Forums > Stand Up Paddle General

Flat Turn VS Hard On A Rail

Reply
Created by OG SUP > 9 months ago, 9 Mar 2013
paul.j
QLD, 3341 posts
10 Mar 2013 8:57AM
Thumbs Up

Think this topic has gone side ways and far from getting boards on there rail.

Back on topic the shorter sup are the future of sup comps with out a doub, I can see fun events where 10ft plus boards will be used but top end will be shorter.

Come on people find the grom within.

paul.j
QLD, 3341 posts
10 Mar 2013 9:01AM
Thumbs Up

Casso said...
Imagine telling Mick Fanning he had to compete on a pop out from China? Ridiculous.


You are right as well for the top 1% who know what they want and need and can get that 1% more out of the board then custom all the way. I had a custom 8ft fanatic and prefer the production 8ft. Theres room for all in this world.

BennyB12
QLD, 918 posts
10 Mar 2013 9:13AM
Thumbs Up

Sure it's growing fast but like the beer belly of an aging man....ugly and in the wrong direction...
I don't think sales is a true indication of sport'growth'... We're talking surfing here right?
Having 200 middle aged men and women floundering around currumbin creek is a good indication of an improving attitude to healthy lifestyle but hardly represents a growing scene with a future... Clubs and juniors are the future, same as 'normal' surfing..... At this rate the future of sup is a lot of dusty boards in garages or at least a healthy 2nd hand market....

micksmith
VIC, 1686 posts
10 Mar 2013 10:31AM
Thumbs Up

paul.j said...
Think this topic has gone side ways and far from getting boards on there rail.

Back on topic the shorter sup are the future of sup comps with out a doub, I can see fun events where 10ft plus boards will be used but top end will be shorter.

Come on people find the grom within.


Agree, my surfing progressed enormously when I went from a 9'3" production to an 8'8" custom. This was due to a number of factors including weight,design and the colour. The width on the custom is wider than old production but carves much better due to rocker, rails etc. please don't confuse length and width with design in regards to on edge carving.
I think as with longboard v shortboard there should be a distinguishing length with short sup to longboard sup.
my 5c worth (had to round it up from 2c worth)

antonfourie
NSW, 140 posts
10 Mar 2013 10:59AM
Thumbs Up

Back to the original topic of the thread, I do not think that the width of boards determine the kind of turns that you can do, it has a lot to do with the rocker profile too.

Again though, if the flat turns are not rewarded in a comp then people will stop doing them.

However, expect SUP surfing to follow short board surfing in where it is heading, airs, 3's and all the rest.

Just because us over 40's think that we can't do those on a 30" wide SUP does not mean that everyone can't.

This is SUP surfing, not "SUP longboarding" so any restrictions on board length will only serve to push people out of the sport

62mac
WA, 24860 posts
10 Mar 2013 8:07AM
Thumbs Up

To grow any sport you need to invest in junior development programs focused on fun not comps,comps can come into play at a later stage,I've see too many sideline parents turn their kids into hating a sport.Keep it simple,a young kid can paddle anything so one board for all,surf,race and bop.Watch the improvement when they get on the good gear.Customs for the above average Joe/Joanne will see times drop and more points scored fact.

Not everyone is made for comps,so don't lose focus when growing any sport.I agree with the old tested 80/20 rule here.So maybe the comp numbers are the same but the people taking SUP up is growing?

On the comp side,look at how far behind longboarding is compared to shortboarding in sponsorship dollars,do you really think SUP is going to attract more corporate dollars than longboarding .You can run two division to the surfing short and long,SUP is simply not big enough to have both short and longboard clubs atm.
I strongly believe Racing and Bop are the true future of SUP and surf a poor third.

