Search for a Location
  Clear Recents
Metro
South West
Central West
North West
  Surf Cameras
  Safety Bay Camera
Metro
North
Mid North
Illawarra
South Coast
Metro
West Coast
East Coast
Brisbane
Far North
Central Coast
Sunshine Coast
Gold Coast
Hobart
West Coast
North Coast
East Coast
Recent
Western Australia
New South Wales
Victoria
South Australia
Queensland
Northern Territory
Tasmania
  My Favourites
  Reverse Arrows
General
Gps & Speed Sailing
Wave Sailing
Foiling
Gear Reviews
Lost & Found
Windsurfing WA
Windsurfing NSW
Windsurfing QLD
Windsurfing Victoria
Windsurfing SA
Windsurfing Tasmania
General
Gear Reviews
Foiling
Newbies / Tips & Tricks
Lost & Found
Western Australia
New South Wales
Queensland
Victoria
South Australia
Tasmania
General
Foiling
Board Talk & Reviews
Wing Foiling
All
Windsurfing
Kitesurfing
Surfing
Longboarding
Stand Up Paddle
Wing Foiling
Sailing
  Active Topics
  Subscribed Topics
  Rules & Guidelines
Login
Lost My Details!
Join! (Its Free)
  Search for a Location
  Clear Recents
Metro
South West
Central West
North West
Surf Cameras
Safety Bay Camera
Metro
North
Mid North
Illawarra
South Coast
Metro
West Coast
East Coast
Brisbane
Far North
Central Coast
Sunshine Coast
Gold Coast
Hobart
West Coast
North Coast
East Coast
Recent
Western Australia
New South Wales
Victoria
South Australia
Queensland
Northern Territory
Tasmania
  My Favourites
  Reverse Arrows
All
Windsurfing
Kitesurfing
Surfing
Longboarding
Stand Up Paddle
Wing Foiling
Sailing
Active Topics
Subscribed Topics
Forum Rules
Login
Lost My Details!
Join! (Its Free)

Forums > Stand Up Paddle General

why not australian

Reply
Created by laceys lane > 9 months ago, 11 May 2011
Bnaccas
VIC, 1722 posts
12 May 2011 12:42AM
Thumbs Up

I'll just answer Laceys question from the original post... and then some...

2+ years ago I wasn't happy with what the Name Brands had to offer, in my eyes boards were too heavy, too big and too expensive.
So I looked at customs and nothing really stood out. Rod's Surf Shapes were definitely different but I didn't think they would quite suit
what I was after.

So I had a go at shaping myself. I had a long history in sailboarding and had worked closely with local shapers and thought I'd do alright
and lucky enough my first board went amazing. The finish was very rough but it worked. Anyway, that shape evolved 3 times and each
board did something different/better.

The problem with customs IMO is you are never happy for long and always want something better. Just like Lacey going through board
after board trying to build the perfect board. The other thing is the quality of workmanship is very high but the overall strength doesn't
quite match that of "some" of the name brands. I've seen this with most of the customs floating around Vicco.

I'm now on production boards again as I believe they got a kick up the bside and are now pushing the limits with development. The fight
to gain market share amongst the big guys is enough for them to be taking R&D seriously.

Anyway, so to wrap it up...for me... as long as the name brands are building quality high performance boards that compare to customs,
the name brands strength of build, warranty, back up service and re-sale value will be enough to keep me coming back and updating.

Simondo
VIC, 8020 posts
12 May 2011 12:45AM
Thumbs Up

Sh!t boys, you've all set a Seabreeze record of high word count per post! Lacey, I think Jacko is still with us all in the general SUP buying public... Of course there are some special offers in there, but he still needs to choose boards to ride, even if it is a slightly limited choice from one manufacturer.... at times.... Plus he must choose to demo other selected boards...

Bnaccas
VIC, 1722 posts
12 May 2011 12:49AM
Thumbs Up

Th0m0 said...

For me information is king. I love it when the industry people get on here and talk about their products. Usually there happy to give info on products that they don't even sell.
The only custom sup I have bought (out of about 10-12) was from Rod Hocker. He used to get on here and give his opinion and you got a sense of where he was heading and why, in both design and production. Then you could decide if you were happy with that. I've bought boards from Jacko and Ang because I get an idea of how they compare to other boards from reviews and comparisons they do. Same with Scotty from Greenline and Courts with JL.
Dale once told me he diidn't think it was right for him to get on here and talk about his boards but I bet his orders would go up if he did. I don't look at it as pimping, it's information and I can choose to take it on board or not. I can ask questions and get answers without having to make an appointment.
If I bought another custom, it would probably be from DTM because he posts on here, gives his opinion and backs them with reasons.
Personally, I don't care if a board is local or not, i'm just looking for the right board for me at the time.


