Forums > Sailing General

overweight sailors: how fat is too fat?

Reply
Created by codelayer > 9 months ago, 15 Jan 2018
sirgallivant
NSW, 1531 posts
16 Jan 2018 3:41PM
Thumbs Up

Our elders were much wiser than we are, giving advice:

Breakfast like a king,
Lunch like a citizen,
Dine like a pauper.

While sailing-cruising one should live by this advice even more.
There are many opportunities to exercise on board, one only has to think about open mindedly about one's opportunities. The "going to the gym" caper is an over rated self denying excuse.

On a boat the opportunity to exercise might not be obvious but nevertheless is there.
The dinghy or kayak is one (not after dinner but instead of!), the anchor is a perfect weight to lift, gymnastics is another one with sit ups, stand ups, push and pull ups never mention yoga which only needs determination.
It is not to build huge muscles just keep one's body pliable so when we have to bend that heavy jib we don't end up with pulled muscles, torn ligaments, bad backs.

There is no valid reason to grow old and also grow fat. There is no medical reason either.

It is down to our screwed up values and lifestyle that the above advice is - literally - turned upside down. Strewth!

We leave home with next to nothing under the belt, run all day long on a sandwich dreaming of dinner when we fill ourselves way over necessity just because we were mentally torturing ourselves dreaming of food all day. Then we go to bed with 2000 calories in our stomachs, could not rest properly while digesting the crap we ate and waking in the morning tired, exhausted, pissed off and late and likely with a bad heartburn, so we don't eat breakfast again. Crazy!
Then, we go cruising and carry our screwed lifestyle aboard drinking excessively in the bargain.

The body works differently. If one has a good breakfast it is going to be burned up by the day's activities while the dinner is going to end up as fat reserve around one's waistline, no matter what, dry land or aboard.

Chris 249
NSW, 3329 posts
16 Jan 2018 3:46PM
Thumbs Up

We did have one very large friend years ago who I stopped inviting on the boat when we found we could not get her back aboard after swimming. It was OK when she could swim to a beach and come back out in the dinghy, but the possibility of her going overboard in the middle of the bay and being unrecoverable was too high for me to be comfortable.

However, if it's your own boat there would be some ways around the issue. A good RIB could make life easier - their stability makes life much easier when getting out to the boat (even if it's on a marina, you want to be able to go ashore when anchored) and if fitted with a boarding ladder it could make MOB retrieval a lot easier, whether you tie it alongside or even go the extreme of leaving the yacht in the middle of the harbour and making the recovery from the RIB. A sugar-scoop or boarding platform with transom door would also seem to be almost mandatory.

Good luck, and good on you!

codelayer
25 posts
16 Jan 2018 1:02PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Chris 249 said..
We did have one very large friend years ago who I stopped inviting on the boat when we found we could not get her back aboard after swimming. It was OK when she could swim to a beach and come back out in the dinghy, but the possibility of her going overboard in the middle of the bay and being unrecoverable was too high for me to be comfortable.

However, if it's your own boat there would be some ways around the issue. A good RIB could make life easier - their stability makes life much easier when getting out to the boat (even if it's on a marina, you want to be able to go ashore when anchored) and if fitted with a boarding ladder it could make MOB retrieval a lot easier, whether you tie it alongside or even go the extreme of leaving the yacht in the middle of the harbour and making the recovery from the RIB. A sugar-scoop or boarding platform with transom door would also seem to be almost mandatory.

Good luck, and good on you!


Thanks Chris,

I can't see it being an issue in the long term, as neither of us intend to sail if we have to resort to such measures (at least while we are young-ish).

Having said that, it is certainly something that could influence the purchase of our first boat.

codelayer
25 posts
16 Jan 2018 1:04PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
sirgallivant said..
Our elders were much wiser than we are, giving advice:

Breakfast like a king,
Lunch like a citizen,
Dine like a pauper.

While sailing-cruising one should live by this advice even more.
There are many opportunities to exercise on board, one only has to think about open mindedly about one's opportunities. The "going to the gym" caper is an over rated self denying excuse.

On a boat the opportunity to exercise might not be obvious but nevertheless is there.
The dinghy or kayak is one (not after dinner but instead of!), the anchor is a perfect weight to lift, gymnastics is another one with sit ups, stand ups, push and pull ups never mention yoga which only needs determination.
It is not to build huge muscles just keep one's body pliable so when we have to bend that heavy jib we don't end up with pulled muscles, torn ligaments, bad backs.

There is no valid reason to grow old and also grow fat. There is no medical reason either.

