Forums > Windsurfing General

when shoud vent plugs be removed

Reply
Created by dkeating > 9 months ago, 3 Jan 2013
dkeating
VIC, 258 posts
4 Jan 2013 12:14AM
Thumbs Up

Hi i,ve been windsurfing for years and recently supping but am never sure when to release the vent plugs.
In winter they stay in permanently but as the weather warms up i am paranoid if boards are in a hot car or shed so i normally release them but occasionally forget to put them back in and realise either just before or after hit the water.
what do other people do? any one had any blow outs when not released?
or should i only release them on really hot days or when airfreighting.
Thanks
Dale

decrepit
WA, 12161 posts
3 Jan 2013 9:58PM
Thumbs Up

I don't think you can be that specific, depends on board construction, I've got a mate with a NZ Styrotech that doesn't have a plug, it's been airfreighted and left in the back of hot vans, about 20 years old and still OK. (I guess there's a chance it's made from closed cell styro but I doubt it.

I've seen other boards blow their bottoms even though their owners say they always loosen the plug.

It's a statistical chance, the more you leave the plug done up the greater the chance of blowing the bottom.
It's up to you, how much of a chance you want to take.

There are strategies that people use to make sure the bung gets done up before hitting the water, there's been several discussed here, I can't remember them all. Hopefully others will give us a new list.

It's also possible to convert to a gortex vent, but as far as I'm concerned the jury is still out on that.
I've done 2 boards, so far so good, but I did have a test vent block up on me after it had water on both sides.

CJW
NSW, 1718 posts
4 Jan 2013 1:12AM
Thumbs Up

I release my vent plugs on one occasion only, when I put my gear on a plane, otherwise I leave them in. I currently own 6 boards and have owned probably 10 over the years, never had a problem.

My theory is that chance i'll leave the plug out is far more likely to happen than something occur from leaving it in. Then there's the maintenance you need to perform if you undo it all the time, keep checking the o-ring, replace it regularly due to wear, the chance that it won't seat properly one day etc etc. All too much like hard work, adding unnecessary risk, leave it in, profit

dinsdale
WA, 1227 posts
3 Jan 2013 10:16PM
Thumbs Up

Any time the board is not in the water.

TurtleHunter
WA, 1675 posts
3 Jan 2013 11:50PM
Thumbs Up

I heard it was the daily change in temperature that over time weakens the board.
For me though the board will last much longer if I eliminate the risk of leaving it open when I hit the water

sboardcrazy
NSW, 8021 posts
4 Jan 2013 4:37AM
Thumbs Up

I loosen it after every sail before it goes in the board bag and retighten it before I put the board in the water.I've got into the habit of doing it after I put the fin in so I don't forget.
If I come in and the board is going to be left in the sun I loosen it and put the screwdriver somewhere on the board where it's a nuisance and I can't miss it!
I've got Tabous and you can do that.. I get the impression that other brands you have to take the plug right out to work..???

Beaglebuddy
1595 posts
4 Jan 2013 5:14AM
Thumbs Up

I think you are much more likely to forget to reinstall it one time and waterlog the board than any benefit gained by removing it every time.
TBS, I don't carry my boards inside a vehicle.
The only time I remove it is on a really hot day I'll leave it out in the sun to try and evaporate any water that may have migrated into the board somehow.
If you use a two bolt mast base the plug can be stored inside the part attached to the board so it will be impossible to rig up without reinstalling the plug.

qldnacra
QLD, 455 posts
4 Jan 2013 8:16AM
Thumbs Up

So here's how i think about it. You do the plug up on an average to warm temperature day and leave it done up. It goes in the car and expands a bit in the heat but enough to damage it "?". You put it in the water to sail and it contracts a little but enough to damage it, obviously not.
If you leave the plug out and it's a really hot day then you do it up then throw the board straight in the water to sail there is probably just as much contraction except at a much quicker rate due to the water being much colder as what you would get expansion if you left the plug in and put the board in the car. Which one is worse for the board i don't know but i do know that if i forgot to do up the plug then that would be worse than both and so would getting a little piece of sand under the o-ring that made it leak or if the o-ring split when you were doing it up because you used it one time too many. So mine stays done up permanently because in my opinion there is much less chance of the board getting damaged by temperature variation than what there is from a stuffed o-ring or being in a rush to hit the water one day and forgetting to tighten it.
That is unless you own a JP because you can't put the mast base in the slot if the vent plug is loose because it is behind the mast track. Good idea i think if it's not just a fluke but you can still wear your o-ring out.

shear tip
NSW, 1125 posts
4 Jan 2013 9:29AM
Thumbs Up

sboardcrazy said...
I loosen it after every sail before it goes in the board bag...


