Forums > Windsurfing Wave sailing

toe in in production boards

Reply
Created by santi4 > 9 months ago, 24 Jan 2023
santi4
58 posts
10 Feb 2023 6:33PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Bernd Roediger














USA
US-1113
My favorite spot has been, and always will be, Ho'okipa.
Flikka Custom Quad 75L down the line, Flikka Custom Quad 74L "competition"















My setup









I'm an intuitive rider. I don't have any formulas for my equipment, other than change. I like changing things constantly, shaking up my fin setups, trying new and experimental configuration like Bonzers or "true quads" (quads with larger front fins than rear). My only rule is not to avoid getting attached to anything for too long.







Gestalt
QLD, 14430 posts
10 Feb 2023 9:36PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
santi4 said..
I was referring to wave boards in waves... in a straight line or lake I don't understand the meaning of 3 fins or toe in angle.
If I buy a rally car, it doesn't make sense for it to leave the factory with normal street springs.
I understand that most of the promotional videos focus on the waves of Kanaha or Hookipa. I think most of us have sold boards without really knowing their potential. ..and the designers know that they can work much better in waves than out of the shop.

i also don't want a rally car with a lawn mower engine.

Gestalt
QLD, 14430 posts
10 Feb 2023 9:41PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
sheddweller said..
I use quite big sides and relatively small centres. I have done quite a lot of "testing" by feeling of toe and fin set ups. Larger sides without toe "feel" draggy to me ( They also don't turn, especially at initiation- straight lining) I don't know if this can be measured with a GPS as I have only been doing this for myself, so I am only interested in my own feel and enjoyment. Small sides /zero toe with a larger centre mitigate the draggy feeling, but then I feel I may as well set up as a single. I am an average wave sailor and I m talking about front side sailing in groundswell waves. I have also found that fin set up in onshore conditions is much less critical, I can generally carry much larger fin clusters, and I don't find toe to be as critical either. Your experiences may differ...


After reading your post my first question was are u using asymmetric side fins.

Wind Smurf
NSW, 247 posts
11 Feb 2023 8:38AM
Thumbs Up

Just read an interesting article in uk Windsurf magazine.

Its a review on the Naish Assault 105.

"There is some real toe-in in the side fins orientation, and we did notice a slight reduction in the Assault's speed and alertness . yet the trade-off was justified when dropping into a bottom turn, the grip and drive through the tail of the board really helping to redirect it tighter up the face."

Personally lately I've had enough of multi fins and have gone back to an older FSW single fin and am loving it, quicker release, takes a larger sail etc and I really haven't noticed the difference even on a wave in the lack of grip. That might also be a case of using the right fin too.

Ola H
91 posts
11 Feb 2023 4:35PM
Thumbs Up

Interesting discussion. A little bit of toe in is in fact better on all boards and with all fins. It is faster and less prone to strange hickups in turns. It baffles me that not all producers us a little toe in, say at least 1 degree. I use a minimum of 1.3 degrees and more commonly 1.5 or 1.8. This is with symmetric fins. A reason a board can still "get away with" 0 toe in is that most use very small and low power front fins. And if you aske me, the reason better working fronts (like surf fins) have not taken off, at least for serious wave riding, is that so many boards lack the necessary toe in. I adjust my toe in between 1.3 and 1.8 depending on the type of board and fin placement. With fins further to the rear and further to the rail, the toe in need to increase. When I have my rear twin/quad boxes relatively far apart, I toe in those too, around 0.5-0.7 degrees. Toe in has little to do with if it is a quad or thruster and I use the same fronts and change between thruster and quad all the time because it is an amazing way to fine tune the turning character fot he board. Toe in can be even more sensitive on quads though, in particular when the rears are wide apart and close to the fronts. Then toe in need to be tuned in concert. A properly toe in setup will not only turn better (as in more predictable) but also be a little be faster in a straightline due to the fins being more in line with the water flow, which "bends" outwards due to the board "parting the water". As somebody mentioned, I make my asymmetric fins with some added toe in in the box, say 1.3-1.5 degrees more (as well as some cant/splay). A standard flat inside surf style fin need around 3 degrees in total. I personally ONLY use fcs style surf fins in my boards and have around 15 different sets with different toe and splay and character so I can play around and fine tune individual boards to my liking. To understand why toe in is such an effective variable, you need to understand the hydrodynamics of a turn. At turn initiation, you g from pushing the windward rail to pushing the leeward rail and the flow need to change direction around the fins, the tail NEEDs to start slip outwards a little and THEN the inner fin starts to engage. Toe in sets the point at which this engagement happens. If you run a more powerful front fin, you often want a smidgen of more toe to avoid the power of the inner front fin to create a hickup in the turn when it engages. I often run full size surf two setups with a trailer. That would be impossible without toe in because botom turn initiation would be super sensitive. But with proper toe you can still get a smooth initiation and then an amazing type of hold in the top turn which is really cool in slower wave conditions.

