 2 bobs is stick with solar just work out how much power you require
per day and get enough wattage to keep that-up X another half.

Charriot
QLD, 880 posts
1 Jul 2011 9:28AM
Thumbs Up

Hey BENNYP, simple answer, just installed 50W panel / of course noncrystalline / cost $150 and cut-off switch $18.
Run 2 batteries + 1 dedicated for motor starter. Pretty much it covers what you have.
But it is very simple, calculate how many amps you need than you know how much you have to put in / plus 20% more /.
Bay the way if not on the boat charging all batteries through shotky diodes, if on the boat,I have individual switches to select which bat. to be charged.

saltiest1
NSW, 2496 posts
1 Jul 2011 11:33PM
Thumbs Up

cisco said...

saltiest1 said...

where are you? where are you going and how log? how big is your boat? what sort of amps are you going to be chewing and when? live aboard? lots of motoring? shore power available? is there a genset? budget? and so on.....


Geez mate!! All the bloke did was ask for some information and now you want to know what time he lets his first fart go in the morning.





yeah. bit much i spose. i just know its hard to get things just right without the right info.
took me a while to figure it out. lived aboard while sailing around for 12 mnts and didnt get it right until the 2nd half. ended up with a 3 stage 240 charger, 2 120 watt solar panels and an airex wind turbine. had all the mod cons though...
we were a family of 3, had a 12 inch flat screen tv, vhf, computer, windlass, radio, fans, loo, radar, lights, and more to run, but if its a small boat with a simple set up a single solar panel of 80 watts might be plenty. it all depends on what you plan to do.

saltiest1
NSW, 2496 posts
2 Jul 2011 12:23AM
Thumbs Up

btw, how long is a piece of string? as long as i want it to be.

dinsdale
WA, 1227 posts
2 Jul 2011 12:30AM
Thumbs Up

planesailing said...
... even in winter. but i guess less sun means less heat means less fridge runs.

Solar panels require visible light, not infra-red light.

cisco
QLD, 12337 posts
2 Jul 2011 11:14AM
Thumbs Up

saltiest1 said...
took me a while to figure it out. lived aboard while sailing around for 12 mnts and didnt get it right until the 2nd half. ended up with a 3 stage 240 charger, 2 120 watt solar panels and an airex wind turbine.

had all the mod cons though...

we were a family of 3, had a 12 inch flat screen tv, vhf, computer, windlass, radio, fans, loo, radar, lights, and more to run, but if its a small boat with a simple set up a single solar panel of 80 watts might be plenty. it all depends on what you plan to do.


All the mod cons is where the rub comes in. It really depends on what your cruising philosopy is.

For me, as long as I can have a good stereo on board I am well entertained. However these days with the advent of computers and the internet it is good to be able to power up a decent laptop. That allows you to have as big a music library as you could ever want plus movies and TV series that you might download.

These days I get most of my video entertainment streaming from the internet and rarely switch the TV on but that of course is at home with ADSL2 over the land line.

I am not sure that kind of bandwidth is possible with mobile internet. Hangtime seems to be quite happy with his Telstra 3G or next G connection and I'd like to know a bit more about that ie is the speed good enough to stream video from abc.net/iview.

Apart from the above I like to keep things electrical very simple on board. On a 34 footer an electric anchor winch is nice but not really necessary and I would not bother with radar as there are some very good AIS receiver units available now. So sounder, VHF, gps plotter and AIS is a quite adequate electronics suite.

Refrigeration is probably the biggest power user if electric. I think I have mentioned it elsewhere that there is a really good article on electrics in the June 2008 Cruising Helmsman magazine. I'll see if I can get it scanned and post it up.

saltiest1
NSW, 2496 posts
3 Jul 2011 10:39AM
Thumbs Up

its also worth looking to the usa to buy stuff like 3 stage chargers, or wind power equipment. saved me more than 600 bucks on the wind turbine alone, although that was a few years ago now. alternative energy store. the warrantees were recognised here and have service agents in australia for their gear too, but check on that for each product.

MichaelR
NSW, 855 posts
4 Jul 2011 3:32PM
Thumbs Up

cisco said...

All the mod cons is where the rub comes in. It really depends on what your cruising philosopy is.

For me, as long as I can have a good stereo on board I am well entertained. However these days with the advent of computers and the internet it is good to be able to power up a decent laptop. That allows you to have as big a music library as you could ever want plus movies and TV series that you might download.