Wouldn't the water vapour from the wet footstraps create a very moist atmosphere in the bag after a sail which would get sucked into the vent plug as the board cools and contracts. It might be better to leave the vent done up on the way home, and then store the board out of it's bag and then loosen the vent.

Just a thought - I don't usually loosen the vent, but I think I might start doing it...

ejmack
VIC, 1308 posts
4 Jan 2013 9:39AM
Thumbs Up

Not sure it would be wise to put a wet board in a board bag with a open vent plug.

I leave mine tight unless I know it's going to be very hot and left in the van.

ka43
NSW, 3075 posts
4 Jan 2013 9:40AM
Thumbs Up

Mike makes a good point. Ive always loosened he plugs in my boards after a sail but of late have stopped doing so straight after a sail. If its a very hot day or board has been sitting in the sun I will quickly loosen it to release any pressure build up then re-tighten (to stop moisture from wet straps etc getting into board) before I put in the bag and car for trip home.
Once home I put the board with vent plug undone on board rack.
Like a lot of things its a habit you get used to.
I guess if it made no difference then manufacturers wouldnt put that warning sticker on their boards.

Mobydisc
NSW, 9029 posts
4 Jan 2013 9:45AM
Thumbs Up

Agree with Shear Tip, Mike. I used to undo the screw after sailing but after reading about how this may result in water getting into the board if the board and straps are wet, I don't worry about undoing it.

After about 5 years of boards with plugs and not undoing them I'm yet to have one have an issue with the hull due to pressure differences that I know of. They have all been Tabou boards.

Ian K
WA, 4049 posts
4 Jan 2013 7:04AM
Thumbs Up

If you sail anywhere near surf and you've loosened the plug after a sail you've got to pull the plug all the way out before tightening so you can blow out the sand that will have found its way onto the seat.

The other thing to bear in mind is all boards leak to some degree. If you've undone the plug and retightened it when it is hot, when you put it in cold water it will suck.

Waiting4wind
NSW, 1871 posts
4 Jan 2013 10:36AM
Thumbs Up

I've seen this debate on a number of occassions and at there isn't a definitive answer.

I've been sailing for 20 years and owned countless number of boards in different constructions. I leave the plug in and have never had a problem.

At one stage I did try taking the plug out and managed to forget to refit it, drenched the board.

I hear a lot more stories of people damaging boards by forgeting to refit the plug than having them blow out.

It would be interesting to hear what a manufacturer would say on this topic WRT warranty.

In the short time I did remove the plug I paid careful attention to to keeping the threads clean from sand and the condition of the O ring. I often found that sand particles (floating around inside the bag) would find their way to the threads. So you need to check thoroughly before re tightening. To me this is a pain in the A, when i get to the beach i want to get in the water ASAP.

evlPanda
NSW, 9202 posts
4 Jan 2013 10:54AM
Thumbs Up

Waiting4wind said...
I hear a lot more stories of people damaging boards by forgetting to refit the plug than having them blow out.


I think that sums it all up very nicely.

DVDA
NSW, 24 posts
4 Jan 2013 11:54AM
Thumbs Up

I've always loosened the plug after every sail, after blowing the residual water out of the area.

I was interested to see JP Australia finally put something in print regarding this question:

JP Australia User Manual
"PRESSURE VALVE
The “valve” or "pressure release screw" (at the mast box) compensates the difference of air pressure inside and outside the board (mostly caused by extreme temperature / sun exposure).
• close the valve for sailing
• otherwise it should be open.
Very important: Make sure that the valve is open when traveling by plane !
Keep/store your board in a board bag to prevent unnecessary sun exposure, scratches, other wear and tear."