Good post ThOmO! I like what you're saying here.

If I was to go custom it would be Laguna Bay so I can surf like Dogman, or DTM cos Dan is a good bloke and
Camo has one here in Vic and it looks great. Haven't had a chance to ride it yet.

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
12 May 2011 1:03AM
Thumbs Up

Minkee said...

laceys lane said...

Minkee said...

I like the doctor's proses even if I dont agree with them generally, they're good value and make you think a bit.

so as for managing stock, I don't agree. How managing a product that changes every week compare to one that changes once a year would be the same is beyond my understanding considering the surf shops we have in this country. Not to mention the resale value of the boards that is gold one week and worth peanuts the week after... I dont consider boards as consumables.

I also smile when we were told we would be third world servants to the big asian countries. Well, when these countries finish or shall I say slow their growth and stop depending on our mining resources, money will have to flow from somewhere else big style and we'll be pleased to rely on tourism.

So Lacey to answer your question.
I bought local, I wanted to do the "right thing". That's where the good bit stops.
Often small business are made of passionate people that love their discipline but haven't got a clue about business, customer service and marketing. Now I'm left with a board (not custom I precise) that has lost more than 55% of its value in not even 7 months. Well if anyone thinks that's acceptable for a racing sup, I don't, not in such a short period anyway. So my next board will be an import because the service will be there this time. If I had a good experience in the first place I'd very likely say different I admit but the truth is in the facts sadly.
On the other hand if you want a custom then it makes sense to go local. A custom board is not a transaction based on money but on emotion in my eyes so it's often an experience that will cost in the end when it comes to re-sale the board.








hi, i just caught this. i don't think its just customs mate, actually i know its not. if you think your gonna get big bucks for your production board come time to sell it- will i don't think so. i know of a girl who can't get anything for her production and custom boards.

it's a real problem for the sup industry and buyers i believe- who wants to get bugger all for their rather expensive board as so as its out the door.

really the smart thing to do is buy second hand and be ruthless, but i'm not that smart

but thats another topic in its self
cheers


I'm not after the big bucks with selling boards, for the big bucks I work
My once a year updated pop out will have a better resale value after 12 months than if I buy local again. That way I feel looked after and not shafted, that's called customer satisfaction. If you look at the "buy & sell" here you can see what goes at what value and how how quick it goes. When I see 2yrs old 14ft glides going for $1400 I think its owner thinks "sweet, I won't have to dig too deep for next one."
Please keep in mind I'm referring to pop-out board not custom.

If you want the latest you're not going to buy second hand either... But sure, people must make bargain from buying from you considering your pace
See you on the water.


the board you are talking is good, however i see 2 for $1250, one for $1150 on the breeze. what their advertised for and what one actually gets is two different things

don't you worry about what i get for mine. i do better then your figures because they all go well. however if you can get $1400 for that board 2 years old ,i better get you to sell all my boards

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
12 May 2011 1:23AM
Thumbs Up

Bnaccas said...

I'll just answer Laceys question from the original post... and then some...

2+ years ago I wasn't happy with what the Name Brands had to offer, in my eyes boards were too heavy, too big and too expensive.
So I looked at customs and nothing really stood out. Rod's Surf Shapes were definitely different but I didn't think they would quite suit
what I was after.

So I had a go at shaping myself. I had a long history in sailboarding and had worked closely with local shapers and thought I'd do alright
and lucky enough my first board went amazing. The finish was very rough but it worked. Anyway, that shape evolved 3 times and each
board did something different/better.

The problem with customs IMO is you are never happy for long and always want something better. Just like Lacey going through board
after board trying to build the perfect board. The other thing is the quality of workmanship is very high but the overall strength doesn't
quite match that of "some" of the name brands. I've seen this with most of the customs floating around Vicco.

I'm now on production boards again as I believe they got a kick up the bside and are now pushing the limits with development. The fight
to gain market share amongst the big guys is enough for them to be taking R&D seriously.

Anyway, so to wrap it up...for me... as long as the name brands are building quality high performance boards that compare to customs,
the name brands strength of build, warranty, back up service and re-sale value will be enough to keep me coming back and updating.



i would like to comment here, generally if you are after a custom, you after a light weight performance board. these board are going to be put into places on a wave most other boards can't go. so along with being a lightweight construction like their shortboard cousins they are going to be subject to breakages etc purely on the basis of where they are going to be put in a wave

however if you said to your shaper i don't mind if my board the same weight as the production models, they would be just as durable as most production boards imo.

its not fair to compare a hi performance lite weight weight board with a heavy production board.

its the same thing with shortboards- you take the punt with lightweight, light glass jobs
cheers
ps i can't get to sleep

Al Hunter
NSW, 367 posts
12 May 2011 1:31AM
Thumbs Up

aus301 said...