These days I get most of my video entertainment streaming from the internet and rarely switch the TV on but that of course is at home with ADSL2 over the land line.

I am not sure that kind of bandwidth is possible with mobile internet. Hangtime seems to be quite happy with his Telstra 3G or next G connection and I'd like to know a bit more about that ie is the speed good enough to stream video from abc.net/iview.

Apart from the above I like to keep things electrical very simple on board. On a 34 footer an electric anchor winch is nice but not really necessary and I would not bother with radar as there are some very good AIS receiver units available now. So sounder, VHF, gps plotter and AIS is a quite adequate electronics suite.

Refrigeration is probably the biggest power user if electric. I think I have mentioned it elsewhere that there is a really good article on electrics in the June 2008 Cruising Helmsman magazine. I'll see if I can get it scanned and post it up.



There are a couple of "depends" in here too.

Your chosen method of recieving wireless broadband will depend on how good it streams.
We don't cruise for any longer than a weekend, so we don't need TV.

We use an iPad for Navionics (as well as charts of course :-)), Internet 3G and some of our music. We use an 30g iPod with 6,000 songs, running in a small alkaline battery powered dock to take care of the music. Standard lights, galley pump, radio etc run off the one gigantic (12V 900CCA 75Ah) absorbed glass mat battery powered by two very old 40w solar panels. You could use the iPad to stream iView, but it would depend on how much you paid for your broadband and what your download limit was. If we want to watch a video, we can load it on the iPad, connect the speakers to the iPod dock etc, but it is a small screen.

We have outboard, with no requirement for power to start, and it doesn't generate power to a battery either.

Mobile phone, iPod, iPad are all charged with connections to the main battery.

If you use a laptop there are converters available at most electronic shops that alleviate the need for the 240volt power supply, connecting straight to 12 volt.

For my money, it's all going to depend on space and how many people need to use power for the mod cons.

Michael

Charriot
QLD, 880 posts
4 Jul 2011 5:17PM
Thumbs Up

BENNYP you still here, was your question answered ?
give us a update how you go with your set up !!!!!

cisco
QLD, 12337 posts
4 Jul 2011 11:15PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks for that input MichaelR. There is more than one way to skin a cat.

I have a Nokia 2730 I think with a 2gb micro SD memory card which allows a huge amount of music to be carried around in your pocket. Output is via a 3mm stereo socket which is a common cord into most car as well as boat stereos.

I do think a TV on a boat that is used mostly for cruising as opposed to living aboard in a marina is out of place.

saltiest1
NSW, 2496 posts
5 Jul 2011 12:15AM
Thumbs Up

cisco said...



I do think a TV on a boat that is used mostly for cruising as opposed to living aboard in a marina is out of place.




you try telling a 3 year old kid the wiggles wont be around any more! again, it all depends. a few of things, out of many, i learnt cruising was that everyone has different needs, every boat is different, everything is a compramise, and everyone thinks that they have THE best boat

BENNYP
QLD, 32 posts
5 Jul 2011 8:30PM
Thumbs Up

ok thanks for all the advice and yes i see there is alot to think about. my next question is that i have a old solar pannel that i found in my parents shed, but it has no wiring, is that fixable.

BENNYP
QLD, 32 posts
5 Jul 2011 8:35PM
Thumbs Up

also to let you all know. my yacht is a 25 roberts adventurer that we plan on using for weekend and holiday crusing. i have never owned a boat biggernough to stay on and this is why i need help. i think my concern is that i have enough power to run lights and music and charge things like phone, also it would like to be able to do work on the lap top or watch the footy on tv.

Ramona
NSW, 7584 posts
6 Jul 2011 8:35AM
Thumbs Up

BENNYP said...

also to let you all know. my yacht is a 25 roberts adventurer that we plan on using for weekend and holiday crusing. i have never owned a boat biggernough to stay on and this is why i need help. i think my concern is that i have enough power to run lights and music and charge things like phone, also it would like to be able to do work on the lap top or watch the footy on tv.


With careful management very little is required for your needs. Two decent deep cycle batteries is all I have at the moment. On the rare occasions I need nav lights I'm motoring anyway. Toshiba laptop draws 4 amps and is only on when navigating. Fm radio is on full time and vhf, don't bother with the hf. Using a 12v LCD TV draws very little. I find just motoring clear of my mooring and returning is enough to keep batteries fully charged. However I intend fitting two 20 watt panels and dropped into BIAS in Sydney yesterday to be told that they only have 3 in stock at the warehouse. The kicker was that they may not let them be sold as they are being held for the Sydney boat show! They had very little stuff in stock in the shop too. The shop assistant did say that a visit to the boat show might enable a couple of cheap purchases.