With regard to "forgetting", when I install the mast base I tighten the vent and check the fin bolt.

I also check all the foot strap screws occasionally. They loosen a little, mostly in the first season.

seanhogan
QLD, 3424 posts
4 Jan 2013 11:26AM
Thumbs Up

I have four boards packed in my van (all year round), never undo the plugs, never had a single issue. been doing that for years.

swoosh
QLD, 1927 posts
4 Jan 2013 11:46AM
Thumbs Up

this is a good thread for who not to buy second hand boards from...

sboardcrazy
NSW, 8021 posts
4 Jan 2013 1:32PM
Thumbs Up

shear tip said...
sboardcrazy said...
I loosen it after every sail before it goes in the board bag...


Wouldn't the water vapour from the wet footstraps create a very moist atmosphere in the bag after a sail which would get sucked into the vent plug as the board cools and contracts. It might be better to leave the vent done up on the way home, and then store the board out of it's bag and then loosen the vent.

Just a thought - I don't usually loosen the vent, but I think I might start doing it...


Maybe if I'm going straight home..I often drive around doing errands and its a few hours of it beiong on top before it gets home..I always take the board out of its bag when home and dry it + the bag leaving the vent loose before I put it back in.

sboardcrazy
NSW, 8021 posts
4 Jan 2013 1:33PM
Thumbs Up

ka43 said...
Mike makes a good point. Ive always loosened he plugs in my boards after a sail but of late have stopped doing so straight after a sail. If its a very hot day or board has been sitting in the sun I will quickly loosen it to release any pressure build up then re-tighten (to stop moisture from wet straps etc getting into board) before I put in the bag and car for trip home.
Once home I put the board with vent plug undone on board rack.
Like a lot of things its a habit you get used to.
I guess if it made no difference then manufacturers wouldnt put that warning sticker on their boards.


Mm good idea I suppose.Another habit Ill have to get into..

CJW
NSW, 1718 posts
4 Jan 2013 2:12PM
Thumbs Up

swoosh said...
this is a good thread for who not to buy second hand boards from...


Oh snap!

Despite what the JP website says I'd almost guarantee that JP himself does not remove the vent plug from his board in normal circumstances. It's honestly way more trouble that it's worth, for all the reasons listed above by anyone with half a clue

cammd
QLD, 3779 posts
4 Jan 2013 2:29PM
Thumbs Up

I always remove the vent plugs. I don't see what the big problem is, takes about 5 seconds to screw it in right after screwing in the fin.

d1
WA, 304 posts
4 Jan 2013 12:34PM
Thumbs Up

CJW said...
It's honestly way more trouble that it's worth, for all the reasons listed above by anyone with half a clue


Yes, half a clue... Here is the viewpoint of someone with more than that - scroll down to "Q: my board has a vent plug. Should I open it when I'm not sailing?"): boardlady.com/faqs.htm

Waiting4wind
NSW, 1871 posts
4 Jan 2013 5:27PM
Thumbs Up

seanhogan said...
I have four boards packed in my van (all year round), never undo the plugs, never had a single issue. been doing that for years.


This is saying something. A couple days when I was in New Cal recently it felt so hot I was wishing I had a valve on my head, as it was about to go pop.

I guess, as I said earlier, this is one topic that the windsurfers will remain divided on (much like do i need to wash my sails after a sessison). There will be those that stay plugged and others don't...pick your club.

Enough talk, time for action, honking NE'er in Sydney atm.

sboardcrazy
NSW, 8021 posts
4 Jan 2013 5:29PM
Thumbs Up

Waiting4wind said...
seanhogan said...
I have four boards packed in my van (all year round), never undo the plugs, never had a single issue. been doing that for years.


This is saying something. A couple days when I was in New Cal recently it felt so hot I was wishing I had a valve on my head, as it was about to go pop.

I guess, as I said earlier, this is one topic that the windsurfers will remain divided on (much like do i need to wash my sails after a sessison). There will be those that stay plugged and others don't...pick your club.

Enough talk, time for action, honking NE'er in Sydney atm.


