Forums > Windsurfing General

Whats the Best Wagon?!?!?!

Reply
Created by sflack > 9 months ago, 27 Apr 2008
sflack
VIC, 574 posts
27 Apr 2008 10:53PM
Thumbs Up

At the moment i have no cash, but at the end of the year im DEFINATLY going to need to sell my good ol' 1990 Toyota Corolla, to buy something bigger to fit my windsurfing kit!

I was thinkin either the Holden Commodore Wagon or the Ford Falcon Wagon.

Prob wanna spend between 2,500 to 7,000??

Any Ideas Fellas!

Cheers Steve

sflack
VIC, 574 posts
27 Apr 2008 10:56PM
Thumbs Up

Like, which is better

Go
VIC, 28 posts
27 Apr 2008 11:00PM
Thumbs Up

Volvo 960

Mark _australia
WA, 22284 posts
27 Apr 2008 9:05PM
Thumbs Up

sflack said...

Like, which is better


Neither? Parts are common etc ..... but how about getting an early 1990's subaru sportswagon?

Pluses: Little bit of driving ability on the beach (not much compared to a 'real' fourby but a sh!tload more ability than a Commondore or Falcon) and hold just as much gear, and reliable, and less fuel use, and cheaper tyres, and cheaper rego....blah blah

x sport guy
VIC, 110 posts
27 Apr 2008 11:06PM
Thumbs Up

imho any commodore with more than 150000 kms on the clock isnt worth touching... and dont get me wrong im not a ford fan really either, (truth be known i wouldnt have either of them after 100000 kms) but most people i know who have had either of them seem to get a better run out of the falcons. but they are both about as cheap as each other to run and service etc, so i reckon its all about finding 1 with low kms and an old fuddy duddy previous owner..... as for carrying your gear theres probably not much between them either..... hope that helps

x sport guy
VIC, 110 posts
27 Apr 2008 11:07PM
Thumbs Up

....subaru..... now theres a good idea

decrepit
WA, 12061 posts
27 Apr 2008 9:11PM
Thumbs Up

I've just bought an old bomb, for a windsurfing wagon.
1990 Toyota Lexcen (commodore look alike) for $800, had to spend about $200 for new muffler, immobiliser etc. and spend a few hours repairing a few little things. Now the only worry is a noisy diff.
No rust, (this is amazing in an 18yr old car, that's had the use this obviously has.)
Blows no smoke.
still about 15-20K kilometers in the tyres.
brakes and steering both OK.
Everything fits inside, (except my 1 piece masts, but not many people have these today)

I had a look at a Falcon, drove well but lots of rust, and tyres worn out.
At first it looks as though the Falcon has more room as the front seat lays right back, level with the back seat, allowing stuff to go all the way thru under the dash. (In the lexcen/commodore, the front seat only tilts forwards)
But the rear squab, is held up by a couple of bolts that stick out into the luggage space, I hit my board on it the first time I tried it for room. (The Lexcen/commodore, is held by a couple of "U" shapes that don't extend into the main cargo area.)
These are both earlier models than you are thinking of, newer versions may be different.

decrepit
WA, 12061 posts
27 Apr 2008 9:14PM
Thumbs Up

Also looked at a subaru, twice the price, ($1600) and very noisy, seemed to be on it's last legs.

elmo
WA, 8716 posts
27 Apr 2008 9:18PM
Thumbs Up

decrepit said...

Also looked at a subaru, twice the price, ($1600) and very noisy, seemed to be on it's last legs.


Subi's sound like that when they are new. They sound the same 20 years later.

good cars though

aus301
QLD, 2039 posts
27 Apr 2008 11:26PM
Thumbs Up

if you are on a budget try to stay away from a 6cyl...they chew through fuel and are more expensive to rego etc.

4cyl magnas and camrys are cheap, good for parts and cheap to run while still being big enough to fit gear inside.

or you can go my personal fav...the 1973 Type 3 VW station wagon. I had one and it went everywhere a 4wd did.

Greenroom
WA, 7608 posts
27 Apr 2008 9:52PM
Thumbs Up

Hey Decrep, have you tried taking the back seat out? Then you push the front passanger seat as far forward as it goes. Then wind it down as far as it goes. This allows you then to put the backrest of the back seat down. I do this in my '94 wagon. You can comfortably put 3 boards on their side and a surfboard on top. Masts go down the middle and then sails go behind the drivers seat.
I can lock up 3 windsurfers, 1 surfboard, 2 masts, 4 sails, 2 booms etc etc etc with plenty more room in my commodore wagon

Greenroom
WA, 7608 posts
27 Apr 2008 9:59PM
Thumbs Up

Mark _australia said...

.....but how about getting an early 1990's subaru sportswagon?

