Forums > Windsurfing General

June & its 2011 gear - w/surfns gettn fn stupid

Reply
Created by russh > 9 months ago, 10 Jun 2010
stehsegler
WA, 3473 posts
11 Jun 2010 9:34PM
Thumbs Up

Gybesports said...
Plenty of time then for the punters to do their research and see whats happening.
It's not great for the northern hemisphere retailers show are mid season now and the punters are already saying I see you changes x or Y for 2011 can you do me a deal on the now obsolete 2010 model.


From my experience the Northern European sales are heavily based on how the magazine tests turn out. They usually arrive at the news stand around December/ January. The main buying season then starts around March / April. Once you get close to July it's pretty much all over red rover and then only way to sell gear is by heavy discounting. Once September rolls around the trade fares start and retailers try to flog "last seasons" stuff at greatly reduced prices.

Not sure what it's like these days but but a few years ago as a retailer payment was structured into multiple payments. Eg 25% upfront then 50% mid season then 25% at the end of the season. Pricing is heavily dependent on the number of units you order... eg if you pickup 200 or 300 sails from a distributor you can expect a pretty healthy discount. I remember working for a store and ordering Gaastra in lots of 500 at a time. Once September would come around and it was time for the trade shows we would often buy up all remaining stock of certain types of sails that sold well through out the season... and subsequently pocketing a huge discount on the wholesale price.

I am guessing the Australian market is minuscule in comparison and hence a dealers bargaining power relatively small.

The advantage though is that due to the small market size dealers will only bring in gear that they think/ know will work well for the local conditions. Plus we tend to get the gear a good 6 months or so before everyone else in Europe.

greenleader
QLD, 5283 posts
11 Jun 2010 11:39PM
Thumbs Up

because the new gear is really easy to use and makes bad sailors look good!

struggle with your old junk, the windsurfing manufacturers soon realised that when "easy kiting" came along and took half of their market that they had better make their stuff easier and more fun to ride too. just gets better every year.

racerX
462 posts
11 Jun 2010 10:11PM
Thumbs Up

greenleader said...

because the new gear is really easy to use and makes bad sailors look good!

struggle with your old junk, the windsurfing manufacturers soon realised that when "easy kiting" came along and took half of their market that they had better make their stuff easier and more fun to ride too. just gets better every year.


Same thing happened with skiing. Lazy manufactures just selling detuned salom skiis, with snowboarding taking so much marketshare they have since lifted their game considerably.

Gestalt
QLD, 14437 posts
12 Jun 2010 1:38AM
Thumbs Up

^^ gotta agree, al those guys that switched to kiting around 2000 have really missed out! they'll never know now....

gear is so much easier to sail.....

Mrgob
116 posts
12 Jun 2010 1:18AM
Thumbs Up

Are the new crop of waveboards REALLY easier to use than some of the past good ones?

Judging from the amount of hot air generated on other forums concerning twin, triple, and quad fin sizes and placement (millionths of an inch one way or the other apparently make all the difference) I'll stick to my original Evo 74 thank you very much! That IS easy to sail.
Also, aren't some old long raceboards just as easy (and fast) to use as their modern equivalents?

stehsegler
WA, 3473 posts
12 Jun 2010 2:56AM
Thumbs Up

Mrgob said...

Are the new crop of waveboards REALLY easier to use than some of the past good ones?

Judging from the amount of hot air generated on other forums concerning twin, triple, and quad fin sizes and placement (millionths of an inch one way or the other apparently make all the difference) I'll stick to my original Evo 74 thank you very much! That IS easy to sail.
Also, aren't some old long raceboards just as easy (and fast) to use as their modern equivalents?


of course the boards make people better and better sailors every year... just look at that Kauli kid... when he first started his gear was obviously not as a good as his gear today... why else would he be a better sailor.

Hence... I'll be buying a new board every year for the next 10 years... that should make me a world champ too.

KenHo
NSW, 1353 posts
12 Jun 2010 7:35AM
Thumbs Up

racerX said...

greenleader said...

because the new gear is really easy to use and makes bad sailors look good!

struggle with your old junk, the windsurfing manufacturers soon realised that when "easy kiting" came along and took half of their market that they had better make their stuff easier and more fun to ride too. just gets better every year.