As a long time Windsurfer I am comfortable buying pop-outs. . Given that I am buying from brands I know and trust through the windsurf relationship I am usually always comfortable that my new board will be well constructed, and a good design - even if it may be 6 to 12 months old by virtue of being a pop out. and I can be comfortable that demo I rode is exactly the same as the new board I just picked up.



I am quite interested with designs and if I try a board that I like....i'll measure it, so maybe it will allow me to understand what makes it feel good.
So if you think the board you are ordering will be the same as the demo board you tried you should think twice....
The fact is most of the imported boards are not moulded boards but just handshape abroad. Wich is why you can see advertising as "handshape, designed in Australia..."
And you can expect a some significant differences . (same for local shapers...)
If we are talking racing boards, for a very popular 14 from a very repectable brand I checked 3 boards, got 3 different rockers at the back within a 2cm range!! which is in theory quite significant.(we are talking + or -20% of the original value!!)
Even the lenght is often different. Everybody realised it at the BOP in Noosa when trying to fit in the boards between the planks to be sure they were under the 12'6 cut. Some from the same brand could hardly fit, some had a 4 cm margin....
At the end of the day I am not sure it all matters as almost nobody feels it while paddling and the best paddlers are always in front. So who really cares??
Instead of thinking we will always benefit from a little difference or on the contrary won't be able to paddle or compete because the board ordered has 1cm more or less rocker than previously thought we should maybe concentrate on paddling more, adapt to the board we have and deal with it.
The most important seems to be the perception of the board we have, and why not.... but to know if what we are paddling is exactly what we think it is is another story

Al Hunter
NSW, 367 posts
12 May 2011 1:41AM
Thumbs Up

chrispychru said...

I WOULD LOVE TO BUY AUSSIE but what shop can i go into and buy a board.
I cant wait for the day that i can walk into a shop and buy a aussie sup,that will make me smile.


Look I don't know where you live but I'm in Byron bay.

So I can go to Maddog and smile because they do their own boards and sell them in their shop.
If I want to take my car I drive 20km south to lennox , go to All above Boards and smile again because they do their own boards and sell them in their shop as well...

both of them will demo their boards and go and paddle with you and give you free tips...and by the way they sell imported boards as well and will still go and paddle with you if you are interested.

So you don't have to wait it's already happening

rahams
NSW, 544 posts
12 May 2011 1:55AM
Thumbs Up

i was going to say what i thought. thanks mate

Al Hunter said...

chrispychru said...

I WOULD LOVE TO BUY AUSSIE but what shop can i go into and buy a board.
I cant wait for the day that i can walk into a shop and buy a aussie sup,that will make me smile.


Look I don't know where you live but I'm in Byron bay.

So I can go to Maddog and smile because they do their own boards and sell them in their shop.
If I want to take my car I drive 20km south to lennox , go to All above Boards and smile again because they do their own boards and sell them in their shop as well...

both of them will demo their boards and go and paddle with you and give you free tips...and by the way they sell imported boards as well and will still go and paddle with you if you are interested.

So you don't have to wait it's already happening




chrispychru
QLD, 7932 posts
12 May 2011 8:20AM
Thumbs Up

hey im not that far from byron so thanks for that. Is it only Byron you can demo or are there other places that do it as well? Advertise people and let simple people like me know that is possible.

rahams said...

i was going to say what i thought. thanks mate
Al Hunter said...

chrispychru said...

I WOULD LOVE TO BUY AUSSIE but what shop can i go into and buy a board.
I cant wait for the day that i can walk into a shop and buy a aussie sup,that will make me smile.


Look I don't know where you live but I'm in Byron bay.

So I can go to Maddog and smile because they do their own boards and sell them in their shop.
If I want to take my car I drive 20km south to lennox , go to All above Boards and smile again because they do their own boards and sell them in their shop as well...

both of them will demo their boards and go and paddle with you and give you free tips...and by the way they sell imported boards as well and will still go and paddle with you if you are interested.

So you don't have to wait it's already happening







chrispychru
QLD, 7932 posts
12 May 2011 8:22AM
Thumbs Up

rahams what piece of advice were you going to give,say it

rahams said...

i was going to say what i thought. thanks mate
Al Hunter said...

chrispychru said...