Wind Smurf
NSW, 247 posts
11 Feb 2023 9:11PM
Thumbs Up

It would be really good for everyone, if when answering about this topic that they stated what boards they use and what size fins are in both front and back and what if any toe in they have and what degree front fins they use. It will then give a bit of data to those wandering what they should be using to make their gear work better.

santi4
58 posts
11 Feb 2023 6:40PM
Thumbs Up

that would be great...in fact...in my opinion all boards should carry out some fins instructions for use.
I think the sailor weight is also important.
table type. sailor weight.. then it does not mean that this is definitive, each one can adjust based on where he sailing and personal preferences.
the year of the model boards can also be interesting... volume distribution and edges sometimes changes, but it is already too much tuning

Rango
WA, 721 posts
11 Feb 2023 7:01PM
Thumbs Up

Running k4 incinerator as quad 14.5 rear and 9 cm one degree incinerators in the front .Board is a 78 Flywave v3 and is magic with this set up especially with bottom turn initiation and reaction mid turn to tighten up more vertical. The rail transition to top turn is also much easier for me .Im 72 kg at the moment.
If you want the AI's though I could not find them in Australia , ordered straight from k4 UK.

Gestalt
QLD, 14430 posts
11 Feb 2023 11:25PM
Thumbs Up

Wouldn't describe myself as a wave sailor. When I'm in the surf its smaller.

Have a bunch of different fins, surfboard fins, assy fins, windsurf fins I use and boards with no toe through to lots of toe. Quads, thrusters, 2+1 and singles. Have a simmer quantum v1 too.

Everyone will have their own take on this and I respect that but It's gonna take a big shift for me to accept adding toe makes fins faster.

SurferKris
380 posts
12 Feb 2023 3:57AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Ola H said..
As somebody mentioned, I make my asymmetric fins with some added toe in in the box, say 1.3-1.5 degrees more (as well as some cant/splay). A standard flat inside surf style fin need around 3 degrees in total.


I think this stems from the issue of how one should defined the angle of incidence on asymmetric fins. It seems to me like K4 (for instance) are measuring the angle compared to the flat inside of the fin. A better definition would be from the angle where there is no "lift" from the profile, or a straight line from the foremost edge to the trailing edge, an example of that is shown in the picture below. So for K4 assymetric fins I'm treating their +1 marking as effectively being about 0 degrees.

Ola, do you use FCS boxes in your boards or do you add SB heads to standard FCS fins?



santi4
58 posts
12 Feb 2023 7:04PM
Thumbs Up

Surf fins due to their super light construction (in comparison with windsurf fin rtm technology) are much more sensitive when they get in contact with the shore or the rocks.

www.wsurf.eu/dual-tab-type-i-fins-to-minituttle-adaptor-set-3-toe-in-angle/

curac
WA, 1145 posts
12 Feb 2023 10:50PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Grantmac said..

flyingmujol said..


santi4 said..
Why do most series wave boards come out without enough toe in?




My guess is because they are designed for the average windsurfer and must work well in a wide range of conditions. I see lot of people using multifin boards in lakes when it's very windy, basically blasing on straight line; so they are not limited to surf waves.

Less toe-in causes less drag whereas more toe-in makes turning easier.