Same thing happened with skiing. Lazy manufactures just selling detuned salom skiis, with snowboarding taking so much marketshare they have since lifted their game considerably.



That is definitely true. You should see the range of Rossi off-piste skis for this year. The S6's I bought last year are a perfect example of what you are saying.
Hard to tell if new gear is easier to use, cos I can still use the old stuff, so it's all easy to me.
DEfinitely was not always the case though, and to get from there to here, there was a bunch of smnall steps, in the form, of annual seasonal improvements. So who knows where we will be in another 10 years.
New gear is certainly nice though I still haven't forgiven Robbie Naish for wiping out single cam bump and jump sails when he wiped out cams all together form everything except race sails.


Wood Duck
157 posts
12 Jun 2010 7:13AM
Thumbs Up

KenHo said...

racerX said...

greenleader said...

because the new gear is really easy to use and makes bad sailors look good!

struggle with your old junk, the windsurfing manufacturers soon realised that when "easy kiting" came along and took half of their market that they had better make their stuff easier and more fun to ride too. just gets better every year.


Same thing happened with skiing. Lazy manufactures just selling detuned salom skiis, with snowboarding taking so much marketshare they have since lifted their game considerably.


That is definitely true. You should see the range of Rossi off-piste skis for this year. The S6's I bought last year are a perfect example of what you are saying.
Hard to tell if new gear is easier to use, cos I can still use the old stuff, so it's all easy to me.
DEfinitely was not always the case though, and to get from there to here, there was a bunch of smnall steps, in the form, of annual seasonal improvements. So who knows where we will be in another 10 years.
New gear is certainly nice though I still haven't forgiven Robbie Naish for wiping out single cam bump and jump sails when he wiped out cams all together form everything except race sails.




And Robby will probably not forgive you for spelling his name wrong.

russh
SA, 3025 posts
12 Jun 2010 9:46AM
Thumbs Up

AUS4 said...
[br

I think you will find it goes by seasons not by the year. So what would you prefer to get you new 2011 gear this season in september of next september a year later. Then you really will be complaining.


Funnily enough we don't have a "Season " in SA winter is mainly about pre frontal cross off waves in Nth Nw'rs / westerley frontal onshores and in summer its seabreeze / gully wind B&J with the occaisonal wave days with a bit of a lull in April.

All the new gear arrives in september / october and by the time you actually get to use it in decent waves its winter, the new stocks on the way and its already old school. So what your saying actually happens.

izaak
TAS, 1977 posts
12 Jun 2010 10:24AM
Thumbs Up

in away i do see where you coming from,i think people are better off holding onto gear for a couple of years then upgrading,that way you can get used to your gear and will preform better than having to change over every year and not really getting the best out of your gear yet.

choco
SA, 4037 posts
12 Jun 2010 10:12AM
Thumbs Up

izaak said...

in away i do see where you coming from,i think people are better off holding onto gear for a couple of years then upgrading,that way you can get used to your gear and will preform better than having to change over every year and not really getting the best out of your gear yet.


so true

gspotxtreme
WA, 94 posts
12 Jun 2010 11:54AM
Thumbs Up


Reasons to upgrade every year or 2 - your used equipment still commands a reasonable price on the second hand market. Especially if you have a good relationship with a retailer who will give you a reasonable trade and/or discount on new equipment if you pre order (now is not to early)

-retain the stoke. Nothing like nice shiny, crisp sails with crystal clear windows and a different/better feeling board under your feet to amp you up for that early season trip to Gnaraloo.

- improve your sailing. Believe the hype. The worlds best sailors are out in all conditions for the whole year tweaking/improving the gear. Believe it or not there are plenty of Aussie sailors who are good enough to notice the improvements and move forward with their sailing ability. Case in point - Quad fins. Now we have boards that can handle extreme/overpowered conditions where in the past they may have felt slightly sketchy. This gives confidence to push harder and try new moves in more radical situations. Also the option of different fin configurations for different conditions on the one board is a noticable step forward in design.

Windsurfing is getting fn more fun.