Pluses: Little bit of driving ability on the beach (not much compared to a 'real' fourby but a sh!tload more ability than a Commondore or Falcon) and hold just as much gear, and reliable, and less fuel use, and cheaper tyres, and cheaper rego....blah blah



I traded my 1990 L series Subi to get a commodore wagon.
I love those Subi's. I even belonged to the Subaru Club.
I wish I didnt have to get rid of it But space was an issue.
There was no way in hell as much room in the Subi as the commodore. They are super tiny.
Leech has a Ford sedan and he could fit more gear in that than the L series Subi.
Bloody awesome car but not much space if you have lots of gear that you want to lock away inside.

Mark _australia
WA, 22284 posts
27 Apr 2008 10:10PM
Thumbs Up

Yeah well I meant for normal people who wnat to pack 1-2 boards, 1-2 masts and 3-4 sails.... not your 3 boards plus surfboard
bloody sparkies, license to print money obviously

Greenroom
WA, 7608 posts
27 Apr 2008 10:28PM
Thumbs Up

Who told you about my printing press Mark? Er... um... I mean... ah darn... Busted

sflack
VIC, 574 posts
28 Apr 2008 7:51AM
Thumbs Up

Yeah too be honest tho, a subi its pretty much outta the question, due to the fact that they are just too expensive and a little bit small, even the foresters are a bit small.

Yeah and agreed that a 6cyl does chew through alot of juice, and with petrol at 1.40 in Melbourne (thieving bastards) its gonna make it hard, maybe if i found one on LPG? are the LPG tanks stored underneith???

So we are probably looking at a Ford at the moment, because 'apparantly' there is more room?

Are you able to fit in boards as well as people... aka do i have to lay the front seat down to fit in boards?

Cheers

choco
SA, 4027 posts
28 Apr 2008 8:31AM
Thumbs Up

The way fuel prices are you can't beat this model for economy.

ka43
NSW, 3069 posts
28 Apr 2008 9:07AM
Thumbs Up

Ive got a 2000 VT wagon. Best car Ive ever owned. It takes heaps of gear inside and is super reliable.
I can get 4 boards, masts down the centre, booms on top of masts and 5 sails in no worries. If the family is included then everything fits in except boards and booms on roof.
If you take the head rest off passenger seat, move it all the way forward and wind down its perfect.
Admittedly it does chew the gas being a 3.8l V6 but if you dont lead foot it its OK!!
The Fords lose space in the back with the spare standing up instead of under floor like Commodore.
Hope this helps.

WINDY MILLER
WA, 3183 posts
28 Apr 2008 7:56AM
Thumbs Up

warnning..if u get an old ford wagon ea eb etc the head WILL blow at 150 - 200...they are programmed to about 2 grand to fix !!!! (so check if it has been changed OR factor it into your bargaining price) they leak on the gasket, so check colour of water in the reservoir.....also at that age, the other biggies to watch out for are the air con motor and worn seals in the power steering.....maybe similar probs with holden.

apart from that;;;; for oldies, fords n holden carry on 4 ever, and parts are cheap as chips if u go to wreckers.....

there is a reason why these are used 4 taxis!


get an rac inspection first...100 bucks for piece of mind!

sflack
VIC, 574 posts
28 Apr 2008 10:02AM
Thumbs Up

WINDY MILLER said...

warnning..if u get an old ford wagon ea eb etc the head WILL blow at 150 - 200...they are programmed to about 2 grand to fix !!!! (so check if it has been changed OR factor it into your bargaining price) they leak on the gasket, so check colour of water in the reservoir.....also at that age, the other biggies to watch out for are the air con motor and worn seals in the power steering.....maybe similar probs with holden.

apart from that;;;; for oldies, fords n holden carry on 4 ever, and parts are cheap as chips if u go to wreckers.....

there is a reason why these are used 4 taxis!


get an rac inspection first...100 bucks for piece of mind!


Yeah man thanks loads, ill prob be taking a mechanic with me to check it out, but thats good info! Cheers

sailquik
VIC, 6089 posts
28 Apr 2008 11:07AM
Thumbs Up

The Scoobiedoos chew up juice more than any other small 4 cyl. wagons. Heavier and AWD. Probably won't get much worse economy from a Falcodore.

When it comes right down to it, the biggest factor in fuel economy is how heavy your right foot is and how much of a hurry you are in. My BA Turbo gets 10lit/100km @ highway 100kmh criusing but hook up the SB trailer and it drops to 14-15lit/100km. Drop the speed back to 80km and kick back listening to the ABC on the radio (very calming :-) and mileage drops back to 10-11lit/100km with the trailer and 7.5 without. Of course, this probably hold true for smaller, lighter cars as well and even more so for blunt fronted Vans.

Pugwash
WA, 7671 posts
28 Apr 2008 9:24AM
Thumbs Up

Watch the auto trans in the old falcons... A little like the heads - guaranteed to die...