Untoed boxes are actually more drag, especially on a thruster.
It's done because it's cheaper and most people don't notice. The manufacturer also oversizes the back fin and undersizes the front to make it less obvious.q


looks like a good thorough discussion for the inebriated. i might not be right but i've never been wrong, but the toe on fin boxes don't mean diddly squat to board cost, unless it's a covid thing they can put a 90 degree fin across your board for the same cost, if it's what you specify. no mater what it is, it's just a jig and a person cutting a hole in your board.

production boards are for one and for all, toe makes a twitchy board, just get a set of fins with toe if you want that. some boards are just pigs not matter how they are marketed. especially big boards in my experience.

you can't have a board that turns good, is fast and planes quickly.

also stock fins, are not always that great, (depending on your wants).

if you find a board you really like, cherish it.

sheddweller
268 posts
13 Feb 2023 2:35AM
Thumbs Up

"production boards are for one and for all"
Or in other words production boards are for the mythical average person, who doesn't actually exist, except in some marketing spreadsheet.

Wind Smurf
NSW, 247 posts
13 Feb 2023 1:21PM
Thumbs Up

The amount of toe is also related to the amount of Vee or double concave where the thruster sits and also the tail width at that point.
A wider tail is usually fitted with bigger side fins and if it has more Vee then it'll also require more toe in, this is only usually the case, and theres a lot of exceptions to the rule. See what Klass says about the Stubby on you tube at about 1:40 he talks about the side fins etc.



More Vee means that the water flow will then release more sideways and therefore more Toe in is needed.
Also the riders weight, the rig and their individual style adds to the whole story.

stonny
NSW, 99 posts
13 Feb 2023 2:17PM
Thumbs Up

Hahaha....I've heard it all now !!!!

Madge
NSW, 471 posts
13 Feb 2023 2:31PM
Thumbs Up

I've got a custom, just measured the toe in, it's around 1.7 degrees if you use the K4 calculator, seems to work well at that angle. I also have a freewave with 0 toe in and that works well too and has heaps of Vee in the tail. As Long as it's working for you and you are having a great time.

Wind Smurf
NSW, 247 posts
13 Feb 2023 4:16PM
Thumbs Up

Here is a direct link to the K4 Toe in Calculator that Madge mentioned.

www.k4fins.com/fin-toe-angle-calculator/

AlexF
496 posts
13 Feb 2023 11:33PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Wind Smurf said..
The amount of toe is also related to the amount of Vee or double concave where the thruster sits and also the tail width at that point.
A wider tail is usually fitted with bigger side fins and if it has more Vee then it'll also require more toe in, this is only usually the case, and theres a lot of exceptions to the rule. See what Klass says about the Stubby on you tube at about 1:40 he talks about the side fins etc.


More Vee means that the water flow will then release more sideways and therefore more Toe in is needed.
Also the riders weight, the rig and their individual style adds to the whole story.


He does not talk about toe in, though.
Just about the bigish 12 sidefins, which i can confirm is necessary on the wide tailed boards.
I got a goya Nitro 106 (no toe in btw.) with a 21/10 fin (stock) setup and i had quite some trouble with going upwind with a bigger sail or riding overpowered. In both cases there's more pressure on the fins than usual and with my 93 kgs i had to be super careful to avoid spinouts. With 12 sidefins the problem was gone completely.

santi4
58 posts
14 Feb 2023 4:20PM
Thumbs Up

you put 12cm k4 fins ? flex model?
If you are happy with that configuration...perfect...I didn't like big straight front fins...for my.. don't works well in gives

AlexF
496 posts
14 Feb 2023 5:53PM
Thumbs Up

No, it tried some Flikka G10 12 sidefins, that i borought from a friend.
I have a pair of 12cm MFC TF1 on order now.

Gestalt
QLD, 14430 posts
14 Feb 2023 8:55PM
Thumbs Up

I wish flikka offered futures bases. Same with tectonics. They have some fins I'd like to try

my current go to fins are from mark stone. I have a quad set from him which are hands down best fins I've ever used. He seems to have nailed the flex and thickness. They feel slippery fast and always maintain control. Not sure if the starboard version are the same.

seabreezer
377 posts
15 Feb 2023 2:24PM
Thumbs Up

Ive never used the stock symmetry fronts ... Always got maybe 30-40% extra performance out of using toed (3 deg) and canted fins on nearly every board Ive ever tried .... bottom turn sets way nicer / less bounce outs , more grip and fun .... Only time they haven't worked is maybe with boards with a lot of hip (like old higher volume models starby quad / older older rrd cult wave ) .... they worked good with 80/20 slight toe 1 deg ( with full toed fins turns would be too quick and over snap out the tail - hard to draw longer more powerful curves ) everything else Ive ever used from Quatro customs , rrd hardcores , Tabou dacurves , small starby quads , Simmer flys and quantum , Tabou pocket , Fanatic stubby etc etc - the list goes on