This is not a troll I have too much respect for many in this forum.Yep who am I to add input,you guys know sup way better than me

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
10 Mar 2013 1:47PM
Thumbs Up

the grom within should still be short board surfing.


it's a standup paddle board we've on, not hp al merrick or dhd.


watch the quickie pro to see the difference people

paul.j
QLD, 3341 posts
10 Mar 2013 2:10PM
Thumbs Up

laceys lane said...
the grom within should still be short board surfing.


it's a standup paddle board we've on, not hp al merrick or dhd.


watch the quickie pro to see the difference people


You right if I was still a real grommet I would still be on my short board and that's my point I don't think our sport at the moment is as attractive to young guys and girls as surfing is and rightly so surfing is cheaper and way more appealing time them. I'm all for bringing in the juniors and know hoe important it is but I still have never had a 15 year old kid time in and buy a board.

In saying that at roar we are nearly ready to launch a junior programme that might just change all this

thePup
13831 posts
10 Mar 2013 12:13PM
Thumbs Up

paul.j said...
laceys lane said...
the grom within should still be short board surfing.


it's a standup paddle board we've on, not hp al merrick or dhd.


watch the quickie pro to see the difference people


You right if I was still a real grommet I would still be on my short board and that's my point I don't think our sport at the moment is as attractive to young guys and girls as surfing is and rightly so surfing is cheaper and way more appealing time them. I'm all for bringing in the juniors and know hoe important it is but I still have never had a 15 year old kid time in and buy a board.

In saying that at roar we are nearly ready to launch a junior programme that might just change all this


I like this highlighted stuff - that is priceless mate , good on you hope you post up any developments

paul.j
QLD, 3341 posts
10 Mar 2013 2:20PM
Thumbs Up

Sitting here watching the sups at noosa it looks painfull on any board!! Keahi and Jackson looked ok but hard work and not much rail surfing going on

62mac
WA, 24860 posts
10 Mar 2013 12:36PM
Thumbs Up

paul.j said...
Sitting here watching the sups at noosa it looks painfull on any board!! Keahi and Jackson looked ok but hard work and not much rail surfing going on


Sounds like they should be on 10 footers

Leroy13
VIC, 1174 posts
10 Mar 2013 3:45PM
Thumbs Up

paul.j said...
laceys lane said...
the grom within should still be short board surfing.


it's a standup paddle board we've on, not hp al merrick or dhd.


watch the quickie pro to see the difference people


You right if I was still a real grommet I would still be on my short board and that's my point I don't think our sport at the moment is as attractive to young guys and girls as surfing is and rightly so surfing is cheaper and way more appealing time them. I'm all for bringing in the juniors and know hoe important it is but I still have never had a 15 year old kid time in and buy a board.

In saying that at roar we are nearly ready to launch a junior programme that might just change all this


I know what I'd rather be doing if i was fit and young enough. I know my 18 year old and 13 year old just laugh at me when I mention SUP to them. Facts are are facts and what Paul J and Lacey are stating are facts. There are some outstanding anomalies but they are few and far between. No amount of old guys fit or fat are going to change the facts. C U later I think the Quicksilver pro is about to come back off hold!!!

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
10 Mar 2013 2:47PM
Thumbs Up

i like supping. been doing it for a while now. i'm just throwing stuff out there so i hope no one takes it the wrong way.

i seen sup comps build and in the last year or so numbers drop away.

i think something has to be done to kick start sup comps again

currumbin ck paddlers are running a juniors program atm and jacko says they are starting one too- which is great for the sport on the goldie and its a good start. most of the kids looked more comfortable on dad's short surfing sup which appears to have done away with the cost factor for the moment.








OG SUP
VIC, 3516 posts
10 Mar 2013 7:16PM
Thumbs Up

paul.j said...
laceys lane said...
the grom within should still be short board surfing.


it's a standup paddle board we've on, not hp al merrick or dhd.


watch the quickie pro to see the difference people


You right if I was still a real grommet I would still be on my short board and that's my point I don't think our sport at the moment is as attractive to young guys and girls as surfing is and rightly so surfing is cheaper and way more appealing time them. I'm all for bringing in the juniors and know hoe important it is but I still have never had a 15 year old kid time in and buy a board.