I WOULD LOVE TO BUY AUSSIE but what shop can i go into and buy a board.
I cant wait for the day that i can walk into a shop and buy a aussie sup,that will make me smile.


Look I don't know where you live but I'm in Byron bay.

So I can go to Maddog and smile because they do their own boards and sell them in their shop.
If I want to take my car I drive 20km south to lennox , go to All above Boards and smile again because they do their own boards and sell them in their shop as well...

both of them will demo their boards and go and paddle with you and give you free tips...and by the way they sell imported boards as well and will still go and paddle with you if you are interested.

So you don't have to wait it's already happening







Minkee
QLD, 225 posts
12 May 2011 8:51AM
Thumbs Up

Al Hunter said...

aus301 said...



As a long time Windsurfer I am comfortable buying pop-outs. . Given that I am buying from brands I know and trust through the windsurf relationship I am usually always comfortable that my new board will be well constructed, and a good design - even if it may be 6 to 12 months old by virtue of being a pop out. and I can be comfortable that demo I rode is exactly the same as the new board I just picked up.



I am quite interested with designs and if I try a board that I like....i'll measure it, so maybe it will allow me to understand what makes it feel good.
So if you think the board you are ordering will be the same as the demo board you tried you should think twice....
The fact is most of the imported boards are not moulded boards but just handshape abroad. Wich is why you can see advertising as "handshape, designed in Australia..."
And you can expect a some significant differences . (same for local shapers...)
If we are talking racing boards, for a very popular 14 from a very repectable brand I checked 3 boards, got 3 different rockers at the back within a 2cm range!! which is in theory quite significant.(we are talking + or -20% of the original value!!)
Even the lenght is often different. Everybody realised it at the BOP in Noosa when trying to fit in the boards between the planks to be sure they were under the 12'6 cut. Some from the same brand could hardly fit, some had a 4 cm margin....
At the end of the day I am not sure it all matters as almost nobody feels it while paddling and the best paddlers are always in front. So who really cares??
Instead of thinking we will always benefit from a little difference or on the contrary won't be able to paddle or compete because the board ordered has 1cm more or less rocker than previously thought we should maybe concentrate on paddling more, adapt to the board we have and deal with it.
The most important seems to be the perception of the board we have, and why not.... but to know if what we are paddling is exactly what we think it is is another story


For something as long as 14ft (4267.2mm), should we be surprised to find up to 20mm difference on the beach (not at the end of the production line) considering we're dealing with materials that 1- cure in the sun and therefore change shape 2- have a generally a limited controled process in the glassing phase so end up with various amount of resin 3- gets loaded differently because of the paddler and its use?


Minkee
QLD, 225 posts
12 May 2011 8:56AM
Thumbs Up

laceys lane said...

Minkee said...

laceys lane said...

Minkee said...

I like the doctor's proses even if I dont agree with them generally, they're good value and make you think a bit.

so as for managing stock, I don't agree. How managing a product that changes every week compare to one that changes once a year would be the same is beyond my understanding considering the surf shops we have in this country. Not to mention the resale value of the boards that is gold one week and worth peanuts the week after... I dont consider boards as consumables.

I also smile when we were told we would be third world servants to the big asian countries. Well, when these countries finish or shall I say slow their growth and stop depending on our mining resources, money will have to flow from somewhere else big style and we'll be pleased to rely on tourism.

So Lacey to answer your question.
I bought local, I wanted to do the "right thing". That's where the good bit stops.
Often small business are made of passionate people that love their discipline but haven't got a clue about business, customer service and marketing. Now I'm left with a board (not custom I precise) that has lost more than 55% of its value in not even 7 months. Well if anyone thinks that's acceptable for a racing sup, I don't, not in such a short period anyway. So my next board will be an import because the service will be there this time. If I had a good experience in the first place I'd very likely say different I admit but the truth is in the facts sadly.
On the other hand if you want a custom then it makes sense to go local. A custom board is not a transaction based on money but on emotion in my eyes so it's often an experience that will cost in the end when it comes to re-sale the board.




hi, i just caught this. i don't think its just customs mate, actually i know its not. if you think your gonna get big bucks for your production board come time to sell it- will i don't think so. i know of a girl who can't get anything for her production and custom boards.

it's a real problem for the sup industry and buyers i believe- who wants to get bugger all for their rather expensive board as so as its out the door.

really the smart thing to do is buy second hand and be ruthless, but i'm not that smart

but thats another topic in its self
cheers


I'm not after the big bucks with selling boards, for the big bucks I work
My once a year updated pop out will have a better resale value after 12 months than if I buy local again. That way I feel looked after and not shafted, that's called customer satisfaction. If you look at the "buy & sell" here you can see what goes at what value and how how quick it goes. When I see 2yrs old 14ft glides going for $1400 I think its owner thinks "sweet, I won't have to dig too deep for next one."
Please keep in mind I'm referring to pop-out board not custom.