The only time I think front production syms slightly ok - is full onshore on say fanatic stubby's - where toed fronts might pull the rail down more frontside top turns ( your not looking for top turn carves , more to be able to release the rail earlier as so twisted clew first switch - and you need more to pivot topturn around .... Im talking total onshore for sums - in side on - I would still sooner be on toed fronts

Funny , a fin maker said to me - ALL his pro sailors order / use toed fins all the time with few exceptions ..... everything else (general public) uses (Struggles !) with symm fronts

Basher
535 posts
15 Feb 2023 10:28PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
santi4 said..
Why do most series wave boards come out without enough toe in?



I'm going to comment here because these discussions usually drive me nuts.
It's way too easy to jump down the toe in rabbit hole.
There are simpler ways of looking at toe in, and they are more based on common sense.


1) Fins have to work with the board shape, and what works for one design is rarely transferable to another.
2) The obsession with toe in started with surf boards, and we windsurfers tend to forget our boards have to blast in a straight line and to jump, as well as to turn on the wave face.
3) Toe in can help a board turn, but too much toe in causes drag that reduces your straight line speed. If you are not planing on the way out anyway, then maybe straight line speed doesn't matter to you.
4) The fin placement is thus a compromise based on hull shape and on what the sailor wants to do. Some hull shapes do not need toe in for the fin boxes, whereas some do.
5) You can experiment with toe in to suit your local conditions by using fins set with an offset in the fin head, but normally this is just 1-3 degrees and no more. The way we sail our boards - often crabbing sideways even at speed - that small angle of difference is actually difficult to notice. This is why most production boards have no toe in - or else the boxes are only offset by about 1 degree.
6) For sure, asymmetric fins need to be set with a couple of degrees of toe in just to get them 'neutral'. So they might look cool, but maybe you're not actually sailing with any true toe in. The argument against using assym fins is that where the board is sailed flat the lift from one of the two fins is not help helpful and creates unwanted drag. This is why production boards are not supplied with assym fins.
7) Some companies claim that all waveboards must have toe in - but that's just their marketing, or else only true for their own design shapes. Toe in has become part of gang or a club that you are expected to join.
8) Like most wave sailors I don't spend much time measuring or fiddling with the toe in of my fins or fin boxes, because the board either works or it doesn't. If it doesn't work straight out of the box then your board is probably a duff design. Perhaps readers here might like to name any recent boards they felt didn't work with the fins provided. I can't think of any.
9) If you are finding your board does not turn easily, or indeed feels stiff and wants to track in a straight line, then this is usually because you have way too much fin area in the back of the board. Fit some shorter fins before you play with toe in.
10) If you are having issues with spinout, this is rarely anything to do with your fins and certainly nothing to do with toe in. (Shift your harness lines back on the boom, and maybe set the deckplate 3cms further back in the mast track.)
11) If you are one of those people who care about toe in and fin kant more than you care about the quality of the wave or the wind strength, then I'd suggest you have your priorities misplaced.

philn
862 posts
16 Feb 2023 12:22AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Basher said..

santi4 said..
Why do most series wave boards come out without enough toe in?




I'm going to comment here because these discussions usually drive me nuts.
It's way too easy to jump down the toe in rabbit hole.
There are simpler ways of looking at toe in, and they are more based on common sense.