In saying that at roar we are nearly ready to launch a junior programme that might just change all this


Your previous post
SUP has being going pretty good up to date with out to many juniors? Pretty sure it's the fastest growing water sport and this is without juniors. Maybe a junior in our sport fir now is someone in their mid 20's?

Why would you post this if your about to launch a juniors program or are the juniors 25?

OG SUP
VIC, 3516 posts
10 Mar 2013 7:39PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
laceys lane said...
i like supping. been doing it for a while now. i'm just throwing stuff out there so i hope no one takes it the wrong way.

i seen sup comps build and in the last year or so numbers drop away.

i think something has to be done to kick start sup comps again

currumbin ck paddlers are running a juniors program atm and jacko says they are starting one too- which is great for the sport on the goldie and its a good start. most of the kids looked more comfortable on dad's short surfing sup which appears to have done away with the cost factor for the moment.

Lacey when Kristi came up for the week and trained with the Currumbin Paddlers group the most impressive thing I saw was how well you include every level of paddler.

It was inspiring to see the genuine encouragement and the inclusivity. Every paddler was encouraged to do their best what ever that was and the training was tailored to suit each paddler. Didn't mater if you were a 1st timer or a world class paddler there was something for everyone.

Watching the young group of kids you had racing was all time, they were having a ball. By the time they get old say 14 they will be smashing it.

The key thing was they all had FUN.

Phill

The images on the web from your training this morning is a real eye opener smokin work!

Simondo
VIC, 8020 posts
10 Mar 2013 8:01PM
Thumbs Up

Hilly, I'll never get tired of looking at that shot!
Great topic Phill!



OG SUP
VIC, 3516 posts
10 Mar 2013 8:19PM
Thumbs Up

62mac said...
paul.j said...
Sitting here watching the sups at noosa it looks painfull on any board!! Keahi and Jackson looked ok but hard work and not much rail surfing going on


Sounds like they should be on 10 footers


Sounds like Noosa being Noosa and 10fter would be a great choice.

skebstebamal
QLD, 579 posts
10 Mar 2013 8:51PM
Thumbs Up

Comes down to judging 2. If judges pay crappy little flick turns that's becoming common... People will do them.

I'm nervous about juniors getting in.... Will the sport lose the big round house cutty and we will see a heap of flicky slidey turns, let's be honest it's. Not hard to get a wide board sliding with tiny fins in it.

I keep going back to the dogs round houses.... They look cool. Much better than flicky slidey stuff.

Until the new school surfers learn to hack like parko and co they won't win a world, title.. Same will go with sup. Custom board or not....

Do I digress, sheez, can't remember what the topic was....

AA
NSW, 2159 posts
11 Mar 2013 10:15AM
Thumbs Up

Good thread even if it has gone sideways!

If we are the fastest growing sport/watersport in the world right now why are numbers dwindling at many Comps and organisers struggling to get sponsorship?

Every sport needs a pointy end and we would not be where we are without the development that comes from customs and team riders. Team riders, Pros and the Elites need to ride customs.

What I am talking about is growing the sport, getting numbers up at comps and events and attracting Sponsorship dollars so they can get bigger and better for everyone to enjoy.

There is room for everyone here, I am not talking about limiting what you can ride, I am talking about shifting the focus to be more inclusive.

Handicapped Time trials are a good example of how to include everyone, let so lets keep working on being inclusive and that means making what the majority ride (production boards) competitive at the majority of comps and events.