If you want the latest you're not going to buy second hand either... But sure, people must make bargain from buying from you considering your pace
See you on the water.


the board you are talking is good, however i see 2 for $1250, one for $1150 on the breeze. what their advertised for and what one actually gets is two different things

don't you worry about what i get for mine. i do better then your figures because they all go well. however if you can get $1400 for that board 2 years old ,i better get you to sell all my boards


True, you're right about advertised price but I think you get my point. The first board is an investment, if by the time you buy you're second board you don't have to fork out too much because of the sale of the first board then you're better off. It's a cycle, you might well buy a wee bit more expensive 2nd board as a result and this will benefit the seller. So overall quality and resale value is what I look in a board now.

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
12 May 2011 9:04AM
Thumbs Up

Minkee said...

laceys lane said...

Minkee said...

laceys lane said...

Minkee said...

I like the doctor's proses even if I dont agree with them generally, they're good value and make you think a bit.

so as for managing stock, I don't agree. How managing a product that changes every week compare to one that changes once a year would be the same is beyond my understanding considering the surf shops we have in this country. Not to mention the resale value of the boards that is gold one week and worth peanuts the week after... I dont consider boards as consumables.

I also smile when we were told we would be third world servants to the big asian countries. Well, when these countries finish or shall I say slow their growth and stop depending on our mining resources, money will have to flow from somewhere else big style and we'll be pleased to rely on tourism.

So Lacey to answer your question.
I bought local, I wanted to do the "right thing". That's where the good bit stops.
Often small business are made of passionate people that love their discipline but haven't got a clue about business, customer service and marketing. Now I'm left with a board (not custom I precise) that has lost more than 55% of its value in not even 7 months. Well if anyone thinks that's acceptable for a racing sup, I don't, not in such a short period anyway. So my next board will be an import because the service will be there this time. If I had a good experience in the first place I'd very likely say different I admit but the truth is in the facts sadly.
On the other hand if you want a custom then it makes sense to go local. A custom board is not a transaction based on money but on emotion in my eyes so it's often an experience that will cost in the end when it comes to re-sale the board.




hi, i just caught this. i don't think its just customs mate, actually i know its not. if you think your gonna get big bucks for your production board come time to sell it- will i don't think so. i know of a girl who can't get anything for her production and custom boards.

it's a real problem for the sup industry and buyers i believe- who wants to get bugger all for their rather expensive board as so as its out the door.

really the smart thing to do is buy second hand and be ruthless, but i'm not that smart

but thats another topic in its self
cheers


I'm not after the big bucks with selling boards, for the big bucks I work
My once a year updated pop out will have a better resale value after 12 months than if I buy local again. That way I feel looked after and not shafted, that's called customer satisfaction. If you look at the "buy & sell" here you can see what goes at what value and how how quick it goes. When I see 2yrs old 14ft glides going for $1400 I think its owner thinks "sweet, I won't have to dig too deep for next one."
Please keep in mind I'm referring to pop-out board not custom.

If you want the latest you're not going to buy second hand either... But sure, people must make bargain from buying from you considering your pace
See you on the water.


the board you are talking is good, however i see 2 for $1250, one for $1150 on the breeze. what their advertised for and what one actually gets is two different things

don't you worry about what i get for mine. i do better then your figures because they all go well. however if you can get $1400 for that board 2 years old ,i better get you to sell all my boards


True, you're right about advertised price but I think you get my point. The first board is an investment, if by the time you buy you're second board you don't have to fork out too much because of the sale of the first board then you're better off. It's a cycle, you might well buy a wee bit more expensive 2nd board as a result and this will benefit the seller. So overall quality and resale value is what I look in a board now.


yeah, thats a fair point and something that has to be considered these days.

early up secondhand sups sold well because there just wasn't that many around.

also i think that is part of the reason for 14' er sbeing popular, quite hard to sell longer boards. i lot of people just don't have the room for them
cheers

gregc
VIC, 1299 posts
12 May 2011 9:26AM
Thumbs Up

I have surfed all my life and I have owned a number of custom boards in that time, however, I am now SUPing, sailing and surfing on pop outs. The reason is simple, they last longer thereby making them cheaper in the long run. I appreciate the craftsmanship of a finely made custom board, I am comfortable with chatting to a shaper about rails and rockers and all the other crap, but why would I do that if I can get a board off the rack that suits my need?