Charriot
QLD, 880 posts
7 Jul 2011 8:40AM
Thumbs Up




This is my set up. System is visually under control. I have connected the same way more batteries. One bat. or more don't matter, on the end of the day they all equalized.

planesailing
WA, 380 posts
7 Jul 2011 9:01AM
Thumbs Up

dinsdale said...

planesailing said...
... even in winter. but i guess less sun means less heat means less fridge runs.

Solar panels require visible light, not infra-red light.


Yes you are right ..but my point was when its cooler (no sun because of clouds) the
fridge doesnt need to be powered as often because ambient temp is less. and we can
even turn it off at night in winter. to save some power to run anchor light.

saltiest1
NSW, 2496 posts
8 Jul 2011 11:51PM
Thumbs Up

BENNYP said...

ok thanks for all the advice and yes i see there is alot to think about. my next question is that i have a old solar pannel that i found in my parents shed, but it has no wiring, is that fixable.



where is the missing? external is fixable, internal im not so sure.
for a 25 ft boat with ample power for all that, for only weekend sails, its a matter of figuring out the amps per hour used, then sorting a battery set up big enough. dont forget that the batteries wil charge back to 100% while you are not on it quite quickly in good weather with 1 x 80 watt panel and smart charger. (id never get a solar system without one). it was hard for me to find the right set up, but asking around was great.

cisco
QLD, 12337 posts
10 Jul 2011 12:36PM
Thumbs Up

I have been doing some market research on battery chargers and everybody seems to agree that although expensive, the Ctek units are the duck's nuts.

The D250S and the Smartpass units appear to be the ideal set up for yachts that rarely go along side and hook up to shore power.

Whether they are actually a charger or a smart regulator is debateable.

If a yacht has solar panels plus windgenerator and engine alternator these units look to be the ideal solution.

http://www.ctek.com/en/chargers

Jedibrad
NSW, 527 posts
17 Jul 2011 11:48AM
Thumbs Up

wow, they have come down a heap in the last 5yrs

rodward
WA, 27 posts
17 Jul 2011 6:11PM
Thumbs Up

c

Jedibrad said...

wow, they have come down a heap in the last 5yrs


Careful what you buy.There is a big difference between some of them.I swear by uni-solar.Slowly pull a shade over them and watch the input and you will see what i mean

Ramona
NSW, 7584 posts
18 Jul 2011 8:25AM
Thumbs Up

rodward said...

c
Jedibrad said...

wow, they have come down a heap in the last 5yrs


Careful what you buy.There is a big difference between some of them.I swear by uni-solar.Slowly pull a shade over them and watch the input and you will see what i mean


As long as you buy Mono crystalline they are pretty much the same, only the prices vary.

Uni-solar are just another Chinese brand. http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/68W-Uni-Solar-Flexible-Solar-Panel-panneau-solaire-/270780758503?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_2&hash=item3f0bca79e7

Ramona
NSW, 7584 posts
19 Jul 2011 6:53PM
Thumbs Up

I have just bought one of these for $200.
http://cgi.ebay.com.au/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=360371149975&ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT

My yacht has 2 - 110 amp hour deep cycle batteries. I only use one bank each day and intend separating the suitcase panels and installing them each side of the pushpit. The unit comes with a regulator and I will buy a second one and have each panel charge its own battery. I have always kept systems separate preferring to have one bank idle. My yacht has never had panels before and managed Sydney Hobart races with out recharging. I normally run the diesel each day I'm sailing even if I sail off/on to my mooring. Normal drain is just Laptop, radios and stereo so 40 watts will handle it easy. I will still be using the diesel anyway.

whiteout
QLD, 264 posts
24 Jul 2011 11:22PM
Thumbs Up





The sloar system should have a good quality controler, Ctek three stage charger, VSR switch, Good Quality AGM battery I have a 270Amphr one and all new wiring on the new boat. Three sloar panels 2x135 and 1x 65watt.


BENNYP
QLD, 32 posts
25 Jul 2011 7:38PM
Thumbs Up

wow thats looks great i can see i have alot of wiring to do to male mine look a bit better. does anyone know how much i sould pay for a 100 amphr battery. also what are peoples oppinions on generators



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Sailing General


"on boat power" started by BENNYP