Sandsy1
NSW, 814 posts
11 Mar 2013 10:50AM
Thumbs Up

Well OG,
Didn't you get the discussion going!!
I'm a newbie / kook, who is starting to get there, in this new world of SUP. Forty years of surfing mals and shorties, still doesn't allow you to get on a SUP and go. I went for a longboard style SUP and in the future will get a short board style SUP.
To your point, all surfing goes through phases, in style, in equipment and that is reflected in competition and judging. Many great surfers have been ignored by the judging systems at the time, because they were either different, or on a different path. Ross Clarke-Jones being a pretty good example.
Give it time. Fat little pig boards will suit some, while others will want to bury the rail and turn, comps will be judged on the most progressive or spectacular.
As for the amount of juniors, well that's a complete post on it's own.
Cheers

paul.j
QLD, 3341 posts
11 Mar 2013 10:22AM
Thumbs Up

OG SUP said...
paul.j said...
laceys lane said...
the grom within should still be short board surfing.


it's a standup paddle board we've on, not hp al merrick or dhd.


watch the quickie pro to see the difference people


You right if I was still a real grommet I would still be on my short board and that's my point I don't think our sport at the moment is as attractive to young guys and girls as surfing is and rightly so surfing is cheaper and way more appealing time them. I'm all for bringing in the juniors and know hoe important it is but I still have never had a 15 year old kid time in and buy a board.

In saying that at roar we are nearly ready to launch a junior programme that might just change all this


Your previous post
SUP has being going pretty good up to date with out to many juniors? Pretty sure it's the fastest growing water sport and this is without juniors. Maybe a junior in our sport fir now is someone in their mid 20's?

Why would you post this if your about to launch a juniors program or are the juniors 25?


Well up to date what i have said is true! but as with every one else here i would love some younger riders to get in to the sport so instead of just hoping they will take it up we are trying to set a plan to give it a push. We are not going to be making any money with this venture but hopefully if it works out it could be good for the sport. But for the juniors to be a big part of this sport there are a few big hurdles to get over first.

paul.j
QLD, 3341 posts
11 Mar 2013 10:30AM
Thumbs Up

62mac said...
paul.j said...
Sitting here watching the sups at noosa it looks painfull on any board!! Keahi and Jackson looked ok but hard work and not much rail surfing going on


Sounds like they should be on 10 footers


I was thinking that and then i watched the 10ft boards go out and the shorter SUPs made it look way better!! It did look more fun on the bigger boards though

Deano72
NSW, 540 posts
11 Mar 2013 12:26PM
Thumbs Up

Here's a couple of ideas to get more groms on SUP's.
1. Crew running SUP schools should be talking to their local primary & secondary schools about incorporating SUP into their sports curriculum.....if they haven't already.
2. Poach groms from the clubbies & nippers.....if that isn't already happening.
They are the kids that love being in and on the water.....seems most clubbies that take up SUP love it.

surfgrub
NSW, 105 posts
11 Mar 2013 2:24PM
Thumbs Up

Mention of Ross Clark-Jones.... Remember the boards both he, Tommy, Sanga & Bainy were riding in the movie 'Mad Wax' way back when? Short, flat rocker - really wide between the fins & big fat tails, as ewe did (except for Kong). & what're they on now - probably the same progressively better boards that SUPpers will be riding in as many years to come, given the same period of development.

& +1 AA.

(my 1cents' worth)

micksmith
VIC, 1686 posts
11 Mar 2013 2:28PM
Thumbs Up

Deano72 said...
Here's a couple of ideas to get more groms on SUP's.
1. Crew running SUP schools should be talking to their local primary & secondary schools about incorporating SUP into their sports curriculum.....if they haven't already.
2. Poach groms from the clubbies & nippers.....if that isn't already happening.
They are the kids that love being in and on the water.....seems most clubbies that take up SUP love it.


Now ya talkin.
When I was heavely in to windsurfing I encouraged our local high school to purchase a number of kits from starboard who had a special deal at the time especially for schools I still see the school using them several years later.
Does that encourage students to take up the sport? don't know, but at least the seed has been sewn.
The question is what are you doing in your area?

CMC
QLD, 3954 posts
11 Mar 2013 5:27PM
Thumbs Up

Original post. Not even a question, rail turns are the only turns. Flat slides etc are in part due to bad design on part due to fins way too small for the widths of the tails. Just my opinion here, but then I'd rather watch Matt Hoy or Occy rather than Gabriel Medina as well. I like to see some power in a turn.


Development of the sport. That's another topic altogether.

I have had this discussion quite a few times in the past months.