AA
NSW, 2159 posts
12 May 2011 10:14AM
Thumbs Up

Interesting discussion about resale value of boards.

I have seen plenty of sports grow at the rate the Stand Up us growing but I have never in 25 years see the dollar escalate so consistently to such a height, at the same time.

It is these two factors that have lead to an over supply and prices dropping on all boards. This then makes it harder to get a good return when you sell your board.
When we started selling SUP's in 2007 the price of imported boards was $2300. Two years later it had dropped to $1800. Last season our cheapest board was $1399. This year it is $1099 with a paddle!

This is going to slow down however if the dollar has finally hit the ceiling.

I guess you cant have it both ways - prices dropping and second hand values not following suit.

As customs are just that 'customised to suit a particular rider, they are always going to be harder to sell and get a good return. They are also generally made lighter for high performance.

It also makes it harder (to get a good return), when you buy into a niche market, that is still developing (race boards) or you go for smaller unknown brands - exceptions being highly sort after, quality product.

Nothing has changed, it happens in every boom sport. It is just made worse with an escalating dollar.

Hope this helps to ease the pain

goatman
NSW, 2151 posts
12 May 2011 10:33AM
Thumbs Up

gregc said...

I have surfed all my life and I have owned a number of custom boards in that time, however, I am now SUPing, sailing and surfing on pop outs. The reason is simple, they last longer thereby making them cheaper in the long run. I appreciate the craftsmanship of a finely made custom board, I am comfortable with chatting to a shaper about rails and rockers and all the other crap, but why would I do that if I can get a board off the rack that suits my need?


Fair point and that is the reason most people ride OS stuff. Lets not get all philisophical about the buy local and support OZ shapers because it pure hypocracy as nearly every consumer good is made in Asia.

Most people will make a purchase based purely on their own perceived needs and that is the basis of our market driven capitalistic society. They don't care if someone sponsors a contest or advertises on here (although it helps with brand awareness) - or if it supports a local shaper. Of course people can also be loyal to a particular shop/brand but usually that suits their needs.

I ride customs because I can get a 6 kilo board with thin rails, a narrow tail and a generous rocker (ie exactly what I want) - simple. Yeah I get em a bit cheaper cause the shaper is a mate; but after riding Mtn Bikes for 5 years where a front fork costs $1200 with bugger all resale value the cost of a SUP isn't a big issue for me. If I am right into something, I want the absolute best mechanical advantage I can get.

PS I am only taking about surf SUPs here, If I ever buy a 12'6" it will be an OS board from a local retailer for the same reasons gregc states above.

goatman
NSW, 2151 posts
12 May 2011 11:16AM
Thumbs Up

paul.j said...


If these guys are doing it for the love of it thats cool but when there product gets pimped on say a forum like this that was built on the big brands putting there money where there month is then yes i think some of there topics should get pulled of as to me that is riding on the coat tails.


I am curious what people think about this. For example, lets look at a shaper who is starting out and is keen to advertise on here but finds the cost is prohibitive with the volume of boards he is doing. Does this mean he shouldn't put up videos of his boards? Or talk generally about design? Won't this help to grow his business to a point where they can afford to advertise?

Should the only people allowed to 'talk up' their products be paid up advertisers? I understand there is a fine line between out and out pimping and a bit of putting it out there.

Is not the forum about sharing info? - be it suptle brand exposure or a stoked dude talking up their favourite shop? To me this is what makes the forum interesting. BTW for the record, I have no financial interest in SUP whatsoever!!!

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
12 May 2011 12:02PM
Thumbs Up

goatman said...

paul.j said...


If these guys are doing it for the love of it thats cool but when there product gets pimped on say a forum like this that was built on the big brands putting there money where there month is then yes i think some of there topics should get pulled of as to me that is riding on the coat tails.


I am curious what people think about this. For example, lets look at a shaper who is starting out and is keen to advertise on here but finds the cost is prohibitive with the volume of boards he is doing. Does this mean he shouldn't put up videos of his boards? Or talk generally about design? Won't this help to grow his business to a point where they can afford to advertise?

Should the only people allowed to 'talk up' their products be paid up advertisers? I understand there is a fine line between out and out pimping and a bit of putting it out there.