For VT-VY commodores, watch the heater core, it's prone to corrosion

For VZ commodores, watch the sump, it’s lower than the rest of the bits and pieces at the front... Fortunately, if this is busted, you'll know all about it...

If choosing between falcon and commodore in that price range, I'd go a VT wagon (at your upper end – but expect new tyres, battery, rego, service etc etc). I'm not a fan of the rear suspension in the older falcons (vs the commodore) and the styling of the falcon wagon is intersting Oh and the driving, older falcons are like driving a couch. Commodores are a little more responsive

monster
TAS, 495 posts
28 Apr 2008 12:10PM
Thumbs Up

just get a trailer

DavMen
NSW, 1498 posts
28 Apr 2008 1:08PM
Thumbs Up

Go Magna Wagon "better built" - the 3.0V6 actually uses less fuel thanits 2.5/4cyl.
post 1994 is best, no rust usually.

stribo
QLD, 1628 posts
28 Apr 2008 1:21PM
Thumbs Up

I bought a 64 xp wagon years ago for 50 bucks . That car did 4 nullabour crossings and up and down the WA coast for 2 seasons. I then sold it for $800...gotta get lucky sometimes.Then i bought an XE 84 wagon ,loads of room,drove that twice across from brissy to perth , when i retired her to my mates paddock the front end was fingered and you could stick a fist through rust holes in about five places.But the engine and gearbox where fine.Had a bombadoor for a while but wasn't as roomy as the fords.
All in all if you want a serious windsurf vehicle you need a van......

table top russ
WA, 26 posts
28 Apr 2008 11:23AM
Thumbs Up

I've currently got a 2004 VZ wagon.
Fit boards on the roof with every thing else inside or long enough to fit two boards inside including sails and gear.
You can spilt the back seats also to carry two passengers (one in the back and one in the front) including yourself with plently of space to spare.
Great as a daily driver.
Rear wheel drive so fun in the wet or on sand
Chews a bit of fuel when you stick the boot in. Plenty of power.
Cheap enough to service. Last major service (80Km's) cost $300.

Also great when you want to move house or take a trailer full of motorbikes away riding. for the weekend.

cheers,
Russ

Rider5
WA, 567 posts
28 Apr 2008 11:30AM
Thumbs Up

Get a commodore! my 94 VR(lexcen) cost 2k it chews 10 lires on a country road and 11.5 to 12 litres around town which I think is great for a 3.8 ltr. I disagree with the x sport guy 150 000 k's on a v6 is fine my last commodore had 290k on it when I sold it, body was rusty but the donk was fine. I think 150k is high for a 4cylinder. It's the rust that kills my cars, bloody salt spray.

Squid Lips
WA, 708 posts
28 Apr 2008 12:05PM
Thumbs Up

I just went through this about 2 weeks ago and ended up getting a VR Commodore. compared to the Falcon they are marginally smaller but they are a fair bit lighter so use less fuel and the engines are quieter and don't have the problem with the heads. I got mine for $4500 and it's straight as a die and no rust. I drove it 300km on the weekend and was surprised how little fuel it used carrying 3 blokes and luggage.

curac
WA, 1144 posts
28 Apr 2008 12:06PM
Thumbs Up

yeah i reckon commodore too. i had a VS and that was pretty sweet, and you could fit heaps of **** in it. not to bad on the open road for fuel but pretty shocking around town.

FormulaNova
WA, 14527 posts
28 Apr 2008 12:09PM
Thumbs Up

My commodore VS wagon had 270k kms on it when I decided to swap the motor. There was nothing wrong (still great fuel economy) with the old V6 except for the fact that it wasn't supercharged...

As KA43 said with his VT, remove the headrest on the passenger side front seat and you can lay the seat down. With the VS you have to remove the seat's trim to get at the head rest clips, but once you get there you can modify the pins so that the headrest becomes removable when needed.

In theory with the VS and later you can fit your gear inside and someone in the seat behind the driver because of the 60/40 split. I hired a new falcon wagon recently and for some reason they do their split seat the other way which would make it impossible to have someone sit there as well as have a couple of boards on the passenger side.

Ian K
WA, 4048 posts
28 Apr 2008 12:41PM
Thumbs Up

Our VN did 450K without any major problems, we've currently got a VS and a VT both with 300k no major problems. Thirsty around town but, because you can put your gear inside them they'd be no worse than a small 4 with gear on the roof on the hwy. But you do look like a bit of an enviro oaf these days running around in a big six, it's pretty cool to stack it all on a fiat 500.

sflack
VIC, 574 posts
28 Apr 2008 8:31PM
Thumbs Up

Yeah awesome guys, ok im lookin at the holdens... whats all the difference with the models tho.. example:

Executive

Berlina

Acclaim

etc etc

Cheers



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"Whats the Best Wagon?!?!?!" started by sflack