Other sports like windsurfing for example had a similar explosion and then died. When equipment becomes too specialized and it becomes hard to learn or start to compete people stop. As the pointy end loses interest there is nobody to replace them and the sport slows down.

While I love the idea of junior development there is a whole much bigger group that is being forgotten or overlooked. Every race or surf event should have a novice section, a short length race or a time based event where new competitors feel comfortable to enter and enjoy.

Look at running for example, you don't only have jogging and marathons, you have 5km, 10km half marathons etc. something where people can start, get involved, love it, get the bug and continue.

The minute novices are forgotten, even with juniors the competitive side of the sport will decline.

Piros
QLD, 6996 posts
11 Mar 2013 6:11PM
Thumbs Up

Haven't read all the post but original question seems to be directed at the "Dishpan".For those that don't what that is , it's when you push hard on the tail to break the fins free to do a cheater tail slide flat cutback. When the surf is small in comps this is all you can do to score points , no it's not a rail turn but without speed and a decent wave face you can't do a full rail turn cut back on a Sup and keep the momentum , you will end up behind the foam ball , ending your wave.

Shortboarders do it all the time , Sup riders do it more because we can't generate the same speed. It's all part of comps and it just gets mixed up and scored with the other manoeuvres what's the problem with that. It all adds to the show.

antonfourie
NSW, 140 posts
11 Mar 2013 7:20PM
Thumbs Up

CMC said...
Original post. Not even a question, rail turns are the only turns. Flat slides etc are in part due to bad design on part due to fins way too small for the widths of the tails. Just my opinion here, but then I'd rather watch Matt Hoy or Occy rather than Gabriel Medina as well. I like to see some power in a turn.


Development of the sport. That's another topic altogether.

I have had this discussion quite a few times in the past months.

Other sports like windsurfing for example had a similar explosion and then died. When equipment becomes too specialized and it becomes hard to learn or start to compete people stop. As the pointy end loses interest there is nobody to replace them and the sport slows down.

While I love the idea of junior development there is a whole much bigger group that is being forgotten or overlooked. Every race or surf event should have a novice section, a short length race or a time based event where new competitors feel comfortable to enter and enjoy.

Look at running for example, you don't only have jogging and marathons, you have 5km, 10km half marathons etc. something where people can start, get involved, love it, get the bug and continue.

The minute novices are forgotten, even with juniors the competitive side of the sport will decline.


Mountain Biking has also fallen into that problem, the pro's create the tracks that no newbies can ride and wonder why there are only 20 people turning up at a race, where there used to be 150 when the track was able to be ridden by anyone.

AA
NSW, 2159 posts
11 Mar 2013 7:48PM
Thumbs Up

antonfourie said...
Mountain Biking has also fallen into that problem, the pro's create the tracks that no newbies can ride and wonder why there are only 20 people turning up at a race, where there used to be 150 when the track was able to be ridden by anyone.


Really? I was going to quote MTBing as a success story!
Most events are generally aimed at a wide range of participants. Most of the good races sell out in a couple of hours. I think it has more to do with the success of various race formats and there are now just way too many choices - 50k, 100k, 8 hour, 12 hour 24 hour and the list goes on. Over supply basically.

hilly
WA, 7323 posts
11 Mar 2013 4:53PM
Thumbs Up

AA said...
antonfourie said...
Mountain Biking has also fallen into that problem, the pro's create the tracks that no newbies can ride and wonder why there are only 20 people turning up at a race, where there used to be 150 when the track was able to be ridden by anyone.


Really? I was going to quote MTBing as a success story!
Most events are generally aimed at a wide range of participants. Most of the good races sell out in a couple of hours. I think it has more to do with the success of various race formats and there are now just way too many choices - 50k, 100k, 8 hour, 12 hour 24 hour and the list goes on. Over supply basically.



+1 did an event last week. 500+ competitors heaps of options to enter. Well run i just need to get fitter



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle General


"Flat Turn VS Hard On A Rail" started by OG SUP