P.C_simpson
NSW, 1489 posts
12 Jun 2010 5:00PM
Thumbs Up

I don't know about the rest of you guys but living in W.A and sailing everytime it's windy, my 5.3m comes out the bag a hell of alot, especially this summer so up grading at least 1 size in my quiver it almost a must as this sail has signs of abuse.. but then the new sail makes the other 4 wave sails feel not as good, so a few more sneak in, if there are big improvements from the year before i end up changing all of them like last year

As far as boards go, i tend to hang onto them if i love them, my favourite boards or a 2005 model and 2008.. but a new twinfin is definately on the cards for this season.

New gear does get the motivation pumping.. and i think i would rather spend the cash on a new sail than something thats going to be out of date as soon as i leave the store like an iPhone..

divaldo
SA, 2878 posts
12 Jun 2010 4:45PM
Thumbs Up

Russ, not all of us are frothing at the mouth waiting for new gear! Who are you talking about? People in SA getting new gear are the sponsored sailors....

I dont buy new sails I win them....when is the next ONBOARD Raffle?

Mrgob
116 posts
12 Jun 2010 5:26PM
Thumbs Up

In reply to gspotxtreme. 'If it aint broke don't mend it'! (A polite way of saying rubbish!)

Gestalt
QLD, 14437 posts
12 Jun 2010 8:17PM
Thumbs Up

i'd say gspot is very much on the money.

i'd rather see a sport where designers strive to achieve a better outcome year after year than be stuck sailing something from 1980 that is less forgiving. it's probably not fair lumping designers and marketting into the same category.

designers are typically chasing perfection in design. the only way to do that is to redesign over and over and over again.

gear does evolve from year to year, new materials, new construction methods, new shapes and on and on.



Chris 249
NSW, 3394 posts
12 Jun 2010 8:45PM
Thumbs Up

gspotxtreme said...


Reasons to upgrade every year or 2 - your used equipment still commands a reasonable price on the second hand market. Especially if you have a good relationship with a retailer who will give you a reasonable trade and/or discount on new equipment if you pre order (now is not to early)

-retain the stoke. Nothing like nice shiny, crisp sails with crystal clear windows and a different/better feeling board under your feet to amp you up for that early season trip to Gnaraloo.

- improve your sailing. Believe the hype. The worlds best sailors are out in all conditions for the whole year tweaking/improving the gear. Believe it or not there are plenty of Aussie sailors who are good enough to notice the improvements and move forward with their sailing ability. Case in point - Quad fins. Now we have boards that can handle extreme/overpowered conditions where in the past they may have felt slightly sketchy. This gives confidence to push harder and try new moves in more radical situations. Also the option of different fin configurations for different conditions on the one board is a noticable step forward in design.

Windsurfing is getting fn more fun.


I'm not saying your post is wrong (although I don't agree with the last sentence, necessarily) but it's just one way of looking at it.

Some of us don't really want to get "better" simply because we spend more. Sure, if we get a new board we may be able to push harder and do more - but in that case we haven't achieved anything at all personally. We haven't stretched our own boundaries one inch. All we've done is spend money and someone else has created something that goes better. Sure, if I went out and spend $7k on new wave gear I may be able to loop - but if I've only achieved that by spending cash rather than improving my sailing, who cares?

I haven't spent more than three days per season in the waves for years, so I'm coming from a slightly different angle. But if you're into something like speed or racing, there can be a pretty hollow feeling when you just go faster by spending more cash.

Some of us prefer to spend less time slaving for a buck, and more time out there on old gear having fun and getting better. And personally, I'm fairly sure that you get more improvement by spending time on the water than by spending money, and a bunch of national champs in everything from Wallies to waves agree with that.

On the other hand, yes there's definitely a buzz in getting better gear, and without developments we'd all be standing on hollow logs hanging onto trees.

Mrgob
116 posts
12 Jun 2010 6:59PM
Thumbs Up

When you say gear evolves from year to year Gestalt, I sgree. But it isn't necessarily for the better.(You improve one aspect but spoil another.)

What I was objecting to was gspotextremes statement that we should - Believe the hype - worlds best sailers working hard - Quad fins- etc. Yes, there has been definite progress over the years, and many new boards are the better for it. I have nine boards in use (a right mix of old and new) so can readily compare them.