1) Fins have to work with the board shape, and what works for one design is rarely transferable to another.
2) The obsession with toe in started with surf boards, and we windsurfers tend to forget our boards have to blast in a straight line and to jump, as well as to turn on the wave face.
3) Toe in can help a board turn, but too much toe in causes drag that reduces your straight line speed. If you are not planing on the way out anyway, then maybe straight line speed doesn't matter to you.
4) The fin placement is thus a compromise based on hull shape and on what the sailor wants to do. Some hull shapes do not need toe in for the fin boxes, whereas some do.
5) You can experiment with toe in to suit your local conditions by using fins set with an offset in the fin head, but normally this is just 1-3 degrees and no more. The way we sail our boards - often crabbing sideways even at speed - that small angle of difference is actually difficult to notice. This is why most production boards have no toe in - or else the boxes are only offset by about 1 degree.
6) For sure, asymmetric fins need to be set with a couple of degrees of toe in just to get them 'neutral'. So they might look cool, but maybe you're not actually sailing with any true toe in. The argument against using assym fins is that where the board is sailed flat the lift from one of the two fins is not help helpful and creates unwanted drag. This is why production boards are not supplied with assym fins.
7) Some companies claim that all waveboards must have toe in - but that's just their marketing, or else only true for their own design shapes. Toe in has become part of gang or a club that you are expected to join.
8) Like most wave sailors I don't spend much time measuring or fiddling with the toe in of my fins or fin boxes, because the board either works or it doesn't. If it doesn't work straight out of the box then your board is probably a duff design. Perhaps readers here might like to name any recent boards they felt didn't work with the fins provided. I can't think of any.
9) If you are finding your board does not turn easily, or indeed feels stiff and wants to track in a straight line, then this is usually because you have way too much fin area in the back of the board. Fit some shorter fins before you play with toe in.
10) If you are having issues with spinout, this is rarely anything to do with your fins and certainly nothing to do with toe in. (Shift your harness lines back on the boom, and maybe set the deckplate 3cms further back in the mast track.)
11) If you are one of those people who care about toe in and fin kant more than you care about the quality of the wave or the wind strength, then I'd suggest you have your priorities misplaced.


Informative post. Only thing I'd change is to remove the sarcasm.

santi4
58 posts
16 Feb 2023 12:50AM
Thumbs Up

Opining is free... but it is better to provide experience information to help everyone,,, sure there are people with more experience here

seabreezer
377 posts
16 Feb 2023 9:21AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Basher said..

santi4 said..
Why do most series wave boards come out without enough toe in?




I'm going to comment here because these discussions usually drive me nuts.
It's way too easy to jump down the toe in rabbit hole.
There are simpler ways of looking at toe in, and they are more based on common sense.


1) Fins have to work with the board shape, and what works for one design is rarely transferable to another.
2) The obsession with toe in started with surf boards, and we windsurfers tend to forget our boards have to blast in a straight line and to jump, as well as to turn on the wave face.
3) Toe in can help a board turn, but too much toe in causes drag that reduces your straight line speed. If you are not planing on the way out anyway, then maybe straight line speed doesn't matter to you.
4) The fin placement is thus a compromise based on hull shape and on what the sailor wants to do. Some hull shapes do not need toe in for the fin boxes, whereas some do.
5) You can experiment with toe in to suit your local conditions by using fins set with an offset in the fin head, but normally this is just 1-3 degrees and no more. The way we sail our boards - often crabbing sideways even at speed - that small angle of difference is actually difficult to notice. This is why most production boards have no toe in - or else the boxes are only offset by about 1 degree.
6) For sure, asymmetric fins need to be set with a couple of degrees of toe in just to get them 'neutral'. So they might look cool, but maybe you're not actually sailing with any true toe in. The argument against using assym fins is that where the board is sailed flat the lift from one of the two fins is not help helpful and creates unwanted drag. This is why production boards are not supplied with assym fins.
7) Some companies claim that all waveboards must have toe in - but that's just their marketing, or else only true for their own design shapes. Toe in has become part of gang or a club that you are expected to join.
8) Like most wave sailors I don't spend much time measuring or fiddling with the toe in of my fins or fin boxes, because the board either works or it doesn't. If it doesn't work straight out of the box then your board is probably a duff design. Perhaps readers here might like to name any recent boards they felt didn't work with the fins provided. I can't think of any.
9) If you are finding your board does not turn easily, or indeed feels stiff and wants to track in a straight line, then this is usually because you have way too much fin area in the back of the board. Fit some shorter fins before you play with toe in.
10) If you are having issues with spinout, this is rarely anything to do with your fins and certainly nothing to do with toe in. (Shift your harness lines back on the boom, and maybe set the deckplate 3cms further back in the mast track.)
11) If you are one of those people who care about toe in and fin kant more than you care about the quality of the wave or the wind strength, then I'd suggest you have your priorities misplaced.