It is down to our screwed up values and lifestyle that the above advice is - literally - turned upside down. Strewth!

We leave home with next to nothing under the belt, run all day long on a sandwich dreaming of dinner when we fill ourselves way over necessity just because we were mentally torturing ourselves dreaming of food all day. Then we go to bed with 2000 calories in our stomachs, could not rest properly while digesting the crap we ate and waking in the morning tired, exhausted, pissed off and late and likely with a bad heartburn, so we don't eat breakfast again. Crazy!
Then, we go cruising and carry our screwed lifestyle aboard drinking excessively in the bargain.

The body works differently. If one has a good breakfast it is going to be burned up by the day's activities while the dinner is going to end up as fat reserve around one's waistline, no matter what, dry land or aboard.



That's some good advice I might start using myself SG.

Bananabender
QLD, 1582 posts
16 Jan 2018 3:11PM
Thumbs Up

Mate, I really can't cannot advise any more than has been said above in regard to the weight issue and sailing however I note from a previous post you are in SEQ and both yourself and misses have 50 years of possible sailing / boating ahead so no rush. If you live anywhere around Moreton Bay /Broardwater you have quite a few advantages to get your Sea legs and not worry to much about things like getting back on board if god forbid you fall overboard. Firstly you can sail to your hearts content in smooth waters behind nth and sth Straddie within reason .Secondly there is a VMR base every mile ( not quite but seems that way) and for the price of $70 pa they will come and assist ( go onto a VMR site and have a look).
If your in the Broardwater and get into trouble a boat will pass you every minute or so on the weekend or hols. anyway and will stop and help.
Ocean sailing can come later.
I now only sail solo and aside from wearing a PDF and PLB I let them know what I'm doing if it's a bit windy just in case .
Its one thing to sit on the shore and watch the sailboats glide by it's another to actually sail a boat . Leave the misses at home and go for a sail and see how you like it. You have some offers above on some pretty fantastic boats to spoil you . 'Just do it'
It may be that if you really want to get out on the great waters you have available a motor boat ( wash my mouth out with soap) may suit you initially and you and your wife can develop your seamanship skills with the plan to get a proper boat in say 2/5 years time when you feel more confident with your weight.
If you sit back and talk about it it won't happen .
So forget you weight and start planning to get on the water.
Dont forget its Queensland "beautiful one day........."so go and get your boat licences and don't miss out .

samsturdy
NSW, 1659 posts
16 Jan 2018 4:43PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Bananabender said..
Mate, I really can't cannot advise any more than has been said above in regard to the weight issue and sailing however I note from a previous post you are in SEQ and both yourself and misses have 50 years of possible sailing / boating ahead so no rush. If you live anywhere around Moreton Bay /Broardwater you have quite a few advantages to get your Sea legs and not worry to much about things like getting back on board if god forbid you fall overboard. Firstly you can sail to your hearts content in smooth waters behind nth and sth Straddie within reason .Secondly there is a VMR base every mile ( not quite but seems that way) and for the price of $70 pa they will come and assist ( go onto a VMR site and have a look).
If your in the Broardwater and get into trouble a boat will pass you every minute or so on the weekend or hols. anyway and will stop and help.
Ocean sailing can come later.
I now only sail solo and aside from wearing a PDF and PLB I let them know what I'm doing if it's a bit windy just in case .
Its one thing to sit on the shore and watch the sailboats glide by it's another to actually sail a boat . Leave the misses at home and go for a sail and see how you like it. You have some offers above on some pretty fantastic boats to spoil you . 'Just do it'
It may be that if you really want to get out on the great waters you have available a motor boat ( wash my mouth out with soap) may suit you initially and you and your wife can develop your seamanship skills with the plan to get a proper boat in say 2/5 years time when you feel more confident with your weight.
If you sit back and talk about it it won't happen .
So forget you weight and start planning to get on the water.
Dont forget its Queensland "beautiful one day........."so go and get your boat licences and don't miss out .