My current mid range favourite is an Exocet Cross 94 which really tick all my boxes. I am an ordinary Joe competent windsurfer with no pretensions or ambitions to be a world champion. Most of those I sail with or meet are the same.WE are the ones who keep the windsurfing industry going by buying new boards, sails, masts etc etc on a regular basis, yet none of us are being sucked into this (mainly Starboard) multi fin hype.

Just look at the Evil Twin debacle! You know the sort of thing - years of developement by the worlds greatest sailors have produced this revolutionary concept- blah blah blah, only for it to be dropped almost immediately, to be replaced by a quad! (Our local dealer who stocked up on them was reduced to flogging them off at half price to get shot of them.) How does gspextreme explain that??

I am not against progress. I love it, provided it is real and relevant to the average Joe. I don't want to go back to the 80's, but neither do I dismiss out of hand some of the better old boards.

mkseven
QLD, 2314 posts
12 Jun 2010 9:41PM
Thumbs Up

Just remember evolution isn't always successful. The pwa and local scene is full of sponsored/team sailors that have gone backwards due to evolution.

It is good that in some disciplines windsurfing gear is able to make substantial gains from year to year. But some disciplines dont, I dont think slalom boards have changed that much in the last 4 years and it's just a case of history repeating. For example slalom boards or sails... new major shape change hits market- they are wickedly quick, then they make the easier to sail, then broaden their range. Then thats pretty much it, they bugger around with marketing bs until a new concept hits. The concept now is multi fin waveboards, but consider anything else in life- if you buy the 1st model be prepared that it might not work.

Perfection in design? Antoine might come in and say I need my boards with more power out of the gybes, alright lets pump some volume into the rails and make em boxy. Never mind that it then only suits a very particular group of sailors and anyone not of peak ability will struggle with all of the downsides that change might bring. The designer might have no real improvements in mind for the year, the powers above might then remind him/her that if they dont come up with something they will find someone that can. You can't associate your touchy feely ethics with the bottom line which is almost always to produce a market-able product for the cheapest possible price.

You can keep buying and buying but it WON'T make you better. Learning to tune and ride what you have is where it's at. I always considered the best sailors those that could grab something unused out of the box and make it work 100% straight away, and from all of the sailors I know that is very few people. For many I would say it would take them up to 2 years to start getting the most out of their gear.

Material changes... alot is trying to make things cheaper. Most everything current here has been done before. Sail brand or board brand might get offered some not quite suitable materials for cheap. The designer makes it work, it doesnt immediately fall to bits in testing so then it can be sold. Then marketing makes it the best new thing to hit windsurfing when it's all just a load of crap.

I am all for sailors having recent gear though, as an industry there is definitely creeping progression. I am definitely for cashed up folk buying up big for whatever reason makes them happy, it keeps the 2nd hand market healthy and fuels that progression

Gestalt
QLD, 14437 posts
12 Jun 2010 11:36PM
Thumbs Up

Mrgob said...

When you say gear evolves from year to year Gestalt, I sgree. But it isn't necessarily for the better.(You improve one aspect but spoil another.)

What I was objecting to was gspotextremes statement that we should - Believe the hype - worlds best sailers working hard - Quad fins- etc. Yes, there has been definite progress over the years, and many new boards are the better for it. I have nine boards in use (a right mix of old and new) so can readily compare them.

My current mid range favourite is an Exocet Cross 94 which really tick all my boxes. I am an ordinary Joe competent windsurfer with no pretensions or ambitions to be a world champion. Most of those I sail with or meet are the same.WE are the ones who keep the windsurfing industry going by buying new boards, sails, masts etc etc on a regular basis, yet none of us are being sucked into this (mainly Starboard) multi fin hype.

Just look at the Evil Twin debacle! You know the sort of thing - years of developement by the worlds greatest sailors have produced this revolutionary concept- blah blah blah, only for it to be dropped almost immediately, to be replaced by a quad! (Our local dealer who stocked up on them was reduced to flogging them off at half price to get shot of them.) How does gspextreme explain that??