Bahser - once you've spent all that money flying to SA .... and you've lined up that dream $$$ wave .... do you want to be bouncing out of your first bottom turn losing the rail .... ? ......

in answer to 11) - a quality set-up - lets you access quality moments on quality waves (and not blow precious turns when you actually get a wave in SA without 10 people on it) .... wether its holding your rail big bottom turn .... pushing to go more vert to hit a lip ..... or setting a nice rail carve off the top .... if your using sym fronts no TOE this is all way harder than with nice toed fronts

If you can't feel the difference - you are likely 'sailing' your board down the line .... passive style ..... playing safe with body positioning .... positioning your body over the board at all times , and NEVER exerting any force in your waveriding ---- ( why maybe - because anything else more expansive has historically bounced you out at the wrong moment with that s^&t stock setup .... ) .... food for thought....




santi4
58 posts
16 Feb 2023 4:13PM
Thumbs Up

sometimes it's a question of time and experience... maybe living in places without much wind requires a little more research... but when as in my case... a small change transforms a small cross shore wave session with my production boring board plenty of all-round volume on a magical front side day. It's then when I consider and get excited again with windsurfing
... I think everything is already invented... just finding that board with the magical combination that it works for you...and then..if you can...customize based on it...that's very difficult with serial boards
...maybe there are people who just want to spend some time in the water...and it's totally respectable...I don't earn my living with this...but it gives me a lot of life

Basher
535 posts
23 Feb 2023 11:03PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote


Bahser - once you've spent all that money flying to SA .... and you've lined up that dream $$$ wave .... do you want to be bouncing out of your first bottom turn losing the rail .... ? ......

in answer to 11) - a quality set-up - lets you access quality moments on quality waves (and not blow precious turns when you actually get a wave in SA without 10 people on it) .... wether its holding your rail big bottom turn .... pushing to go more vert to hit a lip ..... or setting a nice rail carve off the top .... if your using sym fronts no TOE this is all way harder than with nice toed fronts

If you can't feel the difference - you are likely 'sailing' your board down the line .... passive style ..... playing safe with body positioning .... positioning your body over the board at all times , and NEVER exerting any force in your waveriding ---- ( why maybe - because anything else more expansive has historically bounced you out at the wrong moment with that s^&t stock setup .... ) .... food for thought....






Well I haven't been to Cape Town for a while but you make an interesting point.
And I suspect the perfect board set up for one location in Cape Town wouldn't be the best set up at another beach a few miles down the road.
Adapting body stance to the wave on offer will certainly be more important than changing toe in by 1 degree.
Having a board with a different rocker line, or more tail kick would also make far more difference to the sailor who is skilled enough to notice.

But the real point is that every session is different, and your favourite board at one spot might not be the best at another, or on another day. Most of us, when finding a windy and wavey spot, want to maximise our time on the water, and fiddling with fins is almost another hobby. Far better to sail the board in one setting and get your muscle memory attuned to it. Only when you have done that should you consider tweaking fin set ups.


If you have ever borrowed someone else's gear you also know that different sailors have different preferences in their set ups, and I just don't believe that changing fin toe in by 1 degree will make a noticeable difference to a board that is already working well in the right hands.

What I do often notice with other people's gear is that some prefer a lot more fin area than I use, and that must limit the board's turning ability way more than a toe in issue.
In rare cases we might find the fin placement just not working with the board - but I haven't had that problem with a production board for many years.
What we do find is that a fellow windsurfer might complain that their board is draggy or slow to plane - and at that point they might start to talk about toe in - because it has become the fashion to blame your fins. That is usually a misdiagnosis of the problem when the true issue is often that they are on too small a board, or else their technique is not active enough to 'pop' a wave board that has proper tail kick.


Apologies to those who found my earlier list sarcastic. I guess it's always going to sound patronising when listing points that way, but that's how my thinking process works.

seabreezer
377 posts
24 Feb 2023 11:35AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Basher said..