One thing you've got going for you cody is age, by crikey I wish I was in my thirties again.

codelayer
25 posts
16 Jan 2018 2:31PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Bananabender said..
Mate, I really can't cannot advise any more than has been said above in regard to the weight issue and sailing however I note from a previous post you are in SEQ and both yourself and misses have 50 years of possible sailing / boating ahead so no rush. If you live anywhere around Moreton Bay /Broardwater you have quite a few advantages to get your Sea legs and not worry to much about things like getting back on board if god forbid you fall overboard. Firstly you can sail to your hearts content in smooth waters behind nth and sth Straddie within reason .Secondly there is a VMR base every mile ( not quite but seems that way) and for the price of $70 pa they will come and assist ( go onto a VMR site and have a look).
If your in the Broardwater and get into trouble a boat will pass you every minute or so on the weekend or hols. anyway and will stop and help.
Ocean sailing can come later.
I now only sail solo and aside from wearing a PDF and PLB I let them know what I'm doing if it's a bit windy just in case .
Its one thing to sit on the shore and watch the sailboats glide by it's another to actually sail a boat . Leave the misses at home and go for a sail and see how you like it. You have some offers above on some pretty fantastic boats to spoil you . 'Just do it'
It may be that if you really want to get out on the great waters you have available a motor boat ( wash my mouth out with soap) may suit you initially and you and your wife can develop your seamanship skills with the plan to get a proper boat in say 2/5 years time when you feel more confident with your weight.
If you sit back and talk about it it won't happen .
So forget you weight and start planning to get on the water.
Dont forget its Queensland "beautiful one day........."so go and get your boat licences and don't miss out .



Thanks BB,

I guess we're just trying to find the sweet spot between "just do it" and "fools rush in where wise men fear to tread".

We want to get wet as soon as practical, so we don't spend too long dreaming. However neither of us are quite sure when "as soon as practical" is .

Also, the broad water is definitely starting to sound like a great playground for first timers.

sirgallivant
NSW, 1531 posts
16 Jan 2018 6:15PM
Thumbs Up

While we are talking about obesity and over eating one should mention the weight loss regime as well.

While losing weight is recommended, losing weigh FAST is not!
If you are seriously trying to lose large number of kilos perhaps it would be wise to talk to your GP first.
Expedited weight loss if uncontrolled can cause all sorts of health problems even emergencies.

Extended fasting is the fools way of losing weight!
One who lost a lot of kilos should learn how to keep it off and that needs big time lifestyle change.

codelayer
25 posts
16 Jan 2018 3:24PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
sirgallivant said..
While we are talking about obesity and over eating one should mention the weight loss regime as well.

While losing weight is recommended, losing weigh FAST is not!
If you are seriously trying to lose large number of kilos perhaps it would be wise to talk to your GP first.
Expedited weight loss if uncontrolled can cause all sorts of health problems even emergencies.

Extended fasting is the fools way of losing weight!
One who lost a lot of kilos should learn how to keep it off and that needs big time lifestyle change.



Agreed.

someday
NSW, 97 posts
16 Jan 2018 7:09PM
Thumbs Up

I really like body weight exercises, since it saves having to go to the gym. This is my favourite site on these:

www.startbodyweight.com/

Jode5
QLD, 853 posts
16 Jan 2018 7:31PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
boty said..

Jode5 said..
This is a subject I am very close to. 9 months ago I was 136kg and 60 years old and I race single handed and could do everything with no problems. Yes I had to be careful getting into a small hard dingy but a hard floor inflatable was no problem. It would not matter what weight I was, my wife would not be able to get me back on board so we have a recovery module which she can hoist me back on board. The big thing I have over a novice is i have a wealth of experience having sailed since I was 5 years old.
What I did find I would come home from a tough race and I would feel like i'd been hit by a truck and what's more I would like to sail for a lot more years yet which my doctor said if I didn't do something I would not be sailing competitively for much longer.
After much pondering I decided to have Gastric Surgery (Gastric Sleeve) . I was operated at the end of May, 4 weeks before I headed north on the boat for 4 months. I have now dropped 47kg And my current weight is now 89kg which I have not been since I was 20 years old. The first 4 months was tough and I certainly questioned if I had done the right thing, but now everything is normal. I just eat a lot less.
i now get round the boat with a lot more ease and certainly have a lot less aches and pains, my balance is also better. The best thing of all is the dingy goes a lot better.
Weight loss surgery is not for everyone but it is what I did so I could keep doing this wonderful sport for many years to come.
If balance and mobility is a problem you should maybe consider a catamaran as you are sailing on the level most of the time.
If you want to talk to someone about the surgery feel free to pm me your phone number.



good on you john tough call i took up yoga last year to improve flexibility on the boat and sailing dingys though it would be nice to shed 10 kg i would have to give up the rum a big call


Peter, I do struggle drinking beer now, but Rum and Coke goes down better than ever .

Jake888
WA, 106 posts
16 Jan 2018 5:34PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
codelayer said..