I am not against progress. I love it, provided it is real and relevant to the average Joe. I don't want to go back to the 80's, but neither do I dismiss out of hand some of the better old boards.


i do agree with gspot's statement there. multifin boards do handle extreme overpowered conditions better. i've only had limited experience trying different fin arrangments myself but i can say from my experiences that multifin boards do improve max control and do translate into more confident sailing in extreme conditions. whether a quad is a better functional outcome than a trifin i'll leave to others to debate.

If you are sailing flat water then multifin boards feel more draggy and less lit up so probably not what you're after.. so the advantages are really only for wave sailors and extending the wind range of bump and jump boards or giving wide tailed boards more bite.

i also agree that manufacturers do put pro feedback directly into their designs. testing is the only way to know for sure something works and the pro feedback is the testing forum.

re twins, i wasn't a big fan of the twin concept myself. like you i really thought it was all hype and a way of selling more boards. more specifically, regards the jp twins, guys i know that got them did improve their wave riding straight away. for me though a twin would be a waste of money because of the type of sailing i do.....

it's difficult for the manufacturers to some degree, when they build boards or sails for the pro team sailors they have a brief outlined. the average jo's like you and me aren't in the position to be part of that brief creation process unless we buy custom gear. that's where the shop owners come into play recommending the appropriate gear by establishing the clients brief.

the interesting thing is that the people i know that design boards and sails never claim to have designed the best do all piece of kit for all conditions. they will openly say this design is meant for this and that design for that. they will also explain why they tweaked something and how it has improved the function of their product.

i also agree with MK above, like cars a totaly new design does come with flaws. version 2 is normally much better.

Chris 249
NSW, 3394 posts
13 Jun 2010 12:16AM
Thumbs Up

As you noted, Gestalt, there can be problems when you rely on pro testing.

The way I look at it, pros sail at a different level and normally in different conditions to most sailors, so a board that suits them may not suit most of us. Their expertise (and it's not all down to talent but simply due to the fact that they spend so much time sailing) means that they can do things better, and that affects their gear. For example, they may want sails that work better at higher apparent winds because they don't slow down in gybes and therefore don't have to accelerate again.

To use an analogy, it's fairly well known in offshore racing yachts that you may have to change sail trim when a less expert driver (ie the owner) gets on the helm. You crank up the halyard and/or cunno to create a deeper and more forgiving entry, you twist the sails off a bit more, you may have to subtly change things to keep them in the groove.... all these are things that illustrate how a lack of practice changes things, even when nothing else changes. Just like sail shape changes when you go from a pro yacht driver to an amateur driving the same yacht, things should change when you go from a pro sailor to an amateur.

This goes down even to the ex-pro or ex-semi pro level, where the top guys can do things the average championship competitor simply cannot do. Take something as basic as a Wally, and we'll see the top guys can do things with it that the middle guys at titles cannot do*. If the top guys design a Wally-type board to suit them, it simply won't work as well for the average keen sailor.

Whether this is allowed for enough in windsurfers is an open question. I don't bother to buy new stuff these days, but I can get to sail it when I want and IMHO there's still a bit too much designing for pros and not enough designing for Joe Average who can have very different needs and wants. IMHO, this just isn't allowed for sufficiently a lot of the time.

* and the middle guys at the nationals can include guys who are national champs in other types of windsurfing, so it's not lack of talent.

Scotty Mac
SA, 2055 posts
13 Jun 2010 1:15AM
Thumbs Up

chris 249
you auto to get out the house or have a drink every now and then to reset your mind... i got no idea wot planet you are on..... thinking too deeply is giving you a perspective thats not even real... pros get planning and jump waves, surf wave. >amature gets planning, jumps wave, surfs wave..... simple stuff

if anyone wants to see if the new gear is any good, go out and grab some 5 year old stuff(in newish condition) and do a one for one comparison testing on the water one day. If you cant tell the difference, keep your old stuff.

My guess will be you can and that wont neccecarily mean your a pro.....


Russ,
vote with your feet, hang on to your 2010 twin fin another year or two.....it will still go fine. Bet you still dont have it in 4 years... then will you be a hypocrit?

windsufering
VIC, 1124 posts
13 Jun 2010 2:43AM
Thumbs Up

new gear is designed for men with lady like features

windsufering
VIC, 1124 posts
13 Jun 2010 2:45AM
Thumbs Up

the reason he wont have hes twin fin in four years time is that they are not built to last just built tolook good

Mrgob
116 posts
13 Jun 2010 1:12AM
Thumbs Up

If I may add an average Joe's further comment. Out of my current mix of boards the most ancient still in use for a particular set of conditions is a Bic Techno E Medium 112 litre. (10 years old last month.)