Bahser - once you've spent all that money flying to SA .... and you've lined up that dream $$$ wave .... do you want to be bouncing out of your first bottom turn losing the rail .... ? ......

in answer to 11) - a quality set-up - lets you access quality moments on quality waves (and not blow precious turns when you actually get a wave in SA without 10 people on it) .... wether its holding your rail big bottom turn .... pushing to go more vert to hit a lip ..... or setting a nice rail carve off the top .... if your using sym fronts no TOE this is all way harder than with nice toed fronts

If you can't feel the difference - you are likely 'sailing' your board down the line .... passive style ..... playing safe with body positioning .... positioning your body over the board at all times , and NEVER exerting any force in your waveriding ---- ( why maybe - because anything else more expansive has historically bounced you out at the wrong moment with that s^&t stock setup .... ) .... food for thought....







Well I haven't been to Cape Town for a while but you make an interesting point.
And I suspect the perfect board set up for one location in Cape Town wouldn't be the best set up at another beach a few miles down the road.
Adapting body stance to the wave on offer will certainly be more important than changing toe in by 1 degree.
Having a board with a different rocker line, or more tail kick would also make far more difference to the sailor who is skilled enough to notice.

But the real point is that every session is different, and your favourite board at one spot might not be the best at another, or on another day. Most of us, when finding a windy and wavey spot, want to maximise our time on the water, and fiddling with fins is almost another hobby. Far better to sail the board in one setting and get your muscle memory attuned to it. Only when you have done that should you consider tweaking fin set ups.


If you have ever borrowed someone else's gear you also know that different sailors have different preferences in their set ups, and I just don't believe that changing fin toe in by 1 degree will make a noticeable difference to a board that is already working well in the right hands.

What I do often notice with other people's gear is that some prefer a lot more fin area than I use, and that must limit the board's turning ability way more than a toe in issue.
In rare cases we might find the fin placement just not working with the board - but I haven't had that problem with a production board for many years.
What we do find is that a fellow windsurfer might complain that their board is draggy or slow to plane - and at that point they might start to talk about toe in - because it has become the fashion to blame your fins. That is usually a misdiagnosis of the problem when the true issue is often that they are on too small a board, or else their technique is not active enough to 'pop' a wave board that has proper tail kick.


Apologies to those who found my earlier list sarcastic. I guess it's always going to sound patronising when listing points that way, but that's how my thinking process works.


Basher - 1 deg is noticeable - 3 degrees is a different planet ( and YES a big difference) .... ONCE your board is tuned in to its best set-up , I would argue it works best for everything side off to side on ....

Think the sarcasm is when you make comments that folks interested in finding their best set-up are somehow 'anoraks' , who would rather mess about with fins than actually sail ..... (btw - if your after wave quality - SA is NOT the place) . Body positioning is important in wave riding - AS IS A BLOODY GOOD SET - UP . I would wager Ive sailed a stack more board than you Basher -in conditions way more challenging - where **** set-ups get found out really quick - and yes - in 99% of cases - all the boards have worked 60% !!! of their potential with stock set-ups - (no doubt because the front boxes are so OFF with straight angles ! )

And your point re fave boards not working elsewhere , once a good shape and set-up work - they work at alot / most spots - look at Marc Pares interview where he's using a custom bottom shape on a grip EVERYWHERE - and he has kai hopf designed g10 toed canted assys .... and they give him extra grip / squirt in his turns that he loves - and allow him way more agressive body positioning ...

flyingmujol
36 posts
24 Feb 2023 7:12PM
Thumbs Up

An extract from that interview:

So, what is your favorite equipment setup right now?One of my favorite set ups is the Duotone Super Hero 4,2 on the new Fanatic Grip 81. I use 33" Duotone harness lines and the Grip 81 with a quad fin setup. I use 14.5 rears 8 or 8.5 fronts custom fins. I set up the rears to go right under my back foot and then I put the side fins about 2 fingers apart from the rears. I will put my top turn rail side about 0.5 cm to 0.75 cm further back than the bottom turn rail side. I personally use asymmetric sides that are 8 cm and have 3 degrees toe in, that makes the board turn better, but you do sacrifice comfort and planning. I use the mast track that the disc starts right at the edge of the square, to allow the board to be a bit more free and reactive, once again though that comes with a comfort and planning compromise as the board will feel more nervous under feet. I use this setup for down the line to side on wave riding. When it's onshore I use some normal 9 cm sides, nothing crazy just a straight fast fin.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing Wave sailing


"toe in in production boards" started by santi4