Is not the forum about sharing info? - be it suptle brand exposure or a stoked dude talking up their favourite shop? To me this is what makes the forum interesting. BTW for the record, I have no financial interest in SUP whatsoever!!!


it would just become a big brand forum. tell me how long that would last. like it or lump it. the breeze and the big boys needs small manufacturers, backyard do it yourselfers etc, crackpots to continue- IT'S STILL ABOUT SUPS

they would be kidding themselfs if they think people would hang around for an out and out big label forum.

geez, we wouldn't even be able to discuss something like this if that were to happen.

stick with FREEDOM OF CHOICE i say, as it's turned out some one like me has had bugger all impact on buyers habits anyway
cheers

doggie
WA, 15849 posts
12 May 2011 10:05AM
Thumbs Up

goatman said...

paul.j said...


If these guys are doing it for the love of it thats cool but when there product gets pimped on say a forum like this that was built on the big brands putting there money where there month is then yes i think some of there topics should get pulled of as to me that is riding on the coat tails.


I am curious what people think about this. For example, lets look at a shaper who is starting out and is keen to advertise on here but finds the cost is prohibitive with the volume of boards he is doing. Does this mean he shouldn't put up videos of his boards? Or talk generally about design? Won't this help to grow his business to a point where they can afford to advertise?

Should the only people allowed to 'talk up' their products be paid up advertisers? I understand there is a fine line between out and out pimping and a bit of putting it out there.

Is not the forum about sharing info? - be it suptle brand exposure or a stoked dude talking up their favourite shop? To me this is what makes the forum interesting. BTW for the record, I have no financial interest in SUP whatsoever!!!


How come in SBs & LBs we have a couple of shapers that comment on stuff and show pics of boards that they done for people and shown their own quivers ect.
I think its a great thing and there should be more of it. At the same time I dont think they are pimping as such but just sharing what they do.
DTM is a classic example of this in the SUP forum and in my eyes is the same as the other shapers mentioned.

SUP is similar to Windsurf as far as the boards go to a certain degree, but you dont see this type of dicussion over in their room but their tech is alot more refined as they have been around alot longer than SUP as well.

The VIP
QLD, 69 posts
12 May 2011 12:33PM
Thumbs Up

If you can afford it,know what you want(and what you are talking about) and have a shaper you can communicate with you get a custom board. If not you demo as many boards as you can til you find one that works for you and one you can afford. The origin of that board is irrelevant imo--most people make purchases with their wallet not their sense of patriotism!!!! BTW i can only dream of spending 20k on toys---currently saving for my second board(a VERY slow process when you are on a pension)

jedijunglsno
NSW, 231 posts
12 May 2011 12:37PM
Thumbs Up

goatman said...
Should the only people allowed to 'talk up' their products be paid up advertisers?


Yes. Most definately. This is why surfing magazines are in such fine form at the moment, and Seabreeze should follow the same path where all content is dictated by advertiser dollars.

goatman
NSW, 2151 posts
12 May 2011 12:52PM
Thumbs Up

jedijunglsno said...

goatman said...
Should the only people allowed to 'talk up' their products be paid up advertisers?


Yes. Most definately. This is why surfing magazines are in such fine form at the moment, and Seabreeze should follow the same path where all content is dictated by advertiser dollars.


Ah yes I see.......that's a fabuous idea and the reason the internet became so popular in the first place

Next you will be telling us that mainstream media content is dictated to by the giant corporations who happen to own them

62mac
WA, 24860 posts
12 May 2011 11:04AM
Thumbs Up

doggie said...


How come in SBs & LBs we have a couple of shapers that comment on stuff and show pics of boards that they done for people and shown their own quivers ect.
I think its a great thing and there should be more of it. At the same time I dont think they are pimping as such


Well said doggie and I cant wait for another one of Lacey's classic topic's,sure was entertaining.

love you all 62 mac mctavish

CMC
QLD, 3954 posts
12 May 2011 1:08PM
Thumbs Up

goatman said...

jedijunglsno said...

goatman said...
Should the only people allowed to 'talk up' their products be paid up advertisers?


Yes. Most definately. This is why surfing magazines are in such fine form at the moment, and Seabreeze should follow the same path where all content is dictated by advertiser dollars.


Ah yes I see.......that's a fabuous idea and the reason the internet became so popular in the first place

Next you will be telling us that mainstream media content is dictated to by the giant corporations who happen to own them


Love it.......

Dazza65
QLD, 389 posts
12 May 2011 5:50PM
Thumbs Up

Hey breezers firstly just want to say I have found this thread a great read, informative with mostly balanced views from all posters. What I am most impressed is that unlike other 'topical' threads it hasn't degenerated into a heated slanging match.

Back on topic my thoughts are that being relatively new to SUP I will always go for the 'off the shelf' product to start with. Hey it might be a local or an o/s board but it will be my decision based on what I need. If there were two boards I considered suitable I would probably choose the local shaped board but that's me. I like being part of the local community and try and support local as much as I can but that's my mindset and each to their own. As mentioned though that there are limited local 'off the shelf' products available so and o/s board maybe my only choice.