I keep it for Summer seabreeze force 4ish type days, with a grunty 6.0 or 6.8 sail. It is not the fastest, or the lightest, or the worlds greatest board BUT, it has an uncanny knack of making me sing my head off! (Audible from 400 yards out I'm told.)

It's combination of shape, size, weight, and less stiff build all add up to a soul cleansing, highly satisfying, hovery feel, as it gallumphs on a steady plane over a swelly sparkling sunlit sea. No other board I've ever tried can produce the same magic in those conditions. How could anything improve on it? (The nearest equivalent in feel is my Syncro 104, but that is lighter and stiffer, and prefers a bit of surf.)

It isn't necessary to always be extreme, and to be 'pushing the envelope'. I think people who only think that way are missing out on something. It's that old graceful 'poetry in motion' thing, isn't it??

KenHo
NSW, 1353 posts
13 Jun 2010 7:47AM
Thumbs Up

I'm not sure that the design of sailing is gear is aimed solely at pro level sailors.
There is gear to suit a whole range of competency levels, from first-time beginner, to novice, to progressing intermediate etc etc etc. Many boards have very specific design briefs, like the GO series, which are all about the non-pro sailor.
I recall this trend beginning about 10 yr ago, when "free-ride" boards came along to provide an easier to sail alternative to harder edged slalom boards.
I also recall Robby Naish coming out with camberless racing sails about 10 yr ago, in the early days of his independent company, with the idea that cams were too much trouble for the average sailor, and therefore were an evil that needed to be eradicated from the earth. He pretty much succeeded there for a while. I made a comment about this in another thread a few days ago, as I really missed then and now, having a single cam in a 5.5 for borderline conditions.
So, lots and lots of attention has been paid to intermediate recreational sailors for a long time and I'm not sure where this idea is coming from that it's all about the pros.

Gestalt
QLD, 14437 posts
13 Jun 2010 9:49AM
Thumbs Up

hi chris

the difference between OD and other forms of windsurfing is innovation. i don't think it true to say that gear tested by pros doesn't play a positive role in gear development. just look at FW class. the width thing has been the single most positive influence on board design across the spectrum. the pros are also chasing gear that is easier to sail in particular wind strengths and conditions. it allows them to concentrate on tactics or pushing the limits of moves. that said not all pro sailors are racers. some are just exceptional talents that free sail.

the whole tow debate is a moot point. tow will make anyone better. practice is practice.

hi gob

i'm not someone pushing the limits, i just do it for fun. that doesn't mean i can't feel the improvements certain tweaks have made and enjoy well designed gear.

hi ken.

very true. not all gear's brief is for competition.

russh
SA, 3025 posts
13 Jun 2010 10:45AM
Thumbs Up

Scotty Mac said...

Russ,
vote with your feet, hang on to your 2010 twin fin another year or two.....it will still go fine. Bet you still dont have it in 4 years... then will you be a hypocrit?




Agree but the thing won't be hanging together too well by then and no as I won't go and buy a new untested unridden board again purely on hype and hear say.

It rocks in good waves and decent wind >20knts - here lies the problem with w/surfn in Adelaide!! Thats why my 2006 Skate and 2008 Freewave get the most water time - both second hand and after looking at the reviews from crew that had them the years before.



Chris 249
NSW, 3394 posts
13 Jun 2010 3:02PM
Thumbs Up

Scotty Mac said...

chris 249
you auto to get out the house or have a drink every now and then to reset your mind... i got no idea wot planet you are on..... thinking too deeply is giving you a perspective thats not even real... pros get planning and jump waves, surf wave. >amature gets planning, jumps wave, surfs wave..... simple stuff

if anyone wants to see if the new gear is any good, go out and grab some 5 year old stuff(in newish condition) and do a one for one comparison testing on the water one day. If you cant tell the difference, keep your old stuff.