Yep up here too..grr no sailing for me today..Have fun!

jh2703
NSW, 1222 posts
4 Jan 2013 5:54PM
Thumbs Up

I've had a JP in the back of my black van (along with 4 others) all summer long, actually for the last 4 summers including 3 stints in WA in the middle of those summer. My van has no ventilation and I've witnessed sunglasses melting on the dash board and guess what, all my boards are still ok. I've had one board replaced under warranty form JP and they never asked if I removed the vent plug after sailing, only after chopping this board in half with a saw did the vent plug get removed....I still have it as a keep sake. In the early years I removed the vent plug, after a post like this one actually. The very next sail I forgot to put the plug in, had I not stopped to talk to someone I would have hit the water and been in all sorts. Lucky the wind died off and I packed up before getting wet and then noticed the plug missing, lucky for me!

I only ever plan to remove them if flying.

Carantoc
WA, 6666 posts
4 Jan 2013 3:00PM
Thumbs Up

cammd said...
I always remove the vent plugs. I don't see what the big problem is, takes about 5 seconds to screw it in right after screwing in the fin.


Why do you remove the fin ?

choco
SA, 4034 posts
4 Jan 2013 7:23PM
Thumbs Up

good board bag provides great insulation, can be stinking hot in the shed pull out the board from the bag and they are alot cooler

gregwed
QLD, 555 posts
4 Jan 2013 8:17PM
Thumbs Up

I always loosen the vent screw after a sail then retighten before going into the water - just a habit and I never forget. And its also done at the same time I put in or remove the fin. I take the fin out for travelling as the board goes into the car a lot easier. Used to leave the fin in but scratched the car a lot.
Cheers

barn
WA, 2960 posts
4 Jan 2013 6:22PM
Thumbs Up

d1 said...
CJW said...
It's honestly way more trouble that it's worth, for all the reasons listed above by anyone with half a clue


Yes, half a clue... Here is the viewpoint of someone with more than that - scroll down to "Q: my board has a vent plug. Should I open it when I'm not sailing?"): boardlady.com/faqs.htm




Board Lady doesn't know everything, especially when it comes to pressure. Because she thinks pulling a partial vacuum on a board will evaporate (boil) the water inside. That's less than half a clue.

Anyway, bungs are the worst thing ever. First, there's no washer, so the O-ring is twisted and distorted every time you tighten it. Then there's all the sand and salt that gets in there fudging up the seal.

More importantly, why the fark do companies put the bung at the mast track. Put it at the nose or the tail so you can actually get the water that bungs inevitably leak in, back out.

I've sent this info graphic to all the major brands, clearly pointing why the bung is always at the bottom.




We should see bungs correctly installed for the 2014 boards.

CJW
NSW, 1718 posts
4 Jan 2013 9:33PM
Thumbs Up

d1 said...
CJW said...
It's honestly way more trouble that it's worth, for all the reasons listed above by anyone with half a clue


Yes, half a clue... Here is the viewpoint of someone with more than that - scroll down to "Q: my board has a vent plug. Should I open it when I'm not sailing?"): boardlady.com/faqs.htm




Really? Last time I looked the board lady wasn't a physicist, nor am I but lets run some calcs for the fun of it. (Someone may have to correct me, my gas laws are rusty, Ian :P)

Lets pick the absolute worst case, board in car, internally the board has reached 60deg, which in my opinion would never happen, polystyrene is pretty baller insulation you know. P1/T1=P2/T2, Temp = 22C, AtmP = 101.3kPa; 101.3/295 = P2/333, P2 = 114.34kPa giving a pressure differential of ~13kPa

Now that equates to about 13N/cm^2 for force. Now you might think that is a lot, but remember this is the absolute worst case (and imo implausible).

But think about this, when you step on your board your foot probably has a contact area of about 5x5cm + 5x5cm = 50cm^2. Lets say you weigh 80kg, 80*10/50 = 16N/cm^2. Which as you have now deduced is more than the absolute worst case pressure loading on the board.

Also keep in mind the foot load is an impulse load so it will be significantly higher than 16N/cm^2 when you actually put your foot down, not to mention going over chop etc.

Case in point absolute worst case pressure loading is not that bad, it's also a uniform load, nice and gentle, compared to anything else you do to the board. Save yourself the trouble, leave the bung in.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"when shoud vent plugs be removed" started by dkeating