On the question re pimping, I am all for retailers, shapers, suppliers promoting their product as in the end it helps me the consumer make an better informed decision on what in my books is a big purchase. I however wouldn't want to see those who have spent and invested money supporting the site get taken for a ride. Maybe have a separate monitored thread with levels of access for promotion for such posts. Probably cant be done but just an idea.

I am also wondering what's going to happen if/when the AUD falls, will that $1099 board deal AA mentioned go back up to $1500 or beyond. That will be a real test for the market to see
the level of elasticity of demand for SUP's. Dont think we have to worry about the AUD falling too much in the short term though, just came back from an Economic Function in Brissie and the honchos there are saying the exchange rate will fall but will still hover around USD$1 over the next two years. The US is an economic basket case right now with no real upside for a long time.

62mac
WA, 24860 posts
12 May 2011 4:07PM
Thumbs Up

Come on Lacey we need another cracker,stuff all on the box atm

camo hosk
VIC, 613 posts
12 May 2011 7:01PM
Thumbs Up

For me resale was a big factor in buying a board, but now I've progressed to sup's with the volume around 110litres its going to be hard to sell a production board as well a custom of that size because the crew surfing these will want the newest ,latest, greatest anyway so for my most recent purchase went for the custom option and had it made more specific to suit what I wanted.Thanks Dan.
If I wanted a larger sup with more volume it would appeal to more people so would then probably go for a popout as easier to sell.

P.S Would like to thank the big advertisers on this site for giving me the opportunity to post here.

cRAZY Canuk
NSW, 2528 posts
12 May 2011 7:18PM
Thumbs Up

Jez Mac dont' lie - your already in that rocking chair, didn't you order a custom one from McTav?

I have home made, chinese made, Thai made, and Ausie made boards in the garage and have enjoyed riding them all. Will I buy another pop out? Sure if the board suits the purpose.

The nice thing about a custom is just that it's tailor made to suit you and for people like me on the bigger end of the spectrum the status quo doesn't always suit us or you want something just outside of the norm/funky, an extra 1" there or here. Lets be honest if your buying a custom board your not buying it to sell it so the resale thing is a bit null and void, not to mention people value stuff far more than it should be when it's second hand (take half off each year you own it). The other nice thing about a custom is depending on how close you are to the shaper and with the shaper you can be a part of the process and watch it be created.

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
12 May 2011 11:17PM
Thumbs Up

62mac said...

Come on Lacey we need another cracker,stuff all on the box atm


hey mac, i'm thinking of 'while the cats away, the mice will play'

think of all the stuff i can post while all the big wigs are away in hawaii

just kidding

Bnaccas
VIC, 1722 posts
13 May 2011 1:03AM
Thumbs Up

laceys lane said...

Bnaccas said...

I'll just answer Laceys question from the original post... and then some...

The other thing is the quality of workmanship is very high but the overall strength doesn't quite match that of "some" of the name brands. I've seen this with most of the customs floating around Vicco.

I'm now on production boards again as I believe they got a kick up the bside and are now pushing the limits with development. The fight
to gain market share amongst the big guys is enough for them to be taking R&D seriously.

Anyway, so to wrap it up...for me... as long as the name brands are building quality high performance boards that compare to customs,
the name brands strength of build, warranty, back up service and re-sale value will be enough to keep me coming back and updating.



i would like to comment here, generally if you are after a custom, you after a light weight performance board. these board are going to be put into places on a wave most other boards can't go. so along with being a lightweight construction like their shortboard cousins they are going to be subject to breakages etc purely on the basis of where they are going to be put in a wave

its not fair to compare a hi performance lite weight weight board with a heavy production board.



I'm on a Nitro 8'5" which IMO is the closest board to a custom shape on the market and I read it was meant to be 8kgs. Mine comes in at 7.8kg dry with fins so this is very comparable to a custom. Most customs are coming in around 6.5kg to 8kg from what I have seen and read here. Production boards have come a long way in the last 12 months IMO.

As for quality, I'm not really talking breakages, more like rail cracks from paddle hits, cracks/splits around the nose and tail, fin plugs cracking around the outside of the plug taking water etc. This is my first pop-out in 2 summers so can't comment on it but none of my mates on pop-outs have had any of these problems.

I'm still a fan of the customs, but IMO there are a FEW pop-outs on the market now that would rate very close to most customs out there. It's the other things I mentioned (warranty, service, re-sale) that have tipped me in favour of the pop-out.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle General


"why not australian" started by laceys lane