My guess will be you can and that wont neccecarily mean your a pro.....


Scotty, you don't have to be patronising, and I can assure you I DO get out of the house and DO have a drink or two....or three, four, five, whatever. And if you actually read my post you'll see from the first and last sentences that I was NOT against advances, or saying that my view was the only one.

Can I ask how many pros you've sailed against? Pros get planning earlier, jump higher, surf waves by doing better turns at more critical sections and other things. That's why they are pros. If they sailed just like Joe Average, they'd be Joe Average.

Joe Average sails a different way because Joe Average is not Bjorn or someone like him, therefore the gear that suits Bjorn etc often doesn't suit Joe Average who sails slower, jumps lower, gybes slower, yada yada yada.

MKSeven put it well when he said "Perfection in design? Antoine might come in and say I need my boards with more power out of the gybes, alright lets pump some volume into the rails and make em boxy. Never mind that it then only suits a very particular group of sailors and anyone not of peak ability will struggle with all of the downsides that change might bring."

I NEVER said that new gear is crap or anything like that, I merely said that gear that is designed for use by pros doesn't always translate into gear that's better for average sailors.





Chris 249
NSW, 3394 posts
13 Jun 2010 3:47PM
Thumbs Up

Gestalt said...

hi chris

the difference between OD and other forms of windsurfing is innovation.

Yeah, I was using OD gear as an example to show that faster sailors can have very different requirements in gear, because of their extra skill.

i don't think it true to say that gear tested by pros doesn't play a positive role in gear development. just look at FW class. the width thing has been the single most positive influence on board design across the spectrum. the pros are also chasing gear that is easier to sail in particular wind strengths and conditions. it allows them to concentrate on tactics or pushing the limits of moves. that said not all pro sailors are racers. some are just exceptional talents that free sail.

the whole tow debate is a moot point. tow will make anyone better. practice is practice.

hi gob

i'm not someone pushing the limits, i just do it for fun. that doesn't mean i can't feel the improvements certain tweaks have made and enjoy well designed gear.

hi ken.

very true. not all gear's brief is for competition.


Gestalt, I wasn't trying to say that pro developments never helped, merely that there's a good case to say that they don't always help. But the point is that the gear that goes better for the top guys can be very different from the gear that goes better for the average guys.

To explain the Wally analogy; if you have a Wally race in 28 knots and big waves, the top guys will go fastest when they use the normal full sail. But back in the pack (and there's some guys there who are **** hot in the surf on their other gear) they'd often be better off with a smaller sail in heavy winds because they spend too much time struggling to control the full sail or falling off.

The point is that even with such basic gear, what works for the top guys does not always work as well for the average guys because they are often going slower, aren't as strong and/or as good at using their available strength, fall more often and therefore need stuff that re-starts more easily, have a harder time handling the rig through tacks, etc etc etc.

You can apply the same thing to other areas of boards (rail shape, fin size, sail type) and other areas of sailing, in my opinion. Look at Robby Naish, who someone else cited as an example. He can use a smaller board in wave comps than someone like me, because he is soooo much better that he can quickly uphaul when up to his waste in water and in the impact zone. Someone like me just can't consistently uphaul a board that small in those conditions, so I need different gear. And he can do a much more aggressive bottom turn without making a mistake or slowing down, so arguably he needs a different rail shape and rocker line.

If I grabbed Robby's gear I'd just sink and flounder. If I use my easier-to-sail gear I'd still flounder, but not as badly.

Ken's point that not all gear is pointed out pro sailors is a good one, but IMHO there's more windsurfing gear that's aimed at leading edge than in other sports I do, and I think that means that the sport becomes unnecessarily hard and probably doesn't perform any better. I'm a mediocre bike racer and no one tells me to use the same gear settings as Cadel Evans, but plenty of people get told to use the same sail settings as Bjorn despite the fact that we aren't as fast as he is and we sail in a different way.

Time on the water CAN be a different issue, for sure - but it's also sometimes closely related. Most of us have budget limitations on our sailing, and often it can be better using cash to get TOW in good conditions rather than getting a shinier sail..... well, that's my take on it anyway.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"June & its 2011 gear - w/surfns gettn fn stupid" started by russh