Bananabender said..
Mate, I really can't cannot advise any more than has been said above in regard to the weight issue and sailing however I note from a previous post you are in SEQ and both yourself and misses have 50 years of possible sailing / boating ahead so no rush. If you live anywhere around Moreton Bay /Broardwater you have quite a few advantages to get your Sea legs and not worry to much about things like getting back on board if god forbid you fall overboard. Firstly you can sail to your hearts content in smooth waters behind nth and sth Straddie within reason .Secondly there is a VMR base every mile ( not quite but seems that way) and for the price of $70 pa they will come and assist ( go onto a VMR site and have a look).
If your in the Broardwater and get into trouble a boat will pass you every minute or so on the weekend or hols. anyway and will stop and help.
Ocean sailing can come later.
I now only sail solo and aside from wearing a PDF and PLB I let them know what I'm doing if it's a bit windy just in case .
Its one thing to sit on the shore and watch the sailboats glide by it's another to actually sail a boat . Leave the misses at home and go for a sail and see how you like it. You have some offers above on some pretty fantastic boats to spoil you . 'Just do it'
It may be that if you really want to get out on the great waters you have available a motor boat ( wash my mouth out with soap) may suit you initially and you and your wife can develop your seamanship skills with the plan to get a proper boat in say 2/5 years time when you feel more confident with your weight.
If you sit back and talk about it it won't happen .
So forget you weight and start planning to get on the water.
Dont forget its Queensland "beautiful one day........."so go and get your boat licences and don't miss out .




Thanks BB,

I guess we're just trying to find the sweet spot between "just do it" and "fools rush in where wise men fear to tread".

We want to get wet as soon as practical, so we don't spend too long dreaming. However neither of us are quite sure when "as soon as practical" is .

Also, the broad water is definitely starting to sound like a great playground for first timers.


Interesting thread, my two cents, it seems you are over thinking it.

In anything in life don't go past your abilities, but stretch yourself, while weight slows you down it shouldn't be the yard stick at which you measure yourself. So start at the easy end and work your way up until you feel uncomfortable, then take a small step back, you will find your sailing skill in the end is more of a predictor of ability than your weight.

Sailing is also a sliding scale, at one end you can be on 60ft catamaran in 5knt winds on a river, the other end of the spectrum is dinghy sailing in the ocean in a gale. If you are really nervous I would look at tourist charter for single day on a big boat where everything is done for you but you can participate as much as you like, if that works try a discover sailing course on a 40ft monohull in nice conditions, if that works twighlight sailing meet ups at the local yacht club, if that works look to some light level racing or buying your own yacht.

Take small steps and work your way up, if you feel its too challenging you are in a safe environment where others can help.

Weight can also be a good thing, works as ballast, I felt a lot safer kitesurfing when I was 130kg than now when I am 80kg, gusts seem to throw me around a lot more.

Good luck mate and hope you find what you're looking for, congrats with the weight loss so far, its a slow game, find exercise you enjoy doing (eg sailing) and it won't be a chore, much more likely to stick to it that way.

SandS
VIC, 5904 posts
16 Jan 2018 8:56PM
Thumbs Up


OFFS !!! am I. 110 or 130 percent ! what next ?

crustysailor
VIC, 869 posts
16 Jan 2018 10:01PM
Thumbs Up

codelayer, another 2 cents for you.
My wifes a dietitian and I have 2 teenage girls, so weight,eating, and general health is a pretty regular topic at home.

All of the previous Seabreezers have pointed out what I'd be hesitant on, namely the practical safety aspects associated with simply being heavier on a boat, particularly getting back in a boat. The idea is though you don't really want to fall overboard in the first place if you can help it, whether you weigh 150kg in your budgy smugglers, or 75kg plus sailing gear it can be really hard, for yourself and for your crew to perorm a recovery.
My boat is a 30 ft cat with a fairly high freeboard or deck height, and I often sail alone depending on what everyone else is doing. The boat is usually doing 7 to 10 knots, and realistically if I fall in, there's no getting back on in much of a hurry.The cat has wheel steering and its quite happy sailing without any input, so I don't expect it to round up, so its see you later.I wear an auto inflate jacket whenever i'm not below, and have a handheld vhf (probably should have some personal flares too)

I think you end up developing a voice saying 'this is where I end up going in'' and do everything extra cautiously, well as much as possible.

'20kg'over isn't too much, in my opinion its more important how mobile you are, and your strength. A lot of people associate a weight figure with healthy or not, and on a boat its more about how you can get around, concentrate on various situations, and try to foresee possible problems in advance, and look after yourself and your crew. 20kg wont stop that.

Good luck to you both, I say go for it, pick a sensible boat, and plan as much as you can for good weather days, and I hope you both share it together.

andy59
QLD, 1153 posts
16 Jan 2018 9:20PM
Thumbs Up

I lost 15kg sailing around the world, its the best way to lose weight!!!

cisco
QLD, 12324 posts
16 Jan 2018 9:38PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Jode5 said..
Peter, I do struggle drinking beer now, but Rum and Coke goes down better than ever .


Rum OK but forget the Coke!!

Try this:- Crushed lime in the bottom of the glass, a few cubes of ice, rum (2 nips??) over the ice, soda, tonic or just water to your taste. It is the favourite drink in the Carribean but they put a teaspoon of sugar in first. Me, diabetic type 2, so I don't. If you are going to use sugar get demerara sugar, particularly if you are drinking El Dorado rum which is made on demerara sugar.

It is made in Guyana and I think the best rum I have ever had.

Bananabender
QLD, 1582 posts
16 Jan 2018 10:38PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
cisco said..

Jode5 said..
Peter, I do struggle drinking beer now, but Rum and Coke goes down better than ever .



Rum OK but forget the Coke!!

Try this:- Crushed lime in the bottom of the glass, a few cubes of ice, rum (2 nips??) over the ice, soda, tonic or just water to your taste. It is the favourite drink in the Carribean but they put a teaspoon of sugar in first. Me, diabetic type 2, so I don't. If you are going to use sugar get demerara sugar, particularly if you are drinking El Dorado rum which is made on demerara sugar.

It is made in Guyana and I think the best rum I have ever had.


And you live where!

codelayer
25 posts
16 Jan 2018 9:26PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks to everyone for the great advice so far. It's given us a lot to think about.

I'm a big believer in the idea that there is no such thing as "common sense", only the shared wisdom of one's culture. That's why I'm happy to ask questions with seemingly obvious answers. I'm not yet a member of the sailing culture, so I don't share its wisdom.

MorningBird
NSW, 2660 posts
17 Jan 2018 10:45AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
andy59 said..
I lost 15kg sailing around the world, its the best way to lose weight!!!


I lose 5kg on each Lord Howe trip. And I am only starting at 70kgs.

boty
QLD, 685 posts
17 Jan 2018 12:59PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
cisco said..

Jode5 said..
Peter, I do struggle drinking beer now, but Rum and Coke goes down better than ever .



Rum OK but forget the Coke!!

Try this:- Crushed lime in the bottom of the glass, a few cubes of ice, rum (2 nips??) over the ice, soda, tonic or just water to your taste. It is the favourite drink in the Carribean but they put a teaspoon of sugar in first. Me, diabetic type 2, so I don't. If you are going to use sugar get demerara sugar, particularly if you are drinking El Dorado rum which is made on demerara sugar.

It is made in Guyana and I think the best rum I have ever had.


there is nothing you cant make better by adding rum to it

Donk107
TAS, 2446 posts
17 Jan 2018 6:03PM
Thumbs Up

A mate I used to sail with told me a story of when he used to sail in Melbourne with a skipper who could get a bit agro at times

He was a bit on the heavy side but didn't mind because he thought he would be the last one to get picked if someone had to go up the mast

They were racing one night and something went wrong at the top of the mast and the skipper who was a bit upset at the time over what had happened told one of the other crew members to winch that fat bastard up the mast to fix it

Regards Don

Wander66
QLD, 294 posts
17 Jan 2018 6:48PM
Thumbs Up

You csn still be fat and fit, here's a photo of Cisco and I on our last sailing trip . That's me vaulting over the railing.




Donk107
TAS, 2446 posts
17 Jan 2018 8:19PM
Thumbs Up

I weigh about 110 kg and I am constantly being used as moveable ballast on the race boat

I would probably be happy loosing around 20 kg but unfortunately I like my food a bit to much

Regards Don

LooseChange
NSW, 2140 posts
17 Jan 2018 11:44PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Donk107 said..
I weigh about 110 kg and I am constantly being used as moveable ballast on the race boat

I would probably be happy loosing around 20 kg but unfortunately I like my food a bit to much

Regards Don


Amen to that Don.
My body is a temple and I worship it often.

cisco
QLD, 12324 posts
17 Jan 2018 11:16PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Wander66 said..
You csn still be fat and fit, here's a photo of Cisco and I on our last sailing trip . That's me vaulting over the railing.





Backwards after a nudge from me!!



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Sailing General


"overweight sailors: how fat is too fat?